![]() |
|
EU's Chucked Its Dollies - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: EU's Chucked Its Dollies (/showthread.php?tid=15300) |
RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - Protheroe - 02-01-2021 (01-31-2021, 06:39 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Well that was a fuck up wasn't it? Hope that whoever decided that would be a good idea is down the Brussels Job Centre in the morning. Then you didn't read my post, or any others on my reasons for campaigning to leave the EU. The "being inside making changes to the EU" conceit has been exposed as just that for 20 years now. If this episode doesn't convince you of that then nothing will. RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - Protheroe - 02-01-2021 (01-30-2021, 05:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: That is food for thought, Proth. Did you see Simon Reeves documentary on Greece, and the effect the (reckless, but encouraged), borrowing has had on the country and how the EU defied it's own rules to allow Greece to join? Personally I was no fan of the EU after listening to Tony Benn's speech from the early 70's, so probably different reasons to yours (!), but have little faith in our own home grown politicians to improve our lot. Tony Benn, Barbara Castle & Peter Shore were all entirely correct. In fact, I'm sure I posted parts of that Oxford Union debate on here. Thankfully we can vote our incompetent bastards out. Here it is again. RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - baggy1 - 02-01-2021 (02-01-2021, 01:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Then you didn't read my post, or any others on my reasons for campaigning to leave the EU. Maybe if we had taken it a bit more seriously than voting for Farage to sit on the Fisheries committee (when I say sit, I mean take the money and never turn up) or Widdecombe waving flags in the chamber then we might have had more influence. This episode convinces me that when a fuck up happens then it gets highlighted and fixed pretty sharpish because of the controls in place, what controls are stopping the mop haired buffoon and his cronies from fucking up and then being rectified - the last 12 months should show you how that works. RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - Protheroe - 02-01-2021 (02-01-2021, 03:56 PM)baggy1 Wrote:(02-01-2021, 01:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Then you didn't read my post, or any others on my reasons for campaigning to leave the EU. Most of what I consider to be the EU's fuck ups are deliberate long term policy: CAP (Reform took decades) Common Fisheries Policy (overfishing) Common Security & Defence Policy The Common External Tariiff QMV The Stability & Growth Pact and its effect on democratically elected southern European governments Schengen and porous borders The completely unresolved migration crisis in Greece & Italy Our government has made some terrible mistakes during this last year. It's also leading the continent in vaccine roll out (thank fuck because deaths and cases are so high here). You and I can vote the government out in 2024. You and I can do nothing about the general direction of travel for the EU. RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - baggy1 - 02-02-2021 (02-01-2021, 04:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Most of what I consider to be the EU's fuck ups are deliberate long term policy: So with CAP you wait until reform happens and then leave - that seems like the sensible approach. Moan for years about the policy and when you finally get it changed we leave. Common Fisheries Policy, how exactly is leaving going to change that. This is definitely one where we were better fighting this from the inside as has been shown over the last few weeks, if we carry on like this we won't have a fishing fleet left and then have to rely on the EU to provide. Good move. Common Security and Defence Policy - you think working with our closest allies to work together and protect the region whilst we have an aggressive dictator on one side and have to place reliance on NATO which is subject to the whims of whichever far right loon gets voted into the US next time. Again, nice one. The CET - you have this mad idea that we can just import from anywhere which will increase choice, but the long term of that is loss of jobs in the UK. It's mad to think that making trading with our biggest trading partner easier is in some way an issue. This is nothing about trading in everyday items for everyday folk, this is some madcap idea that London will be some deregulated singapore-esque financial hub. It might surprise you to find the singapore is very regulated and a bugger for outside companies to work with. Yeah, lets get rid of trading with our closest neighbours and the standards that they ensure, whilst protecting (yes protectionism) the jobs in the EU which did include the UK - sensible approach. QMV - what exactly is wrong with that, and which policies have been decided based on that where you disagree, or the UK would have been out of step with. The democratically elected southern european governments - are these the same ones that bankrupted the countries that voted them in? On the point though a reset of the measures is probably needed