WBAUnofficial
Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final (/showthread.php?tid=41589)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Josh1873 - 05-16-2026

Not that it makes it right, but I'd be very surprised if spying wasn't common throughout the leagues, in all honesty.

This is yet more evidence of how clueless the EFL are. Their rules don't state what a potential punishment for spying would be, let alone what happens if a club is caught spying during a play-off game.

Is it so difficult, when making the rules, to make it absolutely clear what the fine, points deduction, or forfeit of a result (i.e. a 3-0 loss) would be if a club is found guilty?

Is it so difficult, when making the rules, to state that if you are found guilty of the offence during a play-off campaign, you are thrown out?

Is it so difficult, when making the rules, to state that if you are found guilty of the offence in the lead-up to a game where you can earn automatic promotion, the points deduction will take immediate effect meaning you could lose that promotion (depending on the stage of the season, etc.)? Ditto for avoiding relegation.

It really isn't that difficult to foresee reasonable scenarios, decide on a clear course of action, and make both the rules and the ramifications for breaching them absolutely clear, is it?

I know it's easy for me to say with hindsight, but is it really that difficult to outline the ramifications for breaching rules so clubs know exactly where they stand? Instead, we are left with this ridiculous situation of waiting and guessing. It surely isn't unreasonable to predict that somewhere down the line - be it weeks or decades after a rule is introduced - a team will breach it in one of the biggest games of the season, or in a scenario that has massive implications for promotion and relegation.

They really are a useless organisation that isn't fit for purpose.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - MrBater - 05-16-2026

None of it is difficult, thinking that it might happen is where it fails. I doubt it's that common and I honestly don't see that it would give that much advantage, so doing it seems dumb to me

They've also broken two regulations not one, so you'd need to gave pu ishme rs that link, or were combined, or rules that co.bibe... then you get the legal people involved, and they're worse than asking what £5+£1 is on here to the financial spurts

None of it is intrinsically hard to do, but so many will have a hand in it that they compound things

I honestly don't think they'll kick them out. Maybe do a quick behind close doors replay winner takes all and gets to play hull.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Josh1873 - 05-16-2026

The only advantage to be gained from spying, that I've seen suggested & that makes sense to me, is penalty shootout practice.

In any case, Boro battered Saints in the first leg, so whatever advantage Saints may have gained, didn't really count for much!


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - CarlosCorbewrong - 05-16-2026

Personally I don’t think spying should be banned.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Tom Joad 25 - 05-16-2026

Surely at the same time you make the rule you set a scale of penalties for breaking it? Thus reducing the later legal bills? A quick hearing to establish guilt, then how much guilt and bingo, the level of punishment is already there. This making it up as you go approach is no longer fair on anyone. We felt aggrieved at our punishment, apparently league one clubs are unhappy with the waiving of Wednesday's penalty and Boro, or Saints and who knows who else will be complaining about this latest infringement.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - SW4Baggie - 05-16-2026

You also have to consider Hull’s situation in this - they’ve been very quiet, but they’re now at a significant disadvantage preparing for a huge game in which they don’t have clarity on who they’ll face. They’ve done nothing wrong, yet whoever they end up playing has the advantage of an extra week’s prep time in knowing their opposition. Hull’s team will have to be preparing for both scenarios currently.

I don’t think the FA will kick Saints out - it’s too much hassle, but I expect legal challenges from both Boro and Hull. Boro and Gibson have history for being litigious (they extracted millions out of Derby when they beat them to the playoffs when Mel Morris was flaunting financial rules) and if Hull lose, they’ll claim they suffered in preparation.

Honestly the best outcome here for the EFL is Hull beat Saints and then they leave Saints and Boro to argue amongst themselves in the courts. I wonder if we will see a Forest-Hudds level of VAR application


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Josh1873 - 05-16-2026

I don't think Hull are disadvantaged at all. It's highly unlikely that Saints will be kicked out, so they'll be preparing for Saints, surely.

The league are meeting Tuesday, aren't they? So a decision would be made then, you'd think. So even if it is Boro, as unlikely as that is, that's still plenty of preparation time.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - wba13 - 05-16-2026

(05-16-2026, 09:08 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't think Hull are disadvantaged at all. It's highly unlikely that Saints will be kicked out, so they'll be preparing for Saints, surely.

The league are meeting Tuesday, aren't they? So a decision would be made then, you'd think. So even if it is Boro, as unlikely as that is, that's still plenty of preparation time.

How do you work that one out Josh. Hull have been preparing for Saints for over a week by Tuesday then all of a sudden on late Tuesday they get a phone saying saints kicked out your playing Boro, what thay have Wednesday and Thursday to prepare as they will travel down on Friday for match on Saturday. It’s totally unfair. 
I want the cheating saints kicked out but it ain’t gunna happen because of the timescale. 
They will get a slap on the wrist and a points deduction and big fine which will come into force next time they are in the championship. Hopefully next season.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Josh1873 - 05-16-2026

There's more chance of me shagging Mowatt than Saints getting kicked out!

I do think, and I appreciate this is a hill I'm well and truly standing alone on, that kicking them out of the final would be disproportionate to the crime.

It is cheating, and I think it's deplorable of Southampton to engage in spying, but the idea of potentially removing them from the play-off final doesn't feel like the right punishment to me. I suspect a heavy fine, in the millions, which goes against FFP regulations in whichever league they're in, would be a sufficient punishment. Speaking of FFP, I believe knowingly going over the thresholds and showing no regard to the financial regulations is a far greater crime than sending a teenage kid to peer over a training ground fence.

I can tell I'll be alone in that view, but so be it!

I believe kicking teams out of competitions, or retrospectively changing match results, should be reserved for the most serious of offences, such as match fixing. Whilst this is unbelievably poor from Saints, it doesn't feel to me to be that level of behaviour.

I also, hand on heart, believe that any information and data obtained on Boro would have had little impact on the result over the two legs. Not that that should be of relevance when deciding the case, however. It's just a personal opinion. Boro should have won the first leg. They've only themselves to blame for not getting it done on the pitch.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 05-16-2026

Ok, what if the spying was as suspected is over the whole league and they’ve had the advantage over the whole season to get to the position they’re in now. Dress it up how you like Josh, a fine doesn’t remotely cut it given the riches on offer for the playoff winners.