WBAUnofficial
So obvious. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: So obvious. (/showthread.php?tid=39848)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: So obvious. - Birdman1811 - 12-27-2025

(12-27-2025, 03:51 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(12-27-2025, 02:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: That’s not how the owners want us to play though.

Counter attacking football is still the most exciting form of the game. For me, get the defence rock solid and build from there. At this level teams are riddled with errors and poor finishing,  cut out your own mistakes first then work out how to exploit anything that comes up. I'm no expert but I have seen what works at this level.

I agree.

It's just not fashionable apparently


RE: So obvious. - Lurker#3 - 12-27-2025

(12-27-2025, 03:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-27-2025, 03:51 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(12-27-2025, 02:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: That’s not how the owners want us to play though.

Counter attacking football is still the most exciting form of the game. For me, get the defence rock solid and build from there. At this level teams are riddled with errors and poor finishing,  cut out your own mistakes first then work out how to exploit anything that comes up. I'm no expert but I have seen what works at this level.

I agree.

It's just not fashionable apparently

I agree with you both. 

But, you have to have individuals to carry it out really, but we lack that individual match winning, ability at the moment.


RE: So obvious. - Tom Joad 25 - 12-27-2025

(12-27-2025, 04:01 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-27-2025, 03:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-27-2025, 03:51 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(12-27-2025, 02:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: That’s not how the owners want us to play though.

Counter attacking football is still the most exciting form of the game. For me, get the defence rock solid and build from there. At this level teams are riddled with errors and poor finishing,  cut out your own mistakes first then work out how to exploit anything that comes up. I'm no expert but I have seen what works at this level.

I agree.

It's just not fashionable apparently

I agree with you both. 

But, you have to have individuals to carry it out really, but we lack that individual match winning, ability at the moment.

Not really. Grant, Heggebo, Mikey, Price. Like I say, make the defence solid and these are good enough to turn one point into 3 often enough.


RE: So obvious. - Lurker#3 - 12-27-2025

Only MJ is a player who can get the ball 40 yards out, take somebody on a spank it in.

The other three and good attacking players in a well functioning team.


RE: So obvious. - lemon - 12-27-2025

As much as I don't like Colin, there's no doubt in my mind that he would have this team and squad 8th or better. Players would be motivated, organised, feel valued, and be on their toes. Colin would also have the knack to work with the board and any restrictions they put in place, but having the backbone to push back a bit.

I get the impression that Mason is a 'philosophy' manager but doesn't publicise it as much as Russell Martin. He's stubborn in his ideas and the ideas themselves are not of any great substance to outclass managers and opposition at this level.

Whatever those philosophies of his are, he needs to start picking up points with them. No more sob stories. The season may well be transitional but the points return is completely unacceptable. I don't want us to be the sloppy 5 or 6 out of 10 outfit we are becoming.


RE: So obvious. - Borin' Baggie - 12-27-2025

I don't actually understand what Mason is trying to achieve tactically.

We look at our most threatening when our full backs push up to create overlaps, we don't do that often enough.

We create space on the wings to stretch play but never switch the ball.

We play slowly in the build up to drag defenders out but then lump it to Heggebo

We create the most chances from wing play and counter attacks but rarely set up to exploit that.

We have someone who is technically good and runs his bollocks off but has poor composure as our 2nd striker most of the time instead of deeper.

Our first choice midfield pairing are two players who want to play in the same position instead of creating balance.

We need wingers but Bostock never comes on despite always being on the bench.

Yes, we've been unlucky this season but regardless we're not playing to the extent of the sum of our parts and the infuriating thing is points wise we could still challenge for the Play Offs if we had a manager who could set the team up right. I'm resigned to Mason being in place until the end of the season at this point (wanted him gone after Wednesday) but he needs to speak to someone and get help because if he was more pragmatic with the set up we could be doing a lot better and it would save his job.


RE: So obvious. - Cheshire East Baggie - 12-27-2025

(12-27-2025, 02:06 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: This is my biggest issue with Mason. Despite the rhetoric of him being a young manager, learning his trade, there is zero evidence for this and a whole lot to the opposite. I think Mason has a rigid blueprint of how he wants to play, which he has manufactured in his head in his years as a coach. This is why we see a rigid formation, with like for like personnel changes. It’s not particularly based on defence, possession, high press, it just seems to be a slow, methodical, safety first approach and it doesn’t stand a cat in hells chance in this league.
Trouble is, I think he spent so long convincing himself that this was the magic formula, he can’t understand why it isn’t working so just keeps flogging the same dead horse. It’s also why his in game management is piss poor. His changes can often be predicted pre-kickoff. It’s football by numbers and not in a good “Lurker-esque” way.
Just my opinion of course but it’s why I don’t see us improving under him or him having any long term prospects.

He certainly gives the impression of being very confident in his own way of doing things. I can't imagine the backroom staff having much input, not least because they were already here and will have been happy to hold onto their jobs. Gibbs is a coach without much of a profile, so being Mason's sidekick is probably a good gig for him while it lasts. The whole lot of them must see the wheels coming off, they have more than enough collective experience in the game to see the car crash happening.


RE: So obvious. - Remi_Moses - 12-27-2025

Either Mason is blind or that obstinate he refuses to change
It matters not get him a Taxi.
Birdie is spot on when he says we build from the back, once that is sorted we can push on
It's not always about us buying the best players it's all about organising and getting the players to function as a team. Clough's defence had some cloggers like Kenny Burns but once correctly drilled and knocked into shape he was excellent.
As for keeping Mason on, it's a no from me. Far too much water has gone under the bridge now. Mason should have got an older statesman alongside him from the start. But he and Nestor know best. Don't we have anyone at our club with an ounce of common sense?


