WBAUnofficial
Who would you replace Bilic with? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Who would you replace Bilic with? (/showthread.php?tid=13545)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - TartanRug - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 01:30 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Given money is clearly tight, I don't forsee us going for a manager who is employed at the moment. This would rule out Appy which on one hand is a shame as I think he is a good fit for the next role.

Whoever we employ, I think we need to ensure it's done with an eye on next season. The temptation would be to get someone in who can firefight to try and stay up. What I think is needed is a complete reboot and someone who can build something within our financial constraints. That may mean going backwards to go forwards. We need better coaching but a good coach needs time. It rarely happens quickly. That's why I think Appy is the best fit. The 2 jobs where he has allowed himself to settle and build something has seen excellent medium term results. The job he is currently doing at Lincoln is outstanding.

However, we are unlikely to pay compensation and I also think Appy needs to see this job through. He's had his head turned and jumped too quickly before.

So this leaves out of work managers and the field is small. Pearson is the obvious name but I do think he struggles without a Shakey alongside him.

Another option could be ex players starting out as managers such as Darren Fletcher.

Whilst not unemployed, don't be surprised to see John Terry linked as well.

If we're going for an Appy type appointment I don't think it would be a good move at this stage, they'd more than likely end up with 25-30 defeats and a couple of wins (being optimistic) for the rest of the season and people would want them out before he had a chance to develop us in the chump.


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - ghanaian_baggie - 11-03-2020

One name I've not seen, and it'll never happen, but I'd like to see what Darren Moore would do as a caretaker manager! I'm not suggesting that he is the long-term solution - what I just wonder how it'd turn out.

I honestly don't care about getting points, I just want to see us give the opposition a game. I couldn't stand a Pulis approach, and after all we didn't build a defence. We used our budget to set up counter-attacks. So why we slow the play down when we do get the ball confuses me.


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - Peachy - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 01:30 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Whilst not unemployed, don't be surprised to see John Terry linked as well.

Oh god no. Not Terry please..... 

I guess you'd have to link Steven Gerrard at Rangers too but there is no way he would leave Rangers whilst they are top and look like winning the league for the first time in god knows how long.


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 02:10 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 01:30 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Whilst not unemployed, don't be surprised to see John Terry linked as well.

Oh god no. Not Terry please..... 

I guess you'd have to link Steven Gerrard at Rangers too but there is no way he would leave Rangers whilst they are top and look like winning the league for the first time in god knows how long.
Didn`t know that Terrys brother is at Albion as loans manager. He has just been charged by the FA for betting offences.


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - Duffers - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 02:09 PM)ghanaian_baggie Wrote: One name I've not seen, and it'll never happen, but I'd like to see what Darren Moore would do as a caretaker manager! I'm not suggesting that he is the long-term solution - what I just wonder how it'd turn out.

I honestly don't care about getting points, I just want to see us give the opposition a game. I couldn't stand a Pulis approach, and after all we didn't build a defence. We used our budget to set up counter-attacks. So why we slow the play down when we do get the ball confuses me.

He’d probably do similar to when he was caretaker before... or actual manager.


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - Johnnykayeengland - 11-03-2020

For me, the only chance we had of staying up was with a few factors in our favour, given obvious lack of quality.
Togetherness. Which is why I was- and am - delighted that we got those players who want to be here, show great spirit and fight for the Albion. Pereira, Diang, Robinson, Grant, and I'd add Livermore, and Bartley.

A manager we trust and support. Seems to be going out the window.

Fight. Sadly, see above.

The decisive moment in our season may well be the Hegazi incident, when it looks like the Board stabbed the manager in the back.

If he's really lost interest then he goes. But that's the Board's fault.

I'd give him till Christmas, tell him he can have the Hegazi money+, and stick together.

There's no better man out there.

(Mind you, I'd have kept Steve Clarke)


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - MassDebater - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 02:20 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: For me, the only chance we had of staying up was with a few factors in our favour, given obvious lack of quality.
Togetherness. Which is why I was- and am - delighted that we got those players who want to be here, show great spirit and fight for the Albion. Pereira, Diang, Robinson, Grant, and I'd add Livermore, and Bartley.

A manager we trust and support. Seems to be going out the window.

