WBAUnofficial
Button? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Button? (/showthread.php?tid=23450)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Button? - Dumbo - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 04:14 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(01-09-2022, 11:42 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Very good I thought.

Saved two one on ones and made a racking save to tip an effort round the post. Thought kicking wise he was a step up from SJ. A few moments of me vs my lad on FIFA when I bring the keeper out and try and score with him but other than that, all good.

I’d be happy with him between the sticks and selling SJ to generate funds for area of more concern.

You must’ve been at a different game to me. He’s a prize clown - complete and utter liability. 

Appalling positioning for their equaliser - which should’ve been a routine save pretty much straight at him - and caused absolute mayhem at least twice by needlessly flying out the area. 

We absolutely will not go up with him in goal, so SJ must be kept at all costs. Keepers like that absolutely destroy defences.

I must have been because Button was solid. Two spectacular saves. Two ‘1 on 1’ saves. Decent kicking. 

As I said, a few dodgy sweeper keeper moments but no more than SJ’ usual.


RE: Button? - Baggeridgebaggy - 01-09-2022

Think Johnstone would have saved one or poss both goals

The first one wasnt that close to the post - not an agile keeper & didn't move quickly. Less so second goal but again not quick to move

Big step down on what we have


RE: Button? - Tom Joad - 01-09-2022

Definitely two schools of thought on Button.


RE: Button? - Hopalong - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 11:38 AM)oldun Wrote: Good enough?

Fine margins, would Sam have saved the two shots for the goals?  

He's not as good as Sam so it weakens the team in a key position. 

I don't think Sam will go til the summer so hopefully nothing to worry about til next season, but it's likely he''ll move on to cash in on his Bosman status.   Can't really blame him.


RE: Button? - Super_Slav - 01-09-2022

If we are to have any chance of promotion - Johnstone needs to stay.


RE: Button? - Remi_Moses - 01-09-2022

It's really is up to Johnstone. 
His signing on fee goes up every day, so couldn't blame him if he delays his move until the summer.
Will it damage his England chances  if he stays is probably an important consideration.
I'd prefer him to stay and I see Button only as a fair backup. Palmer however has done great things in the lower league's, maybe it's time we gave him a chance.
With Palmer and Griffith's in reserve we have excellent goal keeper cover now and for many years to come.


RE: Button? - Mickyfudge - 01-10-2022

I bet the Johnstone haters are getting worried now that button actually has to prove himself


RE: Button? - standitupbackstick - 01-10-2022

At fault for the 1st goal on Satdee but maybe a little rusty. I think he'd be ok for now.


RE: Button? - CA Baggie - 01-10-2022

Beaten at his near post twice, maybe not completely at fault but no keeper likes that on their record and he got done twice.

AOTS as the sweeper keeper too but did pull off a couple of decent saves too. He’s certainly not the worst keeper we’ve ever had but he’s far from the best either. Will be a downgrade on SJ but if Sam does leave and we can spend the money improving other areas then we may be stronger as a whole albeit weaker in that department.

Alex Palmer is 25 ffs, if he’s not good enough now I doubt he ever will.