![]() |
|
Change badly needsd - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Change badly needsd (/showthread.php?tid=40451) |
RE: Change badly needsd - Lurker#3 - 02-02-2026 (02-02-2026, 09:21 AM)Jacko Wrote:(02-02-2026, 09:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(02-02-2026, 09:15 AM)Lightnin Wrote:(02-02-2026, 08:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(02-02-2026, 07:37 AM)Lightnin Wrote: Or we could just change to a formation that suits the squad and put the round pegs in the round holes whilst working on patterns and moments in training. I fear this may be the case. RE: Change badly needsd - Ted Maul - 02-02-2026 Lurk, Dekka, as per the usual the answer lies somewhere in the middle. We've got 16 games now to avoid the unthinkable, it's a time to find whatever immediate formula works and we don't have 4-5 games to test theories. In the longer-term, Lurker is absolutely right. One of my biggest frustrations with Bilkul thus far is that there was so much chat about 'game models' and 'play styles' yet our recruitment in the summer and in half a season under Mason, I had absolutely no idea how we were trying to win a game or what style the recruitment was pointing towards. Now we've parachuted in Ramsay, who I believe is a good coach, if a little naïve. He was appointed by a man who seemingly knows very little about football (Patel) with no thought given to the way he likes to play, or the personnel we have available within our squad. I can't blame Eric Ramsay for coming in and sticking by the values that got him the job in the first place, what we were doing wasn't working and what he had at Minnesota was working. He's had four games now and I'm hoping that he's seen that we just don't have the players to pull it off. Do I think he's a bad coach? No. Do I think potentially he's a terrible fit for what we need right now? Probably. He needs to play the hand he's been dealt until the end of season, finish 21st or better and then we can look at his system with his players in the summer window and through pre-season. RE: Change badly needsd - ElbowGrease73 - 02-02-2026 (02-02-2026, 09:16 AM)Jacko Wrote: Ramsay needs to stick to his principles and bomb out anyone who's not on board. Fuck these players. I don't disagree Jacko, but the problem is he's stuck with the squad of players he's inherited for now. Our best two centre halves for this system are out for 4 weeks, so we're stuck with Twiddledum and Twiddledee, and we'll continue to leak goals. I know Ramsay will be blamed for the results and performances, and that's to be expected, but we've got some big earners in this squad who aren't doing the basics at present. Whatever happens come the end of the season, it's another huge one in terms of squad overhaul. RE: Change badly needsd - Lurker#3 - 02-02-2026 (02-02-2026, 09:30 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Lurk, Dekka, as per the usual the answer lies somewhere in the middle. We've got 16 games now to avoid the unthinkable, it's a time to find whatever immediate formula works and we don't have 4-5 games to test theories. Completely agree with all that. The issue is, and I keep asking people, what is the immediate formula? It's not about formations, it never has been. It's about the balance within the team and getting enough players on the pitch who can hurt teams offensively whilst offering the aggression needed for us to get out of the hole we are in. I do not agree with, what seems to be the consensus, that us defending our way to survival will work. We haven't got the players for it like we have had before with Furlong, Bartley, Pieter's and Townsend. I thought Mepham and Phillips would be, but they seem shot at the moment. So we need to do something which reduces the defending they (and the others) have to do close to our box. As it stands, a back three of; Campbell Phillips Diakite, is probably as good as we've got as both Campbell and Diakite have the legs to recover if we push the back line up and be more aggressive. They can also play a bit in possession which helps with our transition, which would balance off against M&Ms limitations as a pairing. We then need to play 2 strikers unless we get another wide forward today. RE: Change badly needsd - BurleyBaggie - 02-02-2026 (02-02-2026, 08:00 AM)aj21 Wrote: I just don’t see how Ramsey can get his views across, he has come in and absolutely destroyed these players and they have destroyed him. It feels like something totally broken and the only way to change it, is to remove him. I’m definitely on the players side more than him, lots disagree but I think he hung them out to dry in that Norwich game and he isn’t getting them back. I must have missed the point where the team was flying pre ER appointment. Let’s not kid ourselves on where we were and the form we were in. It has not got better and yes worse but there is a pattern here. Maybe it’s not just the manager… RE: Change badly needsd - Cheshire East Baggie - 02-02-2026 All this talk about systems and philosophies is all very well, but I've just watched the highlights. All three goals were down to rank bad defending. For the first, Imray had loads of time to close down the Pompey player but didn't, Molumby drifted away from the man he was marking in the box. For the second, Mepham was in the wrong place (no shit Sherlock) and not concentrating (as if). Yes it was a great through ball, but a good defender gives himself a better chance of stopping the goal. For the third, Mepham and Taylor both