RE: Gone With The Wind - CA Baggie - 06-10-2020
(06-10-2020, 09:11 AM)steviedm Wrote: This is a worrying development, in my opinion. While I broadly welcome the events of the last few weeks and have no problem with the removal of statues that glorify those who profited from the slave trade, we need to be careful about how far this is pushed. The statue issue is very different to film/TV representations - statues by their nature are erected for the purpose of idolatry: the subject usually stands literally higher than the onlooker and the artwork exists because there is a widely held belief its subject should be admired and venerated. The removal of statues that effectively celebrate those involved in the slave trade is therefore welcome - but they should not be wiped from history; statues such as Colston's have a future in museums with proper interpretation detailing the history of slavery and the way in which it enriched individuals and nations such as our own.
I teach film at A level and one of the options on the Film History paper is The Birth of a Nation, DW Griffiths's groundbreaking 1915 film, which introduced many of the techniques now standard in filmmaking. The film is racist to its core, surpassing Gone With The Wind, but its shocking representations help add context to discussions of race and provide an insight into the way America saw race just over a hundred years ago. Rather than be banned, it should be shown with contextual notes and used as an educational tool to help people frame contemporary debates.
I also teach media and for about 15 years now have shown students excerpts from lots of 1970s TV shows such as Love Thy Neighbour, Curry and Chips, Till Death Us Do Part etc. They are shocked at the racist content and then I show them clips of Matt Lucas playing characters in Come Fly With Me. In one, he is blacked up as a Jamaican coffee shop worker called Precious Little. She is depicted as lazy and overly religious - ridiculous stereotyping for a show broadcast on BBC1 within the last decade. I found it offensive at the time and I find it offensive now, but I don't think it should be removed from streaming services as if it never happened.
I am against historical revisionism in any form - the removal of smoking from Tom and Jerry cartoons, the apparent deletion of Gary Glitter from Glam Rock history (BBC4 once ran a documentary on the history of Glam Rock and did not even mention his name). It is dangerous and sets worrying precedents for the future.
I always teach students that pretty much everything is about context so some orientation/contextual materials to accompany content with questionable representations by modern standards is important to frame them correctly - removing them is a step too far.
Interesting. I never once watched that and saw any racial slur or undertones. I laughed more at the portrayal of the WI women being overtly racist and shining a light on the sort of institutional racism that certain organisations can have.
Making Leigh Francis apologise for imitating Craig David or Mel B is pathetic and just going to feed the right wing. He isn't doing a parody or mocking them for being black, those 2 people just happen to be so.
We have to be careful how we progress through the re-writing of history and the slave trade. The Western ancestors didn't take the Africans across the Atlantic because they were black, they did it for money and because they needed the labour and control of it. It wasn't done with racist intentions, it was about power and money for their themselves and their nations. It has become a racial problem over time because as slaves they were kept with no rights and subjugated to the point that the people with the money and power (mainly the white westerners\Americans) have yet to properly redress this to the mass population and truly adopt equality for all. The slave catchers and masters of West Africa were black and doing it for money and power too as were the Egyptians before them and so on. It's what the Human race does best (or worst). I'm sure history needs revising but the younger generation need to given the context of the times and I suppose the truth and reality of it. It was human-trafficking for financial gain which was legally allowed because the people of power making the laws had self interest in doing so.
The people of the 1950/60s who first immigrated here will see a different world now to when they first arrived, there's still a long way to go. The first wave of immigrants had to suffer inner city housing and worked poorly paid jobs because that was what our economy offered them post-war. It will take time to redress the social injustices and knock-on effects of this but it will happen.
You can't cure the views of each older generation but the passing of time will change this. Ask the kids about race and then ask the grandparent generation and you'll see a different world will emerge, views are thankfully changing. There will always be racists and this is done across many races by all races to others. There will also be homophobia and sexism etc it just needs pushing out to the margins of society. Too many people with these views have too much power and control which is why institutional racism still prevails.
Positive discrimination or enacting Rooney Law type legislation will, in my opinion, slow the natural process of generational change down because it gives the right a fuel to hang on to. It doesn't provide equality for all.
There's no magic switch to take away racism, continual education to the younger generation will make it happen.