Fight. Sadly, see above.

The decisive moment in our season may well be the Hegazi incident, when it looks like the Board stabbed the manager in the back.

If he's really lost interest then he goes. But that's the Board's fault.

I'd give him till Christmas, tell him he can have the Hegazi money+, and stick together.

There's no better man out there.

(Mind you, I'd have kept Steve Clarke)

I honestly think Hegazigate is just being used as an excuse by Slav. He barely bothered with him last season, so the reaction to it seemed suss to me.


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - Duffers - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 02:25 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 02:20 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: For me, the only chance we had of staying up was with a few factors in our favour, given obvious lack of quality.
Togetherness. Which is why I was- and am - delighted that we got those players who want to be here, show great spirit and fight for the Albion. Pereira, Diang, Robinson, Grant, and I'd add Livermore, and Bartley.

A manager we trust and support. Seems to be going out the window.

Fight. Sadly, see above.

The decisive moment in our season may well be the Hegazi incident, when it looks like the Board stabbed the manager in the back.

If he's really lost interest then he goes. But that's the Board's fault.

I'd give him till Christmas, tell him he can have the Hegazi money+, and stick together.

There's no better man out there.

(Mind you, I'd have kept Steve Clarke)

I honestly think Hegazigate is just being used as an excuse by Slav. He barely bothered with him last season, so the reaction to it seemed suss to me.

If anything the problems seemed to start when Hegazi regained fitness and we were trying to shoehorn him in, breaking up the Ajayi/Bartley partnership that was working fine up until that point.


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - richbaggie - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 02:09 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 01:30 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Given money is clearly tight, I don't forsee us going for a manager who is employed at the moment. This would rule out Appy which on one hand is a shame as I think he is a good fit for the next role.

Whoever we employ, I think we need to ensure it's done with an eye on next season. The temptation would be to get someone in who can firefight to try and stay up. What I think is needed is a complete reboot and someone who can build something within our financial constraints. That may mean going backwards to go forwards. We need better coaching but a good coach needs time. It rarely happens quickly. That's why I think Appy is the best fit. The 2 jobs where he has allowed himself to settle and build something has seen excellent medium term results. The job he is currently doing at Lincoln is outstanding.

However, we are unlikely to pay compensation and I also think Appy needs to see this job through. He's had his head turned and jumped too quickly before.

So this leaves out of work managers and the field is small. Pearson is the obvious name but I do think he struggles without a Shakey alongside him.

Another option could be ex players starting out as managers such as Darren Fletcher.

Whilst not unemployed, don't be surprised to see John Terry linked as well.

If we're going for an Appy type appointment I don't think it would be a good move at this stage, they'd more than likely end up with 25-30 defeats and a couple of wins (being optimistic) for the rest of the season and people would want them out before he had a chance to develop us in the chump.

Appy would need time. He changes things from top to bottom. He went into Lincoln and has pretty much ripped up everything the Cowley bros put in place which was brave given their success there. It has taken a while and Lincoln fans took a while to see what he was doing but now they think he's outstanding for them. Good football too. Well organised, pass through the team and plenty of fight in them. Given youth a chance too.


RE: Who would you replace Bilic with? - richbaggie - 11-03-2020

(11-03-2020, 02:25 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 02:20 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: For me, the only chance we had of staying up was with a few factors in our favour, given obvious lack of quality.
Togetherness. Which is why I was- and am - delighted that we got those players who want to be here, show great spirit and fight for the Albion. Pereira, Diang, Robinson, Grant, and I'd add Livermore, and Bartley.

A manager we trust and support. Seems to be going out the window.

Fight. Sadly, see above.

The decisive moment in our season may well be the Hegazi incident, when it looks like the Board stabbed the manager in the back.

If he's really lost interest then he goes. But that's the Board's fault.

I'd give him till Christmas, tell him he can have the Hegazi money+, and stick together.

There's no better man out there.

(Mind you, I'd have kept Steve Clarke)

I honestly think Hegazigate is just being used as an excuse by Slav. He barely bothered with him last season, so the reaction to it seemed suss to me.
 
Yep. 

Bilic was not stabbed in the back. However, he is engineering it to look like that with help of his agent.