WBAUnofficial
Style of Play next season - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Style of Play next season (/showthread.php?tid=4807)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Style of Play next season - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-28-2019

(05-28-2019, 03:12 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 02:59 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 02:53 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 02:47 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I don't think anyone cares about "the style" of play, as long as we show an balance between adventure and solidity that brings results.

We have the financial advantages, youth and core group of decent players for this league that should allow us to carry an attacking threat whilst also being able to do the basics of defending.

Unfortunately we've gone from attritional bollocks to needless pissing about, when actually 90% of managers play something far more in the middle.

(05-28-2019, 02:45 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Stop conceding ridiculous goals in pursuit of a style of football we don't have the resources to properly implement. That would do. Rankles big time that if we had of conceded ten fewer goals last season we would have probably won the league.

If we'd scored 10 more we probably would have too.........

Consider the amount of goals we gifted trying to play out. Scoring goals was never the issue.

It seemed a pretty big problem against Blackburn, Ipswich, Brentford, Sheff Wed, Bolton at home... We managed 5 goals in 5 games, and 5 more and we'd have been up....

The Ipswich, Brentford, Sheffield, Wednesday and the Bolton winner were entirely preventable with some proper defending. How many games did we win 1-0 under Megson when we went up?

I presume if you were in a sinking boat you'd not try and fix the leak you'd just get more buckets and bail faster.

We can bail quick enough. Just ask Rondon, Chadwank, Foster, Evans, Nyom  and the loanees from 2018.


RE: Style of Play next season - Wotty - 05-28-2019

Obviously results are what it’s about.

What I never ever want again is to come up against ‘lesser’ teams like Reading were in the FA cup or against Stoke with 9 men and the manager to have not one single fucking clue as to how to instruct the team to take the game to them and attack even if they did work ‘aard.

Never ever again. 

Apart from that , crack on  Smile


RE: Style of Play next season - Birdman1811 - 05-28-2019

Goals win games, defense wins titles.

Paraphrasing Sir Alex Ferguson there, but it's true, Man City spent most of their riches on defenders, Liverpool look far more like a World Class team because of Van Dijk for a seemingly insane 75 million. Man Utd's biggest issue is their defense is barely Premiership standard and De Gea is finally shell shocked bailing it out all the time.

If you are scoring more than a goal a game on average, often more, yet not winning games, it's the defense that's broken, not the attack. We scored plenty last season, but couldn't defend for shit. We had the players, the coaches failed badly with them.


RE: Style of Play next season - Derek Hardballs - 05-28-2019

(05-28-2019, 07:24 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 02:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Whatever style suits the players we have. There is no need for the worst of Pulis displays, but unless we have an amazing overhaul, we can't be a possession dominating, attacking team either.

You are probably right but plenty were saying we had the best squad in the champ (and some that we should piss the league) yet at the same time suggested we cant take champ teams on football wise and attack them. If we have the better squad (or more importantly better first 11) we can and should at this level and should not be afraid to. We were as successful as at any point this season early on when we scored lots despite conceding sloppy goals. It was when the goals stopped flowing we stalled.

But I think the limitations of the squad were clearer to those who correctly predicted a play off spot, and the play off zone was where we spent most of the season - so Moore and Shan did as well as they could - our players in the end  could not dominate so called lesser teams consistently enough to stay in the top 2.

We still have a squad that can be up there though and we were not that far off points wise at the end of the season - so I would like to think we will get a coach who believes that squad is good enough to dominate games and attack championship teams- and convince the players they are. That doesn't mean not being tidy at the back and improving with less risk taking - but no excuse for us at this level if genuine contenders with a good squad of near prem quality players not to be attack minded.

The fear is some of those players are not really as good as they or we think - else they need an attitude transplant.

(05-28-2019, 07:26 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Goals win games, defense wins titles.

Paraphrasing Sir Alex Ferguson there, but it's true, Man City spent most of their riches on defenders, Liverpool look far more like a World Class team because of Van Dijk for a seemingly insane 75 million. Man Utd's biggest issue is their defense is barely Premiership standard and De Gea is finally shell shocked bailing it out all the time.

If you are scoring more than a goal a game on average, often more, yet not winning games, it's the defense that's broken, not the attack. We scored plenty last season, but couldn't defend for shit. We had the players, the coaches failed badly with them.