Picking these things out misses the bigger picture of the social injustices that black people
RE: Gone With The Wind - TETLEY74 - 06-10-2020
(06-10-2020, 12:31 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (06-10-2020, 09:11 AM)steviedm Wrote: This is a worrying development, in my opinion. While I broadly welcome the events of the last few weeks and have no problem with the removal of statues that glorify those who profited from the slave trade, we need to be careful about how far this is pushed. The statue issue is very different to film/TV representations - statues by their nature are erected for the purpose of idolatry: the subject usually stands literally higher than the onlooker and the artwork exists because there is a widely held belief its subject should be admired and venerated. The removal of statues that effectively celebrate those involved in the slave trade is therefore welcome - but they should not be wiped from history; statues such as Colston's have a future in museums with proper interpretation detailing the history of slavery and the way in which it enriched individuals and nations such as our own.
I teach film at A level and one of the options on the Film History paper is The Birth of a Nation, DW Griffiths's groundbreaking 1915 film, which introduced many of the techniques now standard in filmmaking. The film is racist to its core, surpassing Gone With The Wind, but its shocking representations help add context to discussions of race and provide an insight into the way America saw race just over a hundred years ago. Rather than be banned, it should be shown with contextual notes and used as an educational tool to help people frame contemporary debates.
I also teach media and for about 15 years now have shown students excerpts from lots of 1970s TV shows such as Love Thy Neighbour, Curry and Chips, Till Death Us Do Part etc. They are shocked at the racist content and then I show them clips of Matt Lucas playing characters in Come Fly With Me. In one, he is blacked up as a Jamaican coffee shop worker called Precious Little. She is depicted as lazy and overly religious - ridiculous stereotyping for a show broadcast on BBC1 within the last decade. I found it offensive at the time and I find it offensive now, but I don't think it should be removed from streaming services as if it never happened.
I am against historical revisionism in any form - the removal of smoking from Tom and Jerry cartoons, the apparent deletion of Gary Glitter from Glam Rock history (BBC4 once ran a documentary on the history of Glam Rock and did not even mention his name). It is dangerous and sets worrying precedents for the future.
I always teach students that pretty much everything is about context so some orientation/contextual materials to accompany content with questionable representations by modern standards is important to frame them correctly - removing them is a step too far.
Interesting. I never once watched that and saw any racial slur or undertones. I laughed more at the portrayal of the WI women being overtly racist and shining a light on the sort of institutional racism that certain organisations can have.
Making Leigh Francis apologise for imitating Craig David or Mel B is pathetic and just going to feed the right wing. He isn't doing a parody or mocking them for being black, those 2 people just happen to be so.
We have to be careful how we progress through the re-writing of history and the slave trade. The Western ancestors didn't take the Africans across the Atlantic because they were black, they did it for money and because they needed the labour and control of it. It wasn't done with racist intentions, it was about power and money for their themselves and their nations. It has become a racial problem over time because as slaves they were kept with no rights and subjugated to the point that the people with the money and power (mainly the white westerners\Americans) have yet to properly redress this to the mass population and truly adopt equality for all. The slave catchers and masters of West Africa were black and doing it for money and power too as were the Egyptians before them and so on. It's what the Human race does best (or worst). I'm sure history needs revising but the younger generation need to given the context of the times and I suppose the truth and reality of it. It was human-trafficking for financial gain which was legally allowed because the people of power making the laws had self interest in doing so.
The people of the 1950/60s who first immigrated here will see a different world now to when they first arrived, there's still a long way to go. The first wave of immigrants had to suffer inner city housing and worked poorly paid jobs because that was what our economy offered them post-war. It will take time to redress the social injustices and knock-on effects of this but it will happen.
You can't cure the views of each older generation but the passing of time will change this. Ask the kids about race and then ask the grandparent generation and you'll see a different world will emerge, views are thankfully changing. There will always be racists and this is done across many races by all races to others. There will also be homophobia and sexism etc it just needs pushing out to the margins of society. Too many people with these views have too much power and control which is why institutional racism still prevails.
Positive discrimination or enacting Rooney Law type legislation will, in my opinion, slow the natural process of generational change down because it gives the right a fuel to hang on to. It doesn't provide equality for all.
There's no magic switch to take away racism, continual education to the younger generation will make it happen.
