WBAUnofficial
This season's space goat. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: This season's space goat. (/showthread.php?tid=38315)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: This season's space goat. - Ted Maul - 08-13-2025

(08-13-2025, 02:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 02:02 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 01:47 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Have we nominated a player for this prestigious award yet, or what? Big Grin

Considering Taylor is ‘one ov ar own!’ He is getting some completely ott criticism.

If he was fast and athletic like Ajayi he'd get a lot more leeway with fans.

Fans like old fashioned centre backs, when they're older and they've developed that game reading ability, they don't like them while they learn it. 

This is now the issue Taylor has, in 5 years time if we sell him people could well be on here moaning about that lower Prem level defender that does the basics well and is a unit was here and we sold him for peanuts. However, fans won't allow him the time to make the mistakes he'll need to make to learn that side of the game, that only comes from playing at or close to the level you want to end up at.

A League 1 loan will do nothing for him now, arguable a lower Championship loan might, but if he does well, we'll look stupid, and margins are so fine it might even properly bite us in the ass.

This is why it's a curious situation with Taylor. He isn't a kid anymore and needs to play the games to become the player you talk about. 

Compare and contrast to Williams who got glowing reviews from last night, he's at the perfect age to be an understudy for Furlong and Campbell and play maybe 5-10 games this season off the bench and in the cup competitions. Taylor is past that, I posted on the match thread that we speak of him as though he is still a kid, and he's young for a centre half but we can't afford to keep him on our books for the next four seasons in the hope he comes good. In Phillips and Campbell we have two CBs, rumours are we're looking to sign another when Heggem moves. 

He's got a fair bit to learn to be a regular starter in our team and in a position where you can't hide in games or learn as much as others on the job. He's got a couple of real obvious weaknesses to the fundamentals of being a decent CB. If we are to try and bed him into the side, I think the best place for him would be in the middle of a back three with the Bartley remit of head it and kick it.


RE: This season's space goat. - Lurker#3 - 08-13-2025

(08-13-2025, 02:39 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Scottish Prem would actually be a good shout.

Shall we email the club our proposal? ?

Get on it Birdy, sure Dekka would have him at Hearts?


RE: This season's space goat. - man in the corner shop - 08-13-2025

(08-13-2025, 02:34 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 02:25 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Same as last year for me, Wallace and Swift.
Shite and double shite. Will be looking to see how how Swift dies at Pompey.

Except when they play us when he'll be world class

Dont you know it 
And we will wonder why we let such a gem go Big Grin


RE: This season's space goat. - CarlosCorbewrong - 08-13-2025

Permacrock, Dike. Again.


RE: This season's space goat. - TartanRug - 08-13-2025

(08-13-2025, 02:40 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 02:34 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 02:25 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Same as last year for me, Wallace and Swift.
Shite and double shite. Will be looking to see how how Swift dies at Pompey.

Except when they play us when he'll be world class

Dont you know it 
And we will wonder why we let such a gem go Big Grin

The meltdown will be well worth seeing  Big Grin


RE: This season's space goat. - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-15-2025

The contest is shaping up nicely.

Loads on here don't think Callum Styles is a left back.

Molumby always has his detractors - if he plays 400 games for us and 100 for Ireland there will still be posters telling us he's a parks footballer.

Caleb Taylor is falling into the "just because he's one of our own, that doesn't mean he's any good" trap.

Krystian Bielik is a new entrant into the field. He's a Bluenose, he's been moved on by the 'Noses, he's injury prone, he's a sign we aren't moving in the right direction as a club.

And in the unlikely event that none of the above rise to the challenge, we've always got good old Karlan Grant, ploughing up and down the left flank, doing exactly what the coach asks of him but never quite pleasing the fans.

(08-13-2025, 02:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 02:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 02:02 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 01:47 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Have we nominated a player for this prestigious award yet, or what? Big Grin

Considering Taylor is ‘one ov ar own!’ He is getting some completely ott criticism.

If he was fast and athletic like Ajayi he'd get a lot more leeway with fans.

Fans like old fashioned centre backs, when they're older and they've developed that game reading ability, they don't like them while they learn it. 

This is now the issue Taylor has, in 5 years time if we sell him people could well be on here moaning about that lower Prem level defender that does the basics well and is a unit was here and we sold him for peanuts. However, fans won't allow him the time to make the mistakes he'll need to make to learn that side of the game, that only comes from playing at or close to the level you want to end up at.

