WBAUnofficial
Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games (/showthread.php?tid=39140)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Gzbaggy - 10-26-2025

(10-26-2025, 11:05 AM)Old Fart Wrote: I saw every home game and many of the away games under Giles.

It was obvious from day 1 that he knew what he was doing.

I also worked in Great Barr at that time so was able to sneak out to watch many of the training sessions being conducted at what was Aston University's recreation centre. 

Most of the training was done playing five a sides between attack and defence to sharpen up ball control and shape.  He'd take players aside and talk to them one to one on their game, a bit like Corberan. 

I wish Mason success.  But the season started with us showing signs of having a method and style of playing, with individual players thriving in that set up.  The players were obviously enjoying it and played with a smile on their faces.

We now look tired and jaded with little in the way of method and shape. As someone said earlier, a bit Bruce-like.  There's no joy in our game unless we score and then we withdraw into our own half waiting for the inevitable equaliser.  

Remember Wrexham?  They are now 3 points behind us.  I don't like Phil Parkinson, but he has found a way of winning. He has sorted out their defence and got them organised.

I don't totally buy into the "poor recruitment"  argument. You can go a long way with a group of average players if you instil a bit of belief in them and they know exactly what their role is.   

Fucking about at the back cost us again yesterday.  We expend massive amounts of energy keeping possession in our own half to the extent that we are clueless as to what to do when we get into the opposition half.  As well as being a ridiculous pass, it was a result of having a midfielder facing the wrong way and not having a clue what was behind him.  That ball should have gone out to the wings. 

I know fukcall about football, but if I was Mason, I'd play Grant and MJ on the wings with instructions to push their fullbacks back and get as many crosses in as possible to Maja or Dike.  Price and Mowatt can push forward and the back four push up to condense the action area and Molumby breaking things up in the middle.  The ball needs to come out of defence fast to the wide men. 

It isn't sophisticated but we are not going to win anything if we don't start scoring goals and you can't do that playing in your own half.  

Feel free to tell me I am talking bollocks. I'll try not to cry.

You talk a great deal of sense, although I would be tempted to prefer Bostock to Grant


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Tom Joad 25 - 10-26-2025

(10-26-2025, 11:05 AM)Old Fart Wrote: I saw every home game and many of the away games under Giles.

It was obvious from day 1 that he knew what he was doing.

I also worked in Great Barr at that time so was able to sneak out to watch many of the training sessions being conducted at what was Aston University's recreation centre. 

Most of the training was done playing five a sides between attack and defence to sharpen up ball control and shape.  He'd take players aside and talk to them one to one on their game, a bit like Corberan. 

I wish Mason success.  But the season started with us showing signs of having a method and style of playing, with individual players thriving in that set up.  The players were obviously enjoying it and played with a smile on their faces.

We now look tired and jaded with little in the way of method and shape. As someone said earlier, a bit Bruce-like.  There's no joy in our game unless we score and then we withdraw into our own half waiting for the inevitable equaliser.  

Remember Wrexham?  They are now 3 points behind us.  I don't like Phil Parkinson, but he has found a way of winning. He has sorted out their defence and got them organised.

I don't totally buy into the "poor recruitment"  argument. You can go a long way with a group of average players if you instil a bit of belief in them and they know exactly what their role is.   

Fucking about at the back cost us again yesterday.  We expend massive amounts of energy keeping possession in our own half to the extent that we are clueless as to what to do when we get into the opposition half.  As well as being a ridiculous pass, it was a result of having a midfielder facing the wrong way and not having a clue what was behind him.  That ball should have gone out to the wings. 

I know fukcall about football, but if I was Mason, I'd play Grant and MJ on the wings with instructions to push their fullbacks back and get as many crosses in as possible to Maja or Dike.  Price and Mowatt can push forward and the back four push up to condense the action area and Molumby breaking things up in the middle.  The ball needs to come out of defence fast to the wide men. 

It isn't sophisticated but we are not going to win anything if we don't start scoring goals and you can't do that playing in your own half.  

Feel free to tell me I am talking bollocks. I'll try not to cry.

No, that all makes sense to me.  Of course, Giles addition of himself to the teamsheet improved us 50% at the stroke of a pencil.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 10-26-2025

(10-25-2025, 10:26 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Not now, but 50 years ago. A bloke called Johnny Giles.
12 games in less points than now, less goals.
Difference then there wasn’t all the noise. 
People had more patience then and everyone no matter how unqualified didn’t have an opinion we had to read.
That young manager turned out pretty good in 1976. 
Perhaps there’s a lesson from history we can learn. Let’s hope so.

