![]() |
|
Youth, and our struggles with it. - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Youth, and our struggles with it. (/showthread.php?tid=22177) |
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Shabby Russian - 10-22-2021 Good subject to tackle Birdman. Seems to me we struggle to take promising 16_17 year olds, and realise their potential. And this failure is a factor when good young players have to decide whether to stay at the club or move away. No one has ever given me a satisfactory explanation why Ferguson was so eager to get away. I'm not sure I buy the money explanation, I don't think our offer would have been that far from the one he got from Palace. And I do think we need to be brave in giving a chance to younger players. People say they will make mistakes and cost points but that can happen anyway. I remember Reading away under Clarke . Two up, and we made a sub, had a choice between Rosenberg and Nabi. Logic dictated bringer the former on because there was less a risk we would blow the lead so that's what we did. We blew the lead anyway. Not suggesting history would have been different if we had brought on Nabi, but it does bring into question the idea that giving young players a chance will harm results. RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Birdman1811 - 10-22-2021 (10-22-2021, 11:24 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Good subject to tackle Birdman. Excellent point. That season, we played Man Utd at Old Trafford, in desperation we had to use Thorne, who ended up being our motm. Then he couldn't even get a sub appearance once Mulumbu and Yacob were back, no matter form, tiredness or anything, and he got fucked off. Injuries ruined him of course down the road. But our record with this us poor, and we need to improve. If only to sell them to make some money to boost our poor revenue! RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - GunsOfNavarone - 10-22-2021 (10-22-2021, 11:29 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(10-22-2021, 11:24 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Good subject to tackle Birdman. Ironically enough George Thorne then went on to play 90 minutes in the 3-2 defeat to Reading as described by Shabby before doing his cruciate. Sliding doors. RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Hopalong - 10-22-2021 It doesn't matter how good they are they have to be at least as good or better than whoever is currently in the shirt to get a chance. The division we're in and quality of the first team squad are decisive factors in whether they can make the step up. We have lost quite a few when in the Prem and latterly with this Villa nonsense. But none of the players we have lost were good enough at the time to make the breakthrough. This happens at every club unless they are virtually bankrupt and have no choice. If they are good enough they will find their way into the team. O'Shea and Ferguson did. I see no-one else at the moment - even Tulloch and Castro are nowhere near. It really isn't worth worrying about, 'nature' will take its course. We have a first team squad who will deliver play-offs minimum it's just a question of whether they can go one step further. We should have a better indication of that at 1430 a week tomorrow. RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Ted Maul - 10-22-2021 Our academy is rubbish if it can't produce a better option than Jordan Hugill. Why we wouldn't have Faal or Cleary on the bench instead of him I've no idea. Castro terrifies me, like having Somen Tchoyi in the middle of the park. However, I would be really disappointed if the likes of Gardner-Hickman, Ingram and Tulloch don't get at least some time on the pitch with the first team. Ironically I reckon the youngster most likely to nail down a spot in the team isn't even at the club at the moment. The #1 shirt is Josh Griffiths' once Johnstone leaves. Palmer another we could have arguably given more chances to. RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Birdman1811 - 10-22-2021 Palmer is unfortunate Johnstone has stayed. He could have pushed Button. But Johnstone is far, far better obviously. Griffiths could be absolutely fantastic for us, he's doing very well again this season. RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - UCEbaggie - 10-22-2021 It’s a vicious circle. Like in all professions, people that are new and inexperienced at what they are being asked to do will make more mistakes than those who’ve done it for years. They might also have the potential to do far more than the older heads but in order to realise that potential they have to be allowed to make mistakes and learn from them. I’d say that is hard for a couple of reasons:- 1. High profile nature of this particular “industry” and the likelihood of a Manager losing his job quite quickly if too many mistakes are made across the board. Therefore - minimise the risk of those mistakes happening by not playing those most likely to make them. 2. The frankly pathetic nature of a significant minority of football supporters. The Albion no worse or better in this regard but they annoy me more than others because I witness them acting like utter morons. I’ve spoken about the frankly ludicrous levels of anger boiling close to the surface in lots of football supporters and it never really needs much of an excuse to come exploding to the surface. They might initially cut a youngster some slack but in my opinion this margin of error doesn’t last long enough to accommodate for the period of time when that player is learning his trade - and therefore making more mistakes. It didn’t take very long before prospects like Leko and Harper were suddenly being dismissed as “lazy” having a “bad attitude” and lacking “football intelligence”. I have my own views on why some of those particular criticisms were levelled at the two lads I mentioned. I’m sure you can work it out. Final point - despite all I’ve said above there is always the chance that the youngsters just aren’t good enough at that particular time. Bit like football managers really. Sometimes it just happens for a certain player at a certain club for sometimes quite hard to define reasons. RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Birdman1811 - 10-22-2021 (10-22-2021, 11:51 AM)Hopalong Wrote: It doesn't matter how good they are they have to be at least as good or better than whoever is currently in the shirt to get a chance. And therein lies the problem. No academy graduate is going to be better than a seasoned pro, unless they're uniquely gifted. So if we always go for that logic, chances are we'll very rarely develop anyone. O'Shea and Ferguson weren't considered better at first at all, they were given chances to see if they could develop. They did. Some will, some won't. But less chances you give, less chance any will. RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Hopalong - 10-22-2021 (10-22-2021, 11:24 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Good subject to tackle Birdman. Apparently we offered him more money which together with the fee of £11(13? )m agreed 5 months previously are the two key points of our case. Absolutely disgraceful how long this is taking. Covid is absolutely no excuse. RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - ChamonixBaggie - 10-22-2021 I would say its easier for some clubs to give yoof a chance when they have less to lose. Man City or Chelsea have the freedom to bring on 18 yr olds when they're winning 3-0 against the likes of us. Clubs who are reasonably safe from relegation but not threatening to win anything can do so as well, because why not. Clubs like us, who are either desperately fighting relegation or desperate to go up - have a much smaller margin of error and less leeway for bringing on Youth because the consequences (for the manager) are much higher. A manager expected to finish anywhere from 7-17th doesn't have too much to worry about in the grand scheme of things. If our direction as a club continues on its current path then I think we'll be seeing a lot more youth in the first team given that we'll be a skint mid-table championship make-up-the-numbers club praying for our next Megson. |