WBAUnofficial
VI criticism - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: VI criticism (/showthread.php?tid=23367)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: VI criticism - Peachy - 01-04-2022

(01-04-2022, 01:24 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Revision to the mean or decline? That’s the question isn’t it? Are we now where we should be, is this a short term blip or a decline.

I think until we get to the seasons end we won’t know.

In 19/20 we won 4 in 20 from January and got promoted on what we did in the first 23 games. So I’m willing to see whether the decline, if it is one, is terminal or short lived.

Also it’s not head in sand it’s trying to balance what I believe, what is this squad is not as good as we think it is with whether the manager is getting the most out of it. I think that is something we won’t know until May.

All valid points Burley. Lets see where we end up but I personally believe we should be closer to the top 2 than we are and I want us to be pushing them all the way.


RE: VI criticism - Hopalong - 01-04-2022

(01-04-2022, 09:21 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 12:06 AM)Squid Wrote: The same people who lauded the passion of Bilic, howled about Allardyce sitting down like he didn't care are now claiming that Val is some angry out of control man.

Doesn't sit well with me this.

Hmm a brand new poster comes on saying this and you use the term the same people?

I loved Slav's kick every ball attitude, hated BFS, but not for his lack of appearing to be bothered, although that never helped. Have zero issues with how Six has acted on the touchline, even with the silliness against Cardiff, just have a problem with his seeming inability to change things about when games aren't going our way.

Totally don't get the calls to give him 3 transfer windows either, but he'll get them due to his contract.

(01-04-2022, 09:17 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 08:38 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Do we really need another thread slagging off Val?

I can't recall any manager getting this amount of stick before. I understand performances and results aren't what folks expect, but we're hardly having a disastrous season, and the amount of criticism is borderline silly.

It's exactly the same as when Big Dave would not win a match as convincingly as we should.

Bizarrely Bilic's team were shite for half a year in the championship and he never received the level of vitriol that either Big Dave or Val received. I guess some are swayed by a media friendly persona

I never got the stuff aimed at Dave, other than he appeared to have lost control towards the end, Bilic I criticised, I was one of the few asking questions about Livermore after the pandemic and got shot down on here (it's now the trendy thing to be doing), but mostly lauded due to giving me an enjoyable most of a season with entertaining football that yielded enough results to get us promoted.

Six simply hasn't given us enough to deserve plaudits and the free ride that some are calling for. That's what I don't get.

Thing is MD,  if we'd scored 3 or 4 of the numerous chances we've missed (and not defended like keystone cops at Swansea for example) we'd be top of the league - not forgetting Robinson's perfectly good disallowed goal at Bournemouth...very fine margins indeed


RE: VI criticism - MrFizz - 01-04-2022

(01-04-2022, 01:40 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Val is human, and the club is in a far from perfect state.

Whilst for me there are a few things counting against him - notably his predictability during game management, team selection over recent weeks, the fact that we seem to have effectively lost some players (Snodgrass and Phillips, the latter of whom really hasn't contributed enough for me as a senior player) and most notably the seemingly blind faith in a thoroughly decent but clearly underperforming captain - there are a few things to his credit. He is giving the youngsters a chance, he seems to be partially succeeding in getting a tune out of Grant, Robbo (when he plays him) and his trying to work with Diangana. And to be fair, we are still in touch.

But for me, the squad isn't really good enough to consider ourselves promotion candidates elect. And I think that Val is hamstrung by this, especially against the expectation that we all say we don't have when we are lying at the foot of the EPL and want to start over again, bomb them all out, start from the ground up etc., but seem to magically regain the inverse attitude again by the curtain opener in mid-August.

Under Big Dave, I think the squad clearly was head-and-shoulders good enough, and Slav just about proved this the following year. But this time around I am not so sure. I think that some of the transfer crimes of the past have caught up with us, severely impacted upon the budget (and consequently the team selection) to the extent Val has had to work with what he's got, to a more counterproductive extent than either Slav or Big Dave had to.

Add to that the TD woes and the ensuing shambles that occurred which actually led to Val, and it appears that he really wasn't joining all that steady a ship.

