WBAUnofficial
Boro taking Derby to court - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Boro taking Derby to court (/showthread.php?tid=4699)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - Squid - 05-25-2019

(05-25-2019, 01:47 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-24-2019, 10:32 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-24-2019, 09:30 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I hope Derby go up - and Boro still take them to court. This might just give FFP it's teeth.

I live in hope.

Fair fucks to Gibson for making a stand. I wonder why he's chosen Derby over Villa? I'd have assumed Villa were up to far more mischief personally.

Either way the fact that they have both made the final is gutting but if highlights FFP more now maybe it's a good thing.

I'd like to think other clubs might throw their support behind Boro on this.
You'd like to think so but didn't Gibson call a meeting of all Champo clubs and not get much support? Any way, I reckon Christian Purslow appears to have Villa off scot free and assisted to the play off final. FFS, they even escaped the "failure to control their players" charge after the 22 man riot at Leeds. They have more get out of jail free cards than a monopoly set.



As someone else put it:

If Gibson wins, it brings his rivals down a peg or two.

If he loses, then it shows FFP to be utterly toothless and he can start ignoring it.

Win-win.


That he's gone after Derby is intriguing. It does seem a forever conclusion that Villa will be getting promoted. It's all a bit murky, especially not having VAR.


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - billybassett - 05-25-2019

(05-25-2019, 01:53 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 01:47 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(05-24-2019, 10:32 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-24-2019, 09:30 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I hope Derby go up - and Boro still take them to court. This might just give FFP it's teeth.

I live in hope.

Fair fucks to Gibson for making a stand. I wonder why he's chosen Derby over Villa? I'd have assumed Villa were up to far more mischief personally.

Either way the fact that they have both made the final is gutting but if highlights FFP more now maybe it's a good thing.

I'd like to think other clubs might throw their support behind Boro on this.
You'd like to think so but didn't Gibson call a meeting of all Champo clubs and not get much support? Any way, I reckon Christian Purslow appears to have Villa off scot free and assisted to the play off final. FFS, they even escaped the "failure to control their players" charge after the 22 man riot at Leeds. They have more get out of jail free cards than a monopoly set.



As someone else put it:

If Gibson wins, it brings his rivals down a peg or two.

If he loses, then it shows FFP to be utterly toothless and he can start ignoring it.

Win-win.


That he's gone after Derby is intriguing. It does seem a forever conclusion that Villa will be getting promoted. It's all a bit murky, especially not having VAR.

The thing about Villa and Derby though is there's an equal chance they'll be straight back down if they don't spend serious millions, I mean Villa's squad is barer than a Brazillian model's bottom half, so it could be a stay of execution only


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-25-2019

But they achieve Prem income, parachutes and an increased FFP allowance. Promotion is crucial for them


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - Begley - 05-25-2019

What Derby did may not be in the spirit of the game but it is not against the rules. Villa published their accounts and showed that they are about 1m away from the P&S threshold. The last last 10 home games or so have had 40k+ at each game, that's about 1m revenue per match day. Gibson is on a PR push to try and justify why Boro failed to get into the playoffs. If they had not gone on a 6 game losing run at close season then they could be in the final on Monday and Gibson would keep his mouth shut


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-25-2019

(05-25-2019, 08:52 PM)Begley Wrote: What Derby did may not be in the spirit of the game but it is not against the rules. Villa published their accounts and showed that they are about 1m away from the P&S threshold. The last last 10 home games or so have had 40k+ at each game, that's about 1m revenue per match day. Gibson is on a PR push to try and justify why Boro failed to get into the playoffs. If they had not gone on a 6 game losing run at close season then they could be in the final on Monday and Gibson would keep his mouth shut

As I understand it, Villa haven't published the holding company accounts yet. That is where some people think the bodies are buried. 

Don't forget the published accounts are for season ending 2018, and since then they have received a massive dip in income through reduced parachutes, and have no more players (other than the obvious) to sell.


