RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-15-2026
I’d say the extent of the issues are deeper than the comparison of graffiti and walls and I genuinely don’t think most adults of the generation on here understand that true extent and complexity of what is going on for that generation. That said, i don’t think this will solve all of the issues. I’d sooner have seen much more work done on working forwards with the truths of what is going on and what’s changed.
It’s a bloody complicated one.
RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - Borin' Baggie - 06-16-2026
(06-15-2026, 06:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-15-2026, 05:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Why? The whole point of this legislation is that it's supposed to stop teenagers accessing things but everyone thinks even with this they'll still be able to access it - exposing themselves to worse harms in the unregulated corners in the process - so it's very pertinent. It's already failing in Australia. Why would you do something that is going to fail?
Teenagers can still smoke, take drugs, have sex and drink underage that doesn’t mean you have to condone it or make it easy to do or in this case access. I’m sure some kids will use a VPN, I’m sure that some will go to the dark web but frankly that’s not a reason to not do anything about platforms that do harm kids and adults alike. SM bosses are simply there to make money, they have no scruples or interest in really keeping their platforms safe, so yes I’m in the majority of parents that do support today’s announcement.
Also mentioning the internet of ten, 15, 20 years ago, like it’s the same as now is a ludicrous argument. AI, Musks Twitter, TikTok, bots spreading political, racist, misogynist and plenty more unsavoury ists is not the same as a tiny and unsophisticated dodgy websites and SM years ago.
Are you seriously that naive to think that the issues of political grooming on the internet is a recent phenomenon? Al Qaeda was using the internet to radicalise people back in 2001 at least. Russia had their troll farms up and running in 2008 and 2009 to sow disinformation over Georgia and Moldova. This isn't new.
And you're not going to stop the kids from bypassing the restrictions. They will bypass it and they will risk exposing themselves to worse websites that don't adhere to British law or risk their private data being hijacked by a dodgy free VPN or proxy service. Seeing as you've decided to bring up the sex and drugs analogy; we teach younger teenagers about sex so when they do have it at whatever age they are aware of what safe sex is at whatever age lest they be left to their own devices and get pregnant and our idiotic prohibition attitude to drugs exposes teenagers to harsher strains of soft drugs while exposing them to dealers pushing harder stuff so the teenagers that want to try soft drugs and do it anyway because they always find a way are a hell of a lot more exposed to worse stuff than they are with drink, can you imagine if teenagers could only get alcohol from rum runners and get pushed to try high proof spirits instead of beer and cider? I'm fed up of people demanding the state use legislation as a blunt instrument completely blind to the second and third order effects all because they're to lazy to be a parent. All the while the government is not being pressured to treat social media sites as publishers and withdraw from using Twitter for it's comms which would be significantly more impactful than this crap.
RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - Derek Hardballs - 06-16-2026
(06-16-2026, 01:47 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-15-2026, 06:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-15-2026, 05:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Why? The whole point of this legislation is that it's supposed to stop teenagers accessing things but everyone thinks even with this they'll still be able to access it - exposing themselves to worse harms in the unregulated corners in the process - so it's very pertinent. It's already failing in Australia. Why would you do something that is going to fail?
Teenagers can still smoke, take drugs, have sex and drink underage that doesn’t mean you have to condone it or make it easy to do or in this case access. I’m sure some kids will use a VPN, I’m sure that some will go to the dark web but frankly that’s not a reason to not do anything about platforms that do harm kids and adults alike. SM bosses are simply there to make money, they have no scruples or interest in really keeping their platforms safe, so yes I’m in the majority of parents that do support today’s announcement.
Also mentioning the internet of ten, 15, 20 years ago, like it’s the same as now is a ludicrous argument. AI, Musks Twitter, TikTok, bots spreading political, racist, misogynist and plenty more unsavoury ists is not the same as a tiny and unsophisticated dodgy websites and SM years ago.
Are you seriously that naive to think that the issues of political grooming on the internet is a recent phenomenon? Al Qaeda was using the internet to radicalise people back in 2001 at least. Russia had their troll farms up and running in 2008 and 2009 to sow disinformation over Georgia and Moldova. This isn't new.
