WBAUnofficial
Thornberry to stand as party leader - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Thornberry to stand as party leader (/showthread.php?tid=7894)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - Malcolm Tucker - 01-07-2020

RLB has announced she is the continuity Corbyn candidate. Bin


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - Derek Hardballs - 01-07-2020

(01-07-2020, 10:33 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: RLB has announced she is the continuity Corbyn candidate. Bin

WTF would anyone want a continuity candidate for the worst Labour leader arguably ever?


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - ChamonixBaggie - 01-07-2020

I think thats extremely harsh and pretty revisionist. Back in 2017/18, he was incredibly popular appearing at Glastonbury and attracting a huge groundswell of Labour support leading to Labour giving a surprisingly good account of themselves at the 2017 election. He was successfully billed as an attractive alternative to the establishment IMO. Obviously once it was realised that he was actually a threat then the smears started and the pushing of the narrative that he was ineffective or a bad leader which took hold over the course of 2019. Let us not forget that he inflicted the most govt defeats of any opposition leader ever (misleading as this stat might be...)

I realise that the Corbyn ship has sailed and RLB isn't the right choice any more but I am still wistful about what could have been. JCs policies themselves polled extremely well and I'm of the opinion that if the same (or similar) policies can be framed differently with more focus on improving public services and with a leader who can't be as easily smeared could do well.


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - Ossian - 01-07-2020

(01-07-2020, 11:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-07-2020, 10:33 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: RLB has announced she is the continuity Corbyn candidate. Bin

WTF would anyone want a continuity candidate for the worst Labour leader arguably ever?

Blair's analysis (and whatever peoples' view of him he's still one of the sharpest political minds around) is that the hard left of Labour will never be content to just be a part of the overall structure; their aim is to be in sole control of the agenda and the direction. Hence the desire to have another one of 'their own' at the helm. Already it's like December 12th never happened. 

In the 45 years since Harold Wilson's narrow victory in 1974, Labour have had eight leaders (not counting the caretakers - Margaret Beckett and Harriet Harman twice). Leaving aside John Smith - who never had the opportunity to fight an election - only one of the remaining seven has won one; and he happened to win three. That's three victories from eleven elections across 45 years; and by the time the next one rolls around it will be 50 years passed.

Blair and Mandelson had to actively suppress the very elements who now have ambitions to take total control of the party; both of them have admitted as much - "marginalised" was the word used. That's what it took to win and if it's unpalatable to some, that doesn't stop it being true.

Edit: But... parts of Scandinavia aside, Social Democracy is in deep crisis all across Europe. Rising populism and a planet literally on fire; what could possibly go wrong?

Part 2: Even as a broadly centrist, I've had to set aside some principles: I don't like it, but that's the reality. Corbyn is probably all of the good things people say about him, although I'm not a big fan. But he was consistently at minus 40% and that should have told its own story.

Michael Foot was an exemplary human being and outstanding political orator: he also was never going to win an election. And that's the nub of it for me - I want to win; I didn't want another five years of the fucking Tories; I didn't want another day. But I didn't want Corbyn either.


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - Sotv - 01-07-2020

(01-07-2020, 11:22 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: I think thats extremely harsh and pretty revisionist. Back in 2017/18, he was incredibly popular appearing at Glastonbury and attracting a huge groundswell of Labour support leading to Labour giving a surprisingly good account of themselves at the 2017 election. He was successfully billed as an attractive alternative to the establishment IMO.  Obviously once it was realised that he was actually a threat then the smears started and the pushing of the narrative that he was ineffective or a bad leader which took hold over the course of 2019. Let us not forget that he inflicted the most govt defeats of any opposition leader ever (misleading as this stat might be...)

I realise that the Corbyn ship has sailed and RLB isn't the right choice any more but I am still wistful about what could have been. JCs policies themselves polled extremely well and I'm of the opinion that if the same (or similar) policies can be framed differently with more focus on improving public services and with a leader who can't be as easily smeared could do well.
Ski slope socialism  Big Grin


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - Tom Joad - 01-09-2020

Looking at the paucity of talent available, Keir Starmer is head and shoulders above them all. The problem for me is that his barrister background and smug, comfortable look, makes him look very Toryboy. Still, that didn't do Blair any harm.


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - Borin' Baggie - 01-09-2020

(01-09-2020, 09:26 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Looking at the paucity of talent available, Keir Starmer is head and shoulders above them all. The problem for me is that his barrister background and smug, comfortable look, makes him look very Toryboy.  Still, that didn't do Blair any harm.

Or Boris. Or Nigel.

Kier isn't my cup of tea exactly but he's at least got some decent working class credentials and should inspire some level of "working class kid who made it" given his background, which the Labour party of the last 10 years has abandoned. And though he had some very socialist tendencies as a teenager so did Blair.


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - Sotv - 01-09-2020

(01-09-2020, 09:31 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(01-09-2020, 09:26 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Looking at the paucity of talent available, Keir Starmer is head and shoulders above them all. The problem for me is that his barrister background and smug, comfortable look, makes him look very Toryboy.  Still, that didn't do Blair any harm.

Or Boris. Or Nigel.

Kier isn't my cup of tea exactly but he's at least got some decent working class credentials and should inspire some level of "working class kid who made it" given his background, which the Labour party of the last 10 years has abandoned. And though he had some very socialist tendencies as a teenager so did Blair.

That is true of much of politics since the lowering of grammar school places unfortunately but you are correct to identify it being a real issue amongst labour. I’ve always found it strange that the party many associate with privilege seem to have had more working class people rise to the top in recent years than the party which claims to be for the working class. 
If I was I running the Tory party, the one I’d fear most would probably be Starmer as he seems the most electable of the current lot and the smartest operator.


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - Borin' Baggie - 01-09-2020

(01-09-2020, 09:49 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(01-09-2020, 09:31 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(01-09-2020, 09:26 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Looking at the paucity of talent available, Keir Starmer is head and shoulders above them all. The problem for me is that his barrister background and smug, comfortable look, makes him look very Toryboy.  Still, that didn't do Blair any harm.

Or Boris. Or Nigel.

Kier isn't my cup of tea exactly but he's at least got some decent working class credentials and should inspire some level of "working class kid who made it" given his background, which the Labour party of the last 10 years has abandoned. And though he had some very socialist tendencies as a teenager so did Blair.

That is true of much of politics since the lowering of grammar school places unfortunately but you are correct to identify it being a real issue amongst labour. I’ve always found it strange that the party many associate with privilege seem to have had more working class people rise to the top in recent years than the party which claims to be for the working class. 
If I was I running the Tory party, the one I’d fear most would probably be Starmer as he seems the most electable of the current lot and the smartest operator.


I very much disagree with your assertion on the lack grammar schools being a barrier to social progression. Though they did and do allow some fortunate working class people like Kier Starmer and Jess Phillips to climb the social ladder they were not the norm and were absolutely dominated by middle class children reflective of the makeup of the current postcode lottery in schools. Look at the kind of people who go to the foundation schools in the Edward VI system in Birmingham, very few have poor, working class backgrounds. The current state system is failing working class people and going back to a previous system that also failed to help working class people isn't going to help anyone.


RE: Thornberry to stand as party leader - HeathAyIt - 01-10-2020

Disagree MT that CL would be eaten up by the media. Quite the opposite.