WBAUnofficial
Ppg... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ppg... (/showthread.php?tid=39478)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Ppg... - Derek Hardballs - 11-28-2025

(11-28-2025, 10:10 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The problem is Dekka, you seem to think you should not expect a rookie to do the basics right.

If a newly qualified pilot kept turning the engines off, I am sure people wouldn't say.. "Oh, well, the company commited to hiring young inexperienced pilots, we need to let him learn and develop"

So you think that a rookie manager should be judged at the same level as an experienced manager? There is no room for error, no teething problems that should be expected? I assume you expect the same of young players, no mistakes, no dip in form, no time to find their feet? 

Either fans accept inexperienced players and managers will make mistakes or they don’t. You can’t say we want to develop a young squad, managed by a young manager with new ideas, but we don’t accept mistakes along the way. My preference was Eustace when Mowbray got the job, but Nestor has brought in a young manager and has to show bravery and belief in his choice, otherwise you have to question him more than anyone else.


RE: Ppg... - MrBater - 11-28-2025

(11-28-2025, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 10:10 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The problem is Dekka, you seem to think you should not expect a rookie to do the basics right.

If a newly qualified pilot kept turning the engines off, I am sure people wouldn't say.. "Oh, well, the company commited to hiring young inexperienced pilots, we need to let him learn and develop"

So you think that a rookie manager should be judged at the same level as an experienced manager? There is no room for error, no teething problems that should be expected? I assume you expect the same of young players, no mistakes, no dip in form, no time to find their feet? 

Either fans accept inexperienced players and managers will make mistakes or they don’t. You can’t say we want to develop a young squad, managed by a young manager with new ideas, but we don’t accept mistakes along the way. My preference was Eustace when Mowbray got the job, but Nestor has brought in a young manager and has to show bravery and belief in his choice, otherwise you have to question him more than anyone else.

I think everyone is questioning Nestor and his choices...

I would say that most expected Mason to be a gamble, and that he would make mistakes, but I don't think anyone thought, you know what, we might end up in a relegation fight... Were we about 8th-12th, people would be grumbling, but we're not, so it's amplified.


RE: Ppg... - Tom Joad 25 - 11-28-2025

Looks to me like the mistakes (?) are fairly obvious. Ignoring certain players, terrible subs, puzzling full back selection/substitutions, team selection, hesitancy to react in game etc. Wouldn't this be something Nestor could query? It might even be part of a very cunning plan but those that work on the training/management side must be called to answer. Then Nestor can demand improvement or else.


RE: Ppg... - Derek Hardballs - 11-28-2025

(11-28-2025, 10:32 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 10:10 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The problem is Dekka, you seem to think you should not expect a rookie to do the basics right.

If a newly qualified pilot kept turning the engines off, I am sure people wouldn't say.. "Oh, well, the company commited to hiring young inexperienced pilots, we need to let him learn and develop"

So you think that a rookie manager should be judged at the same level as an experienced manager? There is no room for error, no teething problems that should be expected? I assume you expect the same of young players, no mistakes, no dip in form, no time to find their feet? 

Either fans accept inexperienced players and managers will make mistakes or they don’t. You can’t say we want to develop a young squad, managed by a young manager with new ideas, but we don’t accept mistakes along the way. My preference was Eustace when Mowbray got the job, but Nestor has brought in a young manager and has to show bravery and belief in his choice, otherwise you have to question him more than anyone else.

I think everyone is questioning Nestor and his choices...

I would say that most expected Mason to be a gamble, and that he would make mistakes, but I don't think anyone thought, you know what, we might end up in a relegation fight... Were we about 8th-12th, people would be grumbling, but we're not, so it's amplified.

The league is incredibly tight two wins in a row and you shoot up the league, we aren’t in a relegation fight currently, if could happen but we could also see see us move up the league.


RE: Ppg... - Lurker#3 - 11-28-2025

(11-28-2025, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 10:10 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The problem is Dekka, you seem to think you should not expect a rookie to do the basics right.

If a newly qualified pilot kept turning the engines off, I am sure people wouldn't say.. "Oh, well, the company commited to hiring young inexperienced pilots, we need to let him learn and develop"

So you think that a rookie manager should be judged at the same level as an experienced manager? There is no room for error, no teething problems that should be expected? I assume you expect the same of young players, no mistakes, no dip in form, no time to find their feet? 

Either fans accept inexperienced players and managers will make mistakes or they don’t. You can’t say we want to develop a young squad, managed by a young manager with new ideas, but we don’t accept mistakes along the way. My preference was Eustace when Mowbray got the job, but Nestor has brought in a young manager and has to show bravery and belief in his choice, otherwise you have to question him more than anyone else.

No not at all. I would give him lots of leeway if I saw him trying bold and brave tactical adjustments in game and them not all working. If I saw a level of energy and ambition that I would expect from a young professional in his first real job. 

