WBAUnofficial
The Strange Death of Europe - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The Strange Death of Europe (/showthread.php?tid=14939)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - hudds - 01-12-2021

(01-12-2021, 05:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2021, 04:06 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: I haven't read the book but understand it to be fairly polarising. From the precis I've read I'd probably partially agree with what the author says.

A lot of people from both sides of the aisle need to realise its perfectly possible to be concerned with the rising tide of Islam (as an ideology) in Europe and its incongruence with our cultural norms whilst not being prejudiced or racist towards individual Muslims, vast swathes of whom are perfectly reasonable people and as British as you or I.

As poster's have already mentioned, combatting illegal immigration is much more difficult than its made out to be in a manifesto pledge however and the "torpedo the dinghies!" crowd you get in Leave.EU comments sections aren't helping their own cause.


Half of all Muslims think homosexuality should be illegal; almost half don't think homosexuals should be teachers; 39% agreed that “wives should always obey their husbands” (compared with 5% for the rest of the country);

Unfortunately our liberal leaders seem unable to recognise the rise of illiberalism in their midst. And it's far worse in France.
You could transfer as much as that to the Christian Right in America and among the fundamentalists in Norn Iron (and some in GB).


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - Protheroe - 01-13-2021

(01-12-2021, 07:10 PM)hudds Wrote:
(01-12-2021, 05:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2021, 04:06 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: I haven't read the book but understand it to be fairly polarising. From the precis I've read I'd probably partially agree with what the author says.

A lot of people from both sides of the aisle need to realise its perfectly possible to be concerned with the rising tide of Islam (as an ideology) in Europe and its incongruence with our cultural norms whilst not being prejudiced or racist towards individual Muslims, vast swathes of whom are perfectly reasonable people and as British as you or I.

As poster's have already mentioned, combatting illegal immigration is much more difficult than its made out to be in a manifesto pledge however and the "torpedo the dinghies!" crowd you get in Leave.EU comments sections aren't helping their own cause.


Half of all Muslims think homosexuality should be illegal; almost half don't think homosexuals should be teachers; 39% agreed that “wives should always obey their husbands” (compared with 5% for the rest of the country);

Unfortunately our liberal leaders seem unable to recognise the rise of illiberalism in their midst. And it's far worse in France.
You could transfer as much as that to the Christian Right in America and among the fundamentalists in Norn Iron (and some in GB).

You could. But I don't recall the Christian Right or fundamentalists in Norn Iron using the cover of religious intolerance to stab random gays in parks, massacre kids at pop concerts, knife diners at London Bridge, drive into crowds at Christmas markets, shank & shoot cartoonists for drawing pictures of their particualr sky fairy or force other people of their own faith first into hiding then fleeing their own country (a European country).

Although the cultural norms may be similar, the propensity to act is not. Christian puritianism has been a cutural feature of the US since its foundation. Islam has not, either in the US or the vast majority of Europe. Its intolerant cultural norms are entirely alien.

Elsewhere the question is being posed about Brexit Gains. You could equally pose the question about the gains for European society and culture from Islamic immigration.

(01-12-2021, 05:58 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Point of order - I said "vast swathes" not "majority" as well. No muslim I've met has expressed any kind of homophobic viewpoint but then again, I don't know that many and the subject of gay rights has rarely come up. A couple of muslim guys in my old BJJ club formed a little liberal, leftie clique with me and another white guy against what were mostly right-wing mma knuckleheads. It was quite good fun.

Macron has started to take a stand against some of the ghetto-isation of some parts of larger French cities (a generation too late) and has, IMO, done an OK job at defending himself from the inevitable cries of Islamophobia. This is, of course, in response to the increasing popularity of the far-right Le Pen.

As has been noted, the dilution of extremism through exposure to liberal ideals should be the goal, rather than it's distillation in ghettos. I don't have the answer to that one unfortunately short of mandating that immigrants (or even muslims born here) are not allowed to live near each other which in itself, would be illiberal.

To clarify as well, I am fully in favour of Britain taking its fair share of Syrian, Lybian, Yemeni etc refugees and the people risking their lives and the lives of their children in dinghies don't deserve to be dismissed as 'economic migrants' IMO.

Refugees? Can anyone explain why it's better to "take" them rather than to fund camps in Jordan or Turkey so that they can return when peace returns to Syria? That's been the UK's intended policy and makes sense to me.

What's really telling is that those states who really DID have a direct involvement in Syria (Iran, Russia, Qatar, Saudi Arabia) have taken no refugees at all. Zero. Zilch.

In fact Saudi Arabia's single offer to Europe was to fund the building of 200 mosques to cater for Syrian refugees.


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - hudds - 01-13-2021

(01-13-2021, 11:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2021, 07:10 PM)hudds Wrote:
(01-12-2021, 05:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-12-2021, 04:06 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: I haven't read the book but understand it to be fairly polarising. From the precis I've read I'd probably partially agree with what the author says.

