WBAUnofficial
Small ground for loyal fans latest - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Small ground for loyal fans latest (/showthread.php?tid=9183)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - Tom Joad - 02-27-2020

There's a bit of snobbery here.
We all have different levels of commitment. OK, some of us are every game home and away, others home season ticket holders while others have other commitments preventing them from going all of the time. I remember some of the Grorty Dick team looking down on me while speaking (in a pub in Middlesborough), because I didn't regularly travel to away RESERVE games! There's no need for any levels of one upmanship. Some of my mates stopped their STs under Pulis. Up until then they were home and away dating back to 3rd division days and beyond. I wouldn't like to tell them they aren't real fans.


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - SW4Baggie - 02-27-2020

(02-27-2020, 05:28 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:24 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Ashton Gate’s capacity is a couple hundred more than ours and they’re yet to average over 21k... 

As I said on the other thread, their average jumped 4k after the redevelopment of the stadium.

And I’ve not denied that if we were to expand, our attendances may well jump up too, however what is the point? 

If we get promoted, it doesn’t matter how many fans we have in the ground, we’d still make a profit playing in an empty stadium and with the TV bubble showing no sign of bursting, it wouldn’t realistically give us any competitive advantage on the other sides around us in the PL, and if we dropped into the championship or below, where gate receipts matter, wed still only get 21-22k attendances at best given we don’t always sell out despite being top of the league and playing great football.

Given we have to cut out cloth accordingly, we have far better investments than the 30M+ it would cost to add a significant number of seats to the ground. If we get some benevolent benefactor, then sure, let’s increase capacity, but as it stands the fact the odd few people are embarrassed that Bristol City have a bigger ground than us which they can’t fill, and Spandau can’t sit with his friends aren’t good enough reasons for expansion.

Can anyone name a club with a capacity of around 25k who have expanded their ground without external financial backing and gone on to greater success as a result?

(02-27-2020, 04:30 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:24 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:15 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:02 PM)MassDebater Wrote: So, what proportion of the ground should be kept empty to allow fairweathers to rock up a few hours or a couple of days before kick off?

It's currently about 1/5 of the capacity, which sounds decent to me.

Don't know. Let's look at the likes of Derby, Leicester, Southampton, Forest, Bristol City etc, etc, who have leapfrogged us in capacity and attendances over the years and see how they evaluated it and means now we have a 'mid table championship' capacity.
Think big or think small. It's as simple as that.

2 of those clubs are in the PL, and the other two have average attendances that would fit in the Hawthorns... Ashton Gate’s capacity is a couple hundred more than ours and they’re yet to average over 21k... 

We have the 4th highest average attendance in the division, despite there being at least 10 teams with a higher capacity... other than Fulham and Luton, we have the highest % of bums to seats so I’d suggest our capacity is about where it should be.

Could we put another 3-4000 people on our gates, yes we probably could, is it economically viable, probably not. Given there’s no waiting list for STs and people can still buy tickets on the gate for a lot of games I’d sooner a few fair weather fans missed out on sitting together if it means we don’t have 10k empty seats if the success dries up.

That's the difference I think in thinking. The "when success dries up" is planning on failure. Others think we should plan for success. I know where I am on that

There are 6 (7 if you include Everton due to their top flight record) who will always make up the top 6 places. There are then another 30 or so teams who make up the remaining 14 PL places, and hover between the bottom half of the Prem and the top half of League One.

We have finished 8th, we’ve had 8 successive years in the PL. This is as much as we can hope for in the current set up, and our stadium size in no way influences this.

As long as we remain prudently run, we will continue to hover between the PL and the Champ where increasing the number of people at games will make absolutely fuck all difference.


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - Spandaubaggie - 02-27-2020

I've just read the Jenkins piece, for the first time, and it certainly is enlightening. However, whilst the Halfords remains a bone of contention, especially to people with long legs like me, it's the overall unwillingness to expand that is the issue, not just completely focussing on the Halfords, although that's the obvious problem.
As I said, as a fan I'm not unusual in that I attend occasionally, there's 35,000 like me. You can bet if I'm moaning about lack of choice and spaces in the stadium then there will be many who feel the same. It's not just me and a handful of mates SW4.


