WBAUnofficial
Jenrick - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Jenrick (/showthread.php?tid=41608)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Jenrick - Protheroe - 05-20-2026

(05-20-2026, 09:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Burnham thinks the UK being in the EU is best for the UK but knows that because of politics that isn't feasible in the immediate term. 

He hasn't retreated "cos politics", he's retreated "cos by election".

It would be entirely consistent with what he's said before to unambiguously support rejoining the EU. But he's entirely retreated from that to avoid a short term problem.

This is pretty much everything that's wrong in modern politics. No party has a leader with an overarching philosophy, because of that members of parliamentary parties are motivated by short term popularity and short term expedience. Witness Burnham's volte face on the Manchester CAZ. The right thing to do long term, completely supported by him - then he reinvents himself as the leader of the revolution when it's canned.

Haven't we had enough of this shit? 

Who the hell is he? What on Earth does he stand for? Answers on postcard guys.

(05-20-2026, 08:41 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The world evolves and peoples views evolve with it. Give it a try.

Neither you nor I know what Burnham stands for. And even if we did, it could change tomorrow.

Is that any sort of foundation for good governance?


RE: Jenrick - Borin' Baggie - 05-20-2026

That is politics. I refer you to my examples of Gladstone, Lloyd-George and Roy Jenkins. What you want and what is practicable are different. I would expect someone who campaigned for Vote Leave and the Tories to know that.

(05-20-2026, 09:22 AM)Fido Wrote: Agree, BB. But imagine the political traction you could get from implementing a land tax now. The entitled rich (usually those who've had it handed down or large businesses) have to pay more and would potentially free up land for housing. Sort housing, increase the tax yield and the rest of the political vitriol will start to ebb away.

When the Lib Dems unambiguously announced they were going to implement an LVT in 2015 the Tories via their client media absolutely hammered that policy in Lib Dem-Tory facing constituencies with the message of the Lib Dems are going to tax people's gardens and bullshit like that. Hence retreating to business rates and non-residential LVT.

The same vested interest that worked to undermine it 100 years ago still exists today.


RE: Jenrick - Protheroe - 05-20-2026

The currency of modern politics is that people who want power will say whatever is necessary to get it. That phenomenon is destroying our trust in politics. You may be OK with that, I am not. It has not always been like that.


RE: Jenrick - Borin' Baggie - 05-20-2026

I'm not ok with that, it's exactly why I want political reforms to address that. But ultimately until those reforms happen it's the only way to play the game, lest you're fighting populists from both sides with both hands tied behind your back.


RE: Jenrick - baggy1 - 05-20-2026

Which brings me back to the point you asked about Proth from yesterday. When you used that to your benefit to get what you wanted it was fine, let's not make out that Brexit was anything other than a bullshit driven protest vote, you were happy to ride on the back of Farage's images of lines of foreigners arriving at our gates, or even the threat that we were about to see 20m Turks appear as soon as they got membership (something that is still being pushed back). And by the way, I don't doubt that there were many people that voted for exactly what it said on the tin, but a large enough number to take away any majority were duped with those lies and misrepresentations.

Once you let the genie out of the bottle there is no way of getting it back in, and your lack of protestations at the time as calling them out as simply racist and lies have led us to this point where the Farage's and the bots can say what they like as there is no challenge.


RE: Jenrick - Protheroe - 05-20-2026

(05-20-2026, 10:47 AM)baggy1 Wrote: you were happy to ride on the back of Farage's images of lines of foreigners arriving at our gates, or even the threat that we were about to see 20m Turks appear as soon as they got membership

Do you have any evidence for that baseless and rather offensive contention?

I personally rejected the offer to pool resources with Leave.EU locally precisely because of these messages. So politely, piss off.


RE: Jenrick - baggy1 - 05-20-2026

Ok let me rephrase that, both of those things happened and many more tropes and falsehoods were spouted by Farage and his cronies. I'm not suggesting you yourself made or make those statements, I don't believe that you would, however you did benefit from them by getting the result you wanted. And taking into account that the margin was so small they had a material impact on the referendum. Yet you still lauded it knowing that there was a sizeable chunk of the reason that you won was based on racism pure and simple.You, and by you I mean the wider vote Leave campaign, didn't call them out knowing they were falsehoods and from that point forward it has opened the floodgates to lies and misinformation being normalised.


RE: Jenrick - Protheroe - 05-20-2026

You can rephrase it how you like. I know what I did and I know what I didn't do during that campaign. You'll also know that I am exceptionally in favour of legal migration. And clearly I have no doubt that most racists voted to leave the EU.

That said there's only ever been one political party that's been sanctioned by the EHRC. A party I've never belonged to, that I'm pretty sure drew many of its votes in 2017 and 2019 from some individuals with pretty nasty views about Jews - and I suspect agreeing with Islington mafia about the EU being capitalist plot. I don't recall many people in the PLP or the broader Left calling that out at the time.

And as for misinformation and lies being used on an industrial scale, I think you can look back quite a way further this century than 2016.


RE: Jenrick - baggy1 - 05-20-2026

That's a slight diversion from what i have said. During 2017 and 2019 I wasn't a member of the Labour Party and, for the only time in my life, felt the need to become active and do something about it, but this isn't about me, this is a point on the vote leave campaign using the far right as useful idiots to get what they wanted. Unfortunately, the useful idiots are now calling the shots and if we ever want to get back to normal politics, and by that the standard level of lies and misinformation as opposed to the uber misinformation around now, then these things need to be called out by those that let the genie out of the bottle.

And I'd go and step further in that, the vote leave campaign saw this at the time and have to take a large chunk of the responsibility of where we are now. They should have seen that at the time, but it really didn't suit their wants and so they kept quiet because they thought they could control it and have failed miserably in both that original judgement and anything since.


RE: Jenrick - Protheroe - 05-20-2026

So in a new high for WBAunofficial you now know what was in the minds of the Vote Leave campaign team in 2016. I suppose it makes a pleasant change from just me being told what I actually think by you.