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - Begley - 05-25-2019

(05-25-2019, 09:04 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 08:52 PM)Begley Wrote: What Derby did may not be in the spirit of the game but it is not against the rules. Villa published their accounts and showed that they are about 1m away from the P&S threshold. The last last 10 home games or so have had 40k+ at each game, that's about 1m revenue per match day. Gibson is on a PR push to try and justify why Boro failed to get into the playoffs. If they had not gone on a 6 game losing run at close season then they could be in the final on Monday and Gibson would keep his mouth shut

As I understand it, Villa haven't published the holding company accounts yet. That is where some people think the bodies are buried. 

Don't forget the published accounts are for season ending 2018, and since then they have received a massive dip in income through reduced parachutes, and have no more players (other than the obvious) to sell.
But all clubs submit accounts to the EFL in March with actuals up to March and an estimate for March to May, it is said that these are within 1m of the threshold. I don't believe Villa has any issue with P&S this season, if they lose on Monday they will struggle next year without selling something, whether that is Grealish or Villa Park is anyones guess.


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-25-2019

(05-25-2019, 09:10 PM)Begley Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 09:04 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 08:52 PM)Begley Wrote: What Derby did may not be in the spirit of the game but it is not against the rules. Villa published their accounts and showed that they are about 1m away from the P&S threshold. The last last 10 home games or so have had 40k+ at each game, that's about 1m revenue per match day. Gibson is on a PR push to try and justify why Boro failed to get into the playoffs. If they had not gone on a 6 game losing run at close season then they could be in the final on Monday and Gibson would keep his mouth shut

As I understand it, Villa haven't published the holding company accounts yet. That is where some people think the bodies are buried. 

Don't forget the published accounts are for season ending 2018, and since then they have received a massive dip in income through reduced parachutes, and have no more players (other than the obvious) to sell.
But all clubs submit accounts to the EFL in March with actuals up to March and an estimate for March to May, it is said that these are within 1m of the threshold. I don't believe Villa has any issue with P&S this season, if they lose on Monday they will struggle next year without selling something, whether that is Grealish or Villa Park is anyones guess.

People like Swiss Ramble reckon they are £25M short.

I posted my own analysis last year, and came to similar conclusions. I also said in March 2018 they were bust to buggery - which was reposted on Seal Talk. Oh how they laughed at the "experts" from Sandwell Town, who knew nothing........

They have a wage bill of over £60M, income of only £40M this year, and accumulated loses of approaching £100M. The best they can hope for is a soft embargo, similar to the type that was placed on Sheff Weds last season, whilst they sell off the silver to balance the books.

The only other way out is promotion. Whilst in theory the EFL can still fine them if they are promoted, we all know it won't happen. A fine is immaterial to them. Hard sanctions are a bigger deterrent.


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - Begley - 05-25-2019

(05-25-2019, 09:38 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 09:10 PM)Begley Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 09:04 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 08:52 PM)Begley Wrote: What Derby did may not be in the spirit of the game but it is not against the rules. Villa published their accounts and showed that they are about 1m away from the P&S threshold. The last last 10 home games or so have had 40k+ at each game, that's about 1m revenue per match day. Gibson is on a PR push to try and justify why Boro failed to get into the playoffs. If they had not gone on a 6 game losing run at close season then they could be in the final on Monday and Gibson would keep his mouth shut

As I understand it, Villa haven't published the holding company accounts yet. That is where some people think the bodies are buried. 

Don't forget the published accounts are for season ending 2018, and since then they have received a massive dip in income through reduced parachutes, and have no more players (other than the obvious) to sell.
But all clubs submit accounts to the EFL in March with actuals up to March and an estimate for March to May, it is said that these are within 1m of the threshold. I don't believe Villa has any issue with P&S this season, if they lose on Monday they will struggle next year without selling something, whether that is Grealish or Villa Park is anyones guess.

People like Swiss Ramble reckon they are £25M short.

I posted my own analysis last year, and came to similar conclusions. I also said in March 2018 they were bust to buggery - which was reposted on Seal Talk. Oh how they laughed at the "experts" from Sandwell Town, who knew nothing........