went for the ball and ignored the player stood between them who slipped through to score. Whatever "system" you're playing, if experienced players don't do their jobs properly, you're going to concede soft goals. Now maybe we don't have any "natural" defenders in our squad, maybe they're all guys who have got through their careers being well-coached and surrounded by better players. So coach them well FFS Sake! Same applies at the other end of the pitch. We've been missing chances all season long. Free headers over the bar, one-on-ones where we just knew the goalie would win. What work was Mason doing to improve on these "moments"? Has Ramsay even tried to iron out the errors, or does he believe implementing his "vision" will fix everything? When most of the players can't even pass to a team mate, philosophy, system and shape aren't the problems. RE: Change badly needsd - Birdman1811 - 02-02-2026 Fans obsess about formation, people in the game pay it barely any mind. Player roles and shape with and without the ball are far more important than the actual formation you see on a screen. A 4-5-1 can be more attacking and free flowing than a 4-3-3 or 4-2-2. Wing backs can be less attacking and more defensive than full backs. With the loss of true strikers in the modern game, even the number up front means very little. The issue is with Ramsey, what he wants our squad cannot do, it lacks the pace, the ability to make quick, direct, incisive passes and struggles if under pressure for any length of time. Mason at least had us keeping the ball so we could keep the goals against down, but getting this squad to score often is a difficult task. RE: Change badly needsd - Duffers - 02-02-2026 (02-02-2026, 07:46 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: And why the calls for Big Dave? I keep wondering this. Great guy, but a League One manager at best. RE: Change badly needsd - TartanRug - 02-02-2026 (02-02-2026, 09:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: All this talk about systems and philosophies is all very well, but I've just watched the highlights. All three goals were down to rank bad defending. For the first, Imray had loads of time to close down the Pompey player but didn't, Molumby drifted away from the man he was marking in the box. For the second, Mepham was in the wrong place (no shit Sherlock) and not concentrating (as if). Yes it was a great through ball, but a good defender gives himself a better chance of stopping the goal. For the third, Mepham and Taylor both went for the ball and ignored the player stood between them who slipped through to score. I agree somewhat from a defensive point of view but this system seems to have totally killed us in an attacking sense. At least what we had from Mason in the last few months was a system that created some chances (not saying we should have kept him) RE: Change badly needsd - Tom Joad 25 - 02-02-2026 I checked in on here yesterday in the aftermath of that miserable surrender. I started to type my thoughts and after half an hour all I had written was 'words fail me'. There was so much wrong, so much anger, I didn't know where to start. I've only just began to think clearly. Here's my onions. Nothing to do with formation, just watch those goals again. Pompey take numerous touches, make numerous passes in and around our box. Not a single defender gets even close. This is basic stuff. It's not Ramsey, Nestor, Patel, it's not Mason, It’s rank bad defending - as was the Norwich game. What is on Ramsey is this system. 3 cbs means we play our 3 worst players, no doubt. It also negates our most creative players. Mikey and Price plus it leaves the focal point of our attack (Heggebo) playing with scraps on and around the centre circle. I do not see how we create anything. If this is the hill Ramsay dies upon then he needs to wait until we have the players. For now he has to do what he can with what he has. Mikey, Price. Heggebo are our best chance of goals. New blood. It's a common theme among managers that bringing in anyone at all in January can inject some enthusiasm. With Nestor on the way is there anyone capable of signing someone? The owners? The buck always stops at the top. It looks to me like they were over confident. To think they could just land their "cunning plan" into a game that has evolved over 150 years - and in one of the most competitive leagues in the world - is almost arrogant. Although, I prefer to think it was naive. The Price bust up. Overhyped bollix. A young, admittedly petulant player getting abuse and reacting. So what? Everyone concerned needs to get over it. More importantly the players need to stand up and lead by example. What to do? We don't have a McInnes, Big Dave or Megson (spot the common denominater here), so a statement of unity should be issued by someone capable of stepping up. A rallying cry given by someone willing to lead by example. Now isn't the time for putting arms around delicate souls, the side that stays up in this league needs to be willing to cripple their granny. Ramsey can implement whatever he thinks best next season but right now we need to stay in this division by whatever means we can muster. No more aimless wondering about following the ball as opponents pass it around us. No meaningless hoofs upfield, if Heggebo is the target he needs to get 10 yards upfield with options/support. Play the youngsters off the bench, I understand the need to shelter them but from what I see they have more confidence, less nerves and a point to prove. |