A lot of people from both sides of the aisle need to realise its perfectly possible to be concerned with the rising tide of Islam (as an ideology) in Europe and its incongruence with our cultural norms whilst not being prejudiced or racist towards individual Muslims, vast swathes of whom are perfectly reasonable people and as British as you or I.

As poster's have already mentioned, combatting illegal immigration is much more difficult than its made out to be in a manifesto pledge however and the "torpedo the dinghies!" crowd you get in Leave.EU comments sections aren't helping their own cause.


Half of all Muslims think homosexuality should be illegal; almost half don't think homosexuals should be teachers; 39% agreed that “wives should always obey their husbands” (compared with 5% for the rest of the country);

Unfortunately our liberal leaders seem unable to recognise the rise of illiberalism in their midst. And it's far worse in France.
You could transfer as much as that to the Christian Right in America and among the fundamentalists in Norn Iron (and some in GB).

You could. But I don't recall the Christian Right or fundamentalists in Norn Iron using the cover of religious intolerance to stab random gays in parks, massacre kids at pop concerts, knife diners at London Bridge, drive into crowds at Christmas markets, shank & shoot cartoonists for drawing pictures of their particualr sky fairy or force other people of their own faith first into hiding then fleeing their own country (a European country).

Although the cultural norms may be similar, the propensity to act is not. Christian puritianism has been a cutural feature of the US since its foundation. Islam has not, either in the US or the vast majority of Europe. Its intolerant cultural norms are entirely alien.

Elsewhere the question is being posed about Brexit Gains. You could equally pose the question about the gains for European society and culture from Islamic immigration.

I'm not being apologetic about a belief system that is inexplicable to me.  I was only commenting on the same fundamentalist intolerance from the same Abrahamic root and the same values thus derived.  Christianity has its long history of oppression, torture and murder.

The recent insurgents in Washington have the same "Christian" bigotry and do use violence and intimidation against gays and so forth.  Look also at the death threats and violence against abortion clinics.  These lunatics are armed to the teeth as well. The genie is out of that bottle, to mix up a metaphor.


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - Protheroe - 01-13-2021

(01-13-2021, 11:53 AM)hudds Wrote: I'm not being apologetic about a belief system that is inexplicable to me.  I was only commenting on the same fundamentalist intolerance from the same Abrahamic root and the same values thus derived.  Christianity has its long history of oppression, torture and murder.

The recent insurgents in Washington have the same "Christian" bigotry and do use violence and intimidation against gays and so forth.  Look also at the death threats and violence against abortion clinics.  These lunatics are armed to the teeth as well. The genie is out of that bottle, to mix up a metaphor.

Yes it has, but in Europe it had an Enlightenment. In Europe the state is, broadly, separated from the church.

I think it's a bit of a stretch to suggest the Capitol insurgents were Christian fundamentalists, though I take you point on abortion.


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - hudds - 01-13-2021

(01-13-2021, 12:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-13-2021, 11:53 AM)hudds Wrote: I'm not being apologetic about a belief system that is inexplicable to me.  I was only commenting on the same fundamentalist intolerance from the same Abrahamic root and the same values thus derived.  Christianity has its long history of oppression, torture and murder.

The recent insurgents in Washington have the same "Christian" bigotry and do use violence and intimidation against gays and so forth.  Look also at the death threats and violence against abortion clinics.  These lunatics are armed to the teeth as well. The genie is out of that bottle, to mix up a metaphor.

Yes it has, but in Europe it had an Enlightenment. In Europe the state is, broadly, separated from the church.

I think it's a bit of a stretch to suggest the Capitol insurgents were Christian fundamentalists, though I take you point on abortion.
Yes, the enormities of Christianity are mainly history but Christians oppress other Christians still, often with extreme violence.  The point is that Islaam has not had a monopoly of  this stuff.

The Capitol insurgents and the others who carried out regional marches on State capitols had the Christian Right DNA embedded in their raison d'etre.  The "Jericho marches" and other loony behaviours were precursers and when the mob stormed Capitol Hill a good many were carrying Christian flags and banners and the call to arms is that of "God, Guns and Guts made America".  It's not a stretch; it's clear as day.


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - Shabby Russian - 01-13-2021

Interesting Proth that Christian fundamentalism inNI has not seen violence. I would imagine a fair few victims of the troubles in NI would disagree with you.
I would agree with you though, on the face of it the violence associated with NI had everything to do with religion, but the truth is the allocation of political power and resources were the prime movers of the violence.

The same is true with violence associated with Islamic fundamentalism. For Example the rise of Isis had more to do with the loss of power and access to resource of the former supporters of Saddam Hussein, than any overarching desire to spread the word of Allah. That's why the military leadership of Isis were almost all former members of the Revolutionary Guard.


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - Borin' Baggie - 01-13-2021

(01-13-2021, 01:14 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Interesting Proth that Christian fundamentalism inNI has not seen violence. I would imagine a fair few victims of the troubles in NI would disagree with you.
I would agree with you though, on the face of it the violence associated with NI had everything to do with religion, but the truth is the allocation of political power and resources were the prime movers of the violence.

