![]() |
|
Villa Park sold.... - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Villa Park sold.... (/showthread.php?tid=5241) |
RE: Villa Park sold.... - Pragmatist - 07-01-2019 (06-29-2019, 10:02 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:(06-29-2019, 02:07 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Pretty sure any deals like this have to see rent paid at market value under FFFP (not that it’s worth the paper it’s written on) - in Villa’s case a few million a year in rent won’t be too much of an issue, but Derby having to pay market value on an £80m stadium in the Champ may have a few other challenges. Market value, both to sell and to rent, is what an independent third parry would pay. A professional real estate valuer will come up with both figures. As long as Villa can come up with a valuation from an independent valuer which supports the figures used, then it is hard for those figures to be challenged. The higher the sale figure, the higher the rent figure, as it is based on capital yield. A sale value of £57m at a yield of around 4% equates to rent of around £2.3m a year. It is hard to know what the stadium was in the books at, in terms of depreciated value, as the accounts don’t provide a breakdown of the fixed assets. The total fixed assets had been depreciated down to around £8m, but does that include the training ground? A sale price of £57m could well therefore result in a gain of £49m to offset against their losses, but that may still not yet be enough to see them fall within the maximum permitted FFP loss of £39m in 3 seasons. RE: Villa Park sold.... - SW4Baggie - 07-01-2019 (07-01-2019, 04:09 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:(06-29-2019, 10:02 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:(06-29-2019, 02:07 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Pretty sure any deals like this have to see rent paid at market value under FFFP (not that it’s worth the paper it’s written on) - in Villa’s case a few million a year in rent won’t be too much of an issue, but Derby having to pay market value on an £80m stadium in the Champ may have a few other challenges. Given the EFL have allegedly given them an all clear on finances, I'd imagine the £56m valuation of VP was exactly the amount required to fall in line with the £39m allowed losses. I know it's a lot more complex than this, but given third party forecasts last season anticipated a £40m gap to fill, they then brought in Kalinic (£5m), Abraham (£7m), McGinn (£3m), El Ghazi (£2m), Nyyland (£2m), Mings (£2m), Bolasie (£2m) plus a couple of improved contracts and deals for Carroll, Tuazembe and Haus is about £25m... offset that with the £10m received for Gollini, Gil and Amavi, and you've got £15m to find.... RE: Villa Park sold.... - fuzzbox - 07-01-2019 (07-01-2019, 04:09 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Market value, both to sell and to rent, is what an independent third parry would pay. A professional real estate valuer will come up with both figures. As long as Villa can come up with a valuation from an independent valuer which supports the figures used, then it is hard for those figures to be challenged. The higher the sale figure, the higher the rent figure, as it is based on capital yield. A sale value of £57m at a yield of around 4% equates to rent of around £2.3m a year."A professional real estate valuer will come up with both figures." Ask 3 valuer's to come up with a figure and even without any pressure or promise, they'll come up with three different figures. They may well be close, but as I said, even a 10% difference is £6m. As for rental agreements, we've already seen in retail, whether there's a contract or not, rent can be negotiated right down. I would imagine that's very possible if you're renting to effectively yourself and therefore a very sympathetic landlord. There's plenty of precedent, so it would all be 'market rate' But, ultimately, this is all very hypothetical. The league has obviously capitulated and has no interest in pursuing this. The next step in the complete surrender will be to appease Middlesborough's Gibson by helping him to spend what he wants. Personally, I think using agents to 'lease' players is far more sinister as the money just gets lost for good. I can see agents holding billions of pounds of player assets and, if we're not careful, 'controlling' some of our clubs, all because of an artificial system of regulations, which anybody can see was never going to work. RE: Villa Park sold.... - Kit Kat Chunky - 07-01-2019 Agree with you both. The only caution with the valuation is that the Surveyor will have is Professional Indemnity Insurance on the line, so the figures will have to be justifiable, not just a number that suits Villa. RE: Villa Park sold.... - SW4Baggie - 07-01-2019 (07-01-2019, 12:01 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Agree with you both. I actually thing the figure seems a little low when you consider Derby sold their out of town plot for £80m vs Villa’s fairly central location! Then again I guess the fact it’s a newer asset and it probably has a much larger amount of space around it with carparks and the retail park. RE: Villa Park sold.... - fuzzbox - 07-01-2019 (07-01-2019, 12:01 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Agree with you both. Absolutely, that's why I added the "...even without any pressure or promise". But to be honest, I think the whole thing is fairly irrelevant now. I suspect everybody, including the league, is just playing lip service. Nobody that matters is interested in proving it wrong. I suspect as long as you don't take the piss and make the league look bad, they would rather not get involved. They're certainly getting no backing from the FA. We'll know for sure depending on what Steve Gibson does next. I'm betting he'll go silent, once various deals and 'understandings' get made. RE: Villa Park sold.... - Statto - 07-01-2019 Price of football Twitter account has highlighted where the specific clause about sale of assets was removed at the last FFP rules update. They've swerved it alright, as we always expected they would. |