WBAUnofficial
After Molumby sending off… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: After Molumby sending off… (/showthread.php?tid=39422)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: After Molumby sending off… - SausEggBaton - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 12:50 PM)richbaggie Wrote: I don't think many managers would have taken Molumby off at half time. It's something you might see late in a game with a combative player but not half time. I certainly didn't see or hear much comment about it being the right thing to do during HT just a lot of hindsight comment.

There's other game management issues that were far more deserving of criticism on Saturday such as the timing of the MK switch and not adjusting in a timely manner after the red.

Any manager worth half his salt would risk assess that Molumby is a bit mad and aggressive - while being on a yellow, and the game going in the way of strong challenges, so a simple swap for Diakite at HT would have made perfectly logical and sound sense. Mason didn't see this, clearly.


RE: After Molumby sending off… - richbaggie - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 01:01 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 12:50 PM)richbaggie Wrote: I don't think many managers would have taken Molumby off at half time. It's something you might see late in a game with a combative player but not half time. I certainly didn't see or hear much comment about it being the right thing to do during HT just a lot of hindsight comment.

There's other game management issues that were far more deserving of criticism on Saturday such as the timing of the MK switch and not adjusting in a timely manner after the red.

Any manager worth half his salt would risk assess that Molumby is a bit mad and aggressive - while being on a yellow, and the game going in the way of strong challenges, so a simple swap for Diakite at HT would have made perfectly logical and sound sense. Mason didn't see this, clearly.

I disagree that many would make decision to remove him. They would likely have a word and put their trust in a player to manage the situation. Removing him at half time would have completely undermined the player and possibly caused a problem for the future. If it was that obvious, why was the lack of changed only criticised in hindsight?

The red card was totally on Molumby.


RE: After Molumby sending off… - CA Baggie - 11-24-2025

I don't blame Mason for not subbing him at HT. I would expect him to be aware of Molumby's idiocy such as his punch-up in the pre-season friendly as well as his sending off at Bristol last season. If he doesn't know things like that about his players then not only is he tactically inept he's also plain lazy.

I do blame him for taking Mikey off and replacing him with Sammy the Seal. I also blame him for not making any subs between Molumby being sent off and going 3-2 down. And then putting KG up front.

Let's be honest, is there a single person watching that game who thought "I know what we need, it's Grant up front"? I'd suggest absolutely no one would have come up with that. Genius ffs.


RE: After Molumby sending off… - Old Fart - 11-24-2025

Sorry to be a know all but I said to Mrs OF as soon as he was booked that he should be subbed and not even wait until half time.

He is a fucking idiot at the best of times and from his booking onwards,  he was going to be pretty ineffective in the breaking up play role. He only needed to time a tackle wrong and he is off.  

The way their player turned him was schoolboy stuff.  He only needed to stand off a yard to avoid that happening. 

 And even then he had a time to consider if pulling him back when on a yellow card was really a sensible thing to do.  Mason said it was "instinctive". No it was just fucking stupid.

Mason should have had the bottle to hook him immediately.  

As for the MJ substitution.  Words fucking fail me. 

I refer my readers to an earlier post 

https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread.php?tid=39191

after the Sheffield Wednesday game and I have seen nothing to change my mind. 

Mason is a decent bloke but waaaay out of his depth.  And the fear I saw in his eyes during the post match Sky interview tells me he knows it. 

If he was a dog the vet would put him out of his misery.


RE: After Molumby sending off… - Squid - 11-24-2025

If you look at this week's View from the Opposition thread, quite a few Coventry fans were predicting that Molumby would get a second yellow and they were swiftly proved right.


RE: After Molumby sending off… - SausEggBaton - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 01:09 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 01:01 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 12:50 PM)richbaggie Wrote: I don't think many managers would have taken Molumby off at half time. It's something you might see late in a game with a combative player but not half time. I certainly didn't see or hear much comment about it being the right thing to do during HT just a lot of hindsight comment.

There's other game management issues that were far more deserving of criticism on Saturday such as the timing of the MK switch and not adjusting in a timely manner after the red.

Any manager worth half his salt would risk assess that Molumby is a bit mad and aggressive - while being on a yellow, and the game going in the way of strong challenges, so a simple swap for Diakite at HT would have made perfectly logical and sound sense. Mason didn't see this, clearly.

I disagree that many would make decision to remove him. They would likely have a word and put their trust in a player to manage the situation. Removing him at half time would have completely undermined the player and possibly caused a problem for the future. If it was that obvious, why was the lack of changed only criticised in hindsight?

