RE: Olé.... - Duffers - 09-26-2019
(09-26-2019, 01:00 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: It says something about the current state of Man Utd that managers like LVG and Jose have gone in and not achieved the success they should at a club like Utd.
Is OGS to blame for the start Utd are having? I don't think he is. The club needs a good clear out in playing staff AND a complete shake up at board room level. It's incredible to see the mess they're in, when you consider they've spent as much as City in the last five years (I think? I'm sure Gary Neville mentioned that stat on $ky?).
A club like Utd should never have to rely on players like Lingard and Rashford, they are simply not good enough for that level.
The entire club is stagnant from top to bottom:
A playing staff full of has verbs, never will bed and can’t be arsed...
A management team promoted well beyond their ability level.
A board more interested in securing noodle partnerships in China than success on the field.
They are now 90’s Liverpool.
RE: Olé.... - chasetownbaggie - 09-26-2019
Everything pointed to Poccetino getting the gig before Ole won over the fans during his caretaker period. I wonder if he'll get it this time assuming Solskjaer gets sacked and Spurs poor form continues?
RE: Olé.... - Birdman1811 - 09-26-2019
(09-26-2019, 12:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (09-26-2019, 11:31 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: (09-26-2019, 09:34 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: Big Dave did a decent job and should be looked back very fondly
As a player definitely. As a manager, no
No fault of Big Dave, the job to get us out the champiosnhip at the firs time of asking, with that squad, was well above him. The guy would have been made up with a job in the 1st team coaching structure after what he did at the end of the Premiership season
Jenkins and the heiracrchy here wanted Smith, it was Lai who felt Moore would galvanise the fan base and wanted him, no fault of Darren who will always be remembered fondly IMO but as a club we made the wrong call
Cuzer
I'm far from convinced on Smith, and watching Villa since he took over has only confirmed my concerns on him.
Fact is neither Smith or Moore were the right choice to get us out imo, however I at least preferred Moore.
I rate Bilic higher than both by far so maybe it was for the best long term, sometimes you take a step back to jump forward.
RE: Olé.... - Kit Kat Chunky - 09-26-2019
(09-26-2019, 03:07 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-26-2019, 12:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (09-26-2019, 11:31 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: (09-26-2019, 09:34 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: Big Dave did a decent job and should be looked back very fondly
As a player definitely. As a manager, no
No fault of Big Dave, the job to get us out the champiosnhip at the firs time of asking, with that squad, was well above him. The guy would have been made up with a job in the 1st team coaching structure after what he did at the end of the Premiership season
Jenkins and the heiracrchy here wanted Smith, it was Lai who felt Moore would galvanise the fan base and wanted him, no fault of Darren who will always be remembered fondly IMO but as a club we made the wrong call
Cuzer
I'm far from convinced on Smith, and watching Villa since he took over has only confirmed my concerns on him.
Fact is neither Smith or Moore were the right choice to get us out imo, however I at least preferred Moore.
I rate Bilic higher than both by far so maybe it was for the best long term, sometimes you take a step back to jump forward.
Smith will be gone by November, in my opinion.
I wouldn't want Gammon anywhere near my club
RE: Olé.... - SW4Baggie - 09-26-2019
(09-26-2019, 03:07 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-26-2019, 12:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (09-26-2019, 11:31 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: (09-26-2019, 09:34 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: Big Dave did a decent job and should be looked back very fondly
As a player definitely. As a manager, no
No fault of Big Dave, the job to get us out the champiosnhip at the firs time of asking, with that squad, was well above him. The guy would have been made up with a job in the 1st team coaching structure after what he did at the end of the Premiership season
Jenkins and the heiracrchy here wanted Smith, it was Lai who felt Moore would galvanise the fan base and wanted him, no fault of Darren who will always be remembered fondly IMO but as a club we made the wrong call
Cuzer
I'm far from convinced on Smith, and watching Villa since he took over has only confirmed my concerns on him.
Fact is neither Smith or Moore were the right choice to get us out imo, however I at least preferred Moore.
I rate Bilic higher than both by far so maybe it was for the best long term, sometimes you take a step back to jump forward.
Smith thoroughly deserved the chance to manage us and Villa, he’d shown at Walsall and Brentford he’s a competent and adaptable coach.
He’s done very well at Villa, but has had more than his fair share of luck along the way. The team’s form without Grealish last season is certainly a worry, the fact he’s spent £160m and built a wholly unbalanced side that looks at the moment anyway, far from being good enough for the level they’re at, and his sides have always struggled to defend suggests he may well have gone as far as he can. His attitude and personality since joining Villa is also far from one Id see as a fit for our club.
At the time, I was very pro-Smith, and I think he’d probably be a better fit for us than the job and culture he inherited at Villa but being one of them he’d have fucked us off as soon as they came knocking.
As birdmon says, I am far, far happier with Bilic than Smith, though had it been up to me I’d have probably given it Smith over Slav.
RE: Olé.... - Squid - 09-27-2019
(09-26-2019, 12:46 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: Did a good job overall
9 out of 10 in the PL
6 out of 10 in the Champ
If we do fail to return in the near future and our finances get slashed - we will look back on last season even more as an opportunity missed
The more I look back at that season, I think we had some awful luck.
Barnes recalled.
Barry and Phillips injured.
