RE: From F365 - Squid - 06-18-2021
(06-17-2021, 03:12 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (06-17-2021, 01:54 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: "That Dowling stayed in his position"? He hasn't - instead he's run off!
I've been unconvinced by Dowling for a while, and the more I'm reading doesn't really change that. He presided over an awful Prem campaign, before which he and Bilic clearly struggled with a unanimous brief. As stated elsewhere, if had he better ideas than Bilic on who we should sign, then he should have exercised greater authority. He didn't. It's arguable that he allowed Bilic to fail by mismanaging the summer at a boardroom level.
Once Bilic was determined not good enough (too late to make a meaningful difference) then he appointed another failure; having quite unceremoniously sacked Bilic on the same night he achieved one of his best results at City. Let's not forget what an embarrassing fuck-up this was. He and Allardyce slowly improved us, but who was pulling the reigns more to identify and get the right players in? And - in any case - it ultimately turned out to be a failure.
He's then basically sought-out Wilder and all but agreed to get him in despite not doing due-diligence with the owners, and been hung out to dry by his second choice in Wagner. Furthermore the reports from ex-youth system coaches is hardly flattering.
So there isn't a great deal of success he can point to with us really. It's certainly a blow that his role is vacant, but the bigger fuck-up was allowing us to be in this position. Which is one that he's helped to engineer.
A shambles of a situation that doesn’t reflect well upon us. But I’m hardly going to look back on him fondly. We’re worse off now than when he joined. Whether or not that’s all his fault is another issue, of course; but he took the role after all, and let two popular managers fail before failing not once but twice to secure long-term replacements for either.
Fair post Hawks.
The biggest success of his career feels like managing to prevent the appointment of Alex Neil and holding out for Bilic who delivered success under a lot of pressure.
Sadly, the fact that his departure may well result in us appointing Alex Neil shows just how much of a failure his tenure has ultimately been.
I thought that Alex Neil chose to get a bigger contract from Preston instead?
And, I'll say this now. I don't think Neil is actually a terrible manager. Fewer flaws than Bilic, IMHO.
RE: From F365 - SW4Baggie - 06-18-2021
(06-18-2021, 08:12 AM)Squid Wrote: (06-17-2021, 03:12 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (06-17-2021, 01:54 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: "That Dowling stayed in his position"? He hasn't - instead he's run off!
I've been unconvinced by Dowling for a while, and the more I'm reading doesn't really change that. He presided over an awful Prem campaign, before which he and Bilic clearly struggled with a unanimous brief. As stated elsewhere, if had he better ideas than Bilic on who we should sign, then he should have exercised greater authority. He didn't. It's arguable that he allowed Bilic to fail by mismanaging the summer at a boardroom level.
Once Bilic was determined not good enough (too late to make a meaningful difference) then he appointed another failure; having quite unceremoniously sacked Bilic on the same night he achieved one of his best results at City. Let's not forget what an embarrassing fuck-up this was. He and Allardyce slowly improved us, but who was pulling the reigns more to identify and get the right players in? And - in any case - it ultimately turned out to be a failure.
He's then basically sought-out Wilder and all but agreed to get him in despite not doing due-diligence with the owners, and been hung out to dry by his second choice in Wagner. Furthermore the reports from ex-youth system coaches is hardly flattering.
So there isn't a great deal of success he can point to with us really. It's certainly a blow that his role is vacant, but the bigger fuck-up was allowing us to be in this position. Which is one that he's helped to engineer.
A shambles of a situation that doesn’t reflect well upon us. But I’m hardly going to look back on him fondly. We’re worse off now than when he joined. Whether or not that’s all his fault is another issue, of course; but he took the role after all, and let two popular managers fail before failing not once but twice to secure long-term replacements for either.
Fair post Hawks.
The biggest success of his career feels like managing to prevent the appointment of Alex Neil and holding out for Bilic who delivered success under a lot of pressure.
Sadly, the fact that his departure may well result in us appointing Alex Neil shows just how much of a failure his tenure has ultimately been.
I thought that Alex Neil chose to get a bigger contract from Preston instead?
And, I'll say this now. I don't think Neil is actually a terrible manager. Fewer flaws than Bilic, IMHO.
Think there were quite a few moving parts...
Jenkins wanted Neil, but Dowling wasn't convinced... Neil was very interested, and let's face it, we'd have given him more money than Preston offered, even with the pay rise...
Realising he wasn't the unanimous choice of LD and MJ meant he doubled down on what he had in Preston...
I agree, Neil isn't a terrible manager at all... he did an excellent job in Scotland, took Norwich up when they were floundering, and he made Preston overachieve consistently... He's certainly better than many on the list, but is he the best option we can attract given our financial advantage... no, not at all.
|