RE: The Current Squad Thread - TETLEY74 - 07-09-2019
(07-09-2019, 07:37 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-09-2019, 06:20 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Is this the exciting ‘project’ I’ve heard so much about?
Is this the start of the exciting ‘project’ I’ve heard so much about?
The last time we had similar amounts of players to replace we got Gamboa, Poco, Davidson and Samaras etc.
Yeah but if that hadn't have happened you wouldn't be able to mention them in 2 out of every 5 posts you make.......... 
(07-09-2019, 05:51 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I doubt Hegazi & Rondon will make Benidorm after their international duties, so rolling-subsgate is back. This time with the kids included.
Before anyone else leaves we realistically need 10 new players - is it feasible to mount a play off challenge with such a big change of the playing squad?
Said the same yesterday. I just can't see it. It's a monumental ask bringing in so many and asking them all to gel and buy into whatever the managers style/philosphy/project/bollocks is. Not forgetting some will be coming from abroad with families in tow and having to settle in a new country etc.
Also we are not just losing numbers. We are losing/have lost our quality players and 75% of our goals so far.
Massive task. If we get a play off place I'd say he's had a great season. That's looking at it today.
Let's see who comes in. We might make a load of marquee signings/loans and all will look rosier but from where we stand this evening it's going to take some effort. More so from Dowling/Jenkins. And that's what really worries me.
What worries me is given our track record of how long we fanny about to get transfers over the line I just can't see us getting anywhere near the quanty or quality of players we need, and the deeper we get into the transfer window the more chance there is of the board reverting to type and going into panic mode and signing the usual freebies out of contract and cheap loan players who are over the hill or just plain useless and who will hardly kick a ball in anger for the club, as things stand at this moment things look decidedly bleak let's hope Big Slave can pull a few rabbits out of the hat and work some magic, or the board surpass themselves and bring in 6 or 7 quality players but I won't be holding my breath on the latter. We've been here before and those of us of a certain age can recognise the spectre of 86 beginning to loom large in the back ground, we are at a pivotal point in our clubs history we fugg this up now and it could well set us back decades from which we may well never recover! This is just my opinion based on Albions previous history and our ability to shoot ourselves in both feet at the same time over and over again.
RE: The Current Squad Thread - Kit Kat Chunky - 07-09-2019
(07-09-2019, 08:13 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (07-09-2019, 07:37 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-09-2019, 06:20 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Is this the exciting ‘project’ I’ve heard so much about?
Is this the start of the exciting ‘project’ I’ve heard so much about?
The last time we had similar amounts of players to replace we got Gamboa, Poco, Davidson and Samaras etc.
Yeah but if that hadn't have happened you wouldn't be able to mention them in 2 out of every 5 posts you make.......... 
(07-09-2019, 05:51 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I doubt Hegazi & Rondon will make Benidorm after their international duties, so rolling-subsgate is back. This time with the kids included.
Before anyone else leaves we realistically need 10 new players - is it feasible to mount a play off challenge with such a big change of the playing squad?
Said the same yesterday. I just can't see it. It's a monumental ask bringing in so many and asking them all to gel and buy into whatever the managers style/philosphy/project/bollocks is. Not forgetting some will be coming from abroad with families in tow and having to settle in a new country etc.
Also we are not just losing numbers. We are losing/have lost our quality players and 75% of our goals so far.
Massive task. If we get a play off place I'd say he's had a great season. That's looking at it today.
Let's see who comes in. We might make a load of marquee signings/loans and all will look rosier but from where we stand this evening it's going to take some effort. More so from Dowling/Jenkins. And that's what really worries me.
