WBAUnofficial
Villa accounts.... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Villa accounts.... (/showthread.php?tid=721)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Villa accounts.... - HeathAyIt - 02-15-2019

They seem to be preaching one thing and pursuing another. Talking about sustainability then pissing millions up the wall on short term loans for players that are never gonna sign if they don't go up.Youd also think Greasy will want to play in the Prem sooner rather than later and has some sort of agreement accordingly.


RE: Villa accounts.... - Pragmatist - 02-15-2019

(02-15-2019, 07:34 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 05:28 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-14-2019, 10:12 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-14-2019, 08:18 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Deep down we all know the jammie fishy fuggers will wriggle out of any punishment which in turn will inflate their already massively inflated egos and sense of entitlement, they will be even more fuggin unbearable Angry

I think the same but then surely the efl will be setting an extremely dangerous precedent going forward.

Villa have unashamedly flouted FFP to try and  get promotion and it's completely failed. Having new owners with money now should not come into it.

They need to be hit hard otherwise they will be used as the benchmark for all other cases.

Bit like the Gayle dive ban we can rightly now question every single dive in any game now across all leagues and ask why the player is not being charged.

Getting promoted used to be the way of escaping EFL sanctions. It worked for Bournemouth because they stayed up, and ended up negotiating a modest fine. It would have worked for QPR as well but they got relegated again and had to pay £42m.

Since those instances the PL and the EFL have got together and agreed that they will enforce each other’s sanctions, so if Villa were in blatant breach and got up, the resulting fine and transfer embargo would be enforced by the PL rather than being left in abeyance until they got relegated again.  Going up with a huge fine and with a transfer embargo wouldn’t be much fun!

The trouble is, by the time an embargo was agreed. they would have already spunked trillions on players. Yes they wouldn't enjoy it, but it would be a means to an end.

No - the FFP and STCC tests are now run in March so that sanctions can take place immediately in the current season, including points deductions (and before they could spend in summer window).  Villa have to publish their 31/5/18 audited accounts by 28/2/19, and they also have to produce audited management accounts/forecasts for the year ending 31/5/19 during March 2019 so that current season spending is taken into account (in their cases 9 months of trading in the current financial year).  These will clearly show that Villa are way over the permitted £39m max loss over 3 seasons. The only thing that can possibly save them is the sale of their training ground for a genuine market value and the value would be under massive scrutiny.


RE: Villa accounts.... - HeathAyIt - 02-15-2019

Didn't know that Pragmastist. So why do you think Purslow is so confident they are compliant? Bluster?


RE: Villa accounts.... - Peachy - 02-15-2019

(02-15-2019, 08:19 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Didn't know that Pragmastist. So why do you think Purslow is so confident they are compliant? Bluster?

This is my concern. Wasn't Purslow part of the team that helped set up the FFP rules etc?

He will probably have a greater knowledge of it than anyone. If he's unconcerned he is either bluffing it (can't see the point in why he would) or he's managed to pull some strings with someone influential to get a tweak to the rulings somewhere.

Isn't their best bet to come clean this season, take a points hit which won't effect them (They won't go up or down anyway) and transfer embargo which will hit them for next season. They can consolidate next season with a crap side and then spunk gazillions the following season and probably go up?


RE: Villa accounts.... - Kit Kat Chunky - 02-15-2019

(02-15-2019, 08:04 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 07:34 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 05:28 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-14-2019, 10:12 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-14-2019, 08:18 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Deep down we all know the jammie fishy fuggers will wriggle out of any punishment which in turn will inflate their already massively inflated egos and sense of entitlement, they will be even more fuggin unbearable Angry

I think the same but then surely the efl will be setting an extremely dangerous precedent going forward.

Villa have unashamedly flouted FFP to try and  get promotion and it's completely failed. Having new owners with money now should not come into it.

They need to be hit hard otherwise they will be used as the benchmark for all other cases.

Bit like the Gayle dive ban we can rightly now question every single dive in any game now across all leagues and ask why the player is not being charged.

