WBAUnofficial
Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! (/showthread.php?tid=7869)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - spyro 123 - 12-17-2019

(12-17-2019, 10:06 AM)Solihull Throstle Wrote:
(12-16-2019, 04:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry but seeing an increase in the membership of the party is not the same as engaging the general populace. Labour continually forget this and they will never win an election again until they move back to the centre ground.

The only hope is that in 5, 10yrs time people will be utterly sick of the lies, broken promises and empty presents they thought the Tories and Brexit were going to give them.

Spot on. I have a close mate who is a dyed-in-the-wool Corbynite and a very intelligent bloke. It is impossible trying to point out that the British people will not elect a leftist Labour Party. He will always point out that it's all down to media bias and (dare I say) voter ignorance. This is the problem with his ilk. I would consider myself pretty left-wing but am happy to compromise and move to the centre to kick this arrogant, incompetent rabble out. He talks about Tory-lite, his hatred of Blair, increased party membership under Corbyn. Misses the point completely! Its going to be a bloody fight as these "sixth form politicos" are not going to have the party wrestled from them without a fight, even though they must see their way leads to a lifetime in opposition.

well blair did invade iraq by creating fake evidence and also he killed david kelly


RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Sotv - 12-17-2019

(12-17-2019, 04:56 PM)spyro 123 Wrote:
(12-17-2019, 10:06 AM)Solihull Throstle Wrote:
(12-16-2019, 04:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry but seeing an increase in the membership of the party is not the same as engaging the general populace. Labour continually forget this and they will never win an election again until they move back to the centre ground.

The only hope is that in 5, 10yrs time people will be utterly sick of the lies, broken promises and empty presents they thought the Tories and Brexit were going to give them.

Spot on. I have a close mate who is a dyed-in-the-wool Corbynite and a very intelligent bloke. It is impossible trying to point out that the British people will not elect a leftist Labour Party. He will always point out that it's all down to media bias and (dare I say) voter ignorance. This is the problem with his ilk. I would consider myself pretty left-wing but am happy to compromise and move to the centre to kick this arrogant, incompetent rabble out. He talks about Tory-lite, his hatred of Blair, increased party membership under Corbyn. Misses the point completely! Its going to be a bloody fight as these "sixth form politicos" are not going to have the party wrestled from them without a fight, even though they must see their way leads to a lifetime in opposition.

well blair did invade iraq by creating fake evidence and also he killed david kelly

personally?


RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Solihull Throstle - 12-17-2019

(12-17-2019, 04:56 PM)spyro 123 Wrote:
(12-17-2019, 10:06 AM)Solihull Throstle Wrote:
(12-16-2019, 04:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry but seeing an increase in the membership of the party is not the same as engaging the general populace. Labour continually forget this and they will never win an election again until they move back to the centre ground.

The only hope is that in 5, 10yrs time people will be utterly sick of the lies, broken promises and empty presents they thought the Tories and Brexit were going to give them.

Spot on. I have a close mate who is a dyed-in-the-wool Corbynite and a very intelligent bloke. It is impossible trying to point out that the British people will not elect a leftist Labour Party. He will always point out that it's all down to media bias and (dare I say) voter ignorance. This is the problem with his ilk. I would consider myself pretty left-wing but am happy to compromise and move to the centre to kick this arrogant, incompetent rabble out. He talks about Tory-lite, his hatred of Blair, increased party membership under Corbyn. Misses the point completely! Its going to be a bloody fight as these "sixth form politicos" are not going to have the party wrestled from them without a fight, even though they must see their way leads to a lifetime in opposition.

well blair did invade iraq by creating fake evidence and also he killed david kelly

I can't forgive Blair for the illegal war but it is sad that this eclipsed some great domestic work. Not perfect but showing a glimmer of socialism.


RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Ossian - 12-17-2019

That's the point really, Sol: some people seem unable to concede that just because he was (in my opinion) badly wrong about something doesn't mean he was completely wrong about absolutely everything.

Blair is, at heart, a Social Democrat; which has some relevance to last week's election. We can maybe see the attractions of Norway; not so much Vietnam or Cuba.

Edit: I'm talking about voter perceptions here, rather than any suggestion that Corbyn actually wants to be Europe's Castro. Which isn't to say that there weren't voters out there who were ready to believe that to be his ambition.


RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Ossian - 12-18-2019

A few more pieces to be picked up by the DfT: and then, if past experience is any guide, put back together at taxpayers' expense before being handed back to another privatised operator. 

Actually, rather more than 'a few' pieces in this case - the franchise covers the whole of Scotland...

Scotrail


RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Bloke who lives abroad - 12-19-2019

I get to spend a fair bit of time in Sweden. They tax each other something wicked. But their society has virtually none of the ghastly inequalities that pervade the UK. Housing is mostly affordable, jobs pay ok, good paternal leave, maternal leave, good on the environment, they have half decent healthcare and the trains run in snow! There only real problem seems to be taking in too many immigrants in recent years.

It's a cler choice.

Either build a society based on penny pinching + giving tax cuts to the richest = England for the last 40 years.

Or build a society on trying to create balance and fairness, with decent public services. = Sweden, Finland, Denmark. But you have to pay for that. Cant have it both ways.


RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - baggy1 - 12-19-2019

The strange thing with this election was that, it appeared that there were a number of us in the middle to higher earning bracket (PAYE wise) were prepared to pay more in Taxes. 1 or 2% (potentially more) on the 40% bracket and an increased personal allowance for the low earners would have been acceptable, but the focus was getting Brexit done blindly which meant that the low earners effectively kept the money in the high earners pockets.

We have consistently increased tax revenues for the government due to high employment figures over the past 20 years, but mismanagement of debt and spend means we haven't made a dent in the problems. We can't keep blaming the labour government for the problems, in 6 months time we will have had 10 years of Tory government.

Honesty for the Labour party is the most important part of this next leadership campaign. Over the past 40 years they have held power for 13 of those compared to double that amount for the Tories. The country is ready for some form of change, and lets be honest it's needed, but getting a majority of a population that has spent its lifetime with a generally centrist government to move to either extreme is going to be very difficult if not impossible. The current shift to the right is because the alternative was even starker and the middle ground (Libs) lost their mind and moved towards the raving loony party.