![]() |
|
VAR - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: VAR (/showthread.php?tid=5279) |
RE: VAR - chasetownbaggie - 07-03-2019 If it means fewer incorrect decisions, I'm all for VAR. Both calls last night were correct. RE: VAR - Dumbo - 07-03-2019 (07-03-2019, 11:14 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: If it means fewer incorrect decisions, I'm all for VAR. Both calls last night were correct. I don’t think it was a pen. RE: VAR - LIMABAGGIE - 07-03-2019 Works in Rugby very well indeed. It isn't the Technology that's shit, its the corrupt, hideously grotesque narcissistic culture that football is these days that is misusing and abusing it. RE: VAR - CA Baggie - 07-04-2019 Blatant penalty missed in a World Cup Semi-final. So much for VAR RE: VAR - cornishbaggie - 07-04-2019 (07-02-2019, 09:36 PM)Peachy Wrote: VAR is absolutely ruining the game. The only thing that was ever needed was goal line technology. After all that is the most important thing. The act of the ball crossing the line is all that matters and was always the biggest injustice when not spotted. (Rotherham at home springs to mind for us in our promotion season when Jordao's header wasn't given which meant the 11 point dingle choke could have been ruined) That goal v Rotherham didn't affect us in the end, but it relegated Crewe on goal differance RE: VAR - Sliced - 07-04-2019 If we're going to use VAR there has to be a balance between it being used for every decision and slowing down the game and it never being used. They claim to use it for "clear and obvious errors" but it's already a slippery slope where far too many decisions are being checked that are neither clear nor obvious errors. With this tool there you're inevitably going to have players asking for replays, managers asking for replays although they shouldn't be allowed to do this and it's going to slow the game down further. As pointed out, if we're analysing whether something is a foul (which is subjective anyway in some cases) prior to a goal, then someone may argue and say "ok it wasn't, but lets look at this throw in a few seconds before that". As referees have shown they are incapable of knowing what "clear and obvious" is and they won't punish players who are asking for VAR a better way forward would be just to have a situation like the one in tennis where managers can question a decision. Let's say they get 2 per game, and if they are correct they maintain another one. However at the moment the way VAR is done is bloody rubbish. Slowing down the game and still giving debatable decisions anyway. RE: VAR - LIMABAGGIE - 07-04-2019 It isn't VAR that's rubbish. Its the way it is being used that is rubbish. The sole decision to use VARV should lie with the referee. It should be a tool used at the discretion of the referee and the referee only, to use when they are uncertain, or did not have a clear view of an incident. No one off the pitch should have any input whatsoever unless the referee requests it. The way we are using VAR just undermines a referee and his authority. If there are bad referees sack the twats. RE: VAR - Statto - 07-04-2019 We love all goal line technology that proves a ball is a few millimetres over the line or not, but so many argue about offsides for the same margin being ridiculous. We can't have it both ways. Both goal line and offside are a statement of fact to whatever the laws say. First phase/second phase and the law being an ass is absolutely sod all to do with VAR. IMHO the offside tech will be improved and will speed the process up and my personal view is that I'm comfortable for it being used for matters of fact. Letting play go while VAR checks offside in build up has worked very well, despite Jonathan Pearce's constant wailing. Unless we can clear up the "clear and obvious" issues in implementation or have a margin like cricket, I'd bin it totally for everything else, as it's still subjective and open for consistency issues. It just moves the argument elsewhere, rather than settling it. I've seen it stated that England's was never a pen. To the letter of the law it was 100% a penalty. The defender caught White's shooting leg and made her miss the ball. It was also from behind so by definition there was no chance of winning the ball. Therefore, whether accidental or not, it should have been a red card to the letter of the law. It wasn't clear and obvious, so I'd have been comfortable with not getting the decision. It's new and will need tweaking while it settles down. It can work if allowed to. As DK says, it will take so much away for stadium supporters, but we aren't as important as the armchair fans who allow the broadcasters to sell their advertising. Football is reality TV. RE: VAR - YamYam - 07-04-2019 I read the above and agree it's not cut & dry for offside decisions YET. My main issue is that they look like they're reviewing the lines on a Betamax from Cash Converters with a level of fuzz and not capturing the exact moment of the pass. 2 seconds of research into frame rate found me a ref that made a similar point (and I feel dirty for it) - https://www.refchat.co.uk/threads/var-wobbly-lines.11773/#post-116365 . RE: VAR - Netherbaggy - 07-04-2019 (07-03-2019, 05:03 PM)LIMABAGGIE Wrote: Works in Rugby very well indeed. It isn't the Technology that's shit, its the corrupt, hideously grotesque narcissistic culture that football is these days that is misusing and abusing it. Trouble is there are a lot of towns and cities other than Rugby where it isn’t working
|