WBAUnofficial
Labour's next leader what they need - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Labour's next leader what they need (/showthread.php?tid=41577)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - baggy1 - 05-14-2026

So they've done what they should be doing but you want less boring, fair enough.

If you bothered to read anything I'd written I repeatedly said we need stability, and as Stamer is in place then that is it. Rocking the boat without a plan just gets everyone wet - it's counterproductive and gives even more traction to Reform and the right wing.

This government have performed as well as anyone could given the starting point and the orange roadbumps. You view this as a failure through a media lens that ignores any positives and needs the feeding frenzy that comes with the right or left wings.


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - Protheroe - 05-14-2026

We don’t need stability. We need transformation. Labour has a majority that could achieve this if only they tried and convinced the PLP to fall in line.


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - tHEgLASSdOORS - 05-14-2026

I see Simons is standing down so Burnham can run


Interesting and risky


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - baggy1 - 05-14-2026

We're into shit or bust territory now

So the steps are simple now:
Burnham gets NEC approval - probable
Burnham stands and wins bi-election - likely but will have a hell of a lot of attention from the press and some real effort put in by the Greens and Reform
Burnahm will then have the MPs backing - very likely

Game on, but a seriously risky strategy.


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - Protheroe - 05-14-2026

It's by-election FFS.

And Labour lost every council seat in the locals.


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - baggy1 - 05-14-2026

Sorry, didn't mean to mispel, and hence the shit or bust line


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - man in the corner shop - 05-14-2026

(05-14-2026, 04:36 PM)baggy1 Wrote: We're into shit or bust territory now

So the steps are simple now:
Burnham gets NEC approval - probable
Burnham stands and wins bi-election - likely but will have a hell of a lot of attention from the press and some real effort put in by the Greens and Reform
Burnahm will then have the MPs backing - very likely

Game on, but a seriously risky strategy.

Do I hear the squeaking of the blinkers coming off? A head emerging from the sand and hands ceasing to cover ears ?Labour will do better with a better PM (and de facto so will the government). Your continual denial and rigidness is almost cult like obedience. We cannot wait for glacial progress, no matter how logical and rational you think that approach to be. The public won't wait, more importantly. They won't listen and they won't be convinced of jam tomorrow.

I agree with Proth. It is transformation we need, not plodding and ending up with the inevitable in 2029. Of course, Proth and I have very different views on what transformation means and the ways to get there.


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - baggy1 - 05-14-2026

Not at all, and I’m a bit older than you so more risk averse. I’ve seen where these situations end up if they go wrong, so I don’t like the risk, but we’re here now.

You forget that I joined the party to give it a chance at winning an election, I want to get to this point and always have done but shit or bust isn’t a good strategy.


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - man in the corner shop - 05-14-2026

In a normal world, in normal times with a normal electorate, I'd agree with a lot of what you say.
But normality disappeared thanks to 14 years of charlatans and rogues. Labour's mismanagement of its first 2 years has left us in a casino playing pragmatism as our Ace cards. So unnecessary. And self-inflicted .
Unfortunately the pantomime has further to run.
On one hand it's heartbreaking. On the other it had to be done.
I'm not a Starmer hater and haven't abused the man. Just repeated that he isn't very good at politics. I think that's something he said himself. I'd prefer it actually if he stayed and won the public over by delivering. But he's too far gone in terms of damaged goods for that.

I'm struggling to think of a PM as unpopular that turned it around. Thatcher probably in 1981 and she dug herself out with the Falklands war. When the public turn their back on you, that's it. And they'd rather die than admit they were wrong - see Brexit.

So these 2 years for me have been underwhelming, now turning to depressing that we are here. And this isn't the end of it.


RE: Labour's next leader what they need - Derek Hardballs - 05-15-2026

The mess that Labour Party are currently in, is becuase no one knows what they stand for, or what guiding principles they stick by. Oscillating between ‘islands of strangers’ and where the base of their support lies, was always a recipe for disaster.

Their biggest problem is they have pissed off the left and the right of the country and under Starmer they appeal to a very narrow demographic of people. The list of those that dislike him range from carers, (genuinely before anyone chips in) disabled, small businesses, many ethnic minorities including both Jewish and followers of Islam (impressive to do both), younger voters (moved to the Greens), many from the working class etc. in some cases this was unavoidable but chasing Reform voters at the expense of those that would vote for you naturally was suicidal of Starmer and his advisers.

Let’s put it this way if Burnham was in charge I’d vote for Labour at the next election with Starmer I wouldn’t. Sadly where I live will be a straight scrap between Tory and Reform so I will have to tactically vote to keep Reform out unless the Tories do a grubby deal with their cousins.