So in effect, he's had far less wriggle room, and I think it was an easier job for both of the previous Chump managers than it is for Val. I think both Slav and Big Dave had more than enough quality at their disposal to mask their shortcomings short-term. To me, a fine squad in terms of not just numbers (we've seldom enjoyed a huge roster of players) but quality in addition, not only makes it harder to get points on the board, but to bring those youngsters in confidently also.

Losing two key defensive players early on hasn't helped much, and seems to coincide with when we appeared to lose our guile. Also a couple of players haven't returned with quite the same form.

But I do think that - had Val had either BD or Slav's squad to inherit, we wouldn't be quite so impatient with it all now. Impossible to say of course, but to me the imperfections of the manager are not necessarily the biggest factor at play here. It would be much fairer to judge his work when he has a few more of his own tools to work with, and I doubt replacing him now would result in a candidate with fewer imperfections any more than it would fix what remains wrong behind the scenes.

:Need a round of applause emoji:


RE: VI criticism - Ada - 01-04-2022

(01-04-2022, 01:40 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Val is human, and the club is in a far from perfect state.

Whilst for me there are a few things counting against him - notably his predictability during game management, team selection over recent weeks, the fact that we seem to have effectively lost some players (Snodgrass and Phillips, the latter of whom really hasn't contributed enough for me as a senior player) and most notably the seemingly blind faith in a thoroughly decent but clearly underperforming captain - there are a few things to his credit. He is giving the youngsters a chance, he seems to be partially succeeding in getting a tune out of Grant, Robbo (when he plays him) and his trying to work with Diangana. And to be fair, we are still in touch.

But for me, the squad isn't really good enough to consider ourselves promotion candidates elect. And I think that Val is hamstrung by this, especially against the expectation that we all say we don't have when we are lying at the foot of the EPL and want to start over again, bomb them all out, start from the ground up etc., but seem to magically regain the inverse attitude again by the curtain opener in mid-August.

Under Big Dave, I think the squad clearly was head-and-shoulders good enough, and Slav just about proved this the following year. But this time around I am not so sure. I think that some of the transfer crimes of the past have caught up with us, severely impacted upon the budget (and consequently the team selection) to the extent Val has had to work with what he's got, to a more counterproductive extent than either Slav or Big Dave had to.

Add to that the TD woes and the ensuing shambles that occurred which actually led to Val, and it appears that he really wasn't joining all that steady a ship.

So in effect, he's had far less wriggle room, and I think it was an easier job for both of the previous Chump managers than it is for Val. I think both Slav and Big Dave had more than enough quality at their disposal to mask their shortcomings short-term. To me, a fine squad in terms of not just numbers (we've seldom enjoyed a huge roster of players) but quality in addition, not only makes it harder to get points on the board, but to bring those youngsters in confidently also.

Losing two key defensive players early on hasn't helped much, and seems to coincide with when we appeared to lose our guile. Also a couple of players haven't returned with quite the same form.

But I do think that - had Val had either BD or Slav's squad to inherit, we wouldn't be quite so impatient with it all now. Impossible to say of course, but to me the imperfections of the manager are not necessarily the biggest factor at play here. It would be much fairer to judge his work when he has a few more of his own tools to work with, and I doubt replacing him now would result in a candidate with fewer imperfections any more than it would fix what remains wrong behind the scenes.

All above good points. I have questioned if VI is under-performing or over performing atm given the quality of the squad.  Most of the players aren’t playing better than they were at the start of the season, and or, the quality of the performance has declined over the course of the season - certainly not pressing or bullying teams like we have.  The trajectory is not upward and hasn’t been for a while.  

His reaction to the penalty was OTT and to me it did seem to ignite the whole melee.  Pretty sure he’ll be charged and punished.  It was a bit OTT like his reaction to the winner at Peterborough.  

Personally he wouldn’t have got the BD and Bilic Squads promoted as his style brings the game down to the lowest common denominator - a type of kick and rush.  Comments about Livermore created an impression he was not droppable.  Don’t think our new centre forward will make too much difference, but would be happy to be wrong.  If I saw the press working again I would change my perspective but the doesn’t seem to have worked or been tried in a while (at home as haven’t watched away).