Our squad was easily good enough to go up it was poorly managed in terms of trying to ask players to do things they were not confortable doing. We have / had good players that could defend so play to their strengths not weaknesses. We had players who could deliver fantastic balls from set pieces so play them and work hard on set pieces, we had players that were good on the counter attack so play on the counter rather than try and dominate possession. 

Would Man City have been successful playing direct long ball? I doubt it. Would Leicester have won the league going toe to to with the opposition playing open possession football? 

Playing to the strengths of a team is what matters, we didn’t which is why we failed to go up and their are plenty of ways to play just be the very best at the style you have the players to play.


RE: Style of Play next season - Birdman1811 - 05-28-2019

(05-28-2019, 07:36 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 07:26 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Goals win games, defense wins titles.

Paraphrasing Sir Alex Ferguson there, but it's true, Man City spent most of their riches on defenders, Liverpool look far more like a World Class team because of Van Dijk for a seemingly insane 75 million. Man Utd's biggest issue is their defense is barely Premiership standard and De Gea is finally shell shocked bailing it out all the time.

If you are scoring more than a goal a game on average, often more, yet not winning games, it's the defense that's broken, not the attack. We scored plenty last season, but couldn't defend for shit. We had the players, the coaches failed badly with them.

True re Utd under Ferguson and Man City and Liverpool in defence - but that doesn't mean their style of play isnt to attack and dominate weaker teams. If we truly have better players and a better squad in the league we are in, then we should look to this example of the teams you mention. It requires the players to believe in it if course.

You can be attacking without dominating possession, still nothing better than swift, precise counter attacking football to me, possession based football requires ridiculously deep pockets.

No need to play like Pulis, but nothing wrong with the likes of Hughton for example. No one moaned under Clarke when he had it pretty much perfected or Leicester under Ranierir as they won the league.


RE: Style of Play next season - Remi_Moses - 05-28-2019

(05-28-2019, 07:26 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Goals win games, defense wins titles.

Paraphrasing Sir Alex Ferguson there, but it's true, Man City spent most of their riches on defenders, Liverpool look far more like a World Class team because of Van Dijk for a seemingly insane 75 million. Man Utd's biggest issue is their defense is barely Premiership standard and De Gea is finally shell shocked bailing it out all the time.

If you are scoring more than a goal a game on average, often more, yet not winning games, it's the defense that's broken, not the attack. We scored plenty last season, but couldn't defend for shit. We had the players, the coaches failed badly with them.

That was the biggest issue by a country mile, short term our future will be in the hands of our next manager.
Long term it sits with the senior mgt and owner - they will ultimately decide if go up or down.


RE: Style of Play next season - baggie93 - 05-28-2019

Over the last 2/3 seasons I've personally got fed up of us struggling with basics. I'd like to see us able to pass it a bit.. Control a ball well.... And certainly pace in the team. Apart from that, some football but nowt wrong with a bit of directness either.


RE: Style of Play next season - Derek Hardballs - 05-28-2019

(05-28-2019, 08:07 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote: Its a fallacious argument to me to suggest we had the best squad in the championships, but it was limited to 'playing to its strengths' and cant dominate a game and could only really play counter attack. This approach came up short against some of the teams above and around us later in the season, and if our players/squad was better than the rest, it should have been able to do more.

The argument is sound. You wouldn’t get the best out of Man City’s squad asking them to play direct / long ball football, you wouldn’t get the best out the title winning Leicester team playing open, possession based football. If a squad has been built to play one way then play that way.


RE: Style of Play next season - Remi_Moses - 05-28-2019

(05-28-2019, 08:07 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote: Its a fallacious argument to me to suggest we had the best squad in the championships, but it was limited to 'playing to its strengths' and cant dominate a game and could only really play counter attack. This approach came up short against some of the teams above and around us later in the season, and if our players/squad was better than the rest, it should have been able to do more.

We were lacking a some areas - You can have the best ingredients, but to have a chance the chef must know how to mix them.


RE: Style of Play next season - Shabby Russian - 05-28-2019

To be honest when you consider we had Phillips, Barnes Gayle and Rodriguez in our starting line up, I think we did play to our strengths in the first half of the season. A point of view given some credence that in the first half of the season we beat all 3 teams who eventually finished above us.