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - SW4Baggie - 02-27-2020

(02-27-2020, 06:22 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I've just read the Jenkins piece, for the first time, and it certainly is enlightening. However, whilst the Halfords remains a bone of contention, especially to people with long legs like me, it's the overall unwillingness to expand that is the issue, not just completely focussing on the Halfords, although that's the obvious problem.
As I said, as a fan I'm not unusual in that I attend occasionally, there's 35,000 like me. You can bet if I'm moaning about lack of choice and spaces in the stadium then there will be many who feel the same. It's not just me and a handful of mates SW4.

Sorry Spandau, I don’t mean to be disingenuous. If you’re genuinely not attending because you can’t sit with the people you want to attend with, it’s a shame, but I suppose that’s part of the reason why I get a ST... I know I won’t make every game, and I know that I may well actually be better off buying individual tickets, but I want to sit with people who I know and hence the ST makes the most sense. I realise this isn’t always the case for everyone... if I can’t make a game, I can usually find someone who will use the seat in my absence. 

I’m not anti expansion at all, I agree we probably could have a slightly larger ground, however I’m also a pragmatist. The mythical 35k on the database will include people who have no intention of attending but bought a ticket so they could go to Wembley a few years ago, away fans who sat in the home end for Chelsea and United games, plenty of duplicates (there are 3 of me on my ST membership and the ticket office can’t fix it) and probably a fair few fans who are no longer for this world. I imagine a thorough sweeping of the system would probably halve that number pretty easily.

Unfortunately I’m yet to see a single case of club in our situation expanding their ground and it leading to success. There are plenty of clubs with historically small grounds and large catchment areas that have modernised and reaped the benefit(Hull, Swansea, Brighton)  and others who have build new stadiums on retail parks and ruined the match day experience (Bolton, Derby, Leicester) and seen a boost in their crowds. Neither of these options are ones I’d want to entertain, so we’re reliant on a messy, unaudited database and a business plan based around a baseball field for ghosts...


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - Spandaubaggie - 02-27-2020

(02-27-2020, 06:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 06:22 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I've just read the Jenkins piece, for the first time, and it certainly is enlightening. However, whilst the Halfords remains a bone of contention, especially to people with long legs like me, it's the overall unwillingness to expand that is the issue, not just completely focussing on the Halfords, although that's the obvious problem.
As I said, as a fan I'm not unusual in that I attend occasionally, there's 35,000 like me. You can bet if I'm moaning about lack of choice and spaces in the stadium then there will be many who feel the same. It's not just me and a handful of mates SW4.

Sorry Spandau, I don’t mean to be disingenuous. If you’re genuinely not attending because you can’t sit with the people you want to attend with, it’s a shame, but I suppose that’s part of the reason why I get a ST... I know I won’t make every game, and I know that I may well actually be better off buying individual tickets, but I want to sit with people who I know and hence the ST makes the most sense. I realise this isn’t always the case for everyone... if I can’t make a game, I can usually find someone who will use the seat in my absence. 

I’m not anti expansion at all, I agree we probably could have a slightly larger ground, however I’m also a pragmatist. The mythical 35k on the database will include people who have no intention of attending but bought a ticket so they could go to Wembley a few years ago, away fans who sat in the home end for Chelsea and United games, plenty of duplicates (there are 3 of me on my ST membership and the ticket office can’t fix it) and probably a fair few fans who are no longer for this world. I imagine a thorough sweeping of the system would probably halve that number pretty easily.

Unfortunately I’m yet to see a single case of club in our situation expanding their ground and it leading to success. There are plenty of clubs with historically small grounds and large catchment areas that have modernised and reaped the benefit(Hull, Swansea, Brighton)  and others who have build new stadiums on retail parks and ruined the match day experience (Bolton, Derby, Leicester) and seen a boost in their crowds. Neither of these options are ones I’d want to entertain, so we’re reliant on a messy, unaudited database and a business plan based around a baseball field for ghosts...

