![]() |
|
So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... (/showthread.php?tid=12370) |
RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Sliced - 09-06-2020 (09-05-2020, 01:03 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:(09-05-2020, 12:48 PM)Sliced Wrote: That is a massive leap. You seem to be getting worked up about something that no one has said and I wasn't insinuating. It's ok, my apologies for reading your post as worked up when you weren't. I see your point. I just think that the story doesn't encourage people to check ID's better or do their job properly, it actually discourages thorough checking so not to offend. If this becomes a more regular occurrence then there will be some (not many, but some) people who will happily steal the identity of someone from another gender, using their ID's in the knowledge that it's the potential for an awkward conversation may lead to the ID's not being checked properly. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Squid - 09-06-2020 (09-05-2020, 12:55 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(09-05-2020, 11:53 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:(09-05-2020, 10:56 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(09-05-2020, 10:19 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:(09-05-2020, 09:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Sex and race are biological.Well that concept of gender was introduced in the 50s and started to gain traction in the 70s but it did not mean this for most of human history. And we somehow survived. Not saying it isn't progress to have these new definitions and understandings for affected groups in society, and it is good for everyone to be aware, just don't think we should be spending so much time on it and entertaining any and all ideas. I/we blame social media. So many, many words about the rights of males to be treated as women. Let's be clear. Gender Reassignment is a protected class under the Equality Act 2010. Therefore you cannot be sacked or discriminated against for being transgender. So trans people are protected under law. They have "basic recognition". But Sex (biological sex) is a also a protected class under the Equality Act 2010 and it makes specific mention of where discrimination on the basis of sex may be lawful, e.g for a women's refuge to only employ women. Stonewall and certain other trans rights groups are trying to muddy the law by confusing sex and gender and claiming that those exemptions don't apply to trans women, e.g if a women's shelter wanted to serve biological females only this would be unlawful. Stonewall et al are wrong. The issues surrounding women's sport are real, not soundbites. Laurel Hubbard a trans women, wasn't even in the top 500 male weight lifters. Now winning golds in women's competitions. I see lots of waffle about "third genders in other cultures" upthread. The Samoans indeed have such a culture (the fa'fina) and they still called out Laurel Hubbard winning gold as utter unfairness when Hubbard beat their athlete into second place. In Ireland, a male sex offender who had undergone no treatment whatsoever, was able to complete self-id form and be put in a women's prison https://www.lawsociety.ie/gazette/top-stories/male-bodied-transgender-inmate-housed-with-women-prisoners/ In the UK, a male called themselves Karen White, claimed to be transgender was put in a women's prison and raped four women. But none of that is a bad as not using the correct pronouns I suppose? RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Borin' Baggie - 09-06-2020 (09-06-2020, 12:51 PM)Squid Wrote:(09-05-2020, 12:55 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(09-05-2020, 11:53 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:(09-05-2020, 10:56 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(09-05-2020, 10:19 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Well that concept of gender was introduced in the 50s and started to gain traction in the 70s but it did not mean this for most of human history. And we somehow survived. Not saying it isn't progress to have these new definitions and understandings for affected groups in society, and it is good for everyone to be aware, just don't think we should be spending so much time on it and entertaining any and all ideas. I/we blame social media. Who are you arguing with? Seriously? Nothing you have responded with bears any relevance whatsoever with what I put. First off, the point over "basic recognition" that I made pertained with relation to how difficult it is it to get recognised as being transgender. Workplace protections are irrelevant if they're not able to be legally recognised as the gender they want to be despite having all the qualifiers such as years of evidence pertaining to living as that gender, hormone treatment and surgery. Secondly, I've not mentioned Stonewall in defence. Why bring it up? The only part that alluded to them was a criticism of what they said if you care to actually read what I put. Thirdly, the soundbites I was referring to relate to a report on the risks and advantages of androgenisation being applied to cases where they're not relevant (by Stonewall) with the risk of people who don't have the advantages gained owing to being on puberty blockers before transitioning and the side effect of risking the prevention of mixing at youth sports despite the gender advantage not being present in young children (being ignored by people weaponising the report to attack what Stonewall