RE: Silwood - Lillwall's left foot - 09-30-2021
This is the first, but won't be the last. it was a post in an open media forum and he was shopped by somebody who was quite rightly disgusted by it. He then further established his dubious character by trying to billy bullshit his way out of it to the police (and try any variation on buffoon and see if baboon appears in the spell check) and showing zero remorse. That's what dropped him the eight weeks as much as the original offense.
But lets be clear, he has not been convicted for saying "something we might not like" or for being "offensive". He has been found guilty of the specific offence of racial abuse and carrying out a hate crime. These are laws that most reasonable people would agree should be enforced, rather than an example of oppressive governance cracking down on free speech. SOTV seems to thinks that racism should only become unlawful if it manifests itself in the form of inciting violence, stalking, harrasment or actual physical harm which are all different and equally vile offences.
In the society we now live in racism and racial abuse are a criminal offence in themselves.....racists beware what you post I guess!!
RE: Silwood - FenlandBoing - 09-30-2021
(09-30-2021, 07:36 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: For me, he can't complain. He must have expected a life ban from the club, which he has received, and if an example is made of him with a custodial sentence, then I won't be losing any sleep over it.
As has been alluded to earlier though, a young lady was banned from driving for the 6th time yesterday. She blatantly ignores her driving bans, and this time was twice the legal limit for drink at 6.30 AM, and failed a drugs test. We have the magistrate wishing her good luck in The Priory.
This simply has to end in a custodial sentence for her, otherwise many people (including me) will question the justice of it all.
I seem to recall a father and son mowed down on Boxing Day? Somewhere in the Black Country about 20 years ago by a drink driver who had loads of convictions and bans for driving over the limit etc. How long before she does something similar - give her the choice of a very long sentence or incapacitation so she can't ever drive again.
RE: Silwood - Sotv - 09-30-2021
(09-30-2021, 09:26 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (09-30-2021, 08:56 PM)Sotv Wrote: (09-30-2021, 06:44 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Racial abuse is a civil liberty now?
I think there's a pretty distinct line between racial abuse and name calling.
Yes as uncomfortable as it may be, as long as there is no call for violence then its no business of the state to dictate what people can or can't say.
As I say, right now it's racism which the media have successfully whipped everyone into a frenzy about.
Next it will be anti vaxxers getting jailed. As stupid as I think they are, they have a right to talk shit.
The idea you shut people up with the law for saying things people don't like is dangerous and intolerant.
Far better idiots are exposed and called out for what they are. Far better ideas are challenged and defeated by argument and reason rather than the iron fist of the state.
It actually goes far deeper than just speech. Once the state can ban speech the next is ideas.
I studied philosophy and its really interesting to see how philosophers of a certain time had to be really careful when discussing metaphysics in order to not fall foul of the church. The soviets interfered with scientific research I believe because they didn't want certain truths known.
Is a world.of censorship one you want to live in?
(09-30-2021, 08:55 PM)wba13 Wrote: (09-30-2021, 08:39 PM)Sotv Wrote: (09-30-2021, 06:55 PM)Duffers Wrote: People have a right to be racist!!! Ultimately this is about rights of individuals to say things that others may find offensive
It's racism today, tomorrow it could be something else. The issue is the curtailment of people saying stuff that hasn't physically harmed anyone.
If we shut up anyone who says stuff we don't like, where does it stop?
It’s racism today,tomorrow or the day after that it will always be racism, stop trying to defend the undefendable. He should not have done it and deserves everything he got.
You really haven't got it have you?
No what he said was not pleasant and shouldn't have been said, but to jail someone over calling someone a baboon is fucking ridiculous.
Go and look at other countries or periods in history. Dictatorships very rarely start out as such, they need people willing to go along with the slow chipping away at freedoms.
States always perform a mission creep when it comes to laws designed to tighten their grip. Just look at section 60 for instance.
People are being hoodwinked into giving up their freedoms by having bogeymen put in front of them.
I've read it all in-depth now SoTV and the more I read the more I'm surprised by the sentence.
I thought I'd read that he made a fluffy of racist remarks. It appears he just made the comment on a thread. However, someone had made a comment about white lives matter on the thread he joined, which would lead me to think the context of 'baboon' in his post was racist. Incidentally I've called my son, who is white, an ape and a baboon on many an occasion, but it is all about context.