Good response and possibly one of the most coherent arguments against expansion. I still disagree, but your argument is compelling.
At the end of the day, there's no black and white in this ongoing debate- we have come on a long way since the 21st century came around, bearing in mind the sorry state we were in 20 years ago. However, I want to see our club's fan base grow and getting fans in easier, especially those who aren't originally from the W Mids will allow buy in.
I do think where there's a will there's a way with what we have. i just don't think many have the will.


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - SussexBaggie - 02-27-2020

I raise you the example of Brighton. I used to go with mates to the Withdean, even Gillingham, and the core fanbase was pretty small.
A bit of casino money & a capacity stadium (which can still get bigger yet) enabled them to really stretch out to the community, provide an entertaining day out for kids and families (apart from the team itself imo), free buses from around the areas etc. Is that Ambition?

If we had a decent ticketing system we’d fill the ground;
eg season ticket holders who know they can’t make a game cannot easily resell/recycle their tickets. Last year I tried to offer mine for free to local fans who were struggling with dosh & it was hopeless. Paper tickets allowed me to do this. I had to look at my empty seats on TV
eg get the tickets on general sale earlier (how the guys who fly in from Scandinavia get their tickets and flights beats me) & stop Sky from playing around with fixture uncertainty

It’s basic marketing surely. Listen to the fans, and wannabe fans, never assume you know it all.

P.s. try buying a ticket then collecting it from the ticket office, you have to arrive early, you get frisked like a criminal, no-one smiles, the collection machines don’t work, so you have to queue up to be interrogated


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - CA Baggie - 02-27-2020

(02-27-2020, 10:41 PM)SussexBaggie Wrote: I raise you the example of Brighton. I used to go with mates to the Withdean, even Gillingham, and the core fanbase was pretty small.
A bit of casino money & a capacity stadium (which can still get bigger yet) enabled them to really stretch out to the community, provide an entertaining day out for kids and families (apart from the team itself imo), free buses from around the areas etc. Is that Ambition?

If we had a decent ticketing system we’d fill the ground;
eg season ticket holders who know they can’t make a game cannot easily resell/recycle their tickets. Last year I tried to offer mine for free to local fans who were struggling with dosh & it was hopeless. Paper tickets allowed me to do this. I had to look at my empty seats on TV
eg get the tickets on general sale earlier (how the guys who fly in from Scandinavia get their tickets and flights beats me) & stop Sky from playing around with fixture uncertainty

It’s basic marketing surely. Listen to the fans, and wannabe fans, never assume you know it all.

P.s. try buying a ticket then collecting it from the ticket office, you have to arrive early, you get frisked like a criminal, no-one smiles, the collection machines don’t work, so you have to queue up to be interrogated

I think the club’s whole attitude towards fans is fairly contemptuous. As is it towards the future well being of the club, too interested in the here and now and not leaving behind a better club than when they took over.

The dirty word of ambition isn’t restricted to the playing side, of course that has the biggest impact on things but there are other ways to improve the club as a whole.  A bigger stadium is just one legacy, reaching out to communities and younger fans to tempt them towards the Albion.  An ambition of adding more causal fans and reducing the average age would be good long term. Those that’s start young or as casual fans could be the season ticket holders of the future.  I wonder how many members of the community etc, school kids and other target markets are being bussed in for the Wigan game to help boost future attendance?  I’ll guess none.  And on today’s spreadsheet that makes economic sense, what about the spreadsheet for the future?

One of my big bugbears is the pre and post-match facilities at the ground.  Unless you want to stand in the freezing cold shadows under the terraces then there’s nowhere to go.   We don’t have the geographic luxury of Wolves or Newcastle whereby they’re town centre clubs so we’re a bit stranded, nor do we want to be relocated to a retail park.  Surely within the ground/stadium we could have bar facilities with reasonable screens showing the football and other sports?  The fan-zone was a half-arsed attempt at doing this.  Who wants to stand outside in the rain?  

