WBAUnofficial
Blair - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Blair (/showthread.php?tid=41662)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Blair - Protheroe - 05-28-2026

Where is he claiming that? I can't see it?

He's against Miliband's headlong rush to net zero which is simply increasing costs for every industry and every individual. It's not just the price of energy, it's in Building Control, it's in massive infrastructure spend, it's in some unproven technologies. We're spending huge amounts we don't have on making zero difference to the climate, whilst the poorest suffer the most - again.


RE: Blair - Borin' Baggie - 05-28-2026

(05-28-2026, 08:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Where is he claiming that? I can't see it?

He's against Miliband's headlong rush to net zero which is simply increasing costs for every industry and every individual. It's not just the price of energy, it's in Building Control, it's in massive infrastructure spend, it's in some unproven technologies. We're spending huge amounts we don't have on making zero difference to the climate, whilst the poorest suffer the most - again.


"We must prioritise cheaper energy and electrification over net zero and use what is left of our North Sea oil and gas resources"

Right there? That's a blatant lie.

The whole point of CP2030 and CP2035 is to stop using the thing that is driving up energy prices (gas prices) that is impacting individuals and businesses, I really do not see what your issue with Milliband is frankly. It is as much a practical outcome on energy security and cost as it is carbon. Using gas from the North Sea basin in the UK will not, categorically, make any difference to addressing energy prices in this country and anyone who says otherwise is talking horseshite. Even Badenoch and Claire Coutinho have admitted that (which makes me despise them even more as they have admitted it won't make a difference but are pushing for it anyway, can you imagine that attitude in a life-or-death situation?). All the issues with policy failings (ignoring infrastructure deficiencies which go back a lot longer) stem from the 2021-2024 government's ineptitude and this government is now trying to push forward with reforms to address that (Renewable Obligation phase-out, decoupling gas prices from electricity) are currently in consultation with OFGEM and DESNZ/Treasury right now (thanks to Milliband) but things that fundamentally alter the market structure for one of the most important sectors in the country take time.

Switzerland and Norway have nearly fully decarbonised electricity grids through hydro and renewables, the electricity affordability there is on par with Serbia. Spain is well over 50% renewable average and electricity prices there are well down. France has had consistently low and stable energy prices with their near fully decarbonised grid for decades thanks to nuclear. Australian energy prices are set to drop up 10% in 26/27 vs 25/26 thanks to BESS, solar and wind. Meanwhile, the two countries most reliant on gas for electricity generation (the UK and Germany) have the highest energy bills, that is not a coincidence, and there is not enough gas in the North Sea basin that the UK can extract that is going to disrupt that regional Eurasian gas price we are tied to in the slightest. If you want the UK to properly utilise North Sea gas to benefit the Exchequer that will only happen if we do not use it.


RE: Blair - Protheroe - 05-28-2026

I don’t think you’re seeing the wood for the trees. Energy transition is just one aspect of net zero. I don’t believe in his essay Blair is referring to simply to energy costs, but the much broader costs of net zero. Let me give you an example - we have an EPC D two up two down. Very soon we won’t be able to let it on a new tenancy unless we bring it up to a C.

All very noble I’m sure, but it’s likely to cost us £11,000. And save the tenant £70 a year. It would make far more sense to both us and tenant to write him a cheque for £100 every Christmas. In all likelihood we’ll sell the property when it next becomes vacant as there’s simply no point in spending 5 figures on a box ticking exercise which achieves nothing else.

I’ve already seen £millions needlessly spent on commercial premises in pursuit of compliance and nothing more. There’s a whole parasitic industry, which pretty much sums up the UKs growth problem over the last decade or so.


RE: Blair - man in the corner shop - 05-28-2026

(05-28-2026, 09:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I don’t think you’re seeing the wood for the trees. Energy transition is just one aspect of net zero. I don’t believe in his essay Blair is referring to simply to energy costs, but the much broader costs of net zero. Let me give you an example - we have an EPC D two up two down. Very soon we won’t be able to let it on a new tenancy unless we bring it up to a C.

