WBAUnofficial
VAR - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: VAR (/showthread.php?tid=41548)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: VAR - wba13 - 05-11-2026

(05-11-2026, 11:50 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: VAR is shit. This proves it. Still as much argument as if there was no VAR.
All it does is make celebrations of goals muted. Destroys what we've all been brought up with.
The ref mistakes are part of the game. 40 years on we are on about the hand of God still but so what. We're human.
Regards Arsenal, I'd rather they win the league than Man City and their 100 plus charges.
Anyone looking forward to the cup final on Saturday between the 2 clubs that have bought football greed to a new level? Thought not.

I enjoy the cup final, in Man City defence you cannot blame there present players for what happened years ago. Yes it’s totally wrong but big clubs have big lawyers who can and have delayed things for years but that is no fault of the present day players.


RE: VAR - SW4Baggie - 05-11-2026

(05-11-2026, 11:59 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(05-11-2026, 11:50 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: VAR is shit. This proves it. Still as much argument as if there was no VAR.
All it does is make celebrations of goals muted. Destroys what we've all been brought up with.
The ref mistakes are part of the game. 40 years on we are on about the hand of God still but so what. We're human.
Regards Arsenal, I'd rather they win the league than Man City and their 100 plus charges.
Anyone looking forward to the cup final on Saturday between the 2 clubs that have bought football greed to a new level? Thought not.

I enjoy the cup final, in Man City defence you cannot blame there present players for what happened years ago. Yes it’s totally wrong but big clubs have big lawyers who can and have delayed things for years but that is no fault of the present day players.

6 years ago I worked for a British company that got bought out by a Brazilian one that was heavily involved in Bolsonaro’s dirty practices and was absolutely involved in destroying the Amazon. I didn’t feel comfortable working there and ended up going elsewhere despite them offering me a lot more money to stay.

In the last 18 months I have been approached by jobs for companies owned by a huge Trump donor as well as one tenuously linked to PIF, and I’ve not been interested.

Players are complicit if they take the money from corrupt owners. They have the option to leave.


RE: VAR - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 05-11-2026

(05-11-2026, 11:01 AM)1878andallthat Wrote:
(05-10-2026, 06:39 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: There were about 10 simultaneous fouls both ways there, probably all cancel each other out.

Just watched the BBC/MOTD highlights.

Trossard is manhandling the West Ham player to keep him away from Raya and cleverley slides around from goal side as the ball comes in and, if anything moves him away from goal. I would argue that is a foul. Moreover, Raya moves out towards those two players to meet the ball. Raya initiates contact, the West Ham player is not obliged to move out of the way. It is as likely that the attacker's arm is out as a result of wrestling with Trossard rather than intending to impede the GK. 

All that said, the arm is definitely across the GK who very much makes the most of it.

Overall, I would say 'goal given' (or maybe penalty) due to Trossard's actions.

Sounds about right. It’s a similar story at most corners, you could find a way to disallow virtually any goal from a corner now if you analyse it enough.


RE: VAR - Tom Joad 25 - 05-11-2026

(05-11-2026, 12:26 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(05-11-2026, 11:01 AM)1878andallthat Wrote:
(05-10-2026, 06:39 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: There were about 10 simultaneous fouls both ways there, probably all cancel each other out.

Just watched the BBC/MOTD highlights.

Trossard is manhandling the West Ham player to keep him away from Raya and cleverley slides around from goal side as the ball comes in and, if anything moves him away from goal. I would argue that is a foul. Moreover, Raya moves out towards those two players to meet the ball. Raya initiates contact, the West Ham player is not obliged to move out of the way. It is as likely that the attacker's arm is out as a result of wrestling with Trossard rather than intending to impede the GK. 

All that said, the arm is definitely across the GK who very much makes the most of it.

Overall, I would say 'goal given' (or maybe penalty) due to Trossard's actions.

Sounds about right. It’s a similar story at most corners, you could find a way to disallow virtually any goal from a corner now if you analyse it enough.

Exactly! All we ask for is consistency. . I've been against VAR since its inception and our farcical victory at Anfield. You can do anything you want with it.


RE: VAR - Tetsuo - 05-13-2026

VAR is just a tool to make sure the game stays corrupt and the decisions go the way the authorities, sponsors and the media want. See the Celtic game 10 minutes ago.

In the Prem if Liverpool are the flavour of the month they get the big VAR decisions, if Man U are the flavour of the month then they get them. Unless City are playing and then they get the calls, and in Europe Real Madrid get them.

Just another way to stack the odds


RE: VAR - Tom Joad 25 - 05-14-2026

(05-13-2026, 09:11 PM)Tetsuo Wrote: VAR is just a tool to make sure the game stays corrupt and the decisions go the way the authorities, sponsors and the media want. See the Celtic game 10 minutes ago.

In the Prem if Liverpool are the flavour of the month they get the big VAR decisions, if Man U are the flavour of the month then they get them. Unless City are playing and then they get the calls, and in Europe Real Madrid get them.