The red card was totally on Molumby.

Of course.  However, to pre-empt / mitigate, such red card, and ensure we have a defensive midfield, the swap for 
Collyer or Diakite at Half Time would have made sense, if Mason was an effective football manager. 

Sorry Rich, its not entirely on Molumby this, he's a player that is effective, Mason should have see it's getting tasty and swapped him HT.


RE: After Molumby sending off… - SausEggBaton - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 06:29 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 01:09 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 01:01 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 12:50 PM)richbaggie Wrote: I don't think many managers would have taken Molumby off at half time. It's something you might see late in a game with a combative player but not half time. I certainly didn't see or hear much comment about it being the right thing to do during HT just a lot of hindsight comment.

There's other game management issues that were far more deserving of criticism on Saturday such as the timing of the MK switch and not adjusting in a timely manner after the red.

Any manager worth half his salt would risk assess that Molumby is a bit mad and aggressive - while being on a yellow, and the game going in the way of strong challenges, so a simple swap for Diakite at HT would have made perfectly logical and sound sense. Mason didn't see this, clearly.

I disagree that many would make decision to remove him. They would likely have a word and put their trust in a player to manage the situation. Removing him at half time would have completely undermined the player and possibly caused a problem for the future. If it was that obvious, why was the lack of changed only criticised in hindsight?

The red card was totally on Molumby.

Of course.  However, to pre-empt / mitigate, such red card, and ensure we have a defensive midfield, the swap for 
Collyer or Diakite at Half Time would have made sense, if Mason was an effective football manager. 

Sorry Rich, its not entirely on Molumby this, he's a player that is effective, Mason should have see it's getting tasty and swapped him HT.

My heart strings bleed for him while he's on 20K a week.


RE: After Molumby sending off… - richbaggie - 11-25-2025

(11-24-2025, 06:29 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 01:09 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 01:01 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 12:50 PM)richbaggie Wrote: I don't think many managers would have taken Molumby off at half time. It's something you might see late in a game with a combative player but not half time. I certainly didn't see or hear much comment about it being the right thing to do during HT just a lot of hindsight comment.

There's other game management issues that were far more deserving of criticism on Saturday such as the timing of the MK switch and not adjusting in a timely manner after the red.

Any manager worth half his salt would risk assess that Molumby is a bit mad and aggressive - while being on a yellow, and the game going in the way of strong challenges, so a simple swap for Diakite at HT would have made perfectly logical and sound sense. Mason didn't see this, clearly.

I disagree that many would make decision to remove him. They would likely have a word and put their trust in a player to manage the situation. Removing him at half time would have completely undermined the player and possibly caused a problem for the future. If it was that obvious, why was the lack of changed only criticised in hindsight?

The red card was totally on Molumby.

Of course.  However, to pre-empt / mitigate, such red card, and ensure we have a defensive midfield, the swap for 
Collyer or Diakite at Half Time would have made sense, if Mason was an effective football manager. 

Sorry Rich, its not entirely on Molumby this, he's a player that is effective, Mason should have see it's getting tasty and swapped him HT.

You say it was tasty. Bar that first booking, I don't recall it being too feisty.

Taking him off at HT would have been a big vote of no confidence from the manager in the player, basically saying...I don't trust you despite not letting him down before. In my opinion, that would have been a damaging call and also a dangerous precedent. I don't think many managers would make that call, you rarely see a call like that, that early in games. 
JM has been booked on average 10 times a season for us. Are we saying every time he gets booked, he has to be hooked because he can't be trusted? If so, he shouldn't be anywhere near a team sheet.


RE: After Molumby sending off… - Ted Maul - 11-25-2025

(11-25-2025, 09:15 AM)richbaggie Wrote: You say it was tasty. Bar that first booking, I don't recall it being too feisty.

Taking him off at HT would have been a big vote of no confidence from the manager in the player, basically saying...I don't trust you despite not letting him down before. In my opinion, that would have been a damaging call and also a dangerous precedent. I don't think many managers would make that call, you rarely see a call like that, that early in games. 
JM has been booked on average 10 times a season for us. Are we saying every time he gets booked, he has to be hooked because he can't be trusted? If so, he shouldn't be anywhere near a team sheet.

He shouldn't be anywhere near a team sheet because he's shit, Rich.


RE: After Molumby sending off… - tHEgLASSdOORS - 11-25-2025

I think there’s nuance to situations where you would foresee taking him off would be a good idea. He’s a volatile and erratic character at times and Saturday was one of those situations. This isn’t hindsight, a few of us said he was a walking red well before it happened.