And you're not going to stop the kids from bypassing the restrictions. They will bypass it and they will risk exposing themselves to worse websites that don't adhere to British law or risk their private data being hijacked by a dodgy free VPN or proxy service. Seeing as you've decided to bring up the sex and drugs analogy; we teach younger teenagers about sex so when they do have it at whatever age they are aware of what safe sex is at whatever age lest they be left to their own devices and get pregnant and our idiotic prohibition attitude to drugs exposes teenagers to harsher strains of soft drugs while exposing them to dealers pushing harder stuff so the teenagers that want to try soft drugs and do it anyway because they always find a way are a hell of a lot more exposed to worse stuff than they are with drink, can you imagine if teenagers could only get alcohol from rum runners and get pushed to try high proof spirits instead of beer and cider? I'm fed up of people demanding the state use legislation as a blunt instrument completely blind to the second and third order effects all because they're to lazy to be a parent. All the while the government is not being pressured to treat social media sites as publishers and withdraw from using Twitter for it's comms which would be significantly more impactful than this crap.
I brought up things that under 16yr olds aren’t supposed to do, according to the law. Not every young person goes straight to hard drugs because they aren’t allowed to smoke a spliff, not every kid will go straight to the dark web or unregulated platform because they aren’t allowed on mainstream SM platform. Is it a perfect solution? Clearly not, but that is no excuse for doing nothing at all.
I’m not a big fan of this government, but the criticism of this, smacks of them not being able to win, don’t do something get criticised, do something get criticised.
As for the argument that the internet is the same environment as it was in the 1990s and 2000s ahem…
RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - Fido - 06-16-2026
(06-16-2026, 07:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-16-2026, 01:47 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-15-2026, 06:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-15-2026, 05:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Why? The whole point of this legislation is that it's supposed to stop teenagers accessing things but everyone thinks even with this they'll still be able to access it - exposing themselves to worse harms in the unregulated corners in the process - so it's very pertinent. It's already failing in Australia. Why would you do something that is going to fail?
Teenagers can still smoke, take drugs, have sex and drink underage that doesn’t mean you have to condone it or make it easy to do or in this case access. I’m sure some kids will use a VPN, I’m sure that some will go to the dark web but frankly that’s not a reason to not do anything about platforms that do harm kids and adults alike. SM bosses are simply there to make money, they have no scruples or interest in really keeping their platforms safe, so yes I’m in the majority of parents that do support today’s announcement.
Also mentioning the internet of ten, 15, 20 years ago, like it’s the same as now is a ludicrous argument. AI, Musks Twitter, TikTok, bots spreading political, racist, misogynist and plenty more unsavoury ists is not the same as a tiny and unsophisticated dodgy websites and SM years ago.
Are you seriously that naive to think that the issues of political grooming on the internet is a recent phenomenon? Al Qaeda was using the internet to radicalise people back in 2001 at least. Russia had their troll farms up and running in 2008 and 2009 to sow disinformation over Georgia and Moldova. This isn't new.
And you're not going to stop the kids from bypassing the restrictions. They will bypass it and they will risk exposing themselves to worse websites that don't adhere to British law or risk their private data being hijacked by a dodgy free VPN or proxy service. Seeing as you've decided to bring up the sex and drugs analogy; we teach younger teenagers about sex so when they do have it at whatever age they are aware of what safe sex is at whatever age lest they be left to their own devices and get pregnant and our idiotic prohibition attitude to drugs exposes teenagers to harsher strains of soft drugs while exposing them to dealers pushing harder stuff so the teenagers that want to try soft drugs and do it anyway because they always find a way are a hell of a lot more exposed to worse stuff than they are with drink, can you imagine if teenagers could only get alcohol from rum runners and get pushed to try high proof spirits instead of beer and cider? I'm fed up of people demanding the state use legislation as a blunt instrument completely blind to the second and third order effects all because they're to lazy to be a parent. All the while the government is not being pressured to treat social media sites as publishers and withdraw from using Twitter for it's comms which would be significantly more impactful than this crap.
