![]() |
|
Greed ? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Greed ? (/showthread.php?tid=15616) |
RE: Greed ? - Borin' Baggie - 02-15-2021 You're deflecting away from the points I've been making about how they're rooted into the greed and exploitative practices that EMB was complaining about in the first place and then referring to Ineos' and Ratcliffe's greenwashing as an example of their philanthropy despite it being miniscule in comparison to the harm they cause and it being literally greenwashing, that is textbook defending. The fact that they donated to Oxford University doesn't deny the fact that their donations are greenwashing and the fact that they are happy to cause immense damage to the local and global environment on top of exploit labour with no intent to address that while taking in the money from it. RE: Greed ? - Protheroe - 02-15-2021 I'm not deflecting from those points. I just don't agree that Ineos causes "immense damage" compared with the benefits its products provide to mankind. Is this "immense damage" any worse than most other corporates in the chemicals / energy / mining sectors? There are externalities in any manufacturing process - it's the opportunity cost of funding a comfortable society cost effectively. The company also continues to invest billions into unloved UK assets - including at Grangemouth and other unfashionable locations. Without Ineos several parts of the UK would be far far worse off. The only criticism I hear is from the usual FoE / XR middle and upper class green fascists who don't give a fig about peoples' jobs, nor the cost effective production of essential goods. Perhaps XR would be better off railing at BitCoin which produces nothing, but emits more CO2 annually than Argentina? I'm afraid I simply don't perceive your comments as a 360 degree view. RE: Greed ? - Borin' Baggie - 02-15-2021 They are one of the biggest global polluters in the world (and that's with their official underreported figures), have deliberately ignored implementation of mitigation procedures, have deliberately dumped into the local environment, they have an atrocious track record on safety and have flouted perfectly fair and easy to implement environmental regulations. I know people in the chemicals industry very well through my line of work and they all hate them. As for Grangemouth, you're referring to the plant that is propped up by investment from PetroChina and is in line for closure? You suddenly a fan of the CCP as well are you? What the fuck has extension rebellion got to do with anything? And I'm not on about closing them down, I'm on about them bringing them up with their environmental obligations and responsibilities by following the law to mitigate the environmental impact of their operations, which they don't want to do as it will cost them money they can spend on their greenwashing and sportswashing marketing campaigns. They are scum and the the archetypal example of profit and greed over social and environmental responsibility. RE: Greed ? - Protheroe - 02-15-2021 (02-15-2021, 12:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: They are one of the biggest global polluters in the world (and that's with their official underreported figures), have deliberately ignored implementation of mitigation procedures, have deliberately dumped into the local environment, they have an atrocious track record on safety and have flouted perfectly fair and easy to implement environmental regulations. I know people in the chemicals industry very well through my line of work and they all hate them. An extremely energy intensive manufacturing company is amongst the worst emitters? Well, blow me. IF they're as black as you paint them (in your famous 360 degree view) then isn't it as much about a failure of regulators as it is about their alleged commercial behaviour? RE: Greed ? - Borin' Baggie - 02-15-2021 Ineos alone are responsible for around a third of Scotland's entire CO2e output (and that's their acknowledged underreported figure) and refuse to invest in liquified gas storage that many of their competitors have implemented instead relying on outdated gas flaring. They've also refused to engage with government on implementing said gas storage and refused to provide evidence over their carbon reduction strategy. You've also ignored the issue of local dumping which has a huge environmental impact and if deliberate, as is the case with Ineos, is indefensible. Not to mention them refusing to update their sites to meet regulatory standards. And yes, I think the regulators are toothless. When a single plant (Grangemouth) has 176 permit violations in 3 years and isn't pulled up on it with force then they're weak as shit. Not that this has anything to do with anything that has been discussed before though, as yet another example of your deflection in defence of Ineos and Ratcliffe. You're accusing me of seeing them in black and white yet you refuse to accept or even acknowledge any evidence contrary to your worldview that paints them in a negative light, instead deflecting and giving pitiful excuses. RE: Greed ? - Protheroe - 02-15-2021 (02-15-2021, 01:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Ineos alone are responsible for around a third of Scotland's entire CO2e output (and that's their acknowledged underreported figure) and refuse to invest in liquified gas storage that many of their competitors have implemented instead relying on outdated gas flaring. They've also refused to engage with government on implementing said gas storage and refused to provide evidence over their carbon reduction strategy. You've also ignored the issue of local dumping which has a huge environmental impact and if deliberate, as is the case with Ineos, is indefensible. Not to mention them refusing to update their sites to meet regulatory standards. I'm not giving you any excuses. I'm giving you a few other sides of the story. They're a big emitter. Yes - and Grangemouth is also 10% of Scottish GDP. How do their permit violations compare with others in the same industry? Why does their lack of engagement with the government trouble you? If there's a statutory duty that's one thing, but if the government would like to nudge them to do something and they don't want to - welll that's simply exercising thier property rights and applying the rule of law isn't it? Solution? Change the law. RE: Greed ? - Borin' Baggie - 02-15-2021 I know the other side of the story, that's why I've been talking about their refusal to implement changes to meet their social and environmental obligations and not the impact of their petrochemical products. I don't need you, someone I'd wager isn't a chemist, materials scientist or engineer, to tell me shit I already know. I don't know what the permit violations of their competitors are, but I do know that, unlike Ineos, Exxon (hardly a bastion of commercial morals) actually shut their Fife plant over a violation for a month to voluntarily address it. Don't recall Grangemouth, Runcorn or Durham ever closing over permit violations, just when Ratcliffe decided to hold the Scottish government to ransom over their refusal to allow a fracking permit to one of Ratcliffe's other firms. And I don't think you understand the point that they're in breach of regulations, they're already breaking the law. They've been fined over it, they've been called up on it, they refuse to fix it. It's like when a car manufacturer decides that paying fines is better than fixing a fatal flaw with their car at it's cheaper for them to do so. RE: Greed ? - Protheroe - 02-15-2021 (02-15-2021, 03:12 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And I don't think you understand the point that they're in breach of regulations, they're already breaking the law. They've been fined over it, they've been called up on it, they refuse to fix it. It's like when a car manufacturer decides that paying fines is better than fixing a fatal flaw with their car at it's cheaper for them to do so. If that is so then the law is at fault. RE: Greed ? - Borin' Baggie - 02-15-2021 That doesn't mean that Ineos has been following the rule of law (because they haven't as they've been in breach of the law), and it doesn't absolve of them of any criticism as I've already said. In fact, it further reinforces the point that they're pursuing greed over their societal obligations and are therefore a prime example of the sort of company that EMB was complaining about in the first place. RE: Greed ? - Arti - 02-15-2021 (02-14-2021, 07:43 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:(02-12-2021, 08:00 PM)Arti Wrote: Cadbury were Quakers and driven by their religious beliefs. The village was built booze-free and their workers were well looked after, which is also good for productivity. Totally with you. My dad was there late'50s early '60s too. The idea behind the village was religious to promote temperance as well business, but the old guys died off, taking their altruism with them. |