said). Laurel Hubbard clearly went through androgenisation which has enabled her to have an unfair advantage in that field so I don't why you're bringing it up, it doesn't apply to what I said. Fourthly, as I am pretty sure I have said before to you, I'm not in favour of self ID legislation and I was just presenting the perfectly valid argument people who want it have argued with via that hypothetical as I'm sure Mayo and most, if not all people on here are very well versed in the arguments against it so they didn't need repeating. Fifthly, sex offenders should not be put in with prison populations that are at risk to them full stop. Being trans is irrelevant. Sixthly, specifically in the case of Karen White, ignoring the fact that point 5 applies in that case the legislation needs to be robust enough to handle nuance so as to accommodate the risks posed by the transfer on top of the reasons why the legislation was amended in the first place (that being two trans women died in male prisons). Unless you want to actually have a serious argument related to my points and not make up an irrelevant strawman, don't bother responding. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - HawkingsHalfpint - 09-06-2020 Having been to French Polynesia, you wouldn’t touch (nor argue) with any of ‘em! RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - MassDebater - 09-06-2020 (09-06-2020, 01:51 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Having been to French Polynesia, you wouldn’t touch (nor argue) with any of ‘em! I hope yam self isolating, they're on the list now I believe
RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Squid - 09-06-2020 Borin'Baggie you have no knowledge of current legislation, so nothing in my response is irrelevant. My words are not just for you, but anyone who may be mislead by what you have written. You stated: " they're not able to be legally recognised as the gender they want to be despite having all the qualifiers such as years of evidence pertaining to living as that gender, hormone treatment and surgery." This is untrue. The Gender Recognition Act 2004 enables all this to happen for trans people in the UK on obtaining a gender recognition certificate. The Equality Act 2010 is not just about the workplace, I used it as an example. Are you now clearer about the current UK law and what it actually says? The current debate about trans women in sport is entirely about people who have gone through normal puberty, because this is the case for the vast majority of trans people. The use of puberty blockers in children is massively controversial. Hence the ongoing whistleblowing at the Tavistock gender clinic in the UK https://youtu.be/zTRnrp9pXHY Where the use of puberty blockers has become normalised, so to has "gender confirming" surgeries on children. In the US 13 and 14 year females are having double mastectomies. Unsurprisingly, there is now a growing detransitioner movement, mainly of females who regret having had surgery and hormones. https://www.bioedge.org/mobile/view/13-year-olds-given-mastectomies-at-california-clinic/12816 I note wearily, that you make no mention of the rights of women to have single sex spaces. You refer to two trans women dying in prison, but you do not say why or how they died, or why women should lose their rights and compromise their safety as a result of this. This is not a matter of "nuance". Either women have the rights to acknowledge that biological sex is real and we have the rights to single sex services, or we do not. Under the cover of "nuance" you would be removing the right of all women to have: Single sex hospital wards Single sex domestic violence shelters Single sex prison accommodation Single sex changing facilities in the workplace Our own sporting categories To ask for a female doctor To ask for a female counsellor This is what you are arguing for and I want to hear exactly why you think women deserve to lose these rights. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Borin' Baggie - 09-06-2020 Are you actually reading what I've put because I'm seriously doubting that you are. The GRA 2004 is what I'm talking about with regards to having issues over legal recognition, the hypothetical I put forward is related to the issues over the tribunal and the referral times over legal issues in conflict with referral times for medical issues as per the GRA 2004. Note how I continually refer to recognition, this is clearly in reference to gender recognition certificates. There's also the issues over how many protections as provided by the EA 2010 are reliant on a GRC as cited by the EHRC. This why trans people want it to be easier to obtain a GRC, you're more than welcome to read the GRA consultation document, the bureaucracy surrounding obtaining a GRC as per the GRA is a serious problem. And I know this because I'm friends with a trans man who has gone through various surgeries and as far as I'm concerned is a guy yet legally he isn't owing to the process outlined with the GRA. I repeat, those workplace protections, and the EA 2010, is wholly irrelevant to the discussion. Are you now clear on my point? I really don't give a shit about discussing general trans women status in sport, it isn't relevant to anything I am saying. I am worried about there being a lack of nuance in the discussion where groups that aren't subject to the criticisms (people who haven't undergone androgenisation through puberty) are being lumped in, and therefore ignored, with the actual problems that don't apply to them. With