RE: Swansea match thread - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-08-2023
(05-08-2023, 06:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's quite possible to not rate a player and not hate them.
Has our defence ever looked solid with Ajayi playing? I'd say no, he wanders, he switches off and he is often out of position. The two most important things for a defender, and he's bad at them.
He's a good pro, and he certainly gives his all, and he isn't a technically bad player, but he is a poor defender overall, a few good games over a lot more poor ones don't change that.
I absolutely detest how modern football has decided defending is secondary to being good with the ball, then teams wonder why they concede cheap goals so easily, defending is a skill, one that requires concentration for every second of the game, a sense of positional awareness that comes from discipline and constant practice. Get that all down, and then being able to pass is useful.
Great post, Birdmon. Ajayi has many qualities, but he's unreliable. At risk of being mocked on here for my alleged worship of Craig Dawson, look what an influence he had at West Ham and now at the Wulfs. Short of pace and silky football skills, but good at defending. Ally Robertson was one of my early Hawthorns heroes. Only Dara O'Shea is even remotely close to that quality.
RE: Swansea match thread - Birdman1811 - 05-08-2023
(05-08-2023, 09:00 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (05-08-2023, 06:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's quite possible to not rate a player and not hate them.
Has our defence ever looked solid with Ajayi playing? I'd say no, he wanders, he switches off and he is often out of position. The two most important things for a defender, and he's bad at them.
He's a good pro, and he certainly gives his all, and he isn't a technically bad player, but he is a poor defender overall, a few good games over a lot more poor ones don't change that.
I absolutely detest how modern football has decided defending is secondary to being good with the ball, then teams wonder why they concede cheap goals so easily, defending is a skill, one that requires concentration for every second of the game, a sense of positional awareness that comes from discipline and constant practice. Get that all down, and then being able to pass is useful.
Great post, Birdmon. Ajayi has many qualities, but he's unreliable. At risk of being mocked on here for my alleged worship of Craig Dawson, look what an influence he had at West Ham and now at the Wulfs. Short of pace and silky football skills, but good at defending. Ally Robertson was one of my early Hawthorns heroes. Only Dara O'Shea is even remotely close to that quality.
It's a genuine love of defending that few players have. O`Shea does, can see how he puts his body on the line for blocks and celebrates good defensive actions. Being a tidy footballer too is great, but get the basics of defending down first, it's why I like O`Shea, and like you, I rated Dawson highly.
RE: Swansea match thread - Peachy - 05-08-2023
(05-08-2023, 09:02 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (05-08-2023, 09:00 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (05-08-2023, 06:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's quite possible to not rate a player and not hate them.
Has our defence ever looked solid with Ajayi playing? I'd say no, he wanders, he switches off and he is often out of position. The two most important things for a defender, and he's bad at them.
He's a good pro, and he certainly gives his all, and he isn't a technically bad player, but he is a poor defender overall, a few good games over a lot more poor ones don't change that.
I absolutely detest how modern football has decided defending is secondary to being good with the ball, then teams wonder why they concede cheap goals so easily, defending is a skill, one that requires concentration for every second of the game, a sense of positional awareness that comes from discipline and constant practice. Get that all down, and then being able to pass is useful.
Great post, Birdmon. Ajayi has many qualities, but he's unreliable. At risk of being mocked on here for my alleged worship of Craig Dawson, look what an influence he had at West Ham and now at the Wulfs. Short of pace and silky football skills, but good at defending. Ally Robertson was one of my early Hawthorns heroes. Only Dara O'Shea is even remotely close to that quality.
It's a genuine love of defending that few players have. O`Shea does, can see how he puts his body on the line for blocks and celebrates good defensive actions. Being a tidy footballer too is great, but get the basics of defending down first, it's why I like O`Shea, and like you, I rated Dawson highly.
Olsson and Gmac are two of my all time favourite players in my 47 years. Those two encapsulate everything I love about centre halfs. Tough as rock. Great concentration. Great organisation. Love a battle and most importantly know what their limitations were. Never overplayed. Kept it simple and gave the ball to ball players when needed.
What I would give to have those two back next season.
RE: Swansea match thread - Calgary_Baggie - 05-08-2023
(05-08-2023, 09:22 PM)Peachy Wrote: (05-08-2023, 09:02 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (05-08-2023, 09:00 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (05-08-2023, 06:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's quite possible to not rate a player and not hate them.
Has our defence ever looked solid with Ajayi playing? I'd say no, he wanders, he switches off and he is often out of position. The two most important things for a defender, and he's bad at them.
He's a good pro, and he certainly gives his all, and he isn't a technically bad player, but he is a poor defender overall, a few good games over a lot more poor ones don't change that.
I absolutely detest how modern football has decided defending is secondary to being good with the ball, then teams wonder why they concede cheap goals so easily, defending is a skill, one that requires concentration for every second of the game, a sense of positional awareness that comes from discipline and constant practice. Get that all down, and then being able to pass is useful.
Great post, Birdmon. Ajayi has many qualities, but he's unreliable. At risk of being mocked on here for my alleged worship of Craig Dawson, look what an influence he had at West Ham and now at the Wulfs. Short of pace and silky football skills, but good at defending. Ally Robertson was one of my early Hawthorns heroes. Only Dara O'Shea is even remotely close to that quality.
It's a genuine love of defending that few players have. O`Shea does, can see how he puts his body on the line for blocks and celebrates good defensive actions. Being a tidy footballer too is great, but get the basics of defending down first, it's why I like O`Shea, and like you, I rated Dawson highly.
Olsson and Gmac are two of my all time favourite players in my 47 years. Those two encapsulate everything I love about centre halfs. Tough as rock. Great concentration. Great organisation. Love a battle and most importantly know what their limitations were. Never overplayed. Kept it simple and gave the ball to ball players when needed.
What I would give to have those two back next season.
Don't say that to Pearce, he'll be on the blower!
RE: Swansea match thread - Super-Okay - 05-08-2023
O’Shea
Bartley
Ajayi
Kipré
Caleb Taylor
Kelly
I hope we don’t offer terms to either Pieters or Bryan, because imo we need to move on 2 from above.
Ideally Kelly and one of Kipré/Bartley or Ajayi.
|