RE: VI criticism - Dial M for Mick - 01-04-2022

(01-04-2022, 07:51 PM)Ada Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 01:40 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Val is human, and the club is in a far from perfect state.

Whilst for me there are a few things counting against him - notably his predictability during game management, team selection over recent weeks, the fact that we seem to have effectively lost some players (Snodgrass and Phillips, the latter of whom really hasn't contributed enough for me as a senior player) and most notably the seemingly blind faith in a thoroughly decent but clearly underperforming captain - there are a few things to his credit. He is giving the youngsters a chance, he seems to be partially succeeding in getting a tune out of Grant, Robbo (when he plays him) and his trying to work with Diangana. And to be fair, we are still in touch.

But for me, the squad isn't really good enough to consider ourselves promotion candidates elect. And I think that Val is hamstrung by this, especially against the expectation that we all say we don't have when we are lying at the foot of the EPL and want to start over again, bomb them all out, start from the ground up etc., but seem to magically regain the inverse attitude again by the curtain opener in mid-August.

Under Big Dave, I think the squad clearly was head-and-shoulders good enough, and Slav just about proved this the following year. But this time around I am not so sure. I think that some of the transfer crimes of the past have caught up with us, severely impacted upon the budget (and consequently the team selection) to the extent Val has had to work with what he's got, to a more counterproductive extent than either Slav or Big Dave had to.

Add to that the TD woes and the ensuing shambles that occurred which actually led to Val, and it appears that he really wasn't joining all that steady a ship.

So in effect, he's had far less wriggle room, and I think it was an easier job for both of the previous Chump managers than it is for Val. I think both Slav and Big Dave had more than enough quality at their disposal to mask their shortcomings short-term. To me, a fine squad in terms of not just numbers (we've seldom enjoyed a huge roster of players) but quality in addition, not only makes it harder to get points on the board, but to bring those youngsters in confidently also.

Losing two key defensive players early on hasn't helped much, and seems to coincide with when we appeared to lose our guile. Also a couple of players haven't returned with quite the same form.

But I do think that - had Val had either BD or Slav's squad to inherit, we wouldn't be quite so impatient with it all now. Impossible to say of course, but to me the imperfections of the manager are not necessarily the biggest factor at play here. It would be much fairer to judge his work when he has a few more of his own tools to work with, and I doubt replacing him now would result in a candidate with fewer imperfections any more than it would fix what remains wrong behind the scenes.

All above good points. I have questioned if VI is under-performing or over performing atm given the quality of the squad.  Most of the players aren’t playing better than they were at the start of the season, and or, the quality of the performance has declined over the course of the season - certainly not pressing or bullying teams like we have.  The trajectory is not upward and hasn’t been for a while.  

His reaction to the penalty was OTT and to me it did seem to ignite the whole melee.  Pretty sure he’ll be charged and punished.  It was a bit OTT like his reaction to the winner at Peterborough.  

Personally he wouldn’t have got the BD and Bilic Squads promoted as his style brings the game down to the lowest common denominator - a type of kick and rush.  Comments about Livermore created an impression he was not droppable.  Don’t think our new centre forward will make too much difference, but would be happy to be wrong.  If I saw the press working again I would change my perspective but the doesn’t seem to have worked or been tried in a while (at home as haven’t watched away).

Tony Mowbray stormed onto the pitch to try to blame the ref for conceding a last minute goal to Sheffield Wednesday when he was here. His actions that night were no different to Ismael's on Sunday and yet the reaction to it is completely different. One has to wonder why.


RE: VI criticism - wba13 - 01-04-2022

What Ismael did is only what the likes of Klopp,Gaurdiola, Mourino and as another poster stated Mowbray did. He was passionate about a decision that went against us again. I love to to see passion expressed and it was not over the top.
Also read today from Robinson that they love being at the club and there is no negativity.
Our manager will be here a while we are building a young and vibrant Squad not like the older sides of the past. Hopefully eventually all our younger players will gel and prosper together. I’m right behind him and totally fed up of changing managers let’s give him the chance not 6 months like some of you want.


RE: VI criticism - Spandaubaggie - 01-04-2022

We should actually look at the squad at the start of the season. We really were down to the bare bones with 4 or 5 elder statesmen, a couple of expensive signings that had underperformed, and not a lot else.
Ismael has a rebuild not seen for many seasons.
Really I urge those spitting venom to look at the squad left at the end of 20/21.


