WBAUnofficial
David Duckenfield found not guilty - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: David Duckenfield found not guilty (/showthread.php?tid=7547)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: David Duckenfield found not guilty - Spandaubaggie - 11-29-2019

(11-29-2019, 11:12 AM)Sotv Wrote:
(11-29-2019, 10:16 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-28-2019, 04:07 PM)Baggie Mon Wrote: Why should Duckenfield be found guilty? Don’t remember hearing of any Forest fans being injured. They were at the same game, in the same ground with the same Police Force as Liverpool, weren’t they? It’s the Liverpool fans arriving late at the ground that need to take a long, hard look at themselves. Always someone else’s fault with them lot.

That's an uncomfortable truth that Liverpool have never looked at, and I think apportioning that some of their fan base had a part to play would be healthier. 
Grounds were hideous and dangerous in that there was no escape in the 80s and away fans treated particularly bad. 
Fact is though many thousands of pissed up Liverpool fans without tickets caused that mixed with the lack of safety laws at the time, with fences that couldn't be escaped from. Hindsight is a great thing, but just a total tragedy that could have happened to any of us.
As I said before, I went to the Hillsborough Semi 2 years before, in 87, as I got a tiicket with my Leeds mate for the game v Cov and that was scary that day, in Leppings Lane. Never knew a crush like it, and there was too many.
The  football authorities never took safety seriously until a tragedy happened.
Fact is it was a load of factors, but the Liverpool fans failure to accept the part of some of them is poor.

+1.
There were a multiplicity of factors at play at Hillsborough. The unsafe grounds, the policing, the general attitude towards fans and despite what the inquest found, the behaviour of some fans.
Even if the fans had been totally blamless that day, previous scenarios could well have caused the police to reasonably fear a public order situation outside the ground. 
A whole lot of people need to look and acknowledge their part in this; the football authorities, Sheffield Wednesday and whoever was responsible for ground safety, the police (not just for their actions on the day, but also for the subsequent cover up) the government of the time for colluding in the cover up which led to a muddying of the waters and far more expense to get somewhere near the truth, and a minority of Liverpool supporters who arrived late and had a reputation for rushing grounds. 
The families seem to want to find a single point of blame whilst absolving all Liverpool fans, using the emotional but false argument that somehow saying some fans behaved badly, is to blame the victims. Unfortunately they won't find it as it doesn't exist.
When big things go wrong people want a scapegoat. Truth is life is not so black and white. Duckenfield was no more responsible than those who allowed such dangerous pens at grounds, or the idiots who en-masse without tickets, or the fools who gave Leppings Lane, the smaller end, to the better supported club.
in 87 whoever was in charge did the same with Leeds and Cov. Leeds, a better supported club, had the smaller end.
I was 21 at the time and I was a fair distance from the front, but I said to my mate after, that I've never been in such a dangerous position at a match. We were crammed like sardines and with a surge he went about 10 yards from me- both of us strong and sizeable young lads, but the pressure was unreal. 
A bit like the B'ham Pub Bombings in that there's no closure- horrible for all involved, and I would include David Duckenfield in that. Poor guy has been the most public scapegoat for a perfect storm of ineptness that was years in the making. He's not blameless, but he's paid a big price.


RE: David Duckenfield found not guilty - The liquidator - 11-29-2019

(11-29-2019, 04:31 AM)Idiodyssey Wrote:
(11-29-2019, 12:54 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The trouble is their reputation proceeds them from the early 80's from trying to slash you and nicking your clobber off you to trying to jib into the ground .......even after the tragedy they carried on doing it ......just google it they done it Istanbul and they done it at chelsea in a semi final where they caused mayhem at the turnstiles.