You are eloquently fighting your corner, but many will shut you down as the subject is so touchy at a hypersensitive time. I will take the racism subject out of the equation in the grand scheme of what you're saying too.
Incidentally, I think Silwood must be at least a low-level 'racist' to not have back-tracked throughout this lengthy process. He's a fool. However, being a 'buffoon' which he clearly is, should be no reason for jail. My spell check made baboon bacon, by the way!
You've given us food for thought, as unpalatable as it is.
Incidentally, my daughter is set to do a degree in Philosophy next year, currently reading René Descartes’ ‘Meditations and Other Metaphysical Writings, and despite her being very 'woke' she said she found the sentence excessive.
I still have no sympathy whatsoever for Silwood, but that is quite apart from the point of civil Liberty you have raised.
Oh I agree he is a racist and shouldn’t have said he what he did but jailing him is not the best way to deal with idiots like this. I don’t have sympathy for him as a person but do think this is a dangerous road to go down. As it is, my son boxes at a gym where Sawyers mom is involved with the football club who also train in the same facilities. I’ve met her and she does a great job for her community, I’m certainly not denying there are disadvantages and unique challenges people of colour face in our society.
Anyway, I’m not going to involve myself any further, I’ve made the point I wanted to and as you say, it’s such a hypersensitive subject it’s difficult for many to think clearly.
On the subject of your daughter’s studies I hope she really enjoys it and i hope studying philosophy gives her the tools to really examine arguments and ideas. Descartes is interesting, ask her what she thinks about the problem of the lonely ghost or semantic loneliness I think my lecturer called it. I quite liked David Hume but my favourite branch was most definitely moral and political philosophy. It really has the power to make you question your assumptions and ideas that just seem obvious at first.
RE: Silwood - Spandaubaggie - 09-30-2021
(09-30-2021, 09:59 PM)Sotv Wrote: (09-30-2021, 09:26 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (09-30-2021, 08:56 PM)Sotv Wrote: (09-30-2021, 06:44 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Racial abuse is a civil liberty now?
I think there's a pretty distinct line between racial abuse and name calling.
Yes as uncomfortable as it may be, as long as there is no call for violence then its no business of the state to dictate what people can or can't say.
As I say, right now it's racism which the media have successfully whipped everyone into a frenzy about.
Next it will be anti vaxxers getting jailed. As stupid as I think they are, they have a right to talk shit.
The idea you shut people up with the law for saying things people don't like is dangerous and intolerant.
Far better idiots are exposed and called out for what they are. Far better ideas are challenged and defeated by argument and reason rather than the iron fist of the state.
It actually goes far deeper than just speech. Once the state can ban speech the next is ideas.
I studied philosophy and its really interesting to see how philosophers of a certain time had to be really careful when discussing metaphysics in order to not fall foul of the church. The soviets interfered with scientific research I believe because they didn't want certain truths known.
Is a world.of censorship one you want to live in?
(09-30-2021, 08:55 PM)wba13 Wrote: (09-30-2021, 08:39 PM)Sotv Wrote: Ultimately this is about rights of individuals to say things that others may find offensive
It's racism today, tomorrow it could be something else. The issue is the curtailment of people saying stuff that hasn't physically harmed anyone.
If we shut up anyone who says stuff we don't like, where does it stop?
It’s racism today,tomorrow or the day after that it will always be racism, stop trying to defend the undefendable. He should not have done it and deserves everything he got.
You really haven't got it have you?
No what he said was not pleasant and shouldn't have been said, but to jail someone over calling someone a baboon is fucking ridiculous.
Go and look at other countries or periods in history. Dictatorships very rarely start out as such, they need people willing to go along with the slow chipping away at freedoms.
States always perform a mission creep when it comes to laws designed to tighten their grip. Just look at section 60 for instance.
People are being hoodwinked into giving up their freedoms by having bogeymen put in front of them.
I've read it all in-depth now SoTV and the more I read the more I'm surprised by the sentence.
I thought I'd read that he made a fluffy of racist remarks. It appears he just made the comment on a thread. However, someone had made a comment about white lives matter on the thread he joined, which would lead me to think the context of 'baboon' in his post was racist. Incidentally I've called my son, who is white, an ape and a baboon on many an occasion, but it is all about context.
