WBAUnofficial
New deal - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: New deal (/showthread.php?tid=6986)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: New deal - billybassett - 10-18-2019

Much as I hate Johnson getting a deal that in someway allows NI to be in and out and thus satisfy the good friday agreement is an achievement. Why it has taken 3 years to work this out is another matter. Just shows how inept May really was because let's face it it's 98% May's deal with a few sprinkles. Virtually nothing in the documentation has really changed - a few items moving to the political (and thus unenforceable) declaration.

All that being said is it a good deal? Let's face it nobody knows. Anyone who says they do is a liar. We won't know for 30 years if we come out and we'll never know if we stay in.

What I do know is that if the deal goes through then the election will be a walk over. We'll have a Tory government for the next 4 years with that bumbling, power crazed idiot in control with his far right millionaire friends in cabinet. I shudder at the thought. The Lib Dems are in a fantasy dream, the change/independent MPs can't make a proper party, Corbyn is quite possibly the worst shadow leader the country has ever seen (I mean where has he been the last 2 weeks?) and none of the fringe parties have enough coverage.

Wim doomed. Best thing is demographically, by the time all the paperwork gets done, (probably mid 2020s) a good percentage of the old 'uns who voted to take Britain back to the 50s will be gone, dropping a nuke each as the drop off the mortal coil.


RE: New deal - Derek Hardballs - 10-18-2019

(10-18-2019, 07:56 AM)billybassett Wrote: Much as I hate Johnson getting a deal that in someway allows NI to be in and out and thus satisfy the good friday agreement is an achievement. Why it has taken 3 years to work this out is another matter. Just shows how inept May really was because let's face it it's 98% May's deal with a few sprinkles. Virtually nothing in the documentation has really changed - a few items moving to the political (and thus unenforceable) declaration.

All that being said is it a good deal? Let's face it nobody knows. Anyone who says they do is a liar. We won't know for 30 years if we come out and we'll never know if we stay in.

What I do know is that if the deal goes through then the election will be a walk over. We'll have a Tory government for the next 4 years with that bumbling, power crazed idiot in control with his far right millionaire friends in cabinet. I shudder at the thought. The Lib Dems are in a fantasy dream, the change/independent MPs can't make a proper party, Corbyn is quite possibly the worst shadow leader the country has ever seen (I mean where has he been the last 2 weeks?) and none of the fringe parties have enough coverage.

Wim doomed. Best thing is demographically, by the time all the paperwork gets done, (probably mid 2020s) a good percentage of the old 'uns who voted to take Britain back to the 50s will be gone, dropping a nuke each as the drop off the mortal coil.

Leaving the rest will see of us to  mop up the mess the baby boomers have continually left behind. Has there ever been a more self obsessed, wasteful generation?


RE: New deal - Big Cyrille - 10-18-2019

(10-18-2019, 06:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 11:08 PM)Big Cyrille Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 12:41 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(10-17-2019, 10:49 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: The ONLY was out of this impasse is with a confirmatory vote whether people like it or not.

Agreed.

It wouldn't be pretty, though.

Remain already rejected in 2016. So assume the vote would be Boris Deal vs No Deal?

Er no. The amount of lies told during the run up to the referendum should in any normal circumstances made the result null and void. If you or anyone else can say they knew exactly what they were voting for in regards to leaving then I say to them they’re lying.

Here’s the latest poxy deal, a pig with lipstick on just like every deal apart from remain will / would be... £2000 worse off (applause)

When you have Johnson, Cummings, Mogg, Cleverly, Raab, Patel and the Cheese Woman in favour of a deal be afraid be very afraid.

While Corbyn, McDonnell, Umuna, Smarmy Starmer are against it... so it must be ok.


RE: New deal - bradesbaggie - 10-18-2019

(10-18-2019, 07:56 AM)billybassett Wrote: . Just shows how inept May really was because let's face it it's 98% May's deal with a few sprinkles. Virtually nothing in the documentation has really changed - a few items moving to the political (and thus unenforceable) declaration.

Spot on.