Getting promoted used to be the way of escaping EFL sanctions. It worked for Bournemouth because they stayed up, and ended up negotiating a modest fine. It would have worked for QPR as well but they got relegated again and had to pay £42m.

Since those instances the PL and the EFL have got together and agreed that they will enforce each other’s sanctions, so if Villa were in blatant breach and got up, the resulting fine and transfer embargo would be enforced by the PL rather than being left in abeyance until they got relegated again.  Going up with a huge fine and with a transfer embargo wouldn’t be much fun!

The trouble is, by the time an embargo was agreed. they would have already spunked trillions on players. Yes they wouldn't enjoy it, but it would be a means to an end.

No - the FFP and STCC tests are now run in March so that sanctions can take place immediately in the current season, including points deductions (and before they could spend in summer window).  Villa have to publish their 31/5/18 audited accounts by 28/2/19, and they also have to produce audited management accounts/forecasts for the year ending 31/5/19 during March 2019 so that current season spending is taken into account (in their cases 9 months of trading in the current financial year).  These will clearly show that Villa are way over the permitted £39m max loss over 3 seasons. The only thing that can possibly save them is the sale of their training ground for a genuine market value and the value would be under massive scrutiny.

I don't disagree that they cannot escape sanction, or your understanding of the calculation, but after the hearing, there is right of appeal through Arbitration.

There is strong talk that Blues will not be concluded this season, if Arbitration follows. On the same basis, Villa would have another roll of the dice before any punishment took effect.


RE: Villa accounts.... - Pragmatist - 02-15-2019

(02-15-2019, 08:19 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Didn't know that Pragmastist. So why do you think Purslow is so confident they are compliant? Bluster?

Could be bluster. Could be risking it.  We will find out in due course!

(02-15-2019, 09:04 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 08:19 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Didn't know that Pragmastist. So why do you think Purslow is so confident they are compliant? Bluster?

This is my concern. Wasn't Purslow part of the team that helped set up the FFP rules etc?

He will probably have a greater knowledge of it than anyone. If he's unconcerned he is either bluffing it (can't see the point in why he would) or he's managed to pull some strings with someone influential to get a tweak to the rulings somewhere.

Isn't their best bet to come clean this season, take a points hit which won't effect them (They won't go up or down anyway) and transfer embargo which will hit them for next season. They can consolidate next season with a crap side and then spunk gazillions the following season and probably go up?


My understanding a few months back was that selling Grealish was the easy solution, with selling the training ground as the backup, but with the latter understandably far more complex. Grealish’s injury scuppered Plan A, and they will be really sweating on Plan B working

(02-15-2019, 10:56 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 08:04 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 07:34 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 05:28 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-14-2019, 10:12 PM)Peachy Wrote: I think the same but then surely the efl will be setting an extremely dangerous precedent going forward.

Villa have unashamedly flouted FFP to try and  get promotion and it's completely failed. Having new owners with money now should not come into it.

They need to be hit hard otherwise they will be used as the benchmark for all other cases.

Bit like the Gayle dive ban we can rightly now question every single dive in any game now across all leagues and ask why the player is not being charged.

Getting promoted used to be the way of escaping EFL sanctions. It worked for Bournemouth because they stayed up, and ended up negotiating a modest fine. It would have worked for QPR as well but they got relegated again and had to pay £42m.

Since those instances the PL and the EFL have got together and agreed that they will enforce each other’s sanctions, so if Villa were in blatant breach and got up, the resulting fine and transfer embargo would be enforced by the PL rather than being left in abeyance until they got relegated again.  Going up with a huge fine and with a transfer embargo wouldn’t be much fun!

The trouble is, by the time an embargo was agreed. they would have already spunked trillions on players. Yes they wouldn't enjoy it, but it would be a means to an end.

