WBAUnofficial
Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same (/showthread.php?tid=10235)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-09-2020

(05-07-2020, 06:51 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-07-2020, 06:14 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: What do you think he did that made Labour unelectable? What should he have done differently?

Always interested when people say this sort of thing as I though the policies in the 2019 manifesto were much better than the Conservative one.

It wasn't anything so very much to do with the policies. He came with too much baggage. Corbyn had a terrible image with working class voters that remembered him photographed with people they see as enemies. The PLO, the IRA. Many in our areas have connections with the armed forces and wouldn't overlook this. Then his unfathomable stance on Brexit. A lifelong Brexiteer, yet Corbyn never convinced anyone exactly where he stood.  Then after the Salisbury poisonings, when the leaders of many countries publicly condemned  Russia, he came out with some rubbish about needing time to get to the bottom of it before accusing them (Russia), despite everyone in Europe knowing and castigating them.  Once again appearing unpatriotic.   I've never voted for anyone other than Labour but from the start he was unpopular with the electorate in the traditional Labour voting areas. He may well be the nicest guy in the world, but if the electorate didn't like him, he should have moved out of the way for someone that was electable. Not doing so is, as I said earlier,  a selfish and vain act that let down anyone he claimed to support.

+1 to all of that. Very few people outside the bubble of "Momentum" and similar nostalgia-driven leftist Labour thinkers can have thought Corbyn was fit for the job. You need personality and empathy to sell radical policies (unless you're a Tory in which case you can get away with anything). You need to be free of the kind of baggage that surrounds Corbyn. At a time when Britain needed a functional opposition, we had the buffoon Corbyn, Lib-Dems who can't shake off the blame for the coalition (see my comment above about Tories getting away with anything) and SNP who are obsessed with independence above any other issue.

Just having better policies than the Tories and having a similarly mixed track record while in government is never enough to secure a Labour win on the unequal battleground of British politics. Too many people believe the press-led rhetoric that Labour always get government wrong while the Tories always get government right. The starting point is a charismatic, intelligent, forceful leader. Brown, Miliband and then Corbyn fell far short. Starmer has a huge amount of re-building to do. Meanwhile the feckless Boris will fuck up our economy. He'll blame Covid 19 and austerity for everything "but the Conservative Party is now under new management".


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - chasetownbaggie - 05-09-2020

(05-08-2020, 09:39 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-07-2020, 06:14 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: What do you think he did that made Labour unelectable?

Big Grin Oh may days. How long have you got?

We've all got plenty of time. Answer his question.


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - Ossian - 05-09-2020

(05-07-2020, 06:14 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: What do you think he did that made Labour unelectable? What should he have done differently?

Chammy, if I had to answer this I would probably identify two things as critical (this is just my opinion, by the way).

First thing is that he failed to acknowledge that he personally was an electoral disadvantage; a big one at that. His personal approval ratings were consistently around minus 40%, and I know he's someone who would argue that it should be about policies and not personalities but that in itself betrays a lack of understanding of present day politics in the UK. Particularly for the left, who don't compete on equal terms, and however wrong that is it's a reality that has to be confronted.

Secondly, he appeared wilfully not to grasp that the 2019 election would inevitably centre around a single issue (Brexit, obviously), and he was warned about this by the likes of Blair and Campbell - probably the last voices he was ever likely to listen to, even if they do know a thing or two about winning elections. 

Brexit became, for many voters, almost a patriotic issue, and while I personally never saw it in those terms there were plenty of longtime Labour voters who did. Patriotism is unfortunately an area where he doesn't play well with the electorate and it made him an easy target for his detractors in politics and the media.

For a time I thought Labour were putting together a decent manifesto, but they never seemed to know when they'd reached the point to stop adding to it. By the end every new announcement just further undermined the credibility.

I still voted Labour though: I knew we were going to lose, but I wasn't about to go down without firing off a round.


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - Squid - 05-10-2020

(05-08-2020, 09:47 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: "mischief"
"taking advantage"
"how long have you got"

sooooooo, nothing then? Apart from meaningless soundbites straight from the tory propaganda mill. Labour policies would result in a better quality of life (and longer life, especially in terms of this crisis) for more people in this country. You know it and I know it. Couldn't give a fuck if Corbyn had 'up the ra' tattooed on his arse.

Places which never voted Tory, ever voted for them in droves, because they detested Corbyn that much, as was repeatedly stated on the doorsteps and people are still saying "Waaah, why don't you love Magic Grandad?"