Just another way to stack the odds

You are bang on. When we first got to the Prem under Megson our players talked of referees speaking to 'Roy' (Keane) and Patrick (Viera). Whereas they'd have to ask ours their names to book them. The refs would walk off with their arms on each others shoulders like longtime mates. It is unconscious bias. 
VAR extends this to a level where most things can be interpreted in a number of ways depending how hard you look. It is time to accept the referees decision is final and get rid of VAR. Of course, it won't happen because the TV loves the talking points and sport cones second.


RE: VAR - AnelkasBeard - 05-14-2026

(05-14-2026, 08:12 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 09:11 PM)Tetsuo Wrote: VAR is just a tool to make sure the game stays corrupt and the decisions go the way the authorities, sponsors and the media want. See the Celtic game 10 minutes ago.

In the Prem if Liverpool are the flavour of the month they get the big VAR decisions, if Man U are the flavour of the month then they get them. Unless City are playing and then they get the calls, and in Europe Real Madrid get them.

Just another way to stack the odds

You are bang on. When we first got to the Prem under Megson our players talked of referees speaking to 'Roy' (Keane) and Patrick (Viera). Whereas they'd have to ask ours their names to book them. The refs would walk off with their arms on each others shoulders like longtime mates. It is unconscious bias. 
VAR extends this to a level where most things can be interpreted in a number of ways depending how hard you look. It is time to accept the referees decision is final and get rid of VAR. Of course, it won't happen because the TV loves the talking points and sport cones second.

We had the talking points anyway though? All VAR does is make everything much worse.

Only way to resolve it is have a challenge system like most other sports with video review. Then they aren't re-refereeing the game.


RE: VAR - Duffers - 05-14-2026

(05-14-2026, 08:12 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 09:11 PM)Tetsuo Wrote: VAR is just a tool to make sure the game stays corrupt and the decisions go the way the authorities, sponsors and the media want. See the Celtic game 10 minutes ago.

In the Prem if Liverpool are the flavour of the month they get the big VAR decisions, if Man U are the flavour of the month then they get them. Unless City are playing and then they get the calls, and in Europe Real Madrid get them.

Just another way to stack the odds

You are bang on. When we first got to the Prem under Megson our players talked of referees speaking to 'Roy' (Keane) and Patrick (Viera). Whereas they'd have to ask ours their names to book them. The refs would walk off with their arms on each others shoulders like longtime mates. It is unconscious bias. 
VAR extends this to a level where most things can be interpreted in a number of ways depending how hard you look. It is time to accept the referees decision is final and get rid of VAR. Of course, it won't happen because the TV loves the talking points and sport cones second.

This is exactly it, we've reached a point where the "drama" supercedes the actual football in terms of entertainment.


RE: VAR - SW4Baggie - 05-14-2026

(05-14-2026, 08:12 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 09:11 PM)Tetsuo Wrote: VAR is just a tool to make sure the game stays corrupt and the decisions go the way the authorities, sponsors and the media want. See the Celtic game 10 minutes ago.

In the Prem if Liverpool are the flavour of the month they get the big VAR decisions, if Man U are the flavour of the month then they get them. Unless City are playing and then they get the calls, and in Europe Real Madrid get them.

Just another way to stack the odds

You are bang on. When we first got to the Prem under Megson our players talked of referees speaking to 'Roy' (Keane) and Patrick (Viera). Whereas they'd have to ask ours their names to book them. The refs would walk off with their arms on each others shoulders like longtime mates. It is unconscious bias. 
VAR extends this to a level where most things can be interpreted in a number of ways depending how hard you look. It is time to accept the referees decision is final and get rid of VAR. Of course, it won't happen because the TV loves the talking points and sport cones second.

Agree - we really can't be far away from being able to create an AI VAR review bot... Football is not a difficult game, and it would be able to analyse multiple angles far quicker than a pitch side monitor.


RE: VAR - GunsOfNavarone - 05-14-2026

(05-14-2026, 08:47 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 08:12 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 09:11 PM)Tetsuo Wrote: VAR is just a tool to make sure the game stays corrupt and the decisions go the way the authorities, sponsors and the media want. See the Celtic game 10 minutes ago.

In the Prem if Liverpool are the flavour of the month they get the big VAR decisions, if Man U are the flavour of the month then they get them. Unless City are playing and then they get the calls, and in Europe Real Madrid get them.

Just another way to stack the odds

You are bang on. When we first got to the Prem under Megson our players talked of referees speaking to 'Roy' (Keane) and Patrick (Viera). Whereas they'd have to ask ours their names to book them. The refs would walk off with their arms on each others shoulders like longtime mates. It is unconscious bias. 
VAR extends this to a level where most things can be interpreted in a number of ways depending how hard you look. It is time to accept the referees decision is final and get rid of VAR. Of course, it won't happen because the TV loves the talking points and sport cones second.

Agree - we really can't be far away from being able to create an AI VAR review bot... Football is not a difficult game, and it would be able to analyse multiple angles far quicker than a pitch side monitor.

Anything involving a drone swarm and Villa Park is on my radar. AI ole ole ole.......