I brought up things that under 16yr olds aren’t supposed to do, according to the law. Not every young person goes straight to hard drugs because they aren’t allowed to smoke a spliff, not every kid will go straight to the dark web or unregulated platform because they aren’t allowed on mainstream SM platform. Is it a perfect solution? Clearly not, but that is no excuse for doing nothing at all.
I’m not a big fan of this government, but the criticism of this, smacks of them not being able to win, don’t do something get criticised, do something get criticised.
As for the argument that the internet is the same environment as it was in the 1990s and 2000s ahem…
<spits tea all over laptop screen>
RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - Derek Hardballs - 06-16-2026
(06-16-2026, 07:41 AM)Fido Wrote: (06-16-2026, 07:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-16-2026, 01:47 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-15-2026, 06:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-15-2026, 05:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Why? The whole point of this legislation is that it's supposed to stop teenagers accessing things but everyone thinks even with this they'll still be able to access it - exposing themselves to worse harms in the unregulated corners in the process - so it's very pertinent. It's already failing in Australia. Why would you do something that is going to fail?
Teenagers can still smoke, take drugs, have sex and drink underage that doesn’t mean you have to condone it or make it easy to do or in this case access. I’m sure some kids will use a VPN, I’m sure that some will go to the dark web but frankly that’s not a reason to not do anything about platforms that do harm kids and adults alike. SM bosses are simply there to make money, they have no scruples or interest in really keeping their platforms safe, so yes I’m in the majority of parents that do support today’s announcement.
Also mentioning the internet of ten, 15, 20 years ago, like it’s the same as now is a ludicrous argument. AI, Musks Twitter, TikTok, bots spreading political, racist, misogynist and plenty more unsavoury ists is not the same as a tiny and unsophisticated dodgy websites and SM years ago.
Are you seriously that naive to think that the issues of political grooming on the internet is a recent phenomenon? Al Qaeda was using the internet to radicalise people back in 2001 at least. Russia had their troll farms up and running in 2008 and 2009 to sow disinformation over Georgia and Moldova. This isn't new.
And you're not going to stop the kids from bypassing the restrictions. They will bypass it and they will risk exposing themselves to worse websites that don't adhere to British law or risk their private data being hijacked by a dodgy free VPN or proxy service. Seeing as you've decided to bring up the sex and drugs analogy; we teach younger teenagers about sex so when they do have it at whatever age they are aware of what safe sex is at whatever age lest they be left to their own devices and get pregnant and our idiotic prohibition attitude to drugs exposes teenagers to harsher strains of soft drugs while exposing them to dealers pushing harder stuff so the teenagers that want to try soft drugs and do it anyway because they always find a way are a hell of a lot more exposed to worse stuff than they are with drink, can you imagine if teenagers could only get alcohol from rum runners and get pushed to try high proof spirits instead of beer and cider? I'm fed up of people demanding the state use legislation as a blunt instrument completely blind to the second and third order effects all because they're to lazy to be a parent. All the while the government is not being pressured to treat social media sites as publishers and withdraw from using Twitter for it's comms which would be significantly more impactful than this crap.
I brought up things that under 16yr olds aren’t supposed to do, according to the law. Not every young person goes straight to hard drugs because they aren’t allowed to smoke a spliff, not every kid will go straight to the dark web or unregulated platform because they aren’t allowed on mainstream SM platform. Is it a perfect solution? Clearly not, but that is no excuse for doing nothing at all.
I’m not a big fan of this government, but the criticism of this, smacks of them not being able to win, don’t do something get criticised, do something get criticised.
As for the argument that the internet is the same environment as it was in the 1990s and 2000s ahem…
<spits tea all over laptop screen>
I see the VPN is working
RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - Borin' Baggie - 06-16-2026
(06-16-2026, 07:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-16-2026, 01:47 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-15-2026, 06:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-15-2026, 05:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Why? The whole point of this legislation is that it's supposed to stop teenagers accessing things but everyone thinks even with this they'll still be able to access it - exposing themselves to worse harms in the unregulated corners in the process - so it's very pertinent. It's already failing in Australia. Why would you do something that is going to fail?
