WBAUnofficial
Awkward - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Awkward (/showthread.php?tid=42152)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Awkward - Old Fart - 07-19-2026

Graeme Souness  The Telegraph  18th July

I know what world class looks like and it’s not Rice and Anderson.

I am not a Scotsman with bitter, twisted views, Thomas Tuchel’s tactics were not to blame, England’s players simply bottled it
When it came down to it, there was one inescapable fact about England’s elimination from the World Cup: the players were not good enough.
It is that simple. This is not a Scotsman with bitter and twisted views revelling in the defeat by Argentina, I’m speaking as someone with a lifetime at the highest level in the game. I know what I have seen from England at this tournament and I can say with certainty it wasn’t world class.

I use that phrase for a specific reason. During a Premier League campaign, I hear on a weekly basis that someone is “world class” because they make a good pass or they have become a “legend” after winning one trophy or accumulating 200 appearances by the age of 24.

Please stop this terminology.

The Premier League is the most physically demanding in the world and there is no question it provides excitement – but it isn’t populated by world-class English players and, once again, that was underlined on the biggest stage.

Other than 15 minutes against a Croatia team who had seen better days, England’s football was a difficult watch. They had moments against DR Congo, Mexico and Norway, but when they had to go up a level against Argentina, they couldn’t do it. World class stood in front of them in a navy-blue kit.

Everything I have read and listened to since Wednesday has put Thomas Tuchel front and centre as the man responsible for it all and said his tactics were to blame. I can’t accept that. There was no great change from his tactics against Mexico and Norway, was there?


The rot had set in before Thomas Tuchel’s changes

I’m not absolving Tuchel of blame, by any means, but what really interested me was how a 50-50 game, in which England had dealt admirably with Argentina’s early attempts to break things up, eventually became a game the reigning champions could have won 4-1.

The rot had started before Tuchel made the three substitutions that have got everyone so fired up, almost as soon as Anthony Gordon had put England ahead. I’ve never seen it before – and perhaps a sports psychologist could explain it to me – but how do you lose confidence at 1-0 up?

That is why I look at what was happening on the pitch rather than what Tuchel was doing. He wasn’t the one giving the ball away, he wasn’t the one who told them to stop moving the ball to such an extent England only completed three successful passes in the 18 minutes between the 66th and 84th minutes.

Tuchel wasn’t responsible, either, for Harry Kane not having a touch in Argentina’s area in 90 minutes. They are damning stats. What happened to the belief that should have been fizzing through them when they had such a fantastic opportunity?

You may have heard me say this before but I make no apology for using this story as a reference point. I remember asking Joe Fagan a question early on when I had arrived at Liverpool and, more specifically, the reply – not to mention the look – he gave me in return.

“What?” Joe said. “Listen, son: sort it out yourself.”

I felt like a dummy, like the answer was so obvious yet I couldn’t see it in front of me. But the lesson was in the four words: sort it out yourself. Coaches can help you prepare; they can run you through systems, set-pieces and tactics, but there is always a point when you must take responsibility yourself.

That moment arrived at 1-0 in a World Cup semi-final for England’s players. Whatever way you want to dress it up, the players bottled it and they will have to live with the disappointment. Going one goal up should have made them hard to play against, but the opposite was true.

Perhaps the defeat caused so much debate because their chances of success had been portrayed as good before they went to the United States. But if I take you back to June 7, when I first appeared on these pages, I made it clear I didn’t rate England’s prospects.

I stressed some of the records they had amassed in qualification had come against pub teams, those who would never cause a problem, but the excitement led to rhetoric that didn’t match the reality of England’s actual ability.

I have spoken a lot about Declan Rice and Elliot Anderson during the past month, and the reason my focus is on them is because that is where I played. I’m sure Rice is a good lad and I hear good things about his character, but he isn’t helped when he’s constantly called “world class”.

Elliot Anderson  and Declan Rice cost more than £200m between them but cannot control games at the highest level .

He takes an excellent set-piece and his athleticism is to be admired, but do you ever see him dictate the tempo of a match in the way that Rodri will attempt to do for Spain when they face Argentina on Sunday in New Jersey? The blunt answer is no. He doesn’t have cute, clever balls in his armoury.

Anderson is a young boy and, again, I see no fault in his attitude. But there are limitations to what he can do. I know people will argue back and say Manchester City have just paid £116m for him, but I would counter that and say City don’t always get things right.

Kalvin Phillips, remember, joined City 12 months after having a good tournament at the European Championship in 2021 – playing in the same position as Anderson – but look how things turned out for him. I’m not comparing Phillips and Anderson, I’m saying there must be an understanding of what it takes to reach the top level.

