![]() |
|
So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? (/showthread.php?tid=42622) |
RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - TLMS - 09-02-2026 It’s great we didn’t lose anyone in the last few days of the window. The new signings so far look promising. It’s been a massive change in strategy, recruiting young players with potential and relying on Morrisons coaching team to maximise this. It has been interesting to see how he has evolved the way the team plays since last year and how individual players are benefitting under his direction. I would have preferred a pacy striker, but trust the club that it needs to be the right one. Arguably the hardest and most expensive position to fill, especially with inflated transfer fees. Interested to see how Morrison uses the existing squad to fill this gap and hope injuries don’t expose us. It was mentioned earlier that Dominic Price has done a great job enabling the overhaul, I agree that no way Pearce could have done this on his own. The back room set up looks the best we’ve ever had which must give Morrison the best chance of success. We are in transition this season, I think mid table would be success, but I can’t help feeling we have a good chance of top 8 if we have some luck with injuries. RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - SW4Baggie - 09-02-2026 (09-02-2026, 09:25 AM)TLMS Wrote: It’s great we didn’t lose anyone in the last few days of the window. The new signings so far look promising. Ashworth and Garlick want a word pal. I’d say we finally look to have stabilised our back room and Patel and co. are learning what’s needed at this level, but we are still a decade behind where we were at our peak. RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - PatelsPlatoon - 09-02-2026 The last of the Lai years mixed in with Pulis downing tools screwed us and got us back to a similar mess we hadn't seen since the pre Megson days. However, we have different expectations but we seem to have a plan and some intelligence behind it. It's a world different from the malaise that set in at the club in the 90s. Pretty astonishing that only Townsend, after being away at Ipswich for 2 years, is the only player in the squad who started that defeat v Southampton in the playoffs just over 2 years ago. RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke - 09-02-2026 Kept our better players, which is a novelty when compared to the last few seasons. That's going to be more important than the signings, as we're not sure how they'll pan out. That said, the profile of who has come in looks positive and actually suggests the club is being run by football people with a plan, rather than a marketing fuckwit with a Championship Manager subscription and a DVD of Moneyball. Also like that we haven't panicked and signed a striker for the sake of it, or bussed in the obligatory Villa prick to block our acadamy output. Main negative has been our inability to loan out fringe players. In conclusion, seems positive, but we'll have a better idea come Christmas. No way we should be in another relegation scrap. RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - SW4Baggie - 09-02-2026 I do however reserve the right to claim this was the worst window on record, and that we've signed a load of dross from abroad and sold off our experienced heads when we lose our 2 home games this week. RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - AnelkasBeard - 09-02-2026 (09-02-2026, 10:31 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I do however reserve the right to claim this was the worst window on record, and that we've signed a load of dross from abroad and sold off our experienced heads when we lose our 2 home games this week. I know this is tongue in cheek, but I think it's worth saying on this thread now that the process around how we've recruited has been excellent and shows a clearly identified plan. If come December, 75% of the new signings are cack and wim in the shit, I think it's important to note that the methodology used is pretty universally commended. RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - SW4Baggie - 09-02-2026 (09-02-2026, 10:59 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:(09-02-2026, 10:31 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I do however reserve the right to claim this was the worst window on record, and that we've signed a load of dross from abroad and sold off our experienced heads when we lose our 2 home games this week. Absolutely AB. I have criticised our recruitment consistently since we were relegated for its laziness and predictability. Whoever had the final say on transfers under Val, Bruce and Corberan saddled us with an ageing squad of players sitting on big wages with little motivation. We'd consistently renewed contracts instead of moving players on, and we were seemingly only interested in players that Gourlay knew, or had a direct line to the manager. It was incredibly frustrating watching teams with far fewer resources and standing than us recruit with more purpose and intention. To give Nestor some credit, his game model revolutionised our recruitment, and whilst we got the balance wrong last season, we recruited a very good calibre of individuals and began the process of rebuilding our ageing squad. We have continued this trend in the last 2 windows, and I am cautiously optimistic having seen some of the new recruits that we will continue to uncover gems. I do not expect promotion this season, and I don't expect all of our signings to be a success. However if can continue the trend of around 75% of our permanent signings working, we will be in a good place this year. Players will make mistakes, and I think we will be inconsistent this season - the vast majority of our starting XI this season will be 25 or under, and other than FHM and Townsend, all of our outfield signings this summer were 23 or under. I can't demand we take risks in the transfer market and build something, and then complain when a young side doesn't piss the league on day one. We are at the start of a journey. RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - Sliced - 09-02-2026 3 seasons ago we had 11 players that were 30 and above, including 7 who were regular first teamers. We now have 2, both of which are back ups to the first team. RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - Wednesburybaggie - 09-02-2026 With this being pretty much a brand new team, it will im sure take a while for everything to gel on a consistent basis. Some good days, some bad. What I really hope is that the fans stick with the team on the bad days. Some of our lot are particularly fond of having little patience, and for giving pelters to a scapegoat of their choice. We just need to give JM and Co some time. RE: So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work? - TLMS - 09-03-2026 (09-02-2026, 09:43 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:I agree that Ashworth did a brilliant job as football director and took us ahead of the competition with what he achieved at the club, a time in which we had success, watched some really entertaining positive football and progressed as a club significantly.(09-02-2026, 09:25 AM)TLMS Wrote: It’s great we didn’t lose anyone in the last few days of the window. The new signings so far look promising. Garlick I think is not in the same category, we should have been capable of producing a legacy post Ashworth that continued our progression, we did not. Under Garlick we recruited Pulis and then Pardew, deary me there were some dark days. I appreciate that Pearce agreed that Pulis could take all football related decisions in order for him to stabilise the club when recruited, Pearce wanted to sell and he perceived having a stable club would help him achieve that, it was a short term decision. Garlic was still director of football 2 years into the Lai regime, nothing happened with respect to the back room set up. He’s in a senior role and board director who should have been capable of putting a case together to improve the club and the value of the owners investment, he failed to do this. Under his tenure Garlic did nothing in my view to contribute to the Ashworth legacy. He’s a skilled professional and an excellent business manager who has succeeded in roles at the FA and is now Arsenal Chief Exec but at the Albion he disappointed in the area of football management. Ashworth still excels at this and has become the go to Sporting Director for the monied clubs. So I think in the 13 years post Ashworth we now have the best back room set up to hopefully give Morrison the best chance of success. The increased complexity of coaching, sports science, football analysis and medical services make it vital to ensure this backroom set up is at the forefront of what the club do going forward. It is encouraging that Bilkul have invested in this area and recognise it is not only necessary but good business sense to protect and develop their investment. I think Bilkul identified this area early and put Nestor in charge, he did some good recruitment but became a liability. Dominic Price has a good CV and initial signs are good, it’s an important role to get right. Morrison and the coaching staff have established an identity in the style of play which is another important step. It’s so disappointing we squandered the Ashworth legacy as it would most likely have made us more successful and definitely more cost effective. |