WBAUnofficial
Labour oh dear! - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Labour oh dear! (/showthread.php?tid=5352)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Labour oh dear! - Fido - 07-12-2019

(07-12-2019, 11:37 AM)Sandking Wrote: Corbyn is a 70-year-old man who will be sipping tea through a straw inside his plush London metropolitan nursing home before the pipe dreams of his supporters are fulfilled of seeing him become PM. Tick-Tock.

Labour is currently struggling to reconcile its broad church appeal and the more to the left it positions itself the harder the sell becomes to moderates and the centre ground inside and outside of its party membership. Blindingly obvious to the sane of thought.

Corbyn has some fair rhetoric " A fairer society" 
A modicum of sincerity ( Grenfell ) But ultimately Labour only wins elections when it mans the centre ground and then extends its political tentacles further out to the left. Or more pertinently as far to the left as it's willing to go before it begins to ostracise its moderate centre-ground electorate. 

It plays out currently with the London metropolitan elite and the ever-widening disconnect with Working Class Labour heartlands.
All things to all men broad church appeal is a millstone around the party's neck and Corbyn more often than not is viewed as non-commital preferring instead to sit on the fence caught between two stools.

Still, Emily Thornberry is reaping handsome rewards from her current private enterprise schemes, on that, we can all rest easy.

It’s hard to find a less sincere politician that Emily Thornberry. God knows why she is the default QT choice - she must be on TV more than Man Utd. For want of balance she’s of course not the only one put does stick out like podgy forefinger.


RE: Labour oh dear! - YorkieDan - 07-12-2019

The mural depicts the Rothschilds wjho were, i believe, Jewish but it also depicts the Rockafellas and Morgans who were not? Am i missing something? Surely it is aimed at the idea of a global banking elite ruling over others and nothing directly aimed at a Jewish cartel?

And, isnt the Eye of Provindence which is attached to illuminati ideology actually a Christian symbol?

Isnt it essentially just a couple of people who happen to be Jewish, playing monopoly with the world finances with some people who are not Jewish?

Does the idea that a group of people who are/were involved in banking running the world make the idea "antisemitic" if some if them are Jewish?

The misnomer of "anti-semitic" has long since become a deflector sheild and a major blot on the career book of anyone who dares to question Isreali policy or shows support for Palestine.

Often from parties or people with Isreali influence.

The Cons are funded and supported by Conservative friends of Isreal. Isnt in their interest to push an Antisemitic angle?

Tommy Robinson has had legal fees, salaries and rallues paid for by American Jewish billionaire Robert Shillman who has previously held government and defense ministerial positions for Isreal? 

Is it beyond belief that Jews, by proxy of nation, influence global and local politics as much as anyone?


RE: Labour oh dear! - Sandking - 07-12-2019

(07-12-2019, 04:09 PM)Fido Wrote:
(07-12-2019, 11:37 AM)Sandking Wrote: Corbyn is a 70-year-old man who will be sipping tea through a straw inside his plush London metropolitan nursing home before the pipe dreams of his supporters are fulfilled of seeing him become PM. Tick-Tock.

Labour is currently struggling to reconcile its broad church appeal and the more to the left it positions itself the harder the sell becomes to moderates and the centre ground inside and outside of its party membership. Blindingly obvious to the sane of thought.

Corbyn has some fair rhetoric " A fairer society" 
A modicum of sincerity ( Grenfell ) But ultimately Labour only wins elections when it mans the centre ground and then extends its political tentacles further out to the left. Or more pertinently as far to the left as it's willing to go before it begins to ostracise its moderate centre-ground electorate. 

It plays out currently with the London metropolitan elite and the ever-widening disconnect with Working Class Labour heartlands.
All things to all men broad church appeal is a millstone around the party's neck and Corbyn more often than not is viewed as non-commital preferring instead to sit on the fence caught between two stools.

Still, Emily Thornberry is reaping handsome rewards from her current private enterprise schemes, on that, we can all rest easy.

It’s hard to find a less sincere politician that Emily Thornberry. God knows why she is the default QT choice - she must be on TV more than Man Utd. For want of balance she’s of course not the only one put does stick out like podgy forefinger.

She epitomises Labours London Metropolitan Class and that chasm & disconnect I mentioned with the Labour heartlands. As if that alone were not troubling enough the Remain / Brexit debate of these two polar opposite demographics make it all look very ugly for Labour.


RE: Labour oh dear! - Ossian - 07-13-2019

(07-12-2019, 12:57 PM)bradesbaggie Wrote:
(07-11-2019, 07:04 AM)Ossian Wrote:
(07-11-2019, 06:34 AM)bradesbaggie Wrote: Seems the Red Tories are still fuming that the membership want Corbyn as leader.

Their judgement is clouded by nostalgia for irrelevancies like election victories and adequate funding of public services.

There is little point in winning elections like Blair did if the outcome is that the gap between rich and poor widens. Might as well have had the Tories do it.

There are two options available for the centre/left: it can either come to terms with the need for pragmatic politics, or it can forego power in perpetuity and content itself with just occupying the moral high ground. Hard to see how the latter is of much help to anybody, although there are plenty - Owen Jones as an example - who would probably rejoice in the ideological purity of it all.


