WBAUnofficial
PSR breach reported by John Percy - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: PSR breach reported by John Percy (/showthread.php?tid=41270)



RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - sickParrot - 04-16-2026

(04-16-2026, 10:44 AM)MGalea Wrote: Lisa Nandy: "Now we all know that Dave Whelan broke his leg....."
Not exactly a laughing marrow


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - BristolCityInPeace - 04-16-2026

(04-16-2026, 12:24 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 10:50 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: I will say one thing WBA aside.

The amount Aston Villa get away with..they got promoted just in the nick of time passing FFP only by £5m, £6m despite including £36.6m in Villa Park sale, £14.4m in HS2 Revenue and a 3rd and final year in Parachute Payments??

Looking again Promotion Bonuses aren't excluded now save for the year of Promotion wonder if that pushes them over to 2021 or 2022. The £30m for Xia to Lerner covered by new owners so understandable on one level but in this context??

Warehouse sale wouldn't be permissible under EFL P&S Regs now, neither would their Stadium Sale. Women's Team maybe but by as much.

Aston Villa and Chelsea very charmed life loophole wise.

We know that mon, they pulled a genius stroke by offering Christian Purslow the chance to be their chief finance officer straight after he compiled the FFP rules. From the answer I got ( at a villa unofficial bbq  free for all in Little Aston) it was take us to court and we'll tie you up forever. Villa were an day or so from HMRC locking the doors and the only way the takeover would go ahead would be if they had freedom to compete and get a return. Their problem now is they got out of jail but under the same rules they struggle to threaten the top 2. I guess Newcastle and all their wealth also are thinking about what they signed up for.
Agreed albeit Idk if that was a bit of a one hit thing.

Final year of Parachute, the aforementioned exceptional items would've seen a £60m-£65m hole in 2019-20 ie the 3 years ending in that.

I'm sure them selling Grealish would've been a very real prospect in 2019-20 without Promotion. Had you beat them in the Playoffs..and what we now know that is the EFL are indeed keen to have long standing disputes with clubs about arcane accounting principals..dunno if that was the case in 2018-19 under Shaun Harvey.

I think timing was in their favour too, as well as your expert insight.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - BaggieSloth - 04-16-2026

Obviously everything being said right now is all "Hear say and Speculation" from whatever source you decide to believe - but from what ive read just now - the decision could be made as late as 24th June (The day before the fixtures come out) this would be identical to what happened to Derby.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Duffers - 04-16-2026

(04-16-2026, 11:59 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote:
(04-16-2026, 12:24 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 10:50 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: I will say one thing WBA aside.

The amount Aston Villa get away with..they got promoted just in the nick of time passing FFP only by £5m, £6m despite including £36.6m in Villa Park sale, £14.4m in HS2 Revenue and a 3rd and final year in Parachute Payments??

Looking again Promotion Bonuses aren't excluded now save for the year of Promotion wonder if that pushes them over to 2021 or 2022. The £30m for Xia to Lerner covered by new owners so understandable on one level but in this context??

Warehouse sale wouldn't be permissible under EFL P&S Regs now, neither would their Stadium Sale. Women's Team maybe but by as much.

Aston Villa and Chelsea very charmed life loophole wise.

We know that mon, they pulled a genius stroke by offering Christian Purslow the chance to be their chief finance officer straight after he compiled the FFP rules. From the answer I got ( at a villa unofficial bbq  free for all in Little Aston) it was take us to court and we'll tie you up forever. Villa were an day or so from HMRC locking the doors and the only way the takeover would go ahead would be if they had freedom to compete and get a return. Their problem now is they got out of jail but under the same rules they struggle to threaten the top 2. I guess Newcastle and all their wealth also are thinking about what they signed up for.
Agreed albeit Idk if that was a bit of a one hit thing.

Final year of Parachute, the aforementioned exceptional items would've seen a £60m-£65m hole in 2019-20 ie the 3 years ending in that.

I'm sure them selling Grealish would've been a very real prospect in 2019-20 without Promotion. Had you beat them in the Playoffs..and what we now know that is the EFL are indeed keen to have long standing disputes with clubs about arcane accounting principals..dunno if that was the case in 2018-19 under Shaun Harvey.

I think timing was in their favour too, as well as your expert insight.

They came incredibly close to selling Grealish to Spurs around that time. My Seal mates all talk of it as their great Sliding Doors moment.

At the end of Dr Tony's ownership Villa were on their knees and on the brink of administration, completely fucked financially and needed to sell. They were prepared to sell Grealish to Spurs for £10m right up until Daniel Levy tried to take the piss on the fee (as Levy often did). Instead of just paying the fee he tried to offer £3m plus Josh Onomah, Villa told him to fuck off, kept hold of Grealish and were bought shortly afterwards.

Rest, as they say, is history.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Tom Joad 25 - 04-16-2026

(04-16-2026, 10:14 AM)ericlegrisly too Wrote:
(04-16-2026, 10:05 AM)Mullers Wrote: The matter has been raised in Parliament by Sarah Coombes MP to the Sec. of State for Culture, Media & Sport:

https://x.com/sarahcoombeswb/status/2044716054841106560?s=46&t=603GCPJ36Sk2mCQSort3AQ

Very good, but an entirely non-answer from Nandy.

Yeah. A "your call is very important to us, we will do everything in our power to answer it by 2035....." Thanks Lisa, just get on the phone to the EFL and ask them if they are really sure they want to go ahead with this.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - BristolCityInPeace - 04-16-2026

(04-16-2026, 12:45 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-16-2026, 11:59 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote:
(04-16-2026, 12:24 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 10:50 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: I will say one thing WBA aside.