A League 1 loan will do nothing for him now, arguable a lower Championship loan might, but if he does well, we'll look stupid, and margins are so fine it might even properly bite us in the ass.

This is why it's a curious situation with Taylor. He isn't a kid anymore and needs to play the games to become the player you talk about. 

Compare and contrast to Williams who got glowing reviews from last night, he's at the perfect age to be an understudy for Furlong and Campbell and play maybe 5-10 games this season off the bench and in the cup competitions. Taylor is past that, I posted on the match thread that we speak of him as though he is still a kid, and he's young for a centre half but we can't afford to keep him on our books for the next four seasons in the hope he comes good. In Phillips and Campbell we have two CBs, rumours are we're looking to sign another when Heggem moves. 

He's got a fair bit to learn to be a regular starter in our team and in a position where you can't hide in games or learn as much as others on the job. He's got a couple of real obvious weaknesses to the fundamentals of being a decent CB. If we are to try and bed him into the side, I think the best place for him would be in the middle of a back three with the Bartley remit of head it and kick it.

Can he really do the pointing and shouting though? Could he grow a really shit beard?


RE: This season's space goat. - Lurker#3 - 08-15-2025

Is "doing exactly what the coach asks" the new defence for players who people like but don't really contribute? Seen it a few times in recent weeks.

It seems similar to the notion of the pesky senior pros downing tools to see off poor old ToMo last year, coming from those who nailed their colours to the mask early that he was going to be great after CCs over coaching.

A quick shout out for Campbell, after CAs assertion that he will be Ajayiesque, making regular cock ups, and will need his hand held by Phillips. We have another candidate.


RE: This season's space goat. - Remi_Moses - 08-15-2025

Anyone who's name has a "W" in it.


RE: This season's space goat. - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-15-2025

(08-15-2025, 08:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Is "doing exactly what the coach asks" the new defence for players who people like but don't really contribute? Seen it a few times in recent weeks.

It seems similar to the notion of the pesky senior pros downing tools to see off poor old ToMo last year, coming from those who nailed their colours to the mask early that he was going to be great after CCs over coaching.

A quick shout out for Campbell, after CAs assertion that he will be Ajayiesque, making regular cock ups, and will need his hand held by Phillips. We have another candidate.

Interesting question. In the modern era we have stats bots like you who can quantify "contribution" in terms of actions on the pitch, but you can't quantify all aspects of a player's influence. Ian Bowyer was a stalwart of Brian Clough's successful Forest team, yet it was difficult to see what he was doing. He was so unobtrusive you would hardly notice him during a match. Got picked every week and won a ton of silverware.

I think we miss Karlan Grant's industry when he doesn't play, even though he maybe lacks the attacking impact of an in-form Mikey Johnston. Horses for courses.

I think you're on the money with Campbell. Now CA has made his pronouncement it will become fact, even if the lad never drops a bollock.


RE: This season's space goat. - Lurker#3 - 08-15-2025

(08-15-2025, 09:59 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(08-15-2025, 08:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Is "doing exactly what the coach asks" the new defence for players who people like but don't really contribute? Seen it a few times in recent weeks.

It seems similar to the notion of the pesky senior pros downing tools to see off poor old ToMo last year, coming from those who nailed their colours to the mask early that he was going to be great after CCs over coaching.

A quick shout out for Campbell, after CAs assertion that he will be Ajayiesque, making regular cock ups, and will need his hand held by Phillips. We have another candidate.

Interesting question. In the modern era we have stats bots like you who can quantify "contribution" in terms of actions on the pitch, but you can't quantify all aspects of a player's influence. Ian Bowyer was a stalwart of Brian Clough's successful Forest team, yet it was difficult to see what he was doing. He was so unobtrusive you would hardly notice him during a match. Got picked every week and won a ton of silverware.

I think we miss Karlan Grant's industry when he doesn't play, even though he maybe lacks the attacking impact of an in-form Mikey Johnston. Horses for courses.

I think you're on the money with Campbell. Now CA has made his pronouncement it will become fact, even if the lad never drops a bollock.

Completely agree regarding the work you don't see and struggle to measure. 

I have been on of KGs biggest supporters when he's had pelters over the years. Because of his work rate and attitude. But it's hard to overlook the lack of output when as a team we struggle so badly to open teams up. 

Molumby, Styles and KG are my targets in terms of that lack of contribution at the moment. We know KG can score goals at this level but it seems a long time since he did regularly. I believe Styles has got it in him to up his creative contributions and also his goal contributions. Molumby, I am not so sure.