RE: Labour oh dear! - bradesbaggie - 07-15-2019

(07-13-2019, 02:09 PM)Ossian Wrote:
(07-12-2019, 12:57 PM)bradesbaggie Wrote:
(07-11-2019, 07:04 AM)Ossian Wrote:
(07-11-2019, 06:34 AM)bradesbaggie Wrote: Seems the Red Tories are still fuming that the membership want Corbyn as leader.

Their judgement is clouded by nostalgia for irrelevancies like election victories and adequate funding of public services.

There is little point in winning elections like Blair did if the outcome is that the gap between rich and poor widens. Might as well have had the Tories do it.

There are two options available for the centre/left: it can either come to terms with the need for pragmatic politics, or it can forego power in perpetuity and content itself with just occupying the moral high ground. Hard to see how the latter is of much help to anybody, although there are plenty - Owen Jones as an example - who would probably rejoice in the ideological purity of it all.

The current situation resembles the 1945 Labour election when the public were told - 'we can't afford this', 'Labour are like the Gestapo', - scaremongering all around. Let's see if people fall for it.


RE: Labour oh dear! - Ossian - 07-15-2019

Matter of opinion, I suppose, but I don't see much resemblance between Attlee's 1945 cabinet and the current Labour front bench; or indeed between Attlee and Corbyn themselves.

By 1945 the country was ready for Attlee - as the election result demonstrated. I don't see much evidence of a country ready for Corbyn; bloody hell, I don't want him and my politics are solidly centre/left. Right now I don't want any of the fuckers and if there's a box marked 'None of the above thanks' on the next ballot paper, I'll probably be sticking a cross in there.


RE: Labour oh dear! - Derek Hardballs - 07-15-2019

(07-15-2019, 04:02 PM)Ossian Wrote: Matter of opinion, I suppose, but I don't see much resemblance between Attlee's 1945 cabinet and the current Labour front bench; or indeed between Attlee and Corbyn themselves.

By 1945 the country was ready for Attlee - as the election result demonstrated. I don't see much evidence of a country ready for Corbyn; bloody hell, I don't want him and my politics are solidly centre/left. Right now I don't want any of the fuckers and if there's a box marked 'None of the above thanks' on the next ballot paper, I'll probably be sticking a cross in there.

Exactly, this lurch to the right and left leaves millions of us politically homeless. Any half decent left of centre, moderate party would be walking away with the polls and the next election.


RE: Labour oh dear! - Sunshine - 07-15-2019

(07-15-2019, 04:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-15-2019, 04:02 PM)Ossian Wrote: Matter of opinion, I suppose, but I don't see much resemblance between Attlee's 1945 cabinet and the current Labour front bench; or indeed between Attlee and Corbyn themselves.

By 1945 the country was ready for Attlee - as the election result demonstrated. I don't see much evidence of a country ready for Corbyn; bloody hell, I don't want him and my politics are solidly centre/left. Right now I don't want any of the fuckers and if there's a box marked 'None of the above thanks' on the next ballot paper, I'll probably be sticking a cross in there.

Exactly, this lurch to the right and left leaves millions of us politically homeless. Any half decent left of centre, moderate party would be walking away with the polls and the next election.

How are your little darlings in Changeuk doing?


RE: Labour oh dear! - Derek Hardballs - 07-15-2019

(07-15-2019, 04:22 PM)Sunshine Wrote:
(07-15-2019, 04:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-15-2019, 04:02 PM)Ossian Wrote: Matter of opinion, I suppose, but I don't see much resemblance between Attlee's 1945 cabinet and the current Labour front bench; or indeed between Attlee and Corbyn themselves.

By 1945 the country was ready for Attlee - as the election result demonstrated. I don't see much evidence of a country ready for Corbyn; bloody hell, I don't want him and my politics are solidly centre/left. Right now I don't want any of the fuckers and if there's a box marked 'None of the above thanks' on the next ballot paper, I'll probably be sticking a cross in there.

Exactly, this lurch to the right and left leaves millions of us politically homeless. Any half decent left of centre, moderate party would be walking away with the polls and the next election.

How are your little darlings in Changeuk doing?

You still don’t get it. To make any difference you have to have broad appeal and be electable, you aren’t, despite the fact this is quite easily the worst government in living memory. How many average people do you think put Palestine / Israel on any agenda let alone top like so many Corninisters? It’s meaningless to swing voters in marginals and as grubby as that may feel to those ideologically driven those are exactly who you should be trying to appeal to. The only people who are benefitting from a Corbyn led Labour Party are placard makers.


RE: Labour oh dear! - Babel - 07-18-2019

(07-13-2019, 02:09 PM)Ossian Wrote:
(07-12-2019, 12:57 PM)bradesbaggie Wrote:
(07-11-2019, 07:04 AM)Ossian Wrote:
(07-11-2019, 06:34 AM)bradesbaggie Wrote: Seems the Red Tories are still fuming that the membership want Corbyn as leader.

Their judgement is clouded by nostalgia for irrelevancies like election victories and adequate funding of public services.

There is little point in winning elections like Blair did if the outcome is that the gap between rich and poor widens. Might as well have had the Tories do it.

There are two options available for the centre/left: it can either come to terms with the need for pragmatic politics, or it can forego power in perpetuity and content itself with just occupying the moral high ground. Hard to see how the latter is of much help to anybody, although there are plenty - Owen Jones as an example - who would probably rejoice in the ideological purity of it all.

God post Oss.