with a focus on helping out in a better manner, however with the migration crisis that is happening that needs to be where it gets joined up. Schengen - give me a break, you are against freedom of movement, fucks sake man. And the migration crisis, porous borders problem - this is happening because of war zone and famine stricken regions, do you suggest we just 'Build A Wall', or do you think that better aid and policy decisions are where we need to go (in a time where the UK is cutting overseas aid I might point out). You obviously see north africa and the middle east as someone else's problem, you don't see the long term issues with not helping syria and lebanon for example and let Russia and Iran stretch their borders and influence in the region, whilst China slowly increase their influence on a whole continent - nothing to see here. You have pointed to nothing that was a problem and definately not one worth creating the long term issues of trading with our nearest neighbours, the increased cost of living, the extra difficulties in simply running a business that deals with the world, and being able to move and live freely in the wider area. You just like to highlight words that most people wouldn't really understand and never had it explained to them. And this is the same bunch of creeping fanatics that have been voted in for the last decade and more, you'll be out knocking doors for them by the time of the next election with their new face of moderate conservatism, all the time hiding the nasty loons that object to anything other than little englanders making decisions about keeping pubs open whilst we have the worst death toll of any comparable nation. RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - Protheroe - 02-02-2021 (02-02-2021, 09:37 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You have pointed to nothing that was a problem You're entirely free to disagree. I think they're all long term issues that indicate a direction of travel incompatible with a sovereign state. RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - baggy1 - 02-02-2021 We were always a sovereign state and that hasn't changed, but that detail appears lost in the noise. We could have led decisions in the EU if we'd have taken it seriously, instead we sent Farage and his bunch of racists to take the money and insult the different countries that did try. RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - Protheroe - 02-02-2021 It's pointless debating an issue we'll never agree on baggy1. For all those issues cited I could argue with you for hours, but honestly what's the point? At least you now know what it was like being in my position when we were in the EU. And it's prepostrous to suggest that "we could have led decisions in the EU if we'd taken it seriously" - unless of course you mean roll over and accept the central tenet of the project - Ever Closer Union. The general direction of travel since the formation of the Single Market (a good thing) has run contrary to the democratic will of the British people - hence our opt outs and objections. Like a bad marriage you can only swim against the tide for so long before something gives, and give it has. RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - Derek Hardballs - 02-03-2021 (02-02-2021, 04:35 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It's pointless debating an issue we'll never agree on baggy1. For all those issues cited I could argue with you for hours, but honestly what's the point? You say that like the decision to leave was endorsed / voted for by a huge margin it wasn’t. Younger, higher educated groups voted to remain (as stats prove). Those in that group haven’t disappeared and with your ex only living next door the opportunity to get back together is always a possibility. RE: EU's Chucked Its Dollies - baggy1 - 02-03-2021 (02-02-2021, 04:35 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It's pointless debating an issue we'll never agree on baggy1. For all those issues cited I could argue with you for hours, but honestly what's the point? I wouldn't mind leaving if the points you raise had been openly discuss and articulated in the referendum, however the issue I have comes with the lies and sunlit uplands that were sold to the electorate which ultimately decided on the direction of the country. With such a small margin (a difference of less than 1.3M) do you think that all the fishing industry and exporters would have merrily voted their businesses away like they did. We are talking 650k people to change their decision after finding out there would be a border down the Irish sea, or that there would be a great deal of red tape to sell into the EU, or even that actually Turkey isn't going to be let into the EU and flood our shores with immigrants looking to sponge off the state. The win is hollow based on the lies that were told and now have transpired. Genuine question - do you think the result would have been the same if it had been admitted there would be a border down the Irish sea, or there would be red tape slowing down exports, or the scare stories about Turkey being admitted in hadn't been used. We managed to have one the most prosperous times in our history as part of the EU, we have rolled the dice to gain what exactly? |