![]() |
|
Socialism- Communism or - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Socialism- Communism or (/showthread.php?tid=9838) |
RE: Socialism- Communism or - Borin' Baggie - 04-08-2020 (04-08-2020, 03:47 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-08-2020, 02:05 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Germany's healthcare system has a tremendous level of slack built in due to the decentralised nature of it. One of the big criticisms over there, ironically, is the level of subsidy given to private healthcare over maintaining the number of empty beds in hospitals and practices. That, in conjunction with the huge level of chemical research and manufacturing, is one of the key reasons they've been able to mitigate this crisis effectively. Slack is essential in times of crisis, the issue should never be about having it or not having it in a medical setting but to determine what level is appropriate and manageable financially. The NHS is a successful healthcare system, if you take the terrible procurement systems out of it then you'll see just how lean it is and it is unquestionably better than the social insurance system it replaced as was its purpose. Even if you include the terrible procurement systems it is still the most cost effective and efficient healthcare system. Couple that with the fact that the Germans and Dutch pay more to maintain their healthcare systems than we do there is no evidence that simply moving to a social insurance model will improve things unless you put more money into the healthcare sector, which would still come from tax and a new mandatory insurance levy which functions like a tax. All this would do with the tax burden here is move the books around a bit to hide national debt. That's not even mentioning that fiddling with the NHS is political suicide and no government will ever do it. You can incorporate elements of the Dutch and German systems into the existing system anyway, you just need to empower the trusts more, introduce GP deposits/visitor fees and encourage preventative healthcare (though this would need significant lifestyle changes) alongside changing how NI works by breaking it up and ring fencing NI contributions to their relevant areas. The last time this was tried was during the coalition, though the Tories blocked the latter aspect which meant funding didn't scale properly and Hunt and Lansley obstructed the former which severely damaged how trusts are burdened, Hunt was even called out by David Laws over his incompetence. RE: Socialism- Communism or - Protheroe - 04-09-2020 (04-08-2020, 04:30 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The NHS is a successful healthcare system Not if you measure it internationally on outcomes (what other measure actually matters?), nor by any measure on the sheer scale of the scandals it's tried to sweep under the carpet. Personally my mother's care in the 7 years she's had stage 4 cancer has ranged from the lamentable to the laudable. My late father's care was without exception - appalling. I don't care how 'lean' the organisation is - I only care abut outcomes. RE: Socialism- Communism or - Borin' Baggie - 04-09-2020 (04-09-2020, 09:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-08-2020, 04:30 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The NHS is a successful healthcare system Measuring based on outcomes is useless if you don't equalise for staffing numbers and relative funding, the fact that the NHS is underfunded relative to the healthcare systems around it and has significantly fewer numbers of staff per capita in every area except midwifery than all its contemporaries bar Ireland shows why outcomes are relatively poor. You can't criticise the outcomes and then not address the primary reason for the outcomes. The NHS is a successful healthcare system. It's vastly better than the Bismarckesque social insurance model that it replaced and is still implemented in Germany and Switzerland as was its intended purpose and it is the most efficient healthcare system in the world. The latter point emphasises why it is successful, the outcomes relative to the funding level are world leading which points to the funding level being a huge bottleneck. If you look at other countries that have implemented the Beveridge model and have a higher level of funding than we do (Finland, Italy, Denmark, Norway, Sweden) their healthcare systems are at the top of the list. RE: Socialism- Communism or - Bromley Baggie 2 - 04-09-2020 Is the OP an American? They're unable to understand the difference between socialism and communism, either. RE: Socialism- Communism or - Ossian - 04-09-2020 (04-09-2020, 11:40 AM)Bromley Baggie 2 Wrote: Is the OP an American? Norway, Cuba... peas in a pod. RE: Socialism- Communism or - Protheroe - 04-09-2020 (04-09-2020, 10:59 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:(04-09-2020, 09:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-08-2020, 04:30 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The NHS is a successful healthcare system We won't agree on this. The NHS won't improve one iota unless it is decoupled from general taxation - and those of us who pay for it then start to make proper demands on its service rather than beatifying it despite its abject failings. My biggest fear is that once all this is over we'll just chuck even more money at a sacred cow and ignore its rotting flesh. RE: Socialism- Communism or - Borin' Baggie - 04-14-2020 (04-09-2020, 03:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-09-2020, 10:59 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:(04-09-2020, 09:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-08-2020, 04:30 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: The NHS is a successful healthcare system The NHS won't improve one iota until we're not 24th out of 28 European countries in terms of every single healthcare worker per capita aside from midwives. Finland, Sweden, Denmark, Norway and Taiwan have shown that Beveridge model can provide the best levels of global healthcare in the modern world and Ireland has shown that the Bismarck model doesn't provide better healthcare outcomes than the NHS. We could replicate the Bismarck model or the NHI model in the UK but I guarantee you that they would not fix anything as the underlying issues have nothing to do with the funding source of the NHS. RE: Socialism- Communism or - Protheroe - 04-15-2020 (04-14-2020, 01:31 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: the underlying issues have nothing to do with the funding source of the NHS. I wholly disagree. For as long as the NHS is funded from general taxation its users will not demand the levels of service they would from any other service. The cost needs to be clear. Instead we beatify a wholly failing service. RE: Socialism- Communism or - baggy1 - 04-15-2020 (04-15-2020, 08:39 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-14-2020, 01:31 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: the underlying issues have nothing to do with the funding source of the NHS. When you expect people to complete work that most of us would throw up doing whilst at the same time restrict their wages and underfund their equipment then you will have a problem. Then basing a management structure on the private sector whilst not paying the same as the private sector will only lead you to one result - the idiots that couldn't get by in the well paid private sector roles move down the food chain to the public sector where they can still get their ego's massaged as they hold power (this is a generalisation btw, I know many good managers in the public sector). Pay front line workers the proper wages, pay competitive managerial wages to the management, and restructure into a lean body then we will move towards the solution. Keep underfunding and we will keep getting the same problems. RE: Socialism- Communism or - Borin' Baggie - 04-15-2020 (04-15-2020, 08:39 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-14-2020, 01:31 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: the underlying issues have nothing to do with the funding source of the NHS. I'm confused? You're saying you're not opposed to the Beveridge model but you just want the NHS ringfenced by NI contributions rather than the treasury pool? Regardless, if you look at all the metrics that help determine health outcomes (numbers of staff per capita, hospital capacity, distribution of specialists) then it becomes apparent that the NHS has a lot less of that than the countries with better health outcomes and as such that is the problem area that needs to be addressed and not fiddling the books. |