[Image: EHGgGZ7XYAM25AU.jpg]


RE: New deal - Borin' Baggie - 10-18-2019

It's not a new deal, if it were then Juncker and Barnier would need to have gone to the Comission for approval. It is the original deal that the EU offered May in 2017 dressed up slightly to make it more palatable for the Tory party. The only addition is the exit mechanism which is moot so long as the DUP/TUV don't have a majority in Stormont.


RE: New deal - Ossian - 10-18-2019

(10-17-2019, 02:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The numbers aren’t currently there to see it over the line and frankly any Labour MP that backs the deal which gives no protection to workers etc is betraying (war ref ;Wink one if the fundamental pillars of Labours reason to exist. I suspect there will be a removal of the whip for any of them that do so at this critical time.

I've already heard a few Labour MPs interviewed yesterday evening and this morning; the ones in leave-voting constituencies (and there are a fair number of those) are obviously in a bit of a bind: vote with the whip and risk the wrath of their constituents; vote for the deal and risk helping to facilitate the return of a triumphant, Johnson-led government, with an outright majority at the imminent election. So it might come down to either hanging onto the seat for another five years in opposition; or losing it to either the Tories or The Brexit party. 

Labour have got themselves into this position; nobody else to blame. No clarity, no clear sense of direction; just three and a half years of contorted fence-sitting.


RE: New deal - chasetownbaggie - 10-18-2019

(10-18-2019, 07:56 AM)billybassett Wrote: Much as I hate Johnson getting a deal that in someway allows NI to be in and out and thus satisfy the good friday agreement is an achievement. Why it has taken 3 years to work this out is another matter. Just shows how inept May really was because let's face it it's 98% May's deal with a few sprinkles. Virtually nothing in the documentation has really changed - a few items moving to the political (and thus unenforceable) declaration.


In fairness to May, I think she tried to come up with a deal that would appeal to everyone and keep the UK together. NI was always the conundrum. I recall seeing a simple meme that listed options A, B and C for NI but all of them had an issue that would not satisfy one group's aims be it the EU's, the DUP's or the hard-line Brexiteers. Effectively, Boris has sacrificed NI. This new deal is surely the start of the road to a united Ireland. FWIW, I've no problem with that - we should have never been there in the first place - just a shame so many lives were lost defending it.


RE: New deal - billybassett - 10-18-2019

(10-18-2019, 09:08 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(10-18-2019, 07:56 AM)billybassett Wrote: Much as I hate Johnson getting a deal that in someway allows NI to be in and out and thus satisfy the good friday agreement is an achievement. Why it has taken 3 years to work this out is another matter. Just shows how inept May really was because let's face it it's 98% May's deal with a few sprinkles. Virtually nothing in the documentation has really changed - a few items moving to the political (and thus unenforceable) declaration.


In fairness to May, I think she tried to come up with a deal that would appeal to everyone and keep the UK together. NI was always the conundrum. I recall seeing a simple meme that listed options A, B and C for NI but all of them had an issue that would not satisfy one group's aims be it the EU's, the DUP's or the hard-line Brexiteers. Effectively, Boris has sacrificed NI. This new deal is surely the start of the road to a united Ireland. FWIW, I've no problem with that - we should have never been there in the first place - just a shame so many lives were lost defending it.

And I remember back in July Boris saying, in Belfast, that he'd never agree to a withdrawal agreement down the Irish sea, he called it a terrible moral blackmail. And here we are. No Stormont assembly for 2 years or so tells you all you need to know about the state of NI politics. Can't see a union myself in the near future. What will be interesting is if the deal gets voted through is seeing the Scots implode. I reckon there's Scottish procurement officers already in place liaising with TrumpWallBuildingCo to start re-digging Hadrian wall's footings...


RE: New deal - Ossian - 10-18-2019

Bloody hell...

I'm already booked in for Mull, Ardnamurchan and then a couple of weeks in Rothiemurchus next year.


RE: New deal - sickParrot - 10-18-2019

Seems that the "deal" may be unlawful under Section 55 of the Taxation (Cross-border Trade) Act 2018.

Ironically the breaks an amendment from Rees-Mogg.

It is in court right now.