![]() |
|
Gary's Economics - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Gary's Economics (/showthread.php?tid=42041) |
RE: Gary's Economics - Derek Hardballs - 07-10-2026 Waldorf and Statler, simply arguing for the status-quo or even worse, widening inequality. This sums up the state of the two ‘main’ parties. Then they wonder why no one outside of comfortably well off, white collar, middle aged aren’t flocking to the same parties that are promoting more of the same. RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 07-10-2026 SO GIVE US AN ALTERNATIVE!!! RE: Gary's Economics - Jacko - 07-10-2026 (07-10-2026, 03:37 PM)baggy1 Wrote: SO GIVE US AN ALTERNATIVE!!! Communism?
RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-10-2026 (07-10-2026, 03:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Waldorf and Statler, simply arguing for the status-quo or even worse, widening inequality. This sums up the state of the two ‘main’ parties. Then they wonder why no one outside of comfortably well off, white collar, middle aged aren’t flocking to the same parties that are promoting more of the same. I’m not arguing for the status quo - it’s awful. I’m arguing against making a bad situation even worse by taking advice from a man who doesn’t even seem to be able to explain how the single policy he pontificates about endlessly can actually work or make a difference. You’re clearly his target audience as you don’t know either. RE: Gary's Economics - Pipkins - 07-10-2026 We would all agree about inequality & greed However assuming it happened how could he guarantee the money would end up where it should? Take the NHS for example the money has poured in to fix things Yet how much has been skimmed off & gone on stupid stuff? RE: Gary's Economics - tHEgLASSdOORS - 07-10-2026 (07-10-2026, 06:11 PM)Pipkins Wrote: We would all agree about inequality & greed If you saw my old man’s medical cabinet (ocd about having ten of everything) you’d soon know where the budget deficit has gone RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-11-2026 (07-10-2026, 06:11 PM)Pipkins Wrote: We would all agree about inequality & greed I'm not sure we'd agree about inequality. It's hardly changed in a couple of decades despite the common narrative. Gary is not asking for more money for the NHS or Social Care. He's asking for the redistribution of wealth. RE: Gary's Economics - SW4Baggie - 07-13-2026 (07-11-2026, 12:23 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-10-2026, 06:11 PM)Pipkins Wrote: We would all agree about inequality & greed I believe he's looking for a better standard of living across the board through providing an affordable existence for all. RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-13-2026 (07-13-2026, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I believe he's looking for a better standard of living across the board through providing an affordable existence for all. So am I. So is everyone I expect. Gary promotes himself as a "leading inequality economist" yet seems incapable of providing detail on how a 2% tax on wealth over £10 million will provide better standard of living across the board - let alone the behavioural changes it will force on HNWs to maintain returns. He says nothing, nada, njet. The guy is either a simpleton or a fraud. Depending on your view. RE: Gary's Economics - Øssian - 07-13-2026 (07-10-2026, 03:37 PM)baggy1 Wrote: SO GIVE US AN ALTERNATIVE!!! Morning, B1... One of our problems (the UK, that is, not the pair of us!) is that there’s an understandable but unhelpful inclination to be tactically vague when floating arguments for radical reform. It’s unsurprising: there’s a whole machinery of hostile print and broadcast media, ready to go into attack mode the minute that words like redistributive enter the conversation; there’s little in the way of equivalent counterweight. Something Andy Burnham is going to need to have a strategy for dealing with. Just by way of an example, an idea that’s been discussed on here, and at length elsewhere, is a Land Value Tax; presumably one of the attractions being (coastal erosion aside) the immutability and permanence of landholdings. That said, ownership is obviously easier to offshore than the actual acreage itself… As a concept I can see the attractions (including some which go way beyond fiscal - but that’s for another post), but anyone floating the idea of LVT would need to be clear about the mechanisms (valuation, collection, et al) and how they fit into the existing tax framework. That, for me at least, would mean absolute clarity that this is a replacement concept, rather than just another slice on top of existing property taxes. Without that clarity from the outset the idea doesn’t get past first exposure to daylight. It’s not as if existing property taxation - business rates and council tax in particular - aren’t badly in need of overhaul; but be ready for the backlash and have the rebuttals well rehearsed. |