Build the woodman corner up to add capacity, fuck the car park off and put a club bar under where the old Woodman pub was.  Add a club bar at the end of the east stand and block the away fans off.  How about trying to buy a couple of the houses behind the Smethwick end and wrapping the east stand around to the Halfords?  Build a couple of bar’s in, one for away fans too.

Plenty ways to expand, behave with ambition and increase the standing of the club as a whole if only they really wanted to.  Bigger gates, more corporate receipts, more exposure with advertisers could lead to better kit deals and bigger sponsorship dosh.  And maybe just a better match day for us the fans, instead of everyone arriving last minute because there’s no point getting in the ground before 10 to and people either leaving early or just everyone rushing off together, it’s part the reason the traffic is so bad.  If there was a members bar post match on a Saturday, I’d go for a pint whilst the train queue died down. Instead I drive because I’d rather queue in the warmth of my car listening to the radio than queuing somewhere on Halford’s lane in the rush with everyone else.

The short sighted penny pinching actually turns people away and stops us from reaching our potential to be a bigger player in the grand scheme of things instead of little old Albion punching above our weight.


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - tiptontown - 02-28-2020

(02-27-2020, 11:22 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 10:41 PM)SussexBaggie Wrote: I raise you the example of Brighton. I used to go with mates to the Withdean, even Gillingham, and the core fanbase was pretty small.
A bit of casino money & a capacity stadium (which can still get bigger yet) enabled them to really stretch out to the community, provide an entertaining day out for kids and families (apart from the team itself imo), free buses from around the areas etc. Is that Ambition?

If we had a decent ticketing system we’d fill the ground;
eg season ticket holders who know they can’t make a game cannot easily resell/recycle their tickets. Last year I tried to offer mine for free to local fans who were struggling with dosh & it was hopeless. Paper tickets allowed me to do this. I had to look at my empty seats on TV
eg get the tickets on general sale earlier (how the guys who fly in from Scandinavia get their tickets and flights beats me) & stop Sky from playing around with fixture uncertainty

It’s basic marketing surely. Listen to the fans, and wannabe fans, never assume you know it all.

P.s. try buying a ticket then collecting it from the ticket office, you have to arrive early, you get frisked like a criminal, no-one smiles, the collection machines don’t work, so you have to queue up to be interrogated

I think the club’s whole attitude towards fans is fairly contemptuous. As is it towards the future well being of the club, too interested in the here and now and not leaving behind a better club than when they took over.

The dirty word of ambition isn’t restricted to the playing side, of course that has the biggest impact on things but there are other ways to improve the club as a whole.  A bigger stadium is just one legacy, reaching out to communities and younger fans to tempt them towards the Albion.  An ambition of adding more causal fans and reducing the average age would be good long term. Those that’s start young or as casual fans could be the season ticket holders of the future.  I wonder how many members of the community etc, school kids and other target markets are being bussed in for the Wigan game to help boost future attendance?  I’ll guess none.  And on today’s spreadsheet that makes economic sense, what about the spreadsheet for the future?

One of my big bugbears is the pre and post-match facilities at the ground.  Unless you want to stand in the freezing cold shadows under the terraces then there’s nowhere to go.   We don’t have the geographic luxury of Wolves or Newcastle whereby they’re town centre clubs so we’re a bit stranded, nor do we want to be relocated to a retail park.  Surely within the ground/stadium we could have bar facilities with reasonable screens showing the football and other sports?  The fan-zone was a half-arsed attempt at doing this.  Who wants to stand outside in the rain?  

Build the woodman corner up to add capacity, fuck the car park off and put a club bar under where the old Woodman pub was.  Add a club bar at the end of the east stand and block the away fans off.  How about trying to buy a couple of the houses behind the Smethwick end and wrapping the east stand around to the Halfords?  Build a couple of bar’s in, one for away fans too.

