WBAUnofficial
50 years ago today - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: 50 years ago today (/showthread.php?tid=16793)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: 50 years ago today - ColliersWoodBaggie - 04-18-2021

Leeds have alwasy been twats. Is that the offside rule?

I'm sure it is Billy Martin walking behind the goal, raising a fist as Jeff tucks it away.


RE: 50 years ago today - baggie_ray - 04-18-2021

BurleyBaggie Wrote:
baggie_ray Wrote:
BurleyBaggie Wrote:What’s the interpretation of the offside rule here? I know there was no such thing as interfering with play but hasn’t he just ran into his own deflection and not played the ball?

I wasn’t born for another 10 years so I’ve know idea how offside was interpreted in ‘71.

The offside rule was always the same. A player was in an offside position if they were ahead of the ball when it was played forward by a team mate and there were less than two opposition players between them and the opposition goal line.

In order to be given offside, though, the player had to be involved in the play in some way. If they were, for example, lying unconscious on the floor, they would not be given as offside and play would carry on.

Suggett was deemed as not interfering with play, i.e. he wasn't trying to gain an advantage or become involved in the play, so was not given as offside. Play carried on.

Although he did make an initial move to get involved when the ball broke, but managed to check himself, to the referee's satisfaction.

That’s my point at the core level. This doesn’t even look offside so why the controversy?

Aside from the obvious Revie dirty Leeds reason (live up here now and surrounded by the dirty Leeds).

I think most times players were given as offside whether they were interfering with play or not, even if they were over the other side of the pitch. That was certainly the case in my early supporting years. So to allow play on was very much against the norm. Add in the enormity of the match for Leeds and you can understand why it would have been seen as controversial in the heat of that particular moment.


RE: 50 years ago today - Johnnykayeengland - 04-19-2021

(04-18-2021, 10:42 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
BurleyBaggie Wrote:
baggie_ray Wrote:
BurleyBaggie Wrote:What’s the interpretation of the offside rule here? I know there was no such thing as interfering with play but hasn’t he just ran into his own deflection and not played the ball?

I wasn’t born for another 10 years so I’ve know idea how offside was interpreted in ‘71.

The offside rule was always the same. A player was in an offside position if they were ahead of the ball when it was played forward by a team mate and there were less than two opposition players between them and the opposition goal line.

In order to be given offside, though, the player had to be involved in the play in some way. If they were, for example, lying unconscious on the floor, they would not be given as offside and play would carry on.

Suggett was deemed as not interfering with play, i.e. he wasn't trying to gain an advantage or become involved in the play, so was not given as offside. Play carried on.

Although he did make an initial move to get involved when the ball broke, but managed to check himself, to the referee's satisfaction.

That’s my point at the core level. This doesn’t even look offside so why the controversy?

Aside from the obvious Revie dirty Leeds reason (live up here now and surrounded by the dirty Leeds).

I think most times players were given as offside whether they were interfering with play or not, even if they were over the other side of the pitch. That was certainly the case in my early supporting years. So to allow play on was very much against the norm. Add in the enormity of the match for Leeds and you can understand why it would have been seen as controversial in the heat of that particular moment.
I agree with this.
The change to the law is merely one of emphasis. In favour of the attacking team.
I've seen offside given against players who were prone, or were tens of yards from the action..."if he's not interfering with play, what's he doing on the pitch?". Clough or Shankly I think... Tinkler was right to wave play on, but it was surprising, which is why even Bomber hesitated.
So FIFA changed their advice to refs and clubs as above.
The old way seems absurd now, but that's how it was then.