I'm shocked at the stuff written on this thread - regurgitating the lies told by Duckenfield and printed by newspapers at the time which set the narrative for many years. The victims do not have to be responsible. Yes they probably did behave -  some of them  - in ways that can be criticised. But the response that they were irresponsible and some of them were criminal suggests well, there you go, they deserved it, to die. Serious mistakes were made, negligence, that resulted in the multiple deaths - the opening of the gates and the funnelling of thousands of fans into a death trap. These were horrible times for those of us who lived through them - caged in everywhere and marched by police to and from grounds without access to any food and drink as if we were criminals, or animals. All football fans. I've read fan reports how deaths through crushing nearly happened in previous years at this ground, I think the season before. It could have been Albion fans crushed to death at the ground. The authorities have responsibility for oversight and can't simply wash their hands. People in crowds will behave erratically and ignorantly - it is the job of those in authority to take responsibility for their oversight. It is why they are professional people and paid. Even if Duckenfield is under the law not guilty - and fair enough that was a jury decision - it doesn't mean that you have to denigrate the dead and their family, friends and associates. There by the grace of God go I . . . unharmed and live to see anther sun rise.
Every single word is true if you went up.in the late 70's and 80's you were lucky to come back unscathed.


RE: David Duckenfield found not guilty - aj21 - 11-29-2019

(11-29-2019, 09:22 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-29-2019, 07:52 AM)aj21 Wrote: Sorry you’re a knob. No Liverpool fans were to blame for the deaths, that’s a fact. You seem to want to argue with the facts.

That's a well thought out constructive counter argument.

Th facts should be ALL the facts .. not just the selected ones. No one person was to blame.

Name calling is about the level you're at ...very pointed and reasoned.

You have just labelled 'some' Liverpool fans killers with your language. Not sure you need to counter argue things that are facts. It is a fact, that the fans were not to blame for the deaths, it is not an opinion. Why can't you understand that?


RE: David Duckenfield found not guilty - cornishbaggie - 11-29-2019

It is incredible that anyone thinks that anybody but the authorities are to blame for this disaster. An inescapable fact is the Liverpool fans had 7 turnstiles to access Leppings lane, that's 7 turnstiles for 10,100 fans, it has come out in court that the capacity of each turnstile was 750 an hour with only 7 turnstiles, each one would have to cope with 1,400 + an hour, when the police ordered the gate to be opened ( also admitted all these years later ) there was no attempt to stop the fans from being funnelled into a death trap.
A theme that runs through this thread is that " Liverpool fans had a reputation " it seems the only ones ignorant of this were the authorities, or did they just ignore it, any crush caused outside that day was fans realizing there was no way they would get in for ko.
If it was so cut and dried that fans were to blame, why the years of lies from the media and authorities that have been found to be lies in the inquests and most importantly why did South Yorkshire police need to alter so many statements from their own officers.


RE: David Duckenfield found not guilty - Spandaubaggie - 11-29-2019

(11-29-2019, 12:34 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote: It is incredible that anyone thinks that anybody but the authorities are to blame for this disaster. An inescapable fact is the Liverpool fans had 7 turnstiles to access Leppings lane, that's 7 turnstiles for 10,100 fans, it has come out in court that the capacity of each turnstile was 750 an hour with only 7 turnstiles, each one would have to cope with 1,400 + an hour, when the police ordered the gate to be opened ( also admitted all these years later ) there was no attempt to stop the fans from being funnelled into a death trap.
A theme that runs through this thread is that " Liverpool fans had a reputation " it seems the only ones ignorant of this were the authorities, or did they just ignore it, any crush caused outside that day was fans realizing there was no way they would get in for ko.
If it was so cut and dried that fans were to blame, why the years of lies from the media and authorities that have been found to be lies in the inquests and most importantly why did South Yorkshire police need to alter so many statements from their own officers.
Good response, as I said it's a huge combination of factors, with no obvious culprit. It was years of treating us fans like scum. I recall as a kid walking to the Hawthorns many times in the 70s/80s and police shouting at fans like prisoners of war. One spoke to my hard working law abiding dad like a piece of shit once, going up Halfords Lane as he narrowly averted his horse trampling us.
The more intelligent of the Liverpool ticketless idiots(and all clubs have them), probably do realise that turning up without tickets added to it, but it is the job of authorities to arrange this properly- not football fans just going to a match, no matter how pissed up they are.
In 87 it could so easily have happened, and in 81 similar happened too, as has been proven. Nothing was learnt.
Now years later, all football fans are safer and it's better for us all. There were heaps of cover ups and muck chucked by the authorities, but getting to the bottom of it is endemic of a whole culture then. It's like trying to blame the BBC for the cover ups of sexual predators. It was different times and no one person is responsible.