All very noble I’m sure, but it’s likely to cost us £11,000. And save the tenant £70 a year. It would make far more sense to both us and tenant to write him a cheque for £100 every Christmas. In all likelihood we’ll sell the property when it next becomes vacant as there’s simply no point in spending 5 figures on a box ticking exercise which achieves nothing else.

I’ve already seen £millions needlessly spent on commercial premises in pursuit of compliance and nothing more. There’s a whole parasitic industry, which pretty much sums up the UKs growth problem over the last decade or so.

Alternatively, pay the £11k 
The gaff will have increased in value by that within a couple of years.


RE: Blair - Protheroe - 05-28-2026

(05-28-2026, 09:46 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(05-28-2026, 09:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I don’t think you’re seeing the wood for the trees. Energy transition is just one aspect of net zero. I don’t believe in his essay Blair is referring to simply to energy costs, but the much broader costs of net zero. Let me give you an example - we have an EPC D two up two down. Very soon we won’t be able to let it on a new tenancy unless we bring it up to a C.

All very noble I’m sure, but it’s likely to cost us £11,000. And save the tenant £70 a year. It would make far more sense to both us and tenant to write him a cheque for £100 every Christmas. In all likelihood we’ll sell the property when it next becomes vacant as there’s simply no point in spending 5 figures on a box ticking exercise which achieves nothing else.

I’ve already seen £millions needlessly spent on commercial premises in pursuit of compliance and nothing more. There’s a whole parasitic industry, which pretty much sums up the UKs growth problem over the last decade or so.

Alternatively, pay the £11k 
The gaff will have increased in value by that within a couple of years.

It's the cost of external insulation and altering the roofline which will is actually more likely to create a damp problem and depress the value of the house. Victorian houses were designed to breath you see. What with me being a surveyor and all. 

People actually voted  for this twattery you know. There's still some in Parliament who believe you can get rid of the Leasehold system too. There's others that think the renters rights Act is good for tenants.


RE: Blair - Borin' Baggie - 05-28-2026

I'm sorry but I really do not get what that's got to do with net zero? If you fully decarbonise the grid and heating then you don't need to worry about EPC ratings from a carbon perspective. That's more due to the deficiencies with infrastructure that prevent electrification, not helped by increased demand while infrastructure upgrades to accommodate said deman lag behind.

I also don't really buy your explanation that Blair is not talking about energy and I think you're being extremely generous because he's talking about using North Sea oil and gas in the same sentence, he's made much longer prose with more sentences in his other points in that essay so if he wanted to separate them he could have. And the UK using North Sea oil and gas from the bit of the basin we can extract from still doesn't help with our competitiveness regardless, the benefit comes from selling it to other countries while taxing it instead of us using it. Not helped by the essay in its 5.7k words not mentioning nuclear once, or saying stuff like "remove those parts of the net-zero agenda which prioritise clean energy over cheaper energy" which - as I've already stated - makes no sense as CP2030 and CP2035 are as much to do with cost and energy security as carbon. Though I don't expect much sense on energy policy from the PM that despite being the MP for fucking Sellafield, knowing our nuclear fleet was aging and needed replacing and was in charge during the 2000s energy crisis did absolutely fuck all on energy policy except coming out with the Renewable Obligation that didn't include a cap because he couldn't forsee renewables being so much cheaper than gas and therefore being a massive reason we're in the shit we are now, seems he's learned absolutely nothing from his failure.


RE: Blair - man in the corner shop - 05-28-2026

(05-28-2026, 10:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-28-2026, 09:46 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(05-28-2026, 09:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I don’t think you’re seeing the wood for the trees. Energy transition is just one aspect of net zero. I don’t believe in his essay Blair is referring to simply to energy costs, but the much broader costs of net zero. Let me give you an example - we have an EPC D two up two down. Very soon we won’t be able to let it on a new tenancy unless we bring it up to a C.