RE: VI criticism - Bob Fossil - 01-05-2022

(01-04-2022, 11:36 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: We should actually look at the squad at the start of the season. We really were down to the bare bones with 4 or 5 elder statesmen, a couple of expensive signings that had underperformed, and not a lot else.
Ismael has a rebuild not seen for many seasons.
Really I urge those spitting venom to look at the squad left at the end of 20/21.

I don't think anyone disputes that Spandau, it's the regression that's alarming. We did have decent players, who now appear to be getting worse. Townsend, Furlong, Ajayi, Diangana, Robinson, although not world beaters to start with, all appear to be regressing.

Couple this with the lack of diversity in the set up, sticking with under-performing stalwarts and poor in-game management and Val doesn't appear to be doing much to halt the slide, other than buying Dike.
Don't get me wrong, I hope Dike really is the answer to all our prayers but that's a hell of a lot of expectation on a 21 year old, with only half a season in England to his name.

He's making a tough job, tougher, in my opinion.


RE: VI criticism - HawkingsHalfpint - 01-05-2022

All good points, Bob.

I’ve no major issue with VI’s reaction. As said above many of the top names are guilty of this, Slav lost his cool a few games in last term (against Everton IIRC?). It happens. The ref was piss poor for both sides, but as the game drew on it seemed he had some kind of agenda to want the result to stand.

It’s a poor example to set to the players, especially after the Mowatt incident. Who he now has less justification to be annoyed at. His problem, I guess, but it could be a sign the seams are splitting within a squad I suspect a few incumbents can also see what’s wrong.

So, perhaps in common with these, I’ve far more of an issue with why certain players aren’t performing, why some have vanished, why his club captain isn’t doing more on and off the pitch. It’s a tough hand he’s been dealt, but he chose to sit at the table; yes we’ve had rotten luck at times but to an extent you do make your own. Losing your shit over a last minute penalty appeal against a very lacklustre CCFC (following a dreadful result against WR’s DC) suggests to me he isn’t making a lot right now.


RE: VI criticism - Peachy - 01-05-2022

(01-05-2022, 02:14 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: All good points, Bob.

I’ve no major issue with VI’s reaction. As said above many of the top names are guilty of this, Slav lost his cool a few games in last term (against Everton IIRC?). It happens. The ref was piss poor for both sides, but as the game drew on it seemed he had some kind of agenda to want the result to stand.

It’s a poor example to set to the players, especially after the Mowatt incident. Who he now has less justification to be annoyed at. His problem, I guess, but it could be a sign the seams are splitting within a squad I suspect a few incumbents can also see what’s wrong.

So, perhaps in common with these, I’ve far more of an issue with why certain players aren’t performing, why some have vanished, why his club captain isn’t doing more on and off the pitch. It’s a tough hand he’s been dealt, but he chose to sit at the table; yes we’ve had rotten luck at times but to an extent you do make your own. Losing your shit over a last minute penalty appeal against a very lacklustre CCFC (following a dreadful result against WR’s DC) suggests to me he isn’t making a lot right now.

And this is my issue. Just to restate I dont want him sacked but if you look at the squad he started the season with they are the same players. Those same players make up the same team that started well this season yet we are showing bottom 6 form over the last 9 games. 

For me there are more factors at play than simply missing chances. We are rushed in everything we do as an attacking force. Everything is 100 miles an hour and lacking football intelligence. The players look scared to have the ball at times. For me central midfield is just a big an issue as the forward line. We have a captain who seemingly cant be dropped and along with Mowatt and Molumby they are all too similar.

We also only have one way of playing and it's all so predictable as has been proven by so many shite teams easily taking points off us. We've been worked out and yet we've blindy walked into the next game and the next doing the exact same thing and hoped for a different result. 

All of the above is on the manager. Shite squad or not its irrelevant. Those same players were doing well and now they aren't and Val is at the helm. He needs now to prove he's a coach. A coach that finds other ways to get a result.

I hate us changing managers. I want him to succeed but he needs to be more flexible imo. Both in terms of his approach and his picking of favourites.