RE: So obvious. - Tom Joad 25 - 12-27-2025

(12-27-2025, 04:51 PM)lemon Wrote: As much as I don't like Colin, there's no doubt in my mind that he would have this team and squad 8th or better.  Players would be motivated, organised, feel valued,  and be on their toes.  Colin would also have the knack to work with the board and any restrictions they put in place, but having the backbone to push back a bit.

I get the impression that Mason is a 'philosophy' manager but doesn't publicise it as much as Russell Martin.  He's stubborn in his ideas and the ideas themselves are not of any great substance to outclass managers and opposition at this level.

Whatever those philosophies of his are, he needs to start picking up points with them.  No more sob stories.  The season may well be transitional but the points return is completely unacceptable.  I don't want us to be the sloppy 5 or 6 out of 10 outfit we are becoming.

The issue for me (with Mason) is I don't see any philosophy. I've been prepared to give him every chance yet see no signs of him learning anything at all. I've had a list of pluses and minuses to argue all season but I'm fresh out of positives and have nothing to argue in Mason's favour. The negatives are plentiful enough.

Dropping Griffiths whose saves have kept us in many a game and that behind a steadily getting worse defence. Madness.

Playing SIJ right wing? He said himself he's a left back. Mason wanted Styles mf and we play Taylor? I'm in my 60s and I'm more mobile. Our fans say SIJ is crap, I argue we've not used him right - or even seen him properly. 

Players getting worse. We've seen Price's qualities on the ball yet Mason picks him to chase around without it. Sunderland fans were gutted to lose Mepham. Liverpool kept Phillips (and played him at times) for years before deciding to cash out. Campbell appears to be restricted by the bench, uncertain whether to overlap, when to press?  All looked good for the 1st few games.

Subs. Mental! Losing a game? Change the fullbacks. 
           Need a goal? Bring on Dike for 2 minutes.
          Battering the league leaders? Take off the guy that has ripped them apart.
           Lunacy.

In game reactions. All wrong, apart from the knee jerk gamble of 4 subs that turned a 0-2 ht into a victory. Yesterday was a day for a repeat except most of those that came on in the former were already playing and the bench yesterday was full of kids that were never getting on.

Team selection.  Looks more like he picks the 1st 11 from a hat.

Post game comments.  Inconsistent,  I'm never sure he's seen the same game I have.

In fact, the one plus point remains that the players are still busting a gut for him. Sadly, the more the defence is in Keystone Cops mode, the less this will continue. Then there are no positives. The fans have been incredibly patient so far, this will evaporate unless he pulls the most unlikeliest of cards from his sleeve.


RE: So obvious. - Stillclem4england - 12-27-2025

(12-27-2025, 05:33 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(12-27-2025, 04:51 PM)lemon Wrote: As much as I don't like Colin, there's no doubt in my mind that he would have this team and squad 8th or better.  Players would be motivated, organised, feel valued,  and be on their toes.  Colin would also have the knack to work with the board and any restrictions they put in place, but having the backbone to push back a bit.

I get the impression that Mason is a 'philosophy' manager but doesn't publicise it as much as Russell Martin.  He's stubborn in his ideas and the ideas themselves are not of any great substance to outclass managers and opposition at this level.

Whatever those philosophies of his are, he needs to start picking up points with them.  No more sob stories.  The season may well be transitional but the points return is completely unacceptable.  I don't want us to be the sloppy 5 or 6 out of 10 outfit we are becoming.

The issue for me (with Mason) is I don't see any philosophy. I've been prepared to give him every chance yet see no signs of him learning anything at all. I've had a list of pluses and minuses to argue all season but I'm fresh out of positives and have nothing to argue in Mason's favour. The negatives are plentiful enough.

Dropping Griffiths whose saves have kept us in many a game and that behind a steadily getting worse defence. Madness.

Playing SIJ right wing? He said himself he's a left back. Mason wanted Styles mf and we play Taylor? I'm in my 60s and I'm more mobile. Our fans say SIJ is crap, I argue we've not used him right - or even seen him properly. 

Players getting worse. We've seen Price's qualities on the ball yet Mason picks him to chase around without it. Sunderland fans were gutted to lose Mepham. Liverpool kept Phillips (and played him at times) for years before deciding to cash out. Campbell appears to be restricted by the bench, uncertain whether to overlap, when to press?  All looked good for the 1st few games.

Subs. Mental! Losing a game? Change the fullbacks. 
           Need a goal? Bring on Dike for 2 minutes.
          Battering the league leaders? Take off the guy that has ripped them apart.
           Lunacy.

In game reactions. All wrong, apart from the knee jerk gamble of 4 subs that turned a 0-2 ht into a victory. Yesterday was a day for a repeat except most of those that came on in the former were already playing and the bench yesterday was full of kids that were never getting on.

Team selection.  Looks more like he picks the 1st 11 from a hat.

Post game comments.  Inconsistent,  I'm never sure he's seen the same game I have.

In fact, the one plus point remains that the players are still busting a gut for him. Sadly, the more the defence is in Keystone Cops mode, the less this will continue. Then there are no positives. The fans have been incredibly patient so far, this will evaporate unless he pulls the most unlikeliest of cards from his sleeve.
Good post but he is so far off even being a semi-competent manager it is pointless even considering everything he is getting wrong.