Picking these things out misses the bigger picture of the social injustices that black people Very very good post.
RE: Gone With The Wind - Fido - 06-10-2020
(06-10-2020, 12:31 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (06-10-2020, 09:11 AM)steviedm Wrote: This is a worrying development, in my opinion. While I broadly welcome the events of the last few weeks and have no problem with the removal of statues that glorify those who profited from the slave trade, we need to be careful about how far this is pushed. The statue issue is very different to film/TV representations - statues by their nature are erected for the purpose of idolatry: the subject usually stands literally higher than the onlooker and the artwork exists because there is a widely held belief its subject should be admired and venerated. The removal of statues that effectively celebrate those involved in the slave trade is therefore welcome - but they should not be wiped from history; statues such as Colston's have a future in museums with proper interpretation detailing the history of slavery and the way in which it enriched individuals and nations such as our own.
I teach film at A level and one of the options on the Film History paper is The Birth of a Nation, DW Griffiths's groundbreaking 1915 film, which introduced many of the techniques now standard in filmmaking. The film is racist to its core, surpassing Gone With The Wind, but its shocking representations help add context to discussions of race and provide an insight into the way America saw race just over a hundred years ago. Rather than be banned, it should be shown with contextual notes and used as an educational tool to help people frame contemporary debates.
I also teach media and for about 15 years now have shown students excerpts from lots of 1970s TV shows such as Love Thy Neighbour, Curry and Chips, Till Death Us Do Part etc. They are shocked at the racist content and then I show them clips of Matt Lucas playing characters in Come Fly With Me. In one, he is blacked up as a Jamaican coffee shop worker called Precious Little. She is depicted as lazy and overly religious - ridiculous stereotyping for a show broadcast on BBC1 within the last decade. I found it offensive at the time and I find it offensive now, but I don't think it should be removed from streaming services as if it never happened.
I am against historical revisionism in any form - the removal of smoking from Tom and Jerry cartoons, the apparent deletion of Gary Glitter from Glam Rock history (BBC4 once ran a documentary on the history of Glam Rock and did not even mention his name). It is dangerous and sets worrying precedents for the future.
I always teach students that pretty much everything is about context so some orientation/contextual materials to accompany content with questionable representations by modern standards is important to frame them correctly - removing them is a step too far.
Interesting. I never once watched that and saw any racial slur or undertones. I laughed more at the portrayal of the WI women being overtly racist and shining a light on the sort of institutional racism that certain organisations can have.
Making Leigh Francis apologise for imitating Craig David or Mel B is pathetic and just going to feed the right wing. He isn't doing a parody or mocking them for being black, those 2 people just happen to be so.
We have to be careful how we progress through the re-writing of history and the slave trade. The Western ancestors didn't take the Africans across the Atlantic because they were black, they did it for money and because they needed the labour and control of it. It wasn't done with racist intentions, it was about power and money for their themselves and their nations. It has become a racial problem over time because as slaves they were kept with no rights and subjugated to the point that the people with the money and power (mainly the white westerners\Americans) have yet to properly redress this to the mass population and truly adopt equality for all. The slave catchers and masters of West Africa were black and doing it for money and power too as were the Egyptians before them and so on. It's what the Human race does best (or worst). I'm sure history needs revising but the younger generation need to given the context of the times and I suppose the truth and reality of it. It was human-trafficking for financial gain which was legally allowed because the people of power making the laws had self interest in doing so.
The people of the 1950/60s who first immigrated here will see a different world now to when they first arrived, there's still a long way to go. The first wave of immigrants had to suffer inner city housing and worked poorly paid jobs because that was what our economy offered them post-war. It will take time to redress the social injustices and knock-on effects of this but it will happen.
You can't cure the views of each older generation but the passing of time will change this. Ask the kids about race and then ask the grandparent generation and you'll see a different world will emerge, views are thankfully changing. There will always be racists and this is done across many races by all races to others. There will also be homophobia and sexism etc it just needs pushing out to the margins of society. Too many people with these views have too much power and control which is why institutional racism still prevails.
Positive discrimination or enacting Rooney Law type legislation will, in my opinion, slow the natural process of generational change down because it gives the right a fuel to hang on to. It doesn't provide equality for all.
