WBAUnofficial
Gayle banned - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Gayle banned (/showthread.php?tid=761)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Gayle banned - Fido - 02-15-2019

I still want to know what the trigger was for this as deceiving the referee to gain an advantage, either through a penalty award or a card for the opposition. Injuries are feigned many times a game for that reason alone so is it a complaint or does a panel watch every game?


RE: Gayle banned - Peachy - 02-15-2019

Has he been banned because we scored from it? If we'd missed the penalty would he still have been banned?

The reason I ask is because surely he's been banned for the action itself. The act of diving. If so the FA have fucked themselves here.

Every week in every game this will happen. They now have to ban any player who dives. Simple.

If not we can surely build up a nice big dossier and ask why we got banned when other more obvious ones go unpunished.

For me Gayles wasn't a pen. It was a soft one but I've seen them given.


RE: Gayle banned - CA Baggie - 02-15-2019

The new law was specifically about winning a penalty.

It seems it’s perfectly fine to dive to get a player sent off, to feign injury, to win a free kick that you may score from, to punch the ball in the net and many many other ways to con the ref.

There are too many inconsistencies in the application of this new rule, only the third player to have “won” a penalty across all 4 divisions and cup games in 1 and a half seasons? Salah has done more than that himself.

The other oddity is that had the ref deemed it a dive it’s yellow card offence, how does that then equate to a 2 game ban?


RE: Gayle banned - KratosBaggie - 02-15-2019

If Lukaku dives and wins a pen for Utd, does he get banned? Ditto Salah and Liverpool?

Of course they won't. The rule itself, is a good thing. But we all know it won't be equally applied to all teams on a consistent basis.


RE: Gayle banned - Peachy - 02-15-2019

(02-15-2019, 07:58 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: The new law was specifically about winning a penalty.

It seems it’s perfectly fine to dive to get a player sent off, to feign injury, to win a free kick that you may score from, to punch the ball in the net and many many other ways to con the ref.

There are too many inconsistencies in the application of this new rule, only the third player to have “won” a penalty across all 4 divisions and cup games in 1 and a half seasons? Salah has done more than that himself.

The other oddity is that had the ref deemed it a dive it’s yellow card offence, how does that then equate to a 2 game ban?

That's an extremely good point.

(02-15-2019, 08:17 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: If Lukaku dives and wins a pen for Utd, does he get banned? Ditto Salah and Liverpool?

Of course they won't. The rule itself, is a good thing. But we all know it won't be equally applied to all teams on a consistent basis.

Premier league ay it. Different set of rules. They can't go banning players with such a massive global audience. Too much money at stake.  Angry