WBAUnofficial
So then - this week’s poll - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: So then - this week’s poll (/showthread.php?tid=39415)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: So then - this week’s poll - Derek Hardballs - 11-22-2025

The thread ask’s what aligns with my thoughts… my thoughts are Nestor is not going to sack Mason and make it two failed appointments in six months. It’ll put the spotlight on him and make people question further his ability to do his job.

I also think if you’re going to appoint a rookie manager you have to give them time to find their feet, otherwise you are setting them up for a fall. Fans argue they want long term plans, where squads are built over a several seasons… then when they don’t get instant success they want the manager gone. I’ve long argued there is no such thing as long term plans in football as fans will never accept anything but constant improvement and sometimes that doesn’t happen.


RE: So then - this week’s poll - Ted Maul - 11-22-2025

I think I'm still in the realms of he might as well have the season for the following reasons.

1) We're only halfway through turning the squad over. We lose Maja, Dike, Wallace, Grant in the summer and I'd like to see him with a more balanced squad
2) I think this squad is really limited and unbalanced. I think at best it could finish 8th. In this league if you're not in the top six or bottom three it doesn't matter.
3) I keep thinking that Carlos finished 20th in his first season at Huddersfield. Can't be overstated how different it is having the top job from being just another coach. Mason hasn't even been does this for 20 games yet.

There are a couple of immediate things I want to see improving and improving quickly.

1) I want to see some of our players improving under him. Heggebo seems to have turned a corner, but some of our other signings need time and need to improve.
2) He needs to find place in the team for Bany.
3) His game management needs to improve. I've faith that he can set a team up, today was great until the sending off. The subbing of Heggebo and MJ afterwards was mindboggling.


RE: So then - this week’s poll - CIM - 11-22-2025

If we give him the season on current form we'll be in the 3rd tier next season.


RE: So then - this week’s poll - Derek Hardballs - 11-22-2025

(11-22-2025, 08:38 PM)CIM Wrote: If we give him the season on current form we'll be in the 3rd tier next season.

…you take a massive gamble with the clubs future by employing a rookie manager and then fans blame the manager?


RE: So then - this week’s poll - Ted Maul - 11-22-2025

(11-22-2025, 08:38 PM)CIM Wrote: If we give him the season on current form we'll be in the 3rd tier next season.

The caveat I forgot to add is that obviously he gets sacked if we look like heading into a relegation battle. Which despite recent results, we do not.


RE: So then - this week’s poll - SW4Baggie - 11-22-2025

Demote to coach.

Failing that, sack.


RE: So then - this week’s poll - sickParrot - 11-22-2025

(11-22-2025, 08:52 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Demote to coach driver.


He would only do 45 in the slow lane  Big Grin


RE: So then - this week’s poll - Squid - 11-22-2025

(11-22-2025, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 08:38 PM)CIM Wrote: If we give him the season on current form we'll be in the 3rd tier next season.

…you take a massive gamble with the clubs future by employing a rookie manager and then fans blame the manager?

I've not seen anyone defending Nestor. There was even a thread on here called "Nestor clear your desk" and it wasn't a Marie Kondo-esque exhortation to do some tidying.

I do think if the relegated teams + the other well funded ones were storming up the table, then fans might consider that promotion is unlikely and be more patient. But the unexpected weakness of so many teams this season + plus a general lack of goals has made fans tetchy.


RE: So then - this week’s poll - SW4Baggie - 11-22-2025

(11-22-2025, 10:07 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 08:38 PM)CIM Wrote: If we give him the season on current form we'll be in the 3rd tier next season.

…you take a massive gamble with the clubs future by employing a rookie manager and then fans blame the manager?

I've not seen anyone defending Nestor. There was even a thread on here called "Nestor clear your desk" and it wasn't a Marie Kondo-esque exhortation to do some tidying.

I do think if the relegated teams + the other well funded ones were storming up the table, then fans might consider that promotion is unlikely and be more patient. But the unexpected weakness of so many teams this season + plus a general lack of goals has made fans tetchy.

I don’t even think it’s that Squid, like I know I’ve been amongst the biggest detractors of Mason, but my desire for his sacking isn’t based on  the relative weakness of the division  or how other teams are dong, it’s based on the sheer fact he’s doing a really, really bad job. If we were seeing players improve, if we were seeing progress that suggested this season was a worthwhile year of transition, id be supportive, but we are not. I couldn’t give a damn about teams around us (other than ensuring we are above at least 3 in the league) as I didn’t really expect more than a top half finish this year, but with some visible plan taking shape. Unfortunately we are seeing absolutely nothing of any value other than Mason being paid to play at being a manager, and frankly as a club and a fan base we deserve much better.


RE: So then - this week’s poll - Squid - 11-23-2025

(11-22-2025, 10:24 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 10:07 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 08:38 PM)CIM Wrote: If we give him the season on current form we'll be in the 3rd tier next season.

…you take a massive gamble with the clubs future by employing a rookie manager and then fans blame the manager?

I've not seen anyone defending Nestor. There was even a thread on here called "Nestor clear your desk" and it wasn't a Marie Kondo-esque exhortation to do some tidying.

I do think if the relegated teams + the other well funded ones were storming up the table, then fans might consider that promotion is unlikely and be more patient. But the unexpected weakness of so many teams this season + plus a general lack of goals has made fans tetchy.

I don’t even think it’s that Squid, like I know I’ve been amongst the biggest detractors of Mason, but my desire for his sacking isn’t based on  the relative weakness of the division  or how other teams are dong, it’s based on the sheer fact he’s doing a really, really bad job. If we were seeing players improve, if we were seeing progress that suggested this season was a worthwhile year of transition, id be supportive, but we are not. I couldn’t give a damn about teams around us (other than ensuring we are above at least 3 in the league) as I didn’t really expect more than a top half finish this year, but with some visible plan taking shape. Unfortunately we are seeing absolutely nothing of any value other than Mason being paid to play at being a manager, and frankly as a club and a fan base we deserve much better.

I'm tempted to agree, but actually I think that is the sort of thing that fans say and don't really mean. Ultimately, there's a limit to how "good" or improving" a losing team can look if most of the teams around you are stronger. Whereas this season, the league is weak and therefore we should be beating far more teams then we are currently.