There's no magic switch to take away racism, continual education to the younger generation will make it happen.
Picking these things out misses the bigger picture of the social injustices that black people
Good post. Had a beery Zoom call on Saturday with some old friends from uni days (27 years ago!) and my opinion was very similar re education and time being the best way forward as opposed to knee-jerk symbolic actions that just caused more issues.
RE: Gone With The Wind - baggiebloke - 06-10-2020
Excellent contributions to this thread.
Very considered, refreshing words in this current mini-age of madness.
Thanks, gents.
RE: Gone With The Wind - WWHO - 06-10-2020
(06-10-2020, 12:06 PM)col lard Wrote: (06-10-2020, 11:03 AM)WWHO Wrote: (06-10-2020, 10:41 AM)billybassett Wrote: If I remember correctly the film awarded the first Oscar to an African American.
Society is angry. Social media is the accelerant.
They are angry about lots of things and rightly so: racism, bame representation/rights, climate change, poverty, inequality, homophobia, needless covid deaths.
Media headlines for a few days, a few statues torn down, Netflix disclaimers on films for racism, slavery etc...all worthy but what really changes. America voted in an African American potus but the people voted an orange racist bigot misogynist a few years later. We voted in a PM who has used the words piccaninnies, water melon smiles and bum boys.
So no doubt this will all blow away with the next indignation and deep down people will just carry on looking after themselves. Without proper political and institutional reform people can riot to their hearts content on one issue to the next but whilst we keep voting in the white, middle aged, bigoted, rich, privileged, media controlled puppets nothing will change.
Just watch PMQs later. Two middle aged white sluggers of men, worried about social media feeds and the right's press, spewing out palliatives and plaintives in a parliament built for the rich, with a constitution and electoral system meant to keep those very people in power.
It is also worth noting that, due to segregation laws, she wasn't allowed to attend the film's premiere. Also, she initially wasn't allowed to attend the Oscar ceremony, again to to the Jim Crow laws. It was only after Clark Gable had threatened to boycott the event that she was allowed to accept her award in person. She was still forced to sit alone at a separate table located at the back of the venue.
There's an echo in here.
Doh, sorry pal. Skimmed over it.
RE: Gone With The Wind - baggpuss - 06-10-2020
Where will this end though?
Will the crows in Dumbo be banned next??
RE: Gone With The Wind - Dumbo - 06-10-2020
(06-10-2020, 05:20 PM)baggpuss Wrote: Where will this end though?
Will the crows in Dumbo be banned next??
Excuse me?
RE: Gone With The Wind - baggpuss - 06-10-2020
(06-10-2020, 05:22 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (06-10-2020, 05:20 PM)baggpuss Wrote: Where will this end though?
Will the crows in Dumbo be banned next??
Excuse me?
Well I done seen about everything but........
RE: Gone With The Wind - ColliersWoodBaggie - 06-10-2020
(06-10-2020, 09:02 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (06-10-2020, 08:32 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The re writing of history is concerning it's going one way ....if they want to get all slavery statues that's fine by me but they they want anyone who was a abuser to their workforce and tyrants but I hope some dont go crying to mommy when nelson Mandela is torn down by some as he neclaced his own people by putting tyres around their neck and set them alight burning them alive .its a dangerous path we are going down. They binned little Britain yesterday too!
Some black professor was saying yesterday that getting rid of the slave trader statues, eradicating any references to anything unPC from history actually is counterproductive as it stops people realising these things happened.
As someone middle of the road, cosmopolitan and liberal, I think extreme liberalism is fuelling the right wing. What happened with that George Floyd is a million miles away from a bit of a piss take like they did on Little Britain.
If we can't gently find the humour in life's differences then we are well and truly fecked.
The rise of the right will continue to gather momentum unless we stop such extreme actions by the far left. It really isn't helping our society that we can't have mature debates.
"Some Black Professor".
(06-10-2020, 09:11 AM)steviedm Wrote: This is a worrying development, in my opinion. While I broadly welcome the events of the last few weeks and have no problem with the removal of statues that glorify those who profited from the slave trade, we need to be careful about how far this is pushed. The statue issue is very different to film/TV representations - statues by their nature are erected for the purpose of idolatry: the subject usually stands literally higher than the onlooker and the artwork exists because there is a widely held belief its subject should be admired and venerated. The removal of statues that effectively celebrate those involved in the slave trade is therefore welcome - but they should not be wiped from history; statues such as Colston's have a future in museums with proper interpretation detailing the history of slavery and the way in which it enriched individuals and nations such as our own.