Remember that season under Giles. For one thing, Giles had a reputation as a world class player, not a guy that, meaning no disrespect, won a few U 21 caps. Also, Giles, after the opening  poor results, changed full backs. Gordon Nisbet, a good attacking fullback, was dropped,( apparently, according to Ally Robertson,  Giles didn`t like Nisbet pushing on too much ) experienced Paddy Mulligan took over. Following a 4 - 0 defeat at Fulham, Ray Wilson , a good player, but not one that Giles liked, ( rumours were that they fell out, Wilson getting injured meant Cantello moved to left back, Wilson never played again, Nisbet sold to Plymouth  or somewhere ).
Mick Martin came in for £50,000, decent midfielder.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Gzbaggy - 10-26-2025

Just dug the old Rothmans Yearbook out!

He started off with two central strikers Ally Brown and Joe Mayo, we lost 3-0 at Southampton. For the second game he bought in Geoff Hurst, who played in the next 10 games and did not appear again, he was well past his best by then. As you point out Mulligan and Martin were excellent signings

Although we got promoted in third place, we only scored 50 goals in 42 games.

He also gave a debut to Bryan Robson. Godden and Statham were youngsters in the reserves


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Jacko - 10-26-2025

Someone mentioned Rooney, this reminds me of that, hopefully we don't leave it too late as Blues did.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - garryowensneck - 10-26-2025

(10-26-2025, 01:57 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Just dug the old Rothmans Yearbook out!

He started off with two central strikers Ally Brown and Joe Mayo, we lost 3-0 at Southampton. For the second game he bought in Geoff Hurst, who played in the next 10 games and did not appear again, he was well past his best by then. As you point out Mulligan and Martin were excellent signings

Although we got promoted in third place, we only scored 50 goals in 42 games.

He also gave a debut to Bryan Robson. Godden and Statham were youngsters in the reserves
Robson played and scored the previous season.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Gzbaggy - 10-26-2025

Sorry, you are right


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - igorbalis - 10-26-2025

(10-26-2025, 11:05 AM)Old Fart Wrote: I saw every home game and many of the away games under Giles.

It was obvious from day 1 that he knew what he was doing.

I also worked in Great Barr at that time so was able to sneak out to watch many of the training sessions being conducted at what was Aston University's recreation centre. 

Most of the training was done playing five a sides between attack and defence to sharpen up ball control and shape.  He'd take players aside and talk to them one to one on their game, a bit like Corberan. 

I wish Mason success.  But the season started with us showing signs of having a method and style of playing, with individual players thriving in that set up.  The players were obviously enjoying it and played with a smile on their faces.

We now look tired and jaded with little in the way of method and shape. As someone said earlier, a bit Bruce-like.  There's no joy in our game unless we score and then we withdraw into our own half waiting for the inevitable equaliser.  

Remember Wrexham?  They are now 3 points behind us.  I don't like Phil Parkinson, but he has found a way of winning. He has sorted out their defence and got them organised.

I don't totally buy into the "poor recruitment"  argument. You can go a long way with a group of average players if you instil a bit of belief in them and they know exactly what their role is.   

Fucking about at the back cost us again yesterday.  We expend massive amounts of energy keeping possession in our own half to the extent that we are clueless as to what to do when we get into the opposition half.  As well as being a ridiculous pass, it was a result of having a midfielder facing the wrong way and not having a clue what was behind him.  That ball should have gone out to the wings. 

I know fukcall about football, but if I was Mason, I'd play Grant and MJ on the wings with instructions to push their fullbacks back and get as many crosses in as possible to Maja or Dike.  Price and Mowatt can push forward and the back four push up to condense the action area and Molumby breaking things up in the middle.  The ball needs to come out of defence fast to the wide men. 

It isn't sophisticated but we are not going to win anything if we don't start scoring goals and you can't do that playing in your own half.  

Feel free to tell me I am talking bollocks. I'll try not to cry.

Cant really compare then and now - what I will say is I don't think Mason  knows what his best 11 are, the team in 75/76 pretty much picked its self - only watched the first 25 minutes yesterday and turned it off we were that bad.

Got to give Mason time, but too many performances like yesterday and he wont last long.