You are eloquently fighting your corner, but many will shut you down as the subject is so touchy at a hypersensitive time. I will take the racism subject out of the equation in the grand scheme of what you're saying too.
Incidentally, I think Silwood must be at least a low-level 'racist' to not have back-tracked throughout this lengthy process. He's a fool. However, being a 'buffoon' which he clearly is, should be no reason for jail. My spell check made baboon bacon, by the way!
You've given us food for thought, as unpalatable as it is.
Incidentally, my daughter is set to do a degree in Philosophy next year, currently reading René Descartes’ ‘Meditations and Other Metaphysical Writings, and despite her being very 'woke' she said she found the sentence excessive.
I still have no sympathy whatsoever for Silwood, but that is quite apart from the point of civil Liberty you have raised.
Oh I agree he is a racist and shouldn’t have said he what he did but jailing him is not the best way to deal with idiots like this. I don’t have sympathy for him as a person but do think this is a dangerous road to go down. As it is, my son boxes at a gym where Sawyers mom is involved with the football club who also train in the same facilities. I’ve met her and she does a great job for her community, I’m certainly not denying there are disadvantages and unique challenges people of colour face in our society.
Anyway, I’m not going to involve myself any further, I’ve made the point I wanted to and as you say, it’s such a hypersensitive subject it’s difficult for many to think clearly.
On the subject of your daughter’s studies I hope she really enjoys it and i hope studying philosophy gives her the tools to really examine arguments and ideas. Descartes is interesting, ask her what she thinks about the problem of the lonely ghost or semantic loneliness I think my lecturer called it. I quite liked David Hume but my favourite branch was most definitely moral and political philosophy. It really has the power to make you question your assumptions and ideas that just seem obvious at first.
Cheers chap. By the way fluffy should have been flurry. Bloody spell check!
RE: Silwood - Malcolm Tucker - 09-30-2021
(09-30-2021, 06:29 PM)Sotv Wrote: (09-30-2021, 06:25 PM)wba13 Wrote: (09-30-2021, 06:20 PM)Sotv Wrote: Ridiculous sentence. Whilst what he said was offensive and undeniably racist, this is a huge over reaction and I think we all know why.
Let's look at the facts.
He made a.comment that did not incite any violence or a further commissioning of crime.
He did not stalk or directly harass Sawyers. The comment was made on a Facebook group, in fact if the police hadn't shown it to Sawyers chances are he wouldn't have seen it.
So what we have here is a man jailed for 2 months for the crime of calling someone names.
If we allow people to be jailed for nothing more than saying things that make others uncomfortable or are deemed offensive, where do we stop?
As far as I am concerned people should be free under the law to say what they like as long as this doesn't encourage violence. That should go for the likes of Louis Farrakhan, Paul Golding or anyone else. If someone else doesn't like it they are free to argue their case as well.
Allowing the state to dictate what is and isn't offensive or permitted speech and jailing people for transgressions of this is the road to dictatorship. You only need to see how China uses these laws to understand where this ends up.
The notion we have a good deal of people so whipped up into their own right on frenzy of disgust by the media game that they are cheering on this erosion of a basic liberty is frightening.
Sorry I have no sympathy. In today’s day and age you keep your gob shut or in his case his finger in his pocket. And its attitudes like that are so worrying.
You can’t even racially abuse people on the internet anymore. Nanny state!
RE: Silwood - Remi_Moses - 10-01-2021
The sentencing is all wrong, IMO he should have had 10 days in jail so he could reflect on the shame he bought on himself, his family and our club. Then 2 years community service. With every Saturday used in helping people less fortunate then himself. Especially focussing on ethnic minorities and people of colour seams appropriate.
Reminomics says let him be of use rather then locked up. Together with a large fine based on his ability to pay.
RE: Silwood - Fido - 10-01-2021
(10-01-2021, 06:31 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The sentencing is all wrong, IMO he should have had 10 days in jail so he could reflect on the shame he bought on himself, his family and our club. Then 2 years community service. With every Saturday used in helping people less fortunate then himself. Especially focussing on ethnic minorities and people of colour seams appropriate.
Reminomics says let him be of use rather then locked up. Together with a large fine based on his ability to pay.