I teach film at A level and one of the options on the Film History paper is The Birth of a Nation, DW Griffiths's groundbreaking 1915 film, which introduced many of the techniques now standard in filmmaking. The film is racist to its core, surpassing Gone With The Wind, but its shocking representations help add context to discussions of race and provide an insight into the way America saw race just over a hundred years ago. Rather than be banned, it should be shown with contextual notes and used as an educational tool to help people frame contemporary debates.
I also teach media and for about 15 years now have shown students excerpts from lots of 1970s TV shows such as Love Thy Neighbour, Curry and Chips, Till Death Us Do Part etc. They are shocked at the racist content and then I show them clips of Matt Lucas playing characters in Come Fly With Me. In one, he is blacked up as a Jamaican coffee shop worker called Precious Little. She is depicted as lazy and overly religious - ridiculous stereotyping for a show broadcast on BBC1 within the last decade. I found it offensive at the time and I find it offensive now, but I don't think it should be removed from streaming services as if it never happened.
I am against historical revisionism in any form - the removal of smoking from Tom and Jerry cartoons, the apparent deletion of Gary Glitter from Glam Rock history (BBC4 once ran a documentary on the history of Glam Rock and did not even mention his name). It is dangerous and sets worrying precedents for the future.
I always teach students that pretty much everything is about context so some orientation/contextual materials to accompany content with questionable representations by modern standards is important to frame them correctly - removing them is a step too far.
Very good post. I agree with much of this. The media angle needs to be protected as you say. 'D.W. Griffiths, Curry and Chips' et al a case in point. The former is an uncomfortable watch , and I studied it along with History and Literature of the South at University . It was fascinating.
Statues are different and should be used to form part of a 'Slavery Museum' or exhibition. But, I'd argue, they do not educate as much when standing in a street.
But I think the protests are more than historical revisionism and statues - they are protests against the bigger picture of institutional racism and , let's be fair, direct racism at street level which some people experience. In that sense , it isn't censorship or history being erased - it is history itself as history is fluid and is never a static phenomenon. Things progress on many levels, and this time is a chance for the history of Britain to do that; all it is is acknowledgement that 'philanthropists' often got rich (literally) off the backs of others , whether coal miners, slaves or cotton mill child labour. And the Slave Trade profits fuelled the Industrial Revolution and the technological progress of 18/19th Century Britain. It is also marked that there are quite a number of current Tory MPs and donors, descendents of former slave/plantation owners , who, gained the equivalent of 100s of millions of pounds in compensation following abolition. It probably paved the way for their vast wealth. Which they didn't get by getting on their bikes to work.
And this Island Story has many histories, many are intertwined across class, ethnicity, gender, political and social groups.
One or two crow about 'censorship'. Well, let's talk about the censorship of the GCSE Medicine Through Time Curriculum. Mary Seacole has all but been expunged from the Curriculum. Gove , when Ed Sec in 2013, tried to do it for the KS3 History curriculum. There wa a backlash and the decision was reversed, but Edexcel's textbook is devoid of any mention of her.
RE: Gone With The Wind - Spandaubaggie - 06-10-2020
(06-10-2020, 07:58 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: (06-10-2020, 09:02 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (06-10-2020, 08:32 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The re writing of history is concerning it's going one way ....if they want to get all slavery statues that's fine by me but they they want anyone who was a abuser to their workforce and tyrants but I hope some dont go crying to mommy when nelson Mandela is torn down by some as he neclaced his own people by putting tyres around their neck and set them alight burning them alive .its a dangerous path we are going down. They binned little Britain yesterday too!
Some black professor was saying yesterday that getting rid of the slave trader statues, eradicating any references to anything unPC from history actually is counterproductive as it stops people realising these things happened.
As someone middle of the road, cosmopolitan and liberal, I think extreme liberalism is fuelling the right wing. What happened with that George Floyd is a million miles away from a bit of a piss take like they did on Little Britain.
