WBAUnofficial
SB moaning - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: SB moaning (/showthread.php?tid=8299)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: SB moaning - Tom Joad - 01-13-2020

Just to chuck it out there, zonal marking is based around your main defenders occupying a designated space. Then your other players, not so tall perhaps, block the run of the attackers into the danger zone, nullifying their effectiveness on goal. Well for me, that's obstruction, although that is no longer an indirect free kick, it should be a penalty. Let's face it, few refs give a penalty against the "bigger" clubs for this, hence it works for them. Of course zonal marking works for the best teams, but they have the better players and would be ok whatever system they use.


RE: SB moaning - Statto - 01-13-2020

Zonal marking wasn’t to blame for the second goal. As brilliantly as he’s done, Bartley has simply got to attack that ball. Hegazi, Olsson or GMac all eat that for breakfast.

Attacking the ball in both boxes wins matches - people get far too hung up on systems.


RE: SB moaning - Peachy - 01-13-2020

(01-13-2020, 03:18 AM)Statto Wrote: Zonal marking wasn’t to blame for the second goal. As brilliantly as he’s done, Bartley has simply got to attack that ball. Hegazi, Olsson or GMac all eat that for breakfast.

Attacking the ball in both boxes wins matches - people get far too hung up on systems.

Correct. Zonal marking requires defenders to concentrate on the flight of the ball and attack it rather than marking the player. Hegazi is our best defender in terms of getting to the ball at all costs.

Harsh maybe on the current two but i'd bring him back in now. We are conceding too many sloppy goals which is starting to turn into a bit of a habit.


RE: SB moaning - TartanRug - 01-13-2020

Zonal marking gets a lot of criticism but when a defender gets blocked off when doing man marking so the attacker gets a free header you don't hear man marking getting criticised.


RE: SB moaning - MassDebater - 01-13-2020

(01-12-2020, 01:55 PM)HugeHons Wrote: Considering we have all 11 players defending corners,we don’t defend them particularly well. I’m old fashioned in that I think we should also have a player on each post for corners.

I'm also old fashioned and think we should have a player near the centre circle to chase after any clearances. Why don't teams do that these days? There's never an outlet.

Anyone got the stats on how many corners we've conceded?

Found this, but can't find one showing goals from corners, which seems like an oversight by the statto sites: http://www.footcharts.co.uk/index.cfm?task=basics_corners

We're 5th in corners, almost exactly the same amount for us as against us... We've conceded 30 goals in total, and faced 154 corners... Now not all the conceded goals have come from corners, let's say 20 have (it does feel high this season)... so roughly one in seven corners given away leads to them scoring... Not sure how good / bad that actually is, but reading this thread makes is sound terrible, but I'm not sure.

Further googling suggests that typically 3% of corners end in goals...so OK we're utter dog shyte at defending them! (based on 3% scoring rate ours is nearer 12%... and about 5 should have been conceded)


RE: SB moaning - Lightnin - 01-13-2020

Part of the reason we picked Zohore this weekend was so that we added some height to our team when defending set pieces. Didn’t work out that well.


RE: SB moaning - Ampadu's Left Boot - 01-13-2020

(01-13-2020, 02:15 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 01:55 PM)HugeHons Wrote: Considering we have all 11 players defending corners,we don’t defend them particularly well. I’m old fashioned in that I think we should also have a player on each post for corners.

I'm also old fashioned and think we should have a player near the centre circle to chase after any clearances. Why don't teams do that these days? There's never an outlet.

Anyone got the stats on how many corners we've conceded?

Found this, but can't find one showing goals from corners, which seems like an oversight by the statto sites: http://www.footcharts.co.uk/index.cfm?task=basics_corners

We're 5th in corners, almost exactly the same amount for us as against us... We've conceded 30 goals in total, and faced 154 corners... Now not all the conceded goals have come from corners, let's say 20 have (it does feel high this season)... so roughly one in seven corners given away leads to them scoring... Not sure how good / bad that actually is, but reading this thread makes is sound terrible, but I'm not sure.

Further googling suggests that typically 3% of corners end in goals...so OK we're utter dog shyte at defending them! (based on 3% scoring rate ours is nearer 12%... and about 5 should have been conceded)

We've conceded 11 goals in the league this season from set-pieces. We need to improve in that area but our record there isn't that much worse than a lot of other sides in the league. Leeds and Bristol have both conceded 9 and Forest and Preston have both conceded 8, for example.

Link to stats:

https://www.whoscored.com/Regions/252/Tournaments/7/Seasons/7840/Stages/17629/TeamStatistics/England-Championship-2019-2020


RE: SB moaning - GunsOfNavarone - 01-13-2020

(01-13-2020, 03:42 PM)Lightnin Wrote: Part of the reason we picked Zohore this weekend was so that we added some height to our team when defending set pieces. Didn’t work out that well.

Both goals could and should have been dealt with by our centre halves regardless of whether he was there to add extra height.

Zohore wasn't even on the pitch for their second equaliser.


RE: SB moaning - billybassett - 01-13-2020

As I said on another thread:

This is what we're missing...
[attachment=175]

As a comparison:

Catches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 25
David Martin (brentford) 25
Sam Johnstone 6

Punches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 17
David Martin (brentford) 14
Sam Johnstone 10


RE: SB moaning - Birdman1811 - 01-13-2020

(01-13-2020, 04:45 PM)billybassett Wrote: As I said on another thread:

This is what we're missing...


As a comparison:

Catches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 25
David Martin (brentford) 25
Sam Johnstone 6

Punches this season
Kiko Casilla (leeds) 17
David Martin (brentford) 14
Sam Johnstone 10

If he's instructed not to claim high balls though... 

That is common with teams set up to zonal mark, the keepers area is the goal line.