Rodri is the benchmark in world football for a central midfielder. He has a cuteness that few can match, but his first thought is always how he can help his team move forward. He has a picture in his mind and wants to get it to the strikers as efficiently as possible. What an education and opportunity it will be for Anderson to work with Rodri when he walks through the door.

Before they link up, Rodri will be intent on completing his set of medals in the World Cup final. The right sides are in it and what I loved about Argentina is how they switched on Wednesday. They frustrate you when they push and shove as they did in the first 15 minutes against England.

I was surprised, too, at how they reined things in when they were chasing the game. They could have easily turned that it into a red and yellow card fest and started to cause trouble when things were not going their way.

But I said in Tuesday’s column that Argentina has produced the greatest footballers in history, from Alfredo Di Stéfano to Diego Maradona and Lionel Messi, with many others in between. They are the definition of world class. When you think of them, it should keep your language in check.


RE: Awkward - Dumbo - 07-19-2026

(07-19-2026, 07:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: When’s the parade?

It’s not as awkward as completing 5 passes in 25 minutes of football

Should Tommy be Knighted? Given he’s placed this Country better than Sir Gareth ever did in a World Cup? Only Sir Alf has done better, of course.


RE: Awkward - Mullers - 07-19-2026

(07-19-2026, 09:06 AM)Old Fart Wrote: The rot had set in before Thomas Tuchel’s changes

I’m not absolving Tuchel of blame, by any means, but what really interested me was how a 50-50 game, in which England had dealt admirably with Argentina’s early attempts to break things up, eventually became a game the reigning champions could have won 4-1.

The rot had started before Tuchel made the three substitutions that have got everyone so fired up, almost as soon as Anthony Gordon had put England ahead. I’ve never seen it before – and perhaps a sports psychologist could explain it to me – but how do you lose confidence at 1-0 up?

That is why I look at what was happening on the pitch rather than what Tuchel was doing. He wasn’t the one giving the ball away, he wasn’t the one who told them to stop moving the ball to such an extent England only completed three successful passes in the 18 minutes between the 66th and 84th minutes.

Tuchel wasn’t responsible, either, for Harry Kane not having a touch in Argentina’s area in 90 minutes. They are damning stats. What happened to the belief that should have been fizzing through them when they had such a fantastic opportunity?

This is basically where I’m at. I’ve said on another thread - our goal came on 55’, the Gordon sub came on 72’. That’s 17 mins in which the team immediately sat back and let Argentina come at us (save for one half chance where one more pass would have put us two in front). In that situation, Tuchel is the conductor - he can orchestrate as much as he wants, and he did, along with Anthony Barry, urging players forward. But he can’t play the instruments. The team had 17 mins to prove they could play positively. Even after a hydration break, they failed, and Tuchel saw no alternative than to shore up the defence: if we’re going to sit back regardless, we might as well do it with the players best suited to do so. 
Could Tuchel have countered this capitulation? Perhaps. I personally would have preferred to switch to a 4-4-2 by taking Rice/Anderson off, dropping Jude back to sit a bit deeper and putting Rashford/Saka on to better link the midfield with Kane. But who’s to say that would have worked? If Tuchel did that and we lost, I’m convinced the same people calling for him to go because of his actual subs would still do so because of naivety.

I don’t think the manager is innocent in all of this - if we lost because of poor mentality, it’s on Tuchel to try and change that in his preparation for every game. So I think (and hope) he will have learned a lot from this. Let’s be more like what he said after Croatia: if we’re going to lose, let’s at least play the way we want to play.

We came into the tournament as the fourth best team in the world, we leave as the third. It should have been more, but I’m convinced that if we stick with Tuchel and injuries don’t hamper us, we’ll be successful in Euro 2028.


RE: Awkward - Sliced - 07-19-2026

(07-19-2026, 09:29 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(07-19-2026, 07:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: When’s the parade?

It’s not as awkward as completing 5 passes in 25 minutes of football

Should Tommy be Knighted? Given he’s placed this Country better than Sir Gareth ever did in a World Cup? Only Sir Alf has done better, of course.

Definitely. I remember when he was brought in everyone was psyched that we finally had a manager to win the losers friendly after the semis


RE: Awkward - Dumbo - 07-19-2026

(07-19-2026, 12:06 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(07-19-2026, 09:29 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(07-19-2026, 07:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: When’s the parade?