The same is true with violence associated with Islamic fundamentalism. For Example the rise of Isis had more to do with the loss of power and access to resource of the former supporters of Saddam Hussein, than any overarching desire to spread the word of Allah. That's why the military leadership of Isis were almost all former members of the Revolutionary Guard.

Let's not also forget how Presbyterianists in NI have oppressed the rights of gay people requiring direct rule in order to implement a right that was there for gay people in Ireland and GB. Also abortion rights.


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - Ossian - 01-13-2021

(01-13-2021, 12:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Yes it has, but in Europe it had an Enlightenment. In Europe the state is, broadly, separated from the church.

I think it's a bit of a stretch to suggest the Capitol insurgents were Christian fundamentalists, though I take you point on abortion.

If that's a critical factor (and it almost certainly is, arguably the critical factor) it represents - for want of a better expression - a 'head start' for western democracies of around three centuries. Not much in the context of the evolution and development of cultures.

I'm not arguing that Islamic societies are 'behind'; just that they are, for reasons too complex to bullet point on a message board, in a different position on the curve. But, having argued that three centuries is the blink of an eye in the context of the development of Homo Sapiens, I'll also concede that it's a much more significant disparity when it comes to homogenisation of societies.


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - Tom Joad - 01-13-2021

Ossian Wrote:
Protheroe Wrote:Yes it has, but in Europe it had an Enlightenment. In Europe the state is, broadly, separated from the church.

I think it's a bit of a stretch to suggest the Capitol insurgents were Christian fundamentalists, though I take you point on abortion.

If that's a critical factor (and it almost certainly is, arguably the critical factor) it represents - for want of a better expression - a 'head start' for western democracies of around three centuries. Not much in the context of the evolution and development of cultures.

I'm not arguing that Islamic societies are 'behind'; just that they are, for reasons too complex to bullet point on a message board, in a different position on the curve. But, having argued that three centuries is the blink of an eye in the context of the development of Homo Sapiens, I'll also concede that it's a much more significant disparity when it comes to homogenisation of societies.

One of my regular maintenance calls is a mosque. I rarely encounter anyone although I regularly feel like a fish out of water when it's prayer time (which for convenience I've learned to avoid). When I do bump into anyone, we exchange a pleasant Hello, and that is about it as understandably they are there for spiritual purposes and I just want the job completed. I did have cause to spend some time in the entrance hallway once though and was more than a little shocked at the absolute vengeance message on the preachy notices. The gist was unrelenting suffering for non believers.  I got the job because I do work for a few of the more well heeled members there and although they are far from what I would call westernised, they were born and well educated here. As I say, I was quite shocked at the bluntness of the message.
Just for balance, as a child I was made to go to church regularly, as an adult I've frequented Buddhist centres and I have had occasion to go to Sikh Temples. Only in Islam have I encountered this kind of unforgiving attitude and it doesn't sit well with me.


RE: The Strange Death of Europe - Borin' Baggie - 01-13-2021

(01-13-2021, 04:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Ossian Wrote:
Protheroe Wrote:Yes it has, but in Europe it had an Enlightenment. In Europe the state is, broadly, separated from the church.

I think it's a bit of a stretch to suggest the Capitol insurgents were Christian fundamentalists, though I take you point on abortion.

If that's a critical factor (and it almost certainly is, arguably the critical factor) it represents - for want of a better expression - a 'head start' for western democracies of around three centuries. Not much in the context of the evolution and development of cultures.

I'm not arguing that Islamic societies are 'behind'; just that they are, for reasons too complex to bullet point on a message board, in a different position on the curve. But, having argued that three centuries is the blink of an eye in the context of the development of Homo Sapiens, I'll also concede that it's a much more significant disparity when it comes to homogenisation of societies.

One of my regular maintenance calls is a mosque. I rarely encounter anyone although I regularly feel like a fish out of water when it's prayer time (which for convenience I've learned to avoid). When I do bump into anyone, we exchange a pleasant Hello, and that is about it as understandably they are there for spiritual purposes and I just want the job completed. I did have cause to spend some time in the entrance hallway once though and was more than a little shocked at the absolute vengeance message on the preachy notices. The gist was unrelenting suffering for non believers.  I got the job because I do work for a few of the more well heeled members there and although they are far from what I would call westernised, they were born and well educated here. As I say, I was quite shocked at the bluntness of the message.
Just for balance, as a child I was made to go to church regularly, as an adult I've frequented Buddhist centres and I have had occasion to go to Sikh Temples. Only in Islam have I encountered this kind of unforgiving attitude and it doesn't sit well with me.

Because we decided to let the Saudis run the mosques here and they have been pushing their ultra-hardline fanatical sect, to the surprise to nobody.

It's fine though, we'll ignore them doing this and sell them weapons to bomb the shit out of Yemen.