![]() |
|
May in the Mail - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: May in the Mail (/showthread.php?tid=15111) |
RE: May in the Mail - baggy1 - 01-20-2021 (01-20-2021, 07:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(01-20-2021, 04:08 PM)baggy1 Wrote:(01-20-2021, 03:06 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Crikey, and there was I thinking it was Gordon Brown who himself claimed to have abolished boom & bust completely before overseeing the greatest financial disaster in history. Was the blueprint he laid down the same one that led to the greatest transfer of wealth from the youngest to the oldest and the poorest to richest? Was the blueprint he laid down the same one that has debased our currency and compromised the independence of the BoE and central banks worldwide? Oh mate, pack it in now, i'm cringing. Let's just leave it where it is, eh? RE: May in the Mail - JOK - 01-20-2021 (01-20-2021, 06:02 PM)baggy1 Wrote:(01-20-2021, 05:29 PM)JOK Wrote:(01-20-2021, 02:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote:So they all changed their mind in 2019 then.(01-20-2021, 02:04 PM)JOK Wrote:(01-20-2021, 01:04 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Yes. Cameron should be up there. He wouldn't have been elected without offering the referendum (UKIP would have eaten into the Tory vote not Labour), then he ran away when it went against him.Even though large swathes of the Northern Labour heartlands voted for Brexit? What I was trying to counter (not very well, obviously) was the inference which always seems to crop up, that Tory followers were the only supporters of Brexit. Which, as we know, was not the case. RE: May in the Mail - Tom Joad - 01-20-2021 JOK Wrote:baggy1 Wrote:JOK Wrote:baggy1 Wrote:So they all changed their mind in 2019 then.JOK Wrote:Even though large swathes of the Northern Labour heartlands voted for Brexit? No JOK, I wasn't inferring that at all. I probably should have worded it differently. Obviously, both parties had their leavers but Cameron called the referendum thus keeping his in the fold. Labour didn't address theirs satisfactorily and lost them. RE: May in the Mail - Borin' Baggie - 01-20-2021 Protheroe (01-20-2021, 11:30 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(01-20-2021, 10:48 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(01-20-2021, 09:59 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(01-20-2021, 09:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: It's a tight race for the position of worst prime minister ever, but May just about edges it. Crikey, and there was I thinking it was Gordon Brown who himself claimed to have abolished boom & bust completely before overseeing the greatest financial disaster in history. Was the blueprint he laid down the same one that led to the greatest transfer of wealth from the youngest to the oldest and the poorest to richest? Was the blueprint he laid down the same one that has debased our currency and compromised the independence of the BoE and central banks worldwide? Scratch Brown being the 2nd worst PM, I had my rose-tinted glasses on. He was the worst after all. [/quote] If you want to get into a contest of whom has made the stupidest comments before they became PM, I'm afraid you're going to lose this one by virtue of that buffoon you voted for last year. I forget, when did the EU ban prawn cocktail crisps? The Bank of England was more independent of the government in 2010 than it was in 1997 owing to Brown's policies as Chancellor, so that point makes literally no sense. And debasing our currency? I forgot Brown has been PM for the last 10 years and kept up with QE. Keeping on the topic of QE, the largest transfer of wealth in history has predominantly been under Cameron, followed by May, followed by Boris and then Brown. To completely ignore his predecessors roles in that and lay the blame at Brown's feet is stupid, need I also remind you that Brexit has exasperated that situation further. Furthermore, Brown pushed for QT over QE in 2009 which is something that Cameron abandoned in favour of more QE and we've been printing currency ever since. If you think Brown is worse than Eden, North, Boris and May you are completely up your own arse, moreso than a Villa fan when they're on about football. Eden mislead the House and drove into the worst British foreign endeavour ever and Lord North's fuck ups had the Colonies declare independence and had London put under martial law. RE: May in the Mail - Jack Halford - 01-20-2021 (01-20-2021, 07:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Protheroe If you want to get into a contest of whom has made the stupidest comments before they became PM, I'm afraid you're going to lose this one by virtue of that buffoon you voted for last year. I forget, when did the EU ban prawn cocktail crisps? The Bank of England was more independent of the government in 2010 than it was in 1997 owing to Brown's policies as Chancellor, so that point makes literally no sense. And debasing our currency? I forgot Brown has been PM for the last 10 years and kept up with QE. Keeping on the topic of QE, the largest transfer of wealth in history has predominantly been under Cameron, followed by May, followed by Boris and then Brown. To completely ignore his predecessors roles in that and lay the blame at Brown's feet is stupid, need I also remind you that Brexit has exasperated that situation further. Furthermore, Brown pushed for QT over QE in 2009 which is something that Cameron abandoned in favour of more QE and we've been printing currency ever since. If you think Brown is worse than Eden, North, Boris and May you are completely up your own arse, moreso than a Villa fan when they're on about football. Eden mislead the House and drove into the worst British foreign endeavour ever and Lord North's fuck ups had the Colonies declare independence and had London put under martial law. [/quote] Gordon Brown financial genius ..... ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha Chancellor during the boom years but when they left office there was fuck all for a rainy day Suez the worst British foreign endeavour ever..... Didn’t Blair mislead parliament or has that been whitewashed., Crimean war perhaps....... RE: May in the Mail - Borin' Baggie - 01-20-2021 (01-20-2021, 09:19 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:(01-20-2021, 07:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Protheroe Gordon Brown financial genius ..... ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha Chancellor during the boom years but when they left office there was fuck all for a rainy day Suez the worst British foreign endeavour ever..... Didn’t Blair mislead parliament or has that been whitewashed., Crimean war perhaps....... [/quote] I didn't say that Brown was a financial genius, I said he laid the international blueprint for recovery from the global financial crisis which is an easily verifiable fact. His time as Chancellor has nothing to do with anything. And Suez is the worst British foreign policy endeavour ever, it completely destroyed our international credibility, alienated us from our allies and embolded the Soviets aggressive foreign policy. It also forced us to become lapdogs of the US as we scrambled to save our extremely damaged foreign relations with them. RE: May in the Mail - Protheroe - 01-21-2021 (01-20-2021, 09:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I didn't say that Brown was a financial genius, I said he laid the international blueprint for recovery from the global financial crisis which is an easily verifiable fact. His time as Chancellor has nothing to do with anything. That blueprint, prepared with and copied by many other leaders has completely debased money as a store of value and threatens the greatest inflationary event for a couple of generations. Brown has no defence to that, nor the charge that by saving insolvent institutions he directly transferred the then existing and future wealth from the youngest to the oldest and from the poorest to the richest. The asset bubbles in virtually everything all have their roots in what Brown and other leaders implemented between 2008-10. Personally I benefitted hugely from Brown's benevolence over IceSave & Kaupthing. I shouldn't have, and neither should anyone else. I have also benefitted massively from asset price inflation, thank goodness as I've been able to put a substantial amount aside for my kids. The vast majority of people aren't in that situation, the median level of savings in this country is less than £2000. The already-monied middle-aged middle classes should be erecting statues to Gordon Brown in every suburban and village square. Everyone else should be burning effigies of him. RE: May in the Mail - baggy1 - 01-21-2021 Luckily we’ve had over a decade of Tory government to put those issues right. RE: May in the Mail - Borin' Baggie - 01-21-2021 (01-21-2021, 12:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(01-20-2021, 09:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I didn't say that Brown was a financial genius, I said he laid the international blueprint for recovery from the global financial crisis which is an easily verifiable fact. His time as Chancellor has nothing to do with anything. The UK had ended QE in 2009 and had begun QT, strengthening the pound. This was reversed under Cameron and followed up with by May and now Johnson with no return to QT. If you're pissed off about QE and the devaluation of the pound then blame the people you have spent the last 10 years voting for as they're responsible for it. As for "insolvent institutions", Lloyds was clearly worth bailing out as shown by the fact we as taxpayers made a profit off it after it was sold off. HBOS and RBS less so but they were specifically identified as strategically crucial (unlike Northern Rock) and not bailing them out risked spiralling things out of control with the risk of collapse of Barclays and HSBC if they weren't bailed out, do you know how much deep shit we'd have been in if all the big banks had collapsed all at once? On top of that, bailing out the banks stabilised the stock markets which were in free fall, of HBOS, RBS and Lloyds had collapsed I'm sure you can imagine how much the stock market would have imploded. If we hadn't bailed out the banks we were looking at something the size of the South Sea crisis instead of what we ended up with. Now maybe you should direct your blame towards the people who were responsible for the fuckup in the first place like your mate Saj who you thought would be a good choice as Chancellor. As for asset price inflation, that's been accelerated under the coalition and conservative governments moreso than it was under Brown. And it was started due to short sighted policies made under Thatcher that conservative governments have had 28 years to address. RE: May in the Mail - Protheroe - 01-21-2021 (01-21-2021, 01:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The UK had ended QE in 2009 and had begun QT, strengthening the pound. This was reversed under Cameron and followed up with by May and now Johnson with no return to QT. If you're pissed off about QE and the devaluation of the pound then blame the people you have spent the last 10 years voting for as they're responsible for it. At the risk of repeating myself: a) Yes, I do also blame every successive Chancellor for pursuing equally destructive policies in respect of currency debasement. I can't count the amount of times I've said that on here, it'll be in the hundreds, maybe you were away those days. b) I have *only* ever criticised the way the banks were bailed out, not the principle of bailing them out. This point, again is lost on you and virtually everyone else on the board who mistakenly believes there was no middle ground between wholesale bailing out of utterly failing institutions who'd engaged in (still unpunished) criminal behaviour and failing to to come to their aid at all. The UK, especially the UK, was and remains at systemic risk because of the concentration of banking in so few large institutions. Brown, or the idiot Osborne could have used the crisis to introduce real competition into a diverse banking system - they particularly had the opportunity to do this with RBS Natwest and HBOS by creatively smashing them to pieces. Both men being in the pockets of bankers they chose not to, it was and will remain to our detriment. For the last time - I won't say this again - it wasn't a binary choice between doing what Brown did and doing nothing and it betrays a deep lack of intellect to suggest that it was. c) Yes, you're absolutely right about asset price inflation. If you can't make a real return whatsoever because cash is so cheap to borrow and intrinsicly worth nothing then every other investment opportunity will inflate. Zero interest rates are entirely founded in the way Brown dealt with the crisis in 2008. It's them same reason we still have thousands of zombie companies, the same reason there are thousands of zombie property funds each only able to survive by paying interest cover. Creative destruction was never "a thing" in 2008-09 - for the first time in recession -and we're living with the costs in sclerotic growth and crap productivity. It could have been so much different. |