It’s not as awkward as completing 5 passes in 25 minutes of football

Should Tommy be Knighted? Given he’s placed this Country better than Sir Gareth ever did in a World Cup? Only Sir Alf has done better, of course.

Definitely. I remember when he was brought in everyone was psyched that we finally had a manager to win the losers friendly after the semis

Quite right. Something that was beyond Sir Gareth.


RE: Awkward - Birdman1811 - 07-19-2026

(07-19-2026, 10:57 AM)Mullers Wrote:
(07-19-2026, 09:06 AM)Old Fart Wrote: The rot had set in before Thomas Tuchel’s changes

I’m not absolving Tuchel of blame, by any means, but what really interested me was how a 50-50 game, in which England had dealt admirably with Argentina’s early attempts to break things up, eventually became a game the reigning champions could have won 4-1.

The rot had started before Tuchel made the three substitutions that have got everyone so fired up, almost as soon as Anthony Gordon had put England ahead. I’ve never seen it before – and perhaps a sports psychologist could explain it to me – but how do you lose confidence at 1-0 up?

That is why I look at what was happening on the pitch rather than what Tuchel was doing. He wasn’t the one giving the ball away, he wasn’t the one who told them to stop moving the ball to such an extent England only completed three successful passes in the 18 minutes between the 66th and 84th minutes.

Tuchel wasn’t responsible, either, for Harry Kane not having a touch in Argentina’s area in 90 minutes. They are damning stats. What happened to the belief that should have been fizzing through them when they had such a fantastic opportunity?

This is basically where I’m at. I’ve said on another thread - our goal came on 55’, the Gordon sub came on 72’. That’s 17 mins in which the team immediately sat back and let Argentina come at us (save for one half chance where one more pass would have put us two in front). In that situation, Tuchel is the conductor - he can orchestrate as much as he wants, and he did, along with Anthony Barry, urging players forward. But he can’t play the instruments. The team had 17 mins to prove they could play positively. Even after a hydration break, they failed, and Tuchel saw no alternative than to shore up the defence: if we’re going to sit back regardless, we might as well do it with the players best suited to do so. 
Could Tuchel have countered this capitulation? Perhaps. I personally would have preferred to switch to a 4-4-2 by taking Rice/Anderson off, dropping Jude back to sit a bit deeper and putting Rashford/Saka on to better link the midfield with Kane. But who’s to say that would have worked? If Tuchel did that and we lost, I’m convinced the same people calling for him to go because of his actual subs would still do so because of naivety.

I don’t think the manager is innocent in all of this - if we lost because of poor mentality, it’s on Tuchel to try and change that in his preparation for every game. So I think (and hope) he will have learned a lot from this. Let’s be more like what he said after Croatia: if we’re going to lose, let’s at least play the way we want to play.

We came into the tournament as the fourth best team in the world, we leave as the third. It should have been more, but I’m convinced that if we stick with Tuchel and injuries don’t hamper us, we’ll be successful in Euro 2028.

I think that's fair. 

I'll complain about the subs for sure, they were atrocious and lead to us being unable to deal with the increased pressure. However there is definitely a question to be asked why the players at first fell back after scoring? Something Southgate complained tended to happen without his instructions, I don't think that was what Tuchel wanted, maybe he felt nothing would get the players going again. 

If so, we need to fix that mentality, because no manager will get us over the line.


RE: Awkward - Jacko - 07-19-2026

Souness, while more generous about our first half performance pretty much echoing my thoughts.


RE: Awkward - Tom Joad 25 - 07-19-2026

2nd best ever? Based on a meaningless game? Ridiculous to place any relevance on a pointless kick about to see who comes 3rd. I only heard about the result this morning. Total nonsense. He needs to beat Southgate's record in the Euros now he's equalled a WC semi final, then we might be onto something.


RE: Awkward - man in the corner shop - 07-19-2026

(07-19-2026, 06:05 AM)Loanee Wrote: England ranked 4th in the world

We finished 3rd in the tournament after losing  to the team ranked #1 (& holders)

Whilst disappointing Is it bad / a failure?!

I don't see at as a failure. But if you get someone by the short and curlies you dont let them go!


RE: Awkward - Jacko - 07-19-2026

(07-19-2026, 06:18 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(07-19-2026, 06:05 AM)Loanee Wrote: England ranked 4th in the world

We finished 3rd in the tournament after losing  to the team ranked #1 (& holders)

Whilst disappointing Is it bad / a failure?!

I don't see at as a failure. But if you get someone by the short and curlies you dont let them go!

And that's the fallacy. We didn't have them by the short and curlies. We scored on the break against the run of play.