It would seem a more sensible way of doing things. But surely this is also a useful national news story as well. Being a bastard to people of a different skin colour has severe implications and lands you in a world of shit. We hear most weeks about someone getting racially abused online and no ramifications.
RE: Silwood - Remi_Moses - 10-01-2021
(10-01-2021, 06:54 AM)Fido Wrote: (10-01-2021, 06:31 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The sentencing is all wrong, IMO he should have had 10 days in jail so he could reflect on the shame he bought on himself, his family and our club. Then 2 years community service. With every Saturday used in helping people less fortunate then himself. Especially focussing on ethnic minorities and people of colour seams appropriate.
Reminomics says let him be of use rather then locked up. Together with a large fine based on his ability to pay.
It would seem a more sensible way of doing things. But surely this is also a useful national news story as well. Being a bastard to people of a different skin colour has severe implications and lands you in a world of shit. We hear most weeks about someone getting racially abused online and no ramifications.
The public highlighting of such deplorable behaviour is a clear message, that these type of insults has no place in our society.
RE: Silwood - Borin' Baggie - 10-01-2021
(09-30-2021, 08:56 PM)Sotv Wrote: (09-30-2021, 06:44 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Racial abuse is a civil liberty now?
I think there's a pretty distinct line between racial abuse and name calling.
Yes as uncomfortable as it may be, as long as there is no call for violence then its no business of the state to dictate what people can or can't say.
As I say, right now it's racism which the media have successfully whipped everyone into a frenzy about.
Next it will be anti vaxxers getting jailed. As stupid as I think they are, they have a right to talk shit.
The idea you shut people up with the law for saying things people don't like is dangerous and intolerant.
Far better idiots are exposed and called out for what they are. Far better ideas are challenged and defeated by argument and reason rather than the iron fist of the state.
It actually goes far deeper than just speech. Once the state can ban speech the next is ideas.
I studied philosophy and its really interesting to see how philosophers of a certain time had to be really careful when discussing metaphysics in order to not fall foul of the church. The soviets interfered with scientific research I believe because they didn't want certain truths known.
Is a world.of censorship one you want to live in?
This is not a freedom of speech issue, please do not conflate it as such.
Freedom of speech is about the right to present dissenting opinion, not about protecting abuse. Calling a black person a baboon while accepting the racial connotations is not a dissenting opinion, it's personal abuse based upon racial characteristics. There is a very clear and distinct line between this and more questionable FOS cases.
RE: Silwood - Fido - 10-01-2021
(10-01-2021, 07:06 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-30-2021, 08:56 PM)Sotv Wrote: (09-30-2021, 06:44 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Racial abuse is a civil liberty now?
I think there's a pretty distinct line between racial abuse and name calling.
Yes as uncomfortable as it may be, as long as there is no call for violence then its no business of the state to dictate what people can or can't say.
As I say, right now it's racism which the media have successfully whipped everyone into a frenzy about.
Next it will be anti vaxxers getting jailed. As stupid as I think they are, they have a right to talk shit.
The idea you shut people up with the law for saying things people don't like is dangerous and intolerant.
Far better idiots are exposed and called out for what they are. Far better ideas are challenged and defeated by argument and reason rather than the iron fist of the state.
It actually goes far deeper than just speech. Once the state can ban speech the next is ideas.
I studied philosophy and its really interesting to see how philosophers of a certain time had to be really careful when discussing metaphysics in order to not fall foul of the church. The soviets interfered with scientific research I believe because they didn't want certain truths known.
Is a world.of censorship one you want to live in?
This is not a freedom of speech issue, please do not conflate it as such.
Freedom of speech is about the right to present dissenting opinion, not about protecting abuse. Calling a black person a baboon while accepting the racial connotations is not a dissenting opinion, it's personal abuse based upon racial characteristics. There is a very clear and distinct line between this and more questionable FOS cases.
I agree, BB. I'm wondering though if Sotv's point was about where lines will be drawn in the future about what people find offensive. Calling a prophet of a certain religion a paedo (after a he took a wife at the age of nine, according to their scriptures) would offend millions and cause outrage but it is a opinion that people should be free to state. If so then I get the point. However if this is not the case and he questions any kind of penalty for this kind of offence then I don't.
|