Plenty ways to expand, behave with ambition and increase the standing of the club as a whole if only they really wanted to.  Bigger gates, more corporate receipts, more exposure with advertisers could lead to better kit deals and bigger sponsorship dosh.  And maybe just a better match day for us the fans, instead of everyone arriving last minute because there’s no point getting in the ground before 10 to and people either leaving early or just everyone rushing off together, it’s part the reason the traffic is so bad.  If there was a members bar post match on a Saturday, I’d go for a pint whilst the train queue died down. Instead I drive because I’d rather queue in the warmth of my car listening to the radio than queuing somewhere on Halford’s lane in the rush with everyone else.

The short sighted penny pinching actually turns people away and stops us from reaching our potential to be a bigger player in the grand scheme of things instead of little old Albion punching above our weight.

Well said that man.

The biggest problem we have is our present owners and people who run the club appear to have no inclination to do this.
The evidence to have reasonable expansion of the ground is there irrespective of all the naysayers. Something that appears to be no where near happening for a while at least mind.


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - 4-hero - 02-28-2020

(02-27-2020, 04:32 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:15 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:02 PM)MassDebater Wrote: So, what proportion of the ground should be kept empty to allow fairweathers to rock up a few hours or a couple of days before kick off?

It's currently about 1/5 of the capacity, which sounds decent to me.

Don't know. Let's look at the likes of Derby, Leicester, Southampton, Forest, Bristol City etc, etc, who have leapfrogged us in capacity and attendances over the years and see how they evaluated it and means now we have a 'mid table championship' capacity.
Think big or think small. It's as simple as that.

Forest have a capacity of 30,000 and are getting around 27,500 per game.

Works starts in the Summer to increase capacity to 38,000


RE: Small ground for loyal fans latest - billybassett - 02-28-2020

(02-27-2020, 04:39 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:30 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:24 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:15 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2020, 04:02 PM)MassDebater Wrote: So, what proportion of the ground should be kept empty to allow fairweathers to rock up a few hours or a couple of days before kick off?

It's currently about 1/5 of the capacity, which sounds decent to me.

Don't know. Let's look at the likes of Derby, Leicester, Southampton, Forest, Bristol City etc, etc, who have leapfrogged us in capacity and attendances over the years and see how they evaluated it and means now we have a 'mid table championship' capacity.
Think big or think small. It's as simple as that.

2 of those clubs are in the PL, and the other two have average attendances that would fit in the Hawthorns... Ashton Gate’s capacity is a couple hundred more than ours and they’re yet to average over 21k... 

We have the 4th highest average attendance in the division, despite there being at least 10 teams with a higher capacity... other than Fulham and Luton, we have the highest % of bums to seats so I’d suggest our capacity is about where it should be.

Could we put another 3-4000 people on our gates, yes we probably could, is it economically viable, probably not. Given there’s no waiting list for STs and people can still buy tickets on the gate for a lot of games I’d sooner a few fair weather fans missed out on sitting together if it means we don’t have 10k empty seats if the success dries up.

That's the difference I think in thinking. The "when success dries up" is planning on failure. Others think we should plan for success. I know where I am on that

Which is a nice way to be able to see things. However, with our recent history, the club would be barmy to expect success every season. Ignoring this season we've been averaging around 24,000 and even less, whilst in the Premier League...over the last few years. Where were all the people saying they couldn't sit together for the last 10 years? Apart from against the likes of Vile, Man U, Liverpool, Man City you'd have had to go out of your way to struggle to get a ticket or even a pair together.

Even this season I think our average is only about 24,500.

Err I like the logic but that average has been acquired in a reducing capacity. What would the average be if the ground was 32K. Maybe many games would still be around the 24k but the average would certainly be higher. We start questioning spending £20m on a new stand to increase to 30K+ but no one bats an eye lid when we spunk twice that on absolute playing dross.