They have a wage bill of over £60M, income of only £40M this year, and accumulated loses of approaching £100M. The best they can hope for is a soft embargo, similar to the type that was placed on Sheff Weds last season, whilst they sell off the silver to balance the books.

The only other way out is promotion. Whilst in theory the EFL can still fine them if they are promoted, we all know it won't happen. A fine is immaterial to them. Hard sanctions are a bigger deterrent.

The accumulated losses are not all subject to P&S. 79m of the losses are accounting losses due to changing the value of assets and have no impact on P&S. Swiss Ramble think they will be 25m short next season, not this season. They are not even been investigated this season as they are compliant. They have no issue this year and will not have a soft embargo. Next season is a problem if they don't sell something or get promoted


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - Pragmatist - 05-25-2019

(05-25-2019, 10:03 PM)Begley Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 09:38 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 09:10 PM)Begley Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 09:04 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-25-2019, 08:52 PM)Begley Wrote: What Derby did may not be in the spirit of the game but it is not against the rules. Villa published their accounts and showed that they are about 1m away from the P&S threshold. The last last 10 home games or so have had 40k+ at each game, that's about 1m revenue per match day. Gibson is on a PR push to try and justify why Boro failed to get into the playoffs. If they had not gone on a 6 game losing run at close season then they could be in the final on Monday and Gibson would keep his mouth shut

As I understand it, Villa haven't published the holding company accounts yet. That is where some people think the bodies are buried. 

Don't forget the published accounts are for season ending 2018, and since then they have received a massive dip in income through reduced parachutes, and have no more players (other than the obvious) to sell.
But all clubs submit accounts to the EFL in March with actuals up to March and an estimate for March to May, it is said that these are within 1m of the threshold. I don't believe Villa has any issue with P&S this season, if they lose on Monday they will struggle next year without selling something, whether that is Grealish or Villa Park is anyones guess.

People like Swiss Ramble reckon they are £25M short.

I posted my own analysis last year, and came to similar conclusions. I also said in March 2018 they were bust to buggery - which was reposted on Seal Talk. Oh how they laughed at the "experts" from Sandwell Town, who knew nothing........

They have a wage bill of over £60M, income of only £40M this year, and accumulated loses of approaching £100M. The best they can hope for is a soft embargo, similar to the type that was placed on Sheff Weds last season, whilst they sell off the silver to balance the books.

The only other way out is promotion. Whilst in theory the EFL can still fine them if they are promoted, we all know it won't happen. A fine is immaterial to them. Hard sanctions are a bigger deterrent.

The accumulated losses are not all subject to P&S. 79m of the losses are accounting losses due to changing the value of assets and have no impact on P&S. Swiss Ramble think they will be 25m short next season, not this season. They are not even been investigated this season as they are compliant. They have no issue this year and will not have a soft embargo. Next season is a problem if they don't sell something or get promoted

KKC I’m not sure that’s correct.  There’s a lot of confusion between seasons and financial years.  My understanding is that their losses for this season 2018/9 (accounts not due to be published until March 2020) will take them massively over the 3-year rolling losses limit of £39m, and that their only potential way around the problem, if they don’t go up on Monday, is to immediately do a sale and leaseback of Villa Park.  I believe this has already been agreed with the EFL, who have been very closely monitoring them all season.


RE: Boro taking Derby to court - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-26-2019

We are going over old ground here, we have done this to death.

They passed the 2018 test by the skin of their teeth. They would be unable to pass 2019 without asset sales, which as Prag says they will have to make to comply. They should have complied when they filed in March, rather than wait until the end of the season to see if they comply.

I don't think they will sell/leaseback. They down valued Seal Park on relegation, and I think they will revalue it again. There is some debate though whether such adjustments are excluded from P&S or not.

It's interesting that on our last relegation Ebeneezer amortised all of the players contracts, which made a large operating loss to offset against future tax liabilities. You wouldn't do that now!