If we can't gently find the humour in life's differences then we are well and truly fecked.
The rise of the right will continue to gather momentum unless we stop such extreme actions by the far left. It really isn't helping our society that we can't have mature debates.
"Some Black Professor".
(06-10-2020, 09:11 AM)steviedm Wrote: This is a worrying development, in my opinion. While I broadly welcome the events of the last few weeks and have no problem with the removal of statues that glorify those who profited from the slave trade, we need to be careful about how far this is pushed. The statue issue is very different to film/TV representations - statues by their nature are erected for the purpose of idolatry: the subject usually stands literally higher than the onlooker and the artwork exists because there is a widely held belief its subject should be admired and venerated. The removal of statues that effectively celebrate those involved in the slave trade is therefore welcome - but they should not be wiped from history; statues such as Colston's have a future in museums with proper interpretation detailing the history of slavery and the way in which it enriched individuals and nations such as our own.
I teach film at A level and one of the options on the Film History paper is The Birth of a Nation, DW Griffiths's groundbreaking 1915 film, which introduced many of the techniques now standard in filmmaking. The film is racist to its core, surpassing Gone With The Wind, but its shocking representations help add context to discussions of race and provide an insight into the way America saw race just over a hundred years ago. Rather than be banned, it should be shown with contextual notes and used as an educational tool to help people frame contemporary debates.
I also teach media and for about 15 years now have shown students excerpts from lots of 1970s TV shows such as Love Thy Neighbour, Curry and Chips, Till Death Us Do Part etc. They are shocked at the racist content and then I show them clips of Matt Lucas playing characters in Come Fly With Me. In one, he is blacked up as a Jamaican coffee shop worker called Precious Little. She is depicted as lazy and overly religious - ridiculous stereotyping for a show broadcast on BBC1 within the last decade. I found it offensive at the time and I find it offensive now, but I don't think it should be removed from streaming services as if it never happened.
I am against historical revisionism in any form - the removal of smoking from Tom and Jerry cartoons, the apparent deletion of Gary Glitter from Glam Rock history (BBC4 once ran a documentary on the history of Glam Rock and did not even mention his name). It is dangerous and sets worrying precedents for the future.
I always teach students that pretty much everything is about context so some orientation/contextual materials to accompany content with questionable representations by modern standards is important to frame them correctly - removing them is a step too far.
Very good post. I agree with much of this. The media angle needs to be protected as you say. 'D.W. Griffiths, Curry and Chips' et al a case in point. The former is an uncomfortable watch , and I studied it along with History and Literature of the South at University . It was fascinating.
Statues are different and should be used to form part of a 'Slavery Museum' or exhibition. But, I'd argue, they do not educate as much when standing in a street.
But I think the protests are more than historical revisionism and statues - they are protests against the bigger picture of institutional racism and , let's be fair, direct racism at street level which some people experience. In that sense , it isn't censorship or history being erased - it is history itself as history is fluid and is never a static phenomenon. Things progress on many levels, and this time is a chance for the history of Britain to do that; all it is is acknowledgement that 'philanthropists' often got rich (literally) off the backs of others , whether coal miners, slaves or cotton mill child labour. And the Slave Trade profits fuelled the Industrial Revolution and the technological progress of 18/19th Century Britain. It is also marked that there are quite a number of current Tory MPs and donors, descendents of former slave/plantation owners , who, gained the equivalent of 100s of millions of pounds in compensation following abolition. It probably paved the way for their vast wealth. Which they didn't get by getting on their bikes to work.
And this Island Story has many histories, many are intertwined across class, ethnicity, gender, political and social groups.
One or two crow about 'censorship'. Well, let's talk about the censorship of the GCSE Medicine Through Time Curriculum. Mary Seacole has all but been expunged from the Curriculum. Gove , when Ed Sec in 2013, tried to do it for the KS3 History curriculum. There wa a backlash and the decision was reversed, but Edexcel's textbook is devoid of any mention of her.
Here you go Colliers. Here’s the professor. He is black. Walking on friggin eggshells here! https://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/fp/news/politics/scottish-politics/2246546/sir-geoff-palmer-scotlands-first-black-professor-on-overcoming-racism-demolishing-statues-and-the-highland-clearances/
|