No - the FFP and STCC tests are now run in March so that sanctions can take place immediately in the current season, including points deductions (and before they could spend in summer window).  Villa have to publish their 31/5/18 audited accounts by 28/2/19, and they also have to produce audited management accounts/forecasts for the year ending 31/5/19 during March 2019 so that current season spending is taken into account (in their cases 9 months of trading in the current financial year).  These will clearly show that Villa are way over the permitted £39m max loss over 3 seasons. The only thing that can possibly save them is the sale of their training ground for a genuine market value and the value would be under massive scrutiny.

I don't disagree that they cannot escape sanction, or your understanding of the calculation, but after the hearing, there is right of appeal through Arbitration.

There is strong talk that Blues will not be concluded this season, if Arbitration follows. On the same basis, Villa would have another roll of the dice before any punishment took effect.

Arbitration is always a possibility, as is appeal, but the whole rationale for doing the review in March was brought in so that penalties could be enacted this season and so that teams won’t be allowed to go up with it unresolved


RE: Villa accounts.... - Kit Kat Chunky - 02-15-2019

(02-15-2019, 12:38 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 08:19 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Didn't know that Pragmastist. So why do you think Purslow is so confident they are compliant? Bluster?

Could be bluster. Could be risking it.  We will find out in due course!

(02-15-2019, 09:04 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 08:19 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: Didn't know that Pragmastist. So why do you think Purslow is so confident they are compliant? Bluster?

This is my concern. Wasn't Purslow part of the team that helped set up the FFP rules etc?

He will probably have a greater knowledge of it than anyone. If he's unconcerned he is either bluffing it (can't see the point in why he would) or he's managed to pull some strings with someone influential to get a tweak to the rulings somewhere.

Isn't their best bet to come clean this season, take a points hit which won't effect them (They won't go up or down anyway) and transfer embargo which will hit them for next season. They can consolidate next season with a crap side and then spunk gazillions the following season and probably go up?


My understanding a few months back was that selling Grealish was the easy solution, with selling the training ground as the backup, but with the latter understandably far more complex. Grealish’s injury scuppered Plan A, and they will be really sweating on Plan B working

(02-15-2019, 10:56 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 08:04 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 07:34 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(02-15-2019, 05:28 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Getting promoted used to be the way of escaping EFL sanctions. It worked for Bournemouth because they stayed up, and ended up negotiating a modest fine. It would have worked for QPR as well but they got relegated again and had to pay £42m.

Since those instances the PL and the EFL have got together and agreed that they will enforce each other’s sanctions, so if Villa were in blatant breach and got up, the resulting fine and transfer embargo would be enforced by the PL rather than being left in abeyance until they got relegated again.  Going up with a huge fine and with a transfer embargo wouldn’t be much fun!

The trouble is, by the time an embargo was agreed. they would have already spunked trillions on players. Yes they wouldn't enjoy it, but it would be a means to an end.

No - the FFP and STCC tests are now run in March so that sanctions can take place immediately in the current season, including points deductions (and before they could spend in summer window).  Villa have to publish their 31/5/18 audited accounts by 28/2/19, and they also have to produce audited management accounts/forecasts for the year ending 31/5/19 during March 2019 so that current season spending is taken into account (in their cases 9 months of trading in the current financial year).  These will clearly show that Villa are way over the permitted £39m max loss over 3 seasons. The only thing that can possibly save them is the sale of their training ground for a genuine market value and the value would be under massive scrutiny.

I don't disagree that they cannot escape sanction, or your understanding of the calculation, but after the hearing, there is right of appeal through Arbitration.

There is strong talk that Blues will not be concluded this season, if Arbitration follows. On the same basis, Villa would have another roll of the dice before any punishment took effect.

Arbitration is always a possibility, as is appeal, but the whole rationale for doing the review in March was brought in so that penalties could be enacted this season and so that teams won’t be allowed to go up with it unresolved

Totally  -but you just know that any club receiving a penalty will try and manipulate these things.

From my perspective, the assessment should take place on the first day after the Summer window closes, and based on monies paid out over the summer as well. This would prevent a lot of the shenanigans, and give adequate time for due process and appeal to follow.