But what we have is somebody that does nothing proactively. Is shit scared of his own shadow in game and hasn't showed any tactical acumen at all during matches. 

Regarding Nestor. I can see why they went with Mason. I am sure he interviewed fantastically. Probably did a wonderful PowerPoint. Gave them lots of examples, citing all the wonderful, experienced, winning coaches he's been closely involved with. But sadly his performance on the job has been subpar, and so far, IMVHO, has shown little to zero improvement.


RE: Ppg... - Derek Hardballs - 11-28-2025

(11-28-2025, 10:35 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 10:10 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The problem is Dekka, you seem to think you should not expect a rookie to do the basics right.

If a newly qualified pilot kept turning the engines off, I am sure people wouldn't say.. "Oh, well, the company commited to hiring young inexperienced pilots, we need to let him learn and develop"

So you think that a rookie manager should be judged at the same level as an experienced manager? There is no room for error, no teething problems that should be expected? I assume you expect the same of young players, no mistakes, no dip in form, no time to find their feet? 

Either fans accept inexperienced players and managers will make mistakes or they don’t. You can’t say we want to develop a young squad, managed by a young manager with new ideas, but we don’t accept mistakes along the way. My preference was Eustace when Mowbray got the job, but Nestor has brought in a young manager and has to show bravery and belief in his choice, otherwise you have to question him more than anyone else.

No not at all. I would give him lots of leeway if I saw him trying bold and brave tactical adjustments in game and them not all working. If I saw a level of energy and ambition that I would expect from a young professional in his first real job. 

But what we have is somebody that does nothing proactively. Is shit scared of his own shadow in game and hasn't showed any tactical acumen at all during matches. 

Regarding Nestor. I can see why they went with Mason. I am sure he interviewed fantastically. Probably did a wonderful PowerPoint. Gave them lots of examples, citing all the wonderful, experienced, winning coaches he's been closely involved with. But sadly his performance on the job has been subpar, and so far, IMVHO, has shown little to zero improvement.

Good luck with the new managerial search…


RE: Ppg... - CIM - 11-28-2025

(11-28-2025, 09:40 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: In this league where he is now is sackable.

Ismael we treated awfully and Bruce/Mowbray we kept in a job two months too many.

Why was Ismael treated awfully? He had a better squad and parachute money.


RE: Ppg... - Derek Hardballs - 11-28-2025

(11-28-2025, 11:58 AM)CIM Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 09:40 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: In this league where he is now is sackable.

Ismael we treated awfully and Bruce/Mowbray we kept in a job two months too many.

Why was Ismael treated awfully? He had a better squad and parachute money.

You have summoned the Valantes who will smite you down for blasphemy!


RE: Ppg... - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-28-2025

Ismael was just the wrong man for the job, and too stubborn to change his approach. Bar the first 10 games, by the end of which you could see things beginning to unravel anyway, I don’t look back fondly on any of the rest. He was fourth or fifth choice and it showed. In fairness to him the bigger crime was giving him the contract that we did in the first place, after fannying about for far too long for him to sufficiently indoctrinate the side to his way of attempting to press opposing teams into oblivion; and he took a job managing a club woefully short on firepower. A very strong start masked all of this somewhat.

So yes, it could be argued that we didn’t really give him long enough, or sufficient time to prepare for the season ahead. But on balance it was better than we have now, with more liquidity to play with; and if anyone can’t recall what the players though of him they’d do well to have remind themselves of Robert Snodgrass’s parting statement (a player who had become very much a Championship stalwart by then, and seemed to be pretty well regarded wherever his career had taken him prior). And, how that all came about.


RE: Ppg... - Peachofacross - 11-28-2025

(11-28-2025, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 10:10 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The problem is Dekka, you seem to think you should not expect a rookie to do the basics right.

If a newly qualified pilot kept turning the engines off, I am sure people wouldn't say.. "Oh, well, the company commited to hiring young inexperienced pilots, we need to let him learn and develop"

So you think that a rookie manager should be judged at the same level as an experienced manager? There is no room for error, no teething problems that should be expected? I assume you expect the same of young players, no mistakes, no dip in form, no time to find their feet? 

Either fans accept inexperienced players and managers will make mistakes or they don’t. You can’t say we want to develop a young squad, managed by a young manager with new ideas, but we don’t accept mistakes along the way. My preference was Eustace when Mowbray got the job, but Nestor has brought in a young manager and has to show bravery and belief in his choice, otherwise you have to question him more than anyone else.

I have no problem with inexperienced managers making mistakes. I have a problem if they don't learn from them. So far Mason isn't showing any signs of doing that with his in game management. He is getting out thought in the 2nd half of games and the stats are alarming from 1st to 2nd half. It's proving he can set us up ok but then when the opposition change it up and nullify us he cannot work out what to do. I said the other day it's a shame he doesn't have a better number 2 than Nigel Gibbs who appears to offer fuck all support.