RE: Luke Dowling - chasetownbaggie - 07-15-2019
(07-15-2019, 12:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2019, 12:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I have to say in words and deeds I have not been impressed by Luke Dowling.
That said any reasonable employer should give them enough time to get to grips with the job in hand - 10 months is not enough time.
I really struggle to see how we continue to make this role so hard. His job is to coordinate scouting, transfers and youth and also our medical facilities.
I remember seeing a documentary where David Moyes showed a locked room in the training ground which was covered in whiteboards. One board for each position, with a list of targets, current expected value/demands, and it was updated every week or so, and colour coded for how easy it would be to sign them. There were then other boards with the current team, and how it was expected to evolve including youth players / potential transfers for the next 4 years. Obviously the current squad weren't allowed in!
I've seen another interview with Monchi where he said their approach is simple. He has a team of trusted people who spend 3-4 months watching football. They watch game after game on TV, each specialising in various leagues, and they just write lists and lists of players that impress them. If the name repeats, they start to monitor, and before you know it you have a massive list of targets... this is when you use technology to track and analyse.
It really cannot be hard to scout, monitor and sign players.
I always think compiling a list of players voted player's player and supporter's player of the year is a decent starting point.
RE: Luke Dowling - Sliced - 07-15-2019
(07-15-2019, 12:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2019, 12:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I have to say in words and deeds I have not been impressed by Luke Dowling.
That said any reasonable employer should give them enough time to get to grips with the job in hand - 10 months is not enough time.
I really struggle to see how we continue to make this role so hard. His job is to coordinate scouting, transfers and youth and also our medical facilities.
I remember seeing a documentary where David Moyes showed a locked room in the training ground which was covered in whiteboards. One board for each position, with a list of targets, current expected value/demands, and it was updated every week or so, and colour coded for how easy it would be to sign them. There were then other boards with the current team, and how it was expected to evolve including youth players / potential transfers for the next 4 years. Obviously the current squad weren't allowed in!
I've seen another interview with Monchi where he said their approach is simple. He has a team of trusted people who spend 3-4 months watching football. They watch game after game on TV, each specialising in various leagues, and they just write lists and lists of players that impress them. If the name repeats, they start to monitor, and before you know it you have a massive list of targets... this is when you use technology to track and analyse.
It really cannot be hard to scout, monitor and sign players.
Good post.
Logically the more we sign the easier it should be to sign also. A club with seemingly no plan is much less appealing than one with a plan
RE: Luke Dowling - SW4Baggie - 07-15-2019
(07-15-2019, 01:06 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (07-15-2019, 12:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2019, 12:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I have to say in words and deeds I have not been impressed by Luke Dowling.
That said any reasonable employer should give them enough time to get to grips with the job in hand - 10 months is not enough time.
I really struggle to see how we continue to make this role so hard. His job is to coordinate scouting, transfers and youth and also our medical facilities.
I remember seeing a documentary where David Moyes showed a locked room in the training ground which was covered in whiteboards. One board for each position, with a list of targets, current expected value/demands, and it was updated every week or so, and colour coded for how easy it would be to sign them. There were then other boards with the current team, and how it was expected to evolve including youth players / potential transfers for the next 4 years. Obviously the current squad weren't allowed in!
I've seen another interview with Monchi where he said their approach is simple. He has a team of trusted people who spend 3-4 months watching football. They watch game after game on TV, each specialising in various leagues, and they just write lists and lists of players that impress them. If the name repeats, they start to monitor, and before you know it you have a massive list of targets... this is when you use technology to track and analyse.
It really cannot be hard to scout, monitor and sign players.
I always think compiling a list of players voted player's player and supporter's player of the year is a decent starting point.
Yup!
Get a few people who speak German, French, Spanish give them a couple of days trawling through message boards and twitter... within a couple of days you’ll have 100 players. You then look at freely available stats, narrow it down further and before you know it you’ll have 5-10 potential targets.
I think this is why it’s so frustrating - it really shouldn’t be that hard to at least have a plan.
RE: Luke Dowling - Hopalong - 07-15-2019
(07-15-2019, 01:41 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2019, 01:06 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (07-15-2019, 12:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2019, 12:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I have to say in words and deeds I have not been impressed by Luke Dowling.
That said any reasonable employer should give them enough time to get to grips with the job in hand - 10 months is not enough time.
I really struggle to see how we continue to make this role so hard. His job is to coordinate scouting, transfers and youth and also our medical facilities.
I remember seeing a documentary where David Moyes showed a locked room in the training ground which was covered in whiteboards. One board for each position, with a list of targets, current expected value/demands, and it was updated every week or so, and colour coded for how easy it would be to sign them. There were then other boards with the current team, and how it was expected to evolve including youth players / potential transfers for the next 4 years. Obviously the current squad weren't allowed in!
I've seen another interview with Monchi where he said their approach is simple. He has a team of trusted people who spend 3-4 months watching football. They watch game after game on TV, each specialising in various leagues, and they just write lists and lists of players that impress them. If the name repeats, they start to monitor, and before you know it you have a massive list of targets... this is when you use technology to track and analyse.
It really cannot be hard to scout, monitor and sign players.
I always think compiling a list of players voted player's player and supporter's player of the year is a decent starting point.
Yup!
Get a few people who speak German, French, Spanish give them a couple of days trawling through message boards and twitter... within a couple of days you’ll have 100 players. You then look at freely available stats, narrow it down further and before you know it you’ll have 5-10 potential targets.
I think this is why it’s so frustrating - it really shouldn’t be that hard to at least have a plan.
Last Tuesday/Wednesday? Slav said we had a plan and he had been told we had to sell to buy (purchase a player, not loans?) and now J Rod /Dawson had gone we could activate the targets put together over the past 2 and a half weeks (at that point). He also mentioned that Rondon should be gone soon...
We had good connections, we needed some luck.....so what's happened since? It's only been a few days.
Is something getting lost in translation here? Or is Slav's english actually better than half of Albion's fans as someone said last week?
All very confusing anyway......
RE: Luke Dowling - LIMABAGGIE - 07-15-2019
I think the point is we are not moving forward as a Club. At best we are treading water, at worst we are falling way behind. There is an ever growing credibility gap between ourselves and our two close neighbours. We have been saddled with a useless owner, who cares little about our future as a club. The more we stagnate the more we cement ourselves into the Championship.
We sleepwalked to relegation two years ago, we could sleepwalk into irrelevance if we are not very careful.
The quotes from SB are disturbing. The lack of recruits is disturbing. I am disturbed.
RE: Luke Dowling - Tom Joad - 07-15-2019
(07-15-2019, 02:57 PM)LIMABAGGIE Wrote: I think the point is we are not moving forward as a Club. At best we are treading water, at worst we are falling way behind. There is an ever growing credibility gap between ourselves and our two close neighbours. We have been saddled with a useless owner, who cares little about our future as a club. The more we stagnate the more we cement ourselves into the Championship.
We sleepwalked to relegation two years ago, we could sleepwalk into irrelevance if we are not very careful.
The quotes from SB are disturbing. The lack of recruits is disturbing. I am disturbed.
Very good point.
I disagree about treading water, mind. We are definitely falling way behind.
|