What worries me is given our track record of how long we fanny about to get transfers over the line I just can't see us getting anywhere near the quanty or quality of players we need, and the deeper we get into the transfer window the more chance there is of the board reverting to type and going into panic mode and signing the usual freebies out of contract and cheap loan players who are over the hill or just plain useless and who will hardly kick a ball in anger for the club, as things stand at this moment things look decidedly bleak let's hope Big Slave can pull a few rabbits out of the hat and work some magic, or the board surpass themselves and bring in 6 or 7 quality players but I won't be holding my breath on the latter. We've been here before and those of us of a certain age can recognise the spectre of 86 beginning to loom large in the back ground, we are at a pivotal point in our clubs history we fugg this up now and it could well set us back decades from which we may well never recover! This is just my opinion based on Albions previous history and our ability to shoot ourselves in both feet at the same time over and over again.
Sadly, there is no evidence from our new ownership structure to contradict you.
RE: The Current Squad Thread - TETLEY74 - 07-09-2019
(07-09-2019, 08:14 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (07-09-2019, 08:13 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (07-09-2019, 07:37 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-09-2019, 06:20 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Is this the exciting ‘project’ I’ve heard so much about?
Is this the start of the exciting ‘project’ I’ve heard so much about?
The last time we had similar amounts of players to replace we got Gamboa, Poco, Davidson and Samaras etc.
Yeah but if that hadn't have happened you wouldn't be able to mention them in 2 out of every 5 posts you make.......... 
(07-09-2019, 05:51 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I doubt Hegazi & Rondon will make Benidorm after their international duties, so rolling-subsgate is back. This time with the kids included.
Before anyone else leaves we realistically need 10 new players - is it feasible to mount a play off challenge with such a big change of the playing squad?
Said the same yesterday. I just can't see it. It's a monumental ask bringing in so many and asking them all to gel and buy into whatever the managers style/philosphy/project/bollocks is. Not forgetting some will be coming from abroad with families in tow and having to settle in a new country etc.
Also we are not just losing numbers. We are losing/have lost our quality players and 75% of our goals so far.
Massive task. If we get a play off place I'd say he's had a great season. That's looking at it today.
Let's see who comes in. We might make a load of marquee signings/loans and all will look rosier but from where we stand this evening it's going to take some effort. More so from Dowling/Jenkins. And that's what really worries me.
What worries me is given our track record of how long we fanny about to get transfers over the line I just can't see us getting anywhere near the quanty or quality of players we need, and the deeper we get into the transfer window the more chance there is of the board reverting to type and going into panic mode and signing the usual freebies out of contract and cheap loan players who are over the hill or just plain useless and who will hardly kick a ball in anger for the club, as things stand at this moment things look decidedly bleak let's hope Big Slave can pull a few rabbits out of the hat and work some magic, or the board surpass themselves and bring in 6 or 7 quality players but I won't be holding my breath on the latter. We've been here before and those of us of a certain age can recognise the spectre of 86 beginning to loom large in the back ground, we are at a pivotal point in our clubs history we fugg this up now and it could well set us back decades from which we may well never recover! This is just my opinion based on Albions previous history and our ability to shoot ourselves in both feet at the same time over and over again.
Sadly, there is no evidence from our new ownership structure to contradict you. Sadly that's what worries me the most KK
RE: The Current Squad Thread - Derek Hardballs - 07-09-2019
It was quite important that we went up last season.
RE: The Current Squad Thread - Kit Kat Chunky - 07-09-2019
(07-09-2019, 08:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It was quite important that we went up last season.
You might be stating the bleedin' obvious, Dek, but it is very true. That's why we needed a solid experienced manager last year, rather than an up and coming one.
RE: The Current Squad Thread - Derek Hardballs - 07-09-2019
(07-09-2019, 08:25 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (07-09-2019, 08:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It was quite important that we went up last season.
You might be stating the bleedin' obvious, Dek, but it is very true. That's why we needed a solid experienced manager last year, rather than an up and coming one.
Just going to tap my point in the net ; Ironically the one thing that Jenkins and the board haven’t had much criticism of is the main mistake they made last year.