All very noble I’m sure, but it’s likely to cost us £11,000. And save the tenant £70 a year. It would make far more sense to both us and tenant to write him a cheque for £100 every Christmas. In all likelihood we’ll sell the property when it next becomes vacant as there’s simply no point in spending 5 figures on a box ticking exercise which achieves nothing else.

I’ve already seen £millions needlessly spent on commercial premises in pursuit of compliance and nothing more. There’s a whole parasitic industry, which pretty much sums up the UKs growth problem over the last decade or so.

Alternatively, pay the £11k 
The gaff will have increased in value by that within a couple of years.

It's the cost of external insulation and altering the roofline which will is actually more likely to create a damp problem and depress the value of the house. Victorian houses were designed to breath you see. What with me being a surveyor and all. 

People actually voted  for this twattery you know. There's still some in Parliament who believe you can get rid of the Leasehold system too. There's others that think the renters rights Act is good for tenants.

Well you will know about this than me faw shaw. 

Another scandal involving madness and profiteering was getting people to insulate walls and attics with spray foam. That's fucked a lot of people's houses and lives.


RE: Blair - Tom Joad 25 - 05-29-2026

(05-28-2026, 10:17 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(05-28-2026, 10:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-28-2026, 09:46 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(05-28-2026, 09:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I don’t think you’re seeing the wood for the trees. Energy transition is just one aspect of net zero. I don’t believe in his essay Blair is referring to simply to energy costs, but the much broader costs of net zero. Let me give you an example - we have an EPC D two up two down. Very soon we won’t be able to let it on a new tenancy unless we bring it up to a C.

All very noble I’m sure, but it’s likely to cost us £11,000. And save the tenant £70 a year. It would make far more sense to both us and tenant to write him a cheque for £100 every Christmas. In all likelihood we’ll sell the property when it next becomes vacant as there’s simply no point in spending 5 figures on a box ticking exercise which achieves nothing else.

I’ve already seen £millions needlessly spent on commercial premises in pursuit of compliance and nothing more. There’s a whole parasitic industry, which pretty much sums up the UKs growth problem over the last decade or so.

Alternatively, pay the £11k 
The gaff will have increased in value by that within a couple of years.

It's the cost of external insulation and altering the roofline which will is actually more likely to create a damp problem and depress the value of the house. Victorian houses were designed to breath you see. What with me being a surveyor and all. 

People actually voted  for this twattery you know. There's still some in Parliament who believe you can get rid of the Leasehold system too. There's others that think the renters rights Act is good for tenants.

Well you will know about this than me faw shaw. 

Another scandal involving madness and profiteering was getting people to insulate walls and attics with spray foam. That's fucked a lot of people's houses and lives.

Yes. I don't mean to derail the op but this insulation business has missed it's target. Some of the HMOs I need to visit for work are like saunas. Central heating up to the max, all vents blocked (draughts according to the occupants) and damp aots.  Don't even start me on the drains, built for a family and now serving a large number of people.


RE: Blair - Protheroe - 05-29-2026

It is just box ticking designed by people who don't understand how a building performs. Unfortunately not many people do. One of our other tenants called us in to deal with "damp" caused by her taking baths by candlelight. She now has a 5 litre bottle of white vinegar and a cloth, and had a detailed lecture on mechanical ventilation and why it's a good idea to use it.


RE: Blair - Tom Joad 25 - 05-29-2026

(05-29-2026, 01:28 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It is just box ticking designed by people who don't understand how a building performs. Unfortunately not many people do. One of our other tenants called us in to deal with "damp" caused by her taking baths by candlelight. She now has a 5 litre bottle of white vinegar and a cloth, and had a detailed lecture on mechanical ventilation and why it's a good idea to use it.

I've seen families on local news whinging about damp in perfectly good houses just like the house I grew up in. But then we didn't have gas central heating, there were gaps under the doors and our air vents weren't blocked up. A house needs vents.