respect to the process of prescribing puberty blockers this is again irrelevant and the fact is, whether you like it or not, that people who have been on puberty blockers before transitioning don't have the unfair sporting biological advantages in sports that people are taking objection to competing so the nuance over their participation in said sports clearly needs to be applied differently and subject to a different level of evidence, especially in respect to recreational level and not competitive level sports as per the report on rugby that I have being referred to, on top of the potential knock-on effects on segregating junior level sport (as per U11 rugby and football). Do you think it's fair that in these situations where there isn't a biological advantage should be applied the same as where there is? I don't, and people like Hubbard aren't in any way related to what is being discussed as there is a clear biological advantage. I haven't mentioned single-sex safe spaces as I didn't think they need to be discussed. Why would I be opposed to them? Why would you think I would be opposed to them? I have mates who are women, I'm well aware of why they're needed. Why should trans women who have clearly lived as women be forced into male prison populations where they're at risk? I don't know how or why those trans women died, all I do know is that they died in prison and that is why the legislation was updated. I also know that the legislation was rushed and didn't allow for nuance which is why the decision over moving Karen White wasn't scrutinised to the level is should have been. It is clearly a nuanced issue and treating it as black and white and ignoring any difference in cases is outright ridiculous. Are you saying you support: Trans women and trans men being forced into single sex spaces by virtue of their birth regardless of their level of transition and the risks posed by them or posed to them? Trans women who have no biological advantage by virtue of how they've transitioned being banned from recreational sport? Trans men and women being unable to legally change their gender regardless of the level of their transition and evidence over lifestyle? Trans women who have undergone full surgery and being on hormones for a long period of time to be forced into male changing facilities or toilets? As I affirm, it is cleary nuanced. Treating it as black and white and not allowing for nuance is putting people in danger both one way or another. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - HawkingsHalfpint - 09-06-2020 (09-06-2020, 02:05 PM)MassDebater Wrote:(09-06-2020, 01:51 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Having been to French Polynesia, you wouldn’t touch (nor argue) with any of ‘em! It was 9 years ago, think I’m clear now! (09-06-2020, 09:55 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I'd say the concept is ethnicity, not race. I've always thought the Human Race, therefore our species is termed Homo Sapiens. Apart from Dingels, obviously. This one too. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Derek Hardballs - 09-06-2020 What box would someone who proclaims Covid 19 to be a hoax fit into? RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Squid - 09-06-2020 Borin - 1) You are arguing for Self-ID. You haven't actually referred to anything concrete other than "My friend says". Self-ID would lead to all the problems I have stated above. For those who apply for a GRC, the vast majority obtain one, as can be see here: https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2017-10-06/105995 2)Children being given puberty blockers have problems far beyond sporting participation. This will become one of the greatest medical scandals of our time. Again, I know you don't care about that either. 3) You appear to be opposed to single sex spaces because you are happy to let the opposite sex enter them. 4) Why should trans women who have clearly lived as women be forced into male prison populations where they're at risk? Why are they at risk? Would that be from violent men? Funny you have so little to say about this. Anyway, they've opened a special unit for them for trans women, they can go there. Again, you refer to legislation when you mean policy. Now to your questions: QTrans women and trans men being forced into single sex spaces by virtue of their birth regardless of their level of transition and the risks posed by them or posed to them? ATrans women are male and by all evidence retain male patterns of criminal offending. So they can either use male spaces or campaign for third spaces. Again, you aren't thinking this through. Does this mean you are happy for female police/customs officers to have to strip search transwomen, even if the transwomen retain their male genitalia (as most do). Q Trans women who have no biological advantage by virtue of how they've transitioned being banned from recreational sport? They all retain an advantage. Please see Ross Tucker's extensive work on this. Q Trans men and women being unable to legally change their gender regardless of the level of their transition and evidence over lifestyle? A I am happy with the current legislation. Q Trans women who have undergone full surgery and being on hormones for a long period of time to be forced into male changing facilities or toilets? These are very, very rare. Most trans women retain male genitalia and many don't take hormones. Again, I would want third spaces. For further evidence of why, please see https://www.womenarehuman.com/ |