RE: The Current Squad Thread - Shabby Russian - 07-09-2019
Just to counter balance the general doom and gloom that is all around us.
The last time we faced 2 consecutive seasons in the Championship, there was a very similar feel. In the first season we relied on a squad who had by and large been the one who saw us relegated in a rather dismal fashion. When that squad, unsurprisingly failed to get us promoted, it broke up, spectacularly. From memory 7 of the players who played in the play off final against Derby were not at the club when the next season kicked off.
We brought in a large number of players in that window, in the end more than we needed, and not everyone was a success. But nevertheless we did get promoted.
That's not to say that history will necessarily repeat itself, but just to point out that at this level a huge turnover in the playing staff can be achieved successfully.
Maybe this time the difference is the senior management at the club and the determination for success of the owner.
RE: The Current Squad Thread - MassDebater - 07-09-2019
(07-09-2019, 08:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Just to counter balance the general doom and gloom that is all around us.
The last time we faced 2 consecutive seasons in the Championship, there was a very similar feel. In the first season we relied on a squad who had by and large been the one who saw us relegated in a rather dismal fashion. When that squad, unsurprisingly failed to get us promoted, it broke up, spectacularly. From memory 7 of the players who played in the play off final against Derby were not at the club when the next season kicked off.
We brought in a large number of players in that window, in the end more than we needed, and not everyone was a success. But nevertheless we did get promoted.
That's not to say that history will necessarily repeat itself, but just to point out that at this level a huge turnover in the playing staff can be achieved successfully.
Maybe this time the difference is the senior management at the club and the determination for success of the owner.
Pretty sure we'd had more come in, back then, with only 3 weeks to the start of the season though?
RE: The Current Squad Thread - bigdavestackle - 07-09-2019
(07-09-2019, 09:06 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-09-2019, 08:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Just to counter balance the general doom and gloom that is all around us.
The last time we faced 2 consecutive seasons in the Championship, there was a very similar feel. In the first season we relied on a squad who had by and large been the one who saw us relegated in a rather dismal fashion. When that squad, unsurprisingly failed to get us promoted, it broke up, spectacularly. From memory 7 of the players who played in the play off final against Derby were not at the club when the next season kicked off.
We brought in a large number of players in that window, in the end more than we needed, and not everyone was a success. But nevertheless we did get promoted.
That's not to say that history will necessarily repeat itself, but just to point out that at this level a huge turnover in the playing staff can be achieved successfully.
Maybe this time the difference is the senior management at the club and the determination for success of the owner.
Pretty sure we'd had more come in, back then, with only 3 weeks to the start of the season though?
We’d also obtained good market value for Koumas, Kamara, McShane (!) et al and had a manager who’d been at the club and overseen the squad for many months, not a few weeks.
RE: The Current Squad Thread - Derek Hardballs - 07-10-2019
(07-09-2019, 09:11 PM)bigdavestackle Wrote: (07-09-2019, 09:06 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-09-2019, 08:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Just to counter balance the general doom and gloom that is all around us.
The last time we faced 2 consecutive seasons in the Championship, there was a very similar feel. In the first season we relied on a squad who had by and large been the one who saw us relegated in a rather dismal fashion. When that squad, unsurprisingly failed to get us promoted, it broke up, spectacularly. From memory 7 of the players who played in the play off final against Derby were not at the club when the next season kicked off.
We brought in a large number of players in that window, in the end more than we needed, and not everyone was a success. But nevertheless we did get promoted.
That's not to say that history will necessarily repeat itself, but just to point out that at this level a huge turnover in the playing staff can be achieved successfully.
Maybe this time the difference is the senior management at the club and the determination for success of the owner.
Pretty sure we'd had more come in, back then, with only 3 weeks to the start of the season though?
We’d also obtained good market value for Koumas, Kamara, McShane (!) et al and had a manager who’d been at the club and overseen the squad for many months, not a few weeks.
It was also the poorest Championship in terms of quality I can remember.
|