The amount Aston Villa get away with..they got promoted just in the nick of time passing FFP only by £5m, £6m despite including £36.6m in Villa Park sale, £14.4m in HS2 Revenue and a 3rd and final year in Parachute Payments??

Looking again Promotion Bonuses aren't excluded now save for the year of Promotion wonder if that pushes them over to 2021 or 2022. The £30m for Xia to Lerner covered by new owners so understandable on one level but in this context??

Warehouse sale wouldn't be permissible under EFL P&S Regs now, neither would their Stadium Sale. Women's Team maybe but by as much.

Aston Villa and Chelsea very charmed life loophole wise.

We know that mon, they pulled a genius stroke by offering Christian Purslow the chance to be their chief finance officer straight after he compiled the FFP rules. From the answer I got ( at a villa unofficial bbq  free for all in Little Aston) it was take us to court and we'll tie you up forever. Villa were an day or so from HMRC locking the doors and the only way the takeover would go ahead would be if they had freedom to compete and get a return. Their problem now is they got out of jail but under the same rules they struggle to threaten the top 2. I guess Newcastle and all their wealth also are thinking about what they signed up for.
Agreed albeit Idk if that was a bit of a one hit thing.

Final year of Parachute, the aforementioned exceptional items would've seen a £60m-£65m hole in 2019-20 ie the 3 years ending in that.

I'm sure them selling Grealish would've been a very real prospect in 2019-20 without Promotion. Had you beat them in the Playoffs..and what we now know that is the EFL are indeed keen to have long standing disputes with clubs about arcane accounting principals..dunno if that was the case in 2018-19 under Shaun Harvey.

I think timing was in their favour too, as well as your expert insight.

They came incredibly close to selling Grealish to Spurs around that time. My Seal mates all talk of it as their great Sliding Doors moment.

At the end of Dr Tony's ownership Villa were on their knees and on the brink of administration, completely fucked financially and needed to sell. They were prepared to sell Grealish to Spurs for £10m right up until Daniel Levy tried to take the piss on the fee (as Levy often did). Instead of just paying the fee he tried to offer £3m plus Josh Onomah, Villa told him to fuck off, kept hold of Grealish and were bought shortly afterwards.

Rest, as they say, is history.

£10m eh..that would surely have seen them stay down.

I mean in Summer 2019 though, they would have a huge FFP hole despite major loopholes in the upcoming season.

Did they get their £14.4m HS2 (some reports say as high as £20m in 3 seasons) quicker than the average person or business. I reckon so but speculation on my part.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - baggie_ray - 04-16-2026

(04-16-2026, 10:05 AM)Mullers Wrote: The matter has been raised in Parliament by Sarah Coombes MP to the Sec. of State for Culture, Media & Sport:

https://x.com/sarahcoombeswb/status/2044716054841106560?s=46&t=603GCPJ36Sk2mCQSort3AQ

Just seen this on the news. Absolutely pointless "question". 

Does the minister agree that the club's situation is awful for the fans and can she urge that it is resolved as quickly as possible?

Yes, it's "awful" for the fans. Yes, I can urge all I like but, at the end of the day, the process has to play out within the already determined timescale. Fuck all I can do about that.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - tHEgLASSdOORS - 04-16-2026

(04-16-2026, 06:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(04-16-2026, 10:05 AM)Mullers Wrote: The matter has been raised in Parliament by Sarah Coombes MP to the Sec. of State for Culture, Media & Sport:

https://x.com/sarahcoombeswb/status/2044716054841106560?s=46&t=603GCPJ36Sk2mCQSort3AQ

Just seen this on the news. Absolutely pointless "question". 

Does the minister agree that the club's situation is awful for the fans and can she urge that it is resolved as quickly as possible?

Yes, it's "awful" for the fans. Yes, I can urge all I like but, at the end of the day, the process has to play out within the already determined timescale. Fuck all I can do about that.

I largely agree Ray but every bit of pressure on the grossly incompetent EFL to produce a fudged outcome that leaves all parties happy is a good thing imo


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - baggie_ray - 04-16-2026

(04-16-2026, 06:21 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(04-16-2026, 06:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(04-16-2026, 10:05 AM)Mullers Wrote: The matter has been raised in Parliament by Sarah Coombes MP to the Sec. of State for Culture, Media & Sport:

https://x.com/sarahcoombeswb/status/2044716054841106560?s=46&t=603GCPJ36Sk2mCQSort3AQ

Just seen this on the news. Absolutely pointless "question". 

Does the minister agree that the club's situation is awful for the fans and can she urge that it is resolved as quickly as possible?

Yes, it's "awful" for the fans. Yes, I can urge all I like but, at the end of the day, the process has to play out within the already determined timescale. Fuck all I can do about that.

I largely agree Ray but every bit of pressure on the grossly incompetent EFL to produce a fudged outcome that leaves all parties happy is a good thing imo

Yeah, I hadn't considered that aspect.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Tom Joad 25 - 04-16-2026

(04-16-2026, 06:21 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(04-16-2026, 06:18 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(04-16-2026, 10:05 AM)Mullers Wrote: The matter has been raised in Parliament by Sarah Coombes MP to the Sec. of State for Culture, Media & Sport:

https://x.com/sarahcoombeswb/status/2044716054841106560?s=46&t=603GCPJ36Sk2mCQSort3AQ

Just seen this on the news. Absolutely pointless "question". 

Does the minister agree that the club's situation is awful for the fans and can she urge that it is resolved as quickly as possible?

Yes, it's "awful" for the fans. Yes, I can urge all I like but, at the end of the day, the process has to play out within the already determined timescale. Fuck all I can do about that.

I largely agree Ray but every bit of pressure on the grossly incompetent EFL to produce a fudged outcome that leaves all parties happy is a good thing imo

Yep. Every little helps raise the profile of what appears to be an injustice.