Teenagers can still smoke, take drugs, have sex and drink underage that doesn’t mean you have to condone it or make it easy to do or in this case access. I’m sure some kids will use a VPN, I’m sure that some will go to the dark web but frankly that’s not a reason to not do anything about platforms that do harm kids and adults alike. SM bosses are simply there to make money, they have no scruples or interest in really keeping their platforms safe, so yes I’m in the majority of parents that do support today’s announcement.
Also mentioning the internet of ten, 15, 20 years ago, like it’s the same as now is a ludicrous argument. AI, Musks Twitter, TikTok, bots spreading political, racist, misogynist and plenty more unsavoury ists is not the same as a tiny and unsophisticated dodgy websites and SM years ago.
Are you seriously that naive to think that the issues of political grooming on the internet is a recent phenomenon? Al Qaeda was using the internet to radicalise people back in 2001 at least. Russia had their troll farms up and running in 2008 and 2009 to sow disinformation over Georgia and Moldova. This isn't new.
And you're not going to stop the kids from bypassing the restrictions. They will bypass it and they will risk exposing themselves to worse websites that don't adhere to British law or risk their private data being hijacked by a dodgy free VPN or proxy service. Seeing as you've decided to bring up the sex and drugs analogy; we teach younger teenagers about sex so when they do have it at whatever age they are aware of what safe sex is at whatever age lest they be left to their own devices and get pregnant and our idiotic prohibition attitude to drugs exposes teenagers to harsher strains of soft drugs while exposing them to dealers pushing harder stuff so the teenagers that want to try soft drugs and do it anyway because they always find a way are a hell of a lot more exposed to worse stuff than they are with drink, can you imagine if teenagers could only get alcohol from rum runners and get pushed to try high proof spirits instead of beer and cider? I'm fed up of people demanding the state use legislation as a blunt instrument completely blind to the second and third order effects all because they're to lazy to be a parent. All the while the government is not being pressured to treat social media sites as publishers and withdraw from using Twitter for it's comms which would be significantly more impactful than this crap.
I brought up things that under 16yr olds aren’t supposed to do, according to the law. Not every young person goes straight to hard drugs because they aren’t allowed to smoke a spliff, not every kid will go straight to the dark web or unregulated platform because they aren’t allowed on mainstream SM platform. Is it a perfect solution? Clearly not, but that is no excuse for doing nothing at all.
I’m not a big fan of this government, but the criticism of this, smacks of them not being able to win, don’t do something get criticised, do something get criticised.
As for the argument that the internet is the same environment as it was in the 1990s and 2000s ahem…
The kids that do want to smoke a spliff are pushed onto hard drugs. The kids that will circumvent (a lot of them because this is very easy to circumvent) will be using dodgy free VPNs and proxies that will expose their private data. You need only look at how the Chinese Great Firewall doesn't do anything to see how this is performative nonsense that fails to address the issue and only creates worse issues.
And the argument I made is that the internet was much more of a wild west in the 1990s and 2000s than it is today. You made the argument that grooming online wasn't a thing until recently which is patently false.
RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - Protheroe - 06-16-2026
(06-16-2026, 08:12 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And the argument I made is that the internet was much more of a wild west in the 1990s and 2000s than it is today. You made the argument that grooming online wasn't a thing until recently which is patently false.
That is very true.
RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - Derek Hardballs - 06-16-2026
Erm yeah who can forget kids getting addicted to MySpace, and waiting 30 mins for a blurry JPEG/Gif to download of Razzle porn star, in between negotiating when they could use the computer between phone calls.
I’m not saying you old buggers are talking bollocks, but you’re talking bollocks.
RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - Pipkins - 06-16-2026
Your right about the web being the wild west back in 2000s
No smart phones so a mobile phone was just that
Parents had more control over what the kids saw or could have seen as limited to the front room
RE: Young people opinion on Social Media - Ted Maul - 06-16-2026
Kids like the internet. The internet is fun. Therefore Dekka no likey. Pretty standard really.
In all seriousness, if it prevents one vulnerable child with fuckwit parents being groomed into killing themselves then it's worth it. How you doing this I've no idea.
|