My local Labour MP has said harsher things about Corbyn than anyone on this thread. His only hope for the last election was to hold onto enough decent Labour MPs to rebuild the party.


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - ChamonixBaggie - 05-10-2020

Good reply oss. Your 2nd para is something I know to be true but struggle to reconcile myself with as it's so maddeningly frustrating. "we're not gonna vote for our lives to be significantly improved unless you get a snazzy showman to sell it to us first. If not, the same old bastards it will be!" wtf is wrong with this country.

Lifelong Labour voters going blue because they 'hated' corbyn is equally mental. Who cares if you don't like him and anyway why don't you like him?? Because he didn't bow low enough at the cenotaph?! It's all meaningless

Christ, I hate people


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - Malcolm Tucker - 05-10-2020

Imagine if Diane Abbott has stood in front of the press literally making numbers up...


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - Baggybenny - 05-10-2020

(05-10-2020, 07:42 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Imagine if Diane Abbott has stood in front of the press literally making numbers up...

Do you imagine that Hancock has not made up lots of numbers up ?


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - Tom Joad - 05-10-2020

(05-10-2020, 07:02 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Good reply oss. Your 2nd para is something I know to be true but struggle to reconcile myself with as it's so maddeningly frustrating. "we're not gonna vote for our lives to be significantly improved unless you get a snazzy showman to sell it to us first. If not, the same old bastards it will be!" wtf is wrong with this country.

Lifelong Labour voters going blue because they 'hated' corbyn is equally mental. Who cares if you don't like him and anyway why don't you like him?? Because he didn't bow low enough at the cenotaph?! It's all meaningless

Christ, I hate people

No. I don't like him because he put a personal vanity project above the interests of the people he is supposed to serve. Anyone who bothered to mix with the constituents of the Black Country (and probably every Labour stronghold from there to Gatehead),could have foretold this. As for blaming the people, isn't that like the England cricket team blaming the Barmy Army after a defeat?


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - Derek Hardballs - 05-10-2020

Labour lost because of the following...

Corbyn and Momentum are not appealing to anybody outside of their bubble. In short it was obvious his tenure was self indulgent, myopic and doomed to failure as many more sensible / cynical / realistic centre left types pointed out. Appealing to just your own supporters is not what wins you elections.

Many of our electorate have been convinced by very rich media types to vote against their own interests. Over many, many years. A constant drip of poison has been cleverly introduced to the U.K. conversation conflating austerity with the EU, migration etc. Toxic imo but it has worked.

Most people aren’t interested in politics so simple slogans like ‘Get Brexit Done’ cut through easily with that demographic. You don’t have to appeal to rational argument, belief is a far stronger determining factor in many people’s decision making.

A client media that allowed lie after lie to be told by one party in particular to go unchallenged, one SM platform allowing I think 80% of one parties adverts to be seen and shared by millions despite them being factually misleading shall we say.

But the elephant in the room of course was this election was always about Brexit and Labours message was messy, added further uncertainty and regardless of whether it’s a good or bad decision was appealing to the areas that had seen years and years of under investment.

The fact Labour agreed to an election in the first place was testament to how out of touch they were with many in the country. Frankly the choice at the last election was a shit or sick sandwich for lunch.


RE: Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same - Protheroe - 05-11-2020

(05-08-2020, 09:47 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: "mischief"
"taking advantage"
"how long have you got"

sooooooo, nothing then? Apart from meaningless soundbites straight from the tory propaganda mill. Labour policies would result in a better quality of life (and longer life, especially in terms of this crisis) for more people in this country. You know it and I know it. Couldn't give a fuck if Corbyn had 'up the ra' tattooed on his arse.

Labour became unelectable the day it put a lifelong Brexit supporter in charge of an anti Brexit Party and thought it could come up with a coherent narrative on the greatest consitutional question of our time.

Labour became unelectable the day it appointed a shadow chancellor so inept he'd been sacked by Ken Livingstone. A shadow chancellor who held up mass murderer Mao's little red book in the HoC, a shadow chancellor that would've ridden roughshod over the rule of law, markets and property rights leading to the greatest capital flight in history.

Labour became unelectable the day it elected a leader who happily entertained mass murderers and those who called for mass murder in the HoC.

That's without the ludicrous policies on immigration that appeal to no-one outside London, that's without the playing of the race card to stifle debate on everything from congenital birth defects to FGM to Pakistani rape gangs, that's without the full frontal assault on Britain's proud history, proud heritage and place in the world.

Under Corbyn Labour became a toxic breeding ground for all those elements Kinnock thought he'd defeated in 1985. I'm proud that the electorate put them firmly in their place.