Utterly useless ref making the worst possible decision.
But, we look a more coherent team this season and I'me very impressed with Bilić thus far.
RE: Olé.... - Mancbaggies - 09-27-2019
(09-27-2019, 03:56 PM)Squid Wrote: (09-26-2019, 12:46 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: Did a good job overall
9 out of 10 in the PL
6 out of 10 in the Champ
If we do fail to return in the near future and our finances get slashed - we will look back on last season even more as an opportunity missed
The more I look back at that season, I think we had some awful luck.
Barnes recalled.
Barry and Phillips injured.
Utterly useless ref making the worst possible decision.
But, we look a more coherent team this season and I'me very impressed with Bilić thus far.
The Gayle sending off was incredibly bad luck on us
Even with Barnes - we were flattering to deceive a little. 4th when he left
RE: Olé.... - Super_Slav - 09-27-2019
Losing Livermore and Barry hurt us too. We had a lack of central midfield options come the play offs
RE: Olé.... - Cuzer - 09-28-2019
(09-26-2019, 07:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (09-26-2019, 03:07 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-26-2019, 12:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (09-26-2019, 11:31 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: (09-26-2019, 09:34 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: Big Dave did a decent job and should be looked back very fondly
As a player definitely. As a manager, no
No fault of Big Dave, the job to get us out the champiosnhip at the firs time of asking, with that squad, was well above him. The guy would have been made up with a job in the 1st team coaching structure after what he did at the end of the Premiership season
Jenkins and the heiracrchy here wanted Smith, it was Lai who felt Moore would galvanise the fan base and wanted him, no fault of Darren who will always be remembered fondly IMO but as a club we made the wrong call
Cuzer
I'm far from convinced on Smith, and watching Villa since he took over has only confirmed my concerns on him.
Fact is neither Smith or Moore were the right choice to get us out imo, however I at least preferred Moore.
I rate Bilic higher than both by far so maybe it was for the best long term, sometimes you take a step back to jump forward.
Smith thoroughly deserved the chance to manage us and Villa, he’d shown at Walsall and Brentford he’s a competent and adaptable coach.
He’s done very well at Villa, but has had more than his fair share of luck along the way. The team’s form without Grealish last season is certainly a worry, the fact he’s spent £160m and built a wholly unbalanced side that looks at the moment anyway, far from being good enough for the level they’re at, and his sides have always struggled to defend suggests he may well have gone as far as he can. His attitude and personality since joining Villa is also far from one Id see as a fit for our club.
At the time, I was very pro-Smith, and I think he’d probably be a better fit for us than the job and culture he inherited at Villa but being one of them he’d have fucked us off as soon as they came knocking.
As birdmon says, I am far, far happier with Bilic than Smith, though had it been up to me I’d have probably given it Smith over Slav.
Spot on, taking off the Villa hatred glasses for one second he would have got us promoted with last seasons squad playing attractive football, the job was above Moore and Jones, Gary Johnson was the other very live candidate
Now he’s at Villa I’d love the gammon faced seal to take them down and he find himself out of work, alas I don’t think it will happen
Cuzer
RE: Olé.... - Duffers - 09-28-2019
(09-28-2019, 07:47 AM)Cuzer Wrote: (09-26-2019, 07:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (09-26-2019, 03:07 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-26-2019, 12:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (09-26-2019, 11:31 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: As a player definitely. As a manager, no
No fault of Big Dave, the job to get us out the champiosnhip at the firs time of asking, with that squad, was well above him. The guy would have been made up with a job in the 1st team coaching structure after what he did at the end of the Premiership season
Jenkins and the heiracrchy here wanted Smith, it was Lai who felt Moore would galvanise the fan base and wanted him, no fault of Darren who will always be remembered fondly IMO but as a club we made the wrong call
Cuzer
I'm far from convinced on Smith, and watching Villa since he took over has only confirmed my concerns on him.
Fact is neither Smith or Moore were the right choice to get us out imo, however I at least preferred Moore.
I rate Bilic higher than both by far so maybe it was for the best long term, sometimes you take a step back to jump forward.
Smith thoroughly deserved the chance to manage us and Villa, he’d shown at Walsall and Brentford he’s a competent and adaptable coach.
He’s done very well at Villa, but has had more than his fair share of luck along the way. The team’s form without Grealish last season is certainly a worry, the fact he’s spent £160m and built a wholly unbalanced side that looks at the moment anyway, far from being good enough for the level they’re at, and his sides have always struggled to defend suggests he may well have gone as far as he can. His attitude and personality since joining Villa is also far from one Id see as a fit for our club.
At the time, I was very pro-Smith, and I think he’d probably be a better fit for us than the job and culture he inherited at Villa but being one of them he’d have fucked us off as soon as they came knocking.
As birdmon says, I am far, far happier with Bilic than Smith, though had it been up to me I’d have probably given it Smith over Slav.
Spot on, taking off the Villa hatred glasses for one second he would have got us promoted with last seasons squad playing attractive football, the job was above Moore and Jones, Gary Johnson was the other very live candidate
Now he’s at Villa I’d love the gammon faced seal to take them down and he find himself out of work, alas I don’t think it will happen
Cuzer
Absolutely colossal game for them today. Lose this and it really does look like a long hard season for them.
|