![]() |
|
Growth - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Growth (/showthread.php?tid=37673) |
RE: Growth - Protheroe - 06-22-2026 No. If Welfare was not available for things like "mild anxiety" (Gen Xers call this "life") then youngsters may feel more inclined to get the bus to work. As it is we continue to import low skilled / low wage labour, adding to our housing problems, future welfare / health spending and of course the cultural transformation of our inner cities. RE: Growth - baggy1 - 06-23-2026 Possibly the daftest argument you’ve ever made. I agree that there appear to be too many easy options these days to get benefits and I agree that youngsters are taking advantage of that and it needs to be looked at. The rate of youth unemployment is running slightly over average compared to the last 35 years so this isn’t the ‘crisis’ that is being made out. However the fact that there is immigration doesn’t drive those kids to taking the easy option. There is immigration and there always has been. The words you are using are exactly the same as when my grandad moved over here after the 1st world war when the Irish were being pointed at, and worse, for changing the cultural landscape. If that is the point that you want to make then just say that, don’t use the lame excuse that kids are lazy because there are too many darkies taking there jobs, that isn’t the reason they are not working. We moved my MIL into a home yesterday and all of the staff that I saw working in the unpleasant jobs were immigrants, thank God that they are there because if they weren’t we’d have a bigger crisis in elderly care. RE: Growth - Protheroe - 06-23-2026 (06-23-2026, 06:12 AM)baggy1 Wrote: We moved my MIL into a home yesterday and all of the staff that I saw working in the unpleasant jobs were immigrants, thank God that they are there because if they weren’t we’d have a bigger crisis in elderly care. I'm sorry to hear about your MIL, but that says everything you need to know about the priorities in this country. As even Zack Polanski pointed out, we expect immigrants to wipe our arses on poverty pay. Are you really suggesting to me that if we didn't employ such people on low wages that these jobs wouldn't get done at all? You're not, are you? If One Million kids doing nothing is "not a crisis", then I'm not sure what is. RE: Growth - baggy1 - 06-23-2026 Thanks. I've shown you the 16-24 year old unemployment figures for the past 35 years and we are currently running 1.4% above average (16.2% compared with 14.8%). 2010 - 2013 ran at over 20% for the whole period. We are simply in a cycle of youth unemployment that is just above the average. Do I think that is bad, yes, do I think that kids could do more to get off their arses, yes, do I think that there are benefits available to them that weren't there 40 years ago when I was in that bracket, yes, do I think that it is a crisis, no but something needs to be done, do I think immigrants are to blame, not at all, do I think that kids don't want to wipe arses, we've conditioned them to believing that they should be getting better so I'm not surprised. And I'm suggesting that if we doubled the wages we still wouldn't get kids off their arses to do it, so we need the immigrants otherwise we'd have a real crisis where kids would have to be unpaid carers for their elderly relations otherwise they'd have no-one to look after them. RE: Growth - Borin' Baggie - 06-23-2026 Most PIP and DLA claimants are "Gen X", four times the rate of Gen Z, so shove your "life" comment up your arse. Non-EU migrants are higher earners in both full-time and part-time work than their native equivalents and therefore pay more tax. Referring to migrant labour as being "imported" is horribly dehumanising. UK population growth is lower than it would have been if we'd had zero net migration over the last 30 years but maintained a birth rate of 2.1. RE: Growth - baggy1 - 06-23-2026 Arf, good facting, but I would expect them to be more likely to claim DLA or PIP purely on the basis that they will all be over 50 i.e. more likely to need help with disabilities. A better measure would be a comparison between the numbers claiming benefit over the last 40 years in that age bracket (or indeed in all age brackets). RE: Growth - Borin' Baggie - 06-23-2026 There is actually a drop in both the rate and absolute numbers of DLA and PIP claimants from the previous cohort for the baby boomer cohort (60-66) so that doesn't track either. RE: Growth - baggy1 - 06-23-2026 It's more the 18-24 year old bracket that I was looking at. I managed to find the data on those claiming JSA and UC and the figures are better - 422k in 1997 compared with 336.3k now for that age group (low being 156.4k in Feb 17, and high being 532.4 in July 2020 obviously covid related) Which is why i'm wondering is this just a contrived issue that is being highlighted now because we have a Labour government. One thing is certain though is the amount that is being spent on benefits is going up dramatically since covid, that is the bit that is unaffordable although the biggest chunk there is pensions. RE: Growth - Protheroe - 06-23-2026 (06-23-2026, 07:25 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Most PIP and DLA claimants are "Gen X", four times the rate of Gen Z, so shove your "life" comment up your arse. Non-EU migrants are higher earners in both full-time and part-time work than their native equivalents and therefore pay more tax. Referring to migrant labour as being "imported" is horribly dehumanising. UK population growth is lower than it would have been if we'd had zero net migration over the last 30 years but maintained a birth rate of 2.1. You don't surprise me that grasping bastards exist across the ages. After all, successive governments have conditioned them to be clients of the state whether through tax credits, bank bailouts, furlough or energy price support. You seem to believe I'm anti legal immigration. I'm not. I'm anti people sitting on their arses, the fact that the government enables migration in for low level and entry level jobs simply enables such behaviour by individuals. If I'm honest, it's also about the middle classes not taking enough responsibility for themselves and their future. Zac Polanksi inadvertently slipped out their / our dirty secret. RE: Growth - baggy1 - 06